
Former Trinamool MP Jawhar Sircar demands 'answers' for animals missing from Alipore Zoo
'There is no doubt that the number of animals and birds at Alipore Zoo have declined remarkably. In 1996, the Alipore Zoo housed roughly 1,872 animals and birds. As of the opening stock data of 2024, there are only 351 creatures. This drastic decrease has no logic,' Mr. Sircar said at a public meeting called by the Kolkata-based NGO, Save Wild Animal and Zoo and Our Nature (SWAZON).
He added that clerical or typographic error in data entry can account for roughly 1% irregularity.
'However, in this case, the discrepancy in inventory data is too large. Where did the animals go? If there are deaths, they need to submit autopsy reports,' Mr. Sircar said.
According to the Annual Inventory of Animals in Indian Zoos reports of 2023-24, the total closing stock of all creatures at Alipore Zoo as of March 31, 2023, was 672. However, the opening stock as of the following day, April 1, 2024, was 351 — marking an apparent one day decrease of over 300 creatures.
The closing stock as of March 31, 2025, according to the report, is 1084.
Mr. Sircar added that the 2024-25 data have no records for big animals like lions, tigers, elephants, and giraffes, and demanded that the State government needs to 'provide answers to explain the fundamental problem behind this discrepancy for public interest.'
'There is either gross negligence or a large conspiracy at play here. The government does not own land; they are the protectors of a certain land. It is their duty to protect such properties,' Mr. Sircar said.
It is worth noting that Mr. Sircar in September last year had resigned from his position of MP in the Upper House over the rape and murder of a doctor at R.G. Kar Medical College and Hospital and allegations of corruption at the hospital.
Alleged auction of Zoo land
Meanwhile, former Director General of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation and member of SWAZON Dipankar Sinha claimed on Wednesday that the West Bengal Housing Infrastructure Development Corporation (HIDCO) issued a tender for the e-auction of a part of the Alipore Zoo land.
On May 23, HIDCO floated a notice for e-auction inviting offers for the 'for allotment of 166.50 Katha (11137.50 SQ.M) land in premises no. 34A, Belvedere Road, Alipore under ward no 74 of Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) on freehold basis for Commercial use which shall inter alia includes an aquarium.'
He alleged that 34A Belvedere Road belongs to the Alipore Zoo and houses the zoo's veterinary hospital and animal rescue centre.
'As we know the Alipore Zoo is located on two sides of the Alipore Road. On one side we have the aquarium, the veterinary hospital and rescue centre, and an auditorium. The land on which the veterinary hospital is located has been put up on auction. But KMC does not own that land, it is not the government's to sell,' Mr Sinha told The Hindu.
He added that the veterinary hospital is critical for the welfare of the animals and criticised the proposal for its purported e-auction.
Mr. Sinha further said that the alleged 'disappearance' of hundreds of creatures from the zoo coupled with the auction of a part of the zoo land signals a 'grave and dark future' for the city's ecosphere and raises concerns over whether the space is being deteriorated to a lower-tier zoological garden.
'One side of the zoo, of which the address is 2, Alipore Road, is a heritage property. The second part of the zoo, which is located on the opposite side of the same road, strangely has a different address — 34A Belvedere Road. It makes one wonder if there is a concerted effort to eventually sell off the latter entirely, on account of it not being on the same address as the heritage property,' SWAZON member Swarnali Chattopadhyay said.
She also highlighted that according to the report on the Annual Inventory of Animals in Zoos, the inventory of animals and birds in Alipore Zoo has shown a gross and sudden decline in earlier years as well.
'If it is indeed a clerical error as zoo authorities claim, then why has the data not been corrected? And have the so-called missing animals been retrieved in consequent inventory reports? Questions remain on how such gross 'typographical errors' are being made year after year, and if there are larger forces at play,' Ms. Chattopadhyay said.
Notably, SWAZON filed a Public Interest Litigation at the Calcutta High Court on July 1 alleging that 'attempted alienation of [zoo land] without obtaining prior consent from the Central Zoo Authority (CZA), constitutes a direct violation of Section 38-H of the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972, as well as Rules 10, 10.3(8), and 10.4(2) of the Recognition of Zoo Rules, 2009.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Bangladesh Security Forces Fired Indiscriminately During Clashes In Sheikh Hasina's Hometown: Report
Security forces fired indiscriminately during clashes involving supporters of ousted premier Sheikh Hasina this month, killing at least five people, human rights activists said Friday. The clashes erupted in Hasina's hometown of Gopalganj after members of her Awami League party tried to foil a rally by the National Citizens Party (NCP), made up of many students who spearheaded the uprising that toppled her government last year. The Bangladesh-based human rights group Ain O Salish Kendra (ASK) said that it had "identified at least two gross violations of constitutional rights". "The law enforcement agencies fired at civilians indiscriminately, and the right to hold a peaceful assembly was not upheld," Abu Ahmed Faijul Kabir, senior coordinator at ASK, told AFP. Locals in Gopalganj told ASK that clashes erupted soon after NCP concluded its rally, with a crowd throwing bricks at the party members and security personnel. "Though some carried Molotov cocktails, they were not armed with firearms," ASK said. Those killed