Mary Robinson: Gaza situation is ‘unconscionable' and ceasefire is ‘an utter urgency'
Mary Robinson
has said what is happening
in Gaza
is 'unconscionable' and that there is an 'utter urgency' for a ceasefire.
The former UN high commissioner for human rights told RTÉ radio's Morning Ireland there needs to be a parallel humanitarian and political approach.
Yesterday, more than 100 human rights and aid organisations – including Mercy Corps, the
Norwegian Refugee Council
and Refugees International – warned that
mass starvation was spreading across the enclave
even as tons of food, clean water, medical supplies and other items sit untouched just outside Gaza as humanitarian organisations are blocked from accessing or delivering them.
'It is unconscionable what is happening and there is an utter urgency to have a ceasefire and to allow the stockpiles of food, water, medical supplies, shelter, etc, to be distributed by the UN and by the many aid agencies who are more than willing and ready to distribute.'
READ MORE
Mrs Robinson, former chair of The Elders – an international organisation of public figures noted as elder statespeople, peace activists and human rights advocates – called for all hostages to be released.
However, she called for a 'parallel approach' saying: 'We also need the political approach and we need that to be a turning point'.
She said there was potential for that at an upcoming conference in New York. 'If western countries, particularly P5 [UN security council permanent members] countries like the United Kingdom and France, recognise the state of Palestine , then we begin the political road towards that state. We restore the humanity of the Palestinians who are being dehumanised . . . The political solution is for the countries who will be involved, the foreign ministers who will present in New York, to rally together and begin to plan.
'The Elders are very in favour of an approach which has both Israeli and Palestinian support, not at the political level, but at the academic and civil society level. It's called a land for all. It's a two-state collaborative, two-states solution for the states of Palestine and Israel together. One state with two states within it. And that's a possibility. There are other possibilities, but there must be a political way forward. That's what's been absent.'
Mrs Robinson said that during the second World War the Nazis had 'dehumanised the Jews so that they could exterminate them in gas chambers. And that's why we have to have the humanitarian and the political side by side'.
Recently Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu telephoned Pope Leo to apologise for the injury to Fr Gabriel Romanelli when a Catholic church was bombed. However, he has not made any other apologies, Mrs Robinson said.
'Prime minister Netanyahu has not apologised for the more than 17,000 children killed in Gaza. He has not apologised for the many more children left without limbs and without family members. He has not apologised for all the children of Gaza who've been traumatised by this totally disproportionate war and are now hungry to the point of starvation because no apology is deemed to be necessary because this right-wing government has dehumanised the Palestinians.'
When asked if Israel should face sanctions as had Syria and Russia, she said: 'Yes, there should be more sanctions on the leaders who are responsible, and there should be no arms supplied to continue this war which has been involved in so many war crimes.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Pressure mounts on Israeli government to break deadlock on Gaza conflict
Videos released in recent days, one by Hamas and one by the Islamic Jihad, showing two severely emaciated hostages, Rom Braslavski and Evyatar David , sent shock waves throughout Israel and increased the pressure on the government to act to end the deadlock. More than 60 per cent of Israelis back a ceasefire that will bring all the 50 hostages home, 20 of whom are believed to be alive. But the far-right members of the coalition reacted to the videos by calling for the conquest of all of Gaza and for the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) to operate in areas of Gaza city and the central refugee camps where it is believed hostages are being held. Prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu told ministers on Monday that he intends to convene the security cabinet this week to instruct the IDF on how to reach three objectives the government set for the war in Gaza: 'defeating the enemy; releasing the hostages; and ensuring that Gaza will no longer pose a threat to Israel'. READ MORE The Hostages and Missing Families Forum, which represents most of the 50 hostage families, came out against expanding the military operation in Gaza. 'Netanyahu is preparing the largest possible scam,' the forum said in a statement. 'His talking points about releasing the hostages while claiming victory in Gaza have been made repeatedly, and they are meant to deceive the public.' The forum also said that 'expanding the war endangers the lives of the hostages, who are already in immediate danger of death.' Also opposing an escalation of the war was a group of some 600 retired Israeli security officials, including former heads of intelligence agencies, who wrote to US president Donald Trump , urging him to pressure Israel to immediately end the war. [ Hundreds of ex-Israeli security officials urge Trump to help end Gaza war in open letter Opens in new window ] 'It is our professional judgement that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel,' the officials said. Israel is reportedly considering annexing parts of Gaza in an attempt to pressure Hamas to release hostages, but no decision has yet been made. On the ground the fighting continues, along with the dire humanitarian crisis. Gaza's Hamas-controlled health ministry said on Monday that at least 94 Palestinians were killed in the past 24 hours by IDF fire, 29 of them killed while waiting to receive humanitarian aid. This screengrab from a video released on August 1st shows Israeli hostage Evyatar David looking weak and malnourished. It has increased pressure on the Israeli government to act to end the Gaza conflict. Photograph: AFP Canada, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Egypt, Germany and Belgium all air-dropped aid on Monday. Despite the fact that Israel recently allowed more aid to enter the enclave, including daily international air drops, UNRWA, the UN agency for refugees, warned that 500-600 lorries a day are needed to prevent the more than 2.1 million population from starving. The World Food Programme said it has still not been open to reopen bakeries and food kitchens that have been closed since May. The war began on October 7th, 2023 when 1,200 people were killed when Hamas militants stormed into southern Israel. Up to 250 people were taken hostage into Gaza. More than 60,000 people have been killed in Gaza in almost 22 months of fighting.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Israeli government dismisses attorney general who opposed radical judicial overhaul
Israel 's government has voted unanimously to dismiss attorney general Gali Baharav-Miara after she opposed the efforts of the right-wing government to implement a radical judicial overhaul, shifting the balance of power away from the judicial branch, and blocked moves to grant the ultra-Orthodox an exemption from military service. She also serves as chief prosecutor in the ongoing corruption trial against prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu and opponents of the government say the real aim is to replace her with a 'yes-man' who may end the proceedings. Mr Netanyahu claims he is innocent of the charges of fraud, breach of trust and accepting bribes. Ministers, led by justice minister Yariv Levin, have accused her of pushing a progressive agenda aimed at undermining the policies of the democratically elected right-wing government. Ms Baharav-Miara refused to attend Monday's cabinet meeting, instead sending a letter to ministers accusing the government of acting illegally by not following accepted procedure required for such a dismissal. READ MORE 'The attorney general's participation in a process that contradicts the law, whose outcome is known in advance, would create an appearance of proper procedure and give it validity,' she wrote. 'We will continue to perform our work with statesmanship, objectivity and without fear.' The unprecedented dismissal was described by the opposition as a 'constitutional earthquake'. It will only go into effect after the high court of justice rules on a number of petitions against the move and legal experts believe the court is likely to strike it down, leaving Israel in unchartered constitutional waters. Ministers say they will boycott Ms Baharav-Miara, not inviting her to key government meetings and not seeking her legal opinion. However, she enjoys strong support from judges, senior civil servants and the security establishment – both past and present
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Hundreds of ex-Israeli security officials urge Trump to help end Gaza war in open letter
About 600 former Israeli security officials, including previous heads of intelligence services the Mossad and the military, have urged US president Donald Trump to pressure Israel to end the war in Gaza as the country's prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu , considers expanding the conflict. In an open letter, the former officials said an end to the war is the only way to save hostages still held by Hamas . 'Your credibility with the vast majority of Israelis augments your ability to steer prime minister Netanyahu and his government in the right direction: end the war, return the hostages, stop the suffering,' they wrote. They added that they thought Hamas no longer posed a strategic threat to Israel . READ MORE The letter comes as pressure mounts for the Israeli government to end the war, even as Mr Netanyahu considers intensifying the offensive. Thousands of protesters took to the streets in Israel over the weekend after two videos were released of emaciated hostages held in Gaza . One video in particular, which depicted a skeletal Evyatar David digging what he said could be his own grave, prompted a wave of outrage across Israel. An image from a video released on August 1st, 2025 shows Israeli hostage Evyatar David. Photograph: AFP via Getty Images President Michael D Higgins on Sunday condemned the footage as a 'shocking act of cruelty' that 'reflects not only on those responsible for such actions but damages any cause to which they attach themselves'. On Sunday night, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum headquarters released a statement accusing Mr Netanyahu of 'leading Israel and the kidnapped to doom'. According to Israeli media, Mr Netanyahu wants to try 'pushing for the release of the hostages through decisive military victory'. He is expected to hold a meeting on Tuesday to decide on the best path forward in Gaza, with expanded military operations on the table. Intensifying military activity in the Palestinian territory would placate the far-right ministers in Mr Netanyahu's governing coalition, who have consistently advocated against a ceasefire. The Israeli government is exploring the idea of intensified military operations as ceasefire negotiations seemed to have stalled, which it blames on Hamas. The US and Israel withdrew their negotiators from Doha 10 days ago and said they would explore 'alternative options' to retrieve the hostages. An expansion of the war would be contrary to what Mr Trump's Middle East envoy told the families of hostages over the weekend was the US position. Steve Witkoff said Washington was backing a comprehensive end to the Gaza war that would bring hostages home and assured the families that would not mean more fighting. Seven-month-old Hasan Ahmed Felfel, whose condition is worsening by the day due to severe malnutrition in Gaza. Photograph: Mohammad Yasir/Anadolu via Getty Images Any expansion of the conflict would risk worsening the already catastrophic humanitarian situation in Gaza. A UN-affiliated humanitarian body said the territory was experiencing famine, as the approximate 2.1 million people who live there experience mass starvation. Despite the announcement of expanded aid measures in Gaza, humanitarian groups say Israel is still not letting nearly enough aid into the territory. Israel blames the UN for not distributing aid efficiently. At least 40 Palestinians were killed by Israeli gunfire and air strikes in Gaza on Monday, in addition to five people who died of starvation, health authorities said. At least 10 of those who were killed were shot as they queued for aid outside distribution centres run by the private US Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). Almost 61,000 people have been killed in Gaza since the war began. Israel launched the war in response to an attack on Israel on October 7th, 2023 in which Hamas-led militants killed about 1,200 people and took 251 hostage. Families of the hostages rejected the idea of further fighting in Gaza, which they said on Sunday 'endangers the lives of the kidnapped, who are already in immediate danger of death'. The former Israeli security officials also warned against an expansion of the war, arguing that Israel had long since achieved its military objectives in Gaza. 'At first this war was a just war, a defensive war, but when we achieved all military objectives, this war ceased to be a just war,' Ami Ayalon, the former head of the Shin Bet security agency, said in a video on Sunday night. 'This [war] is leading the state of Israel to the loss of its security and identity.' – The Guardian
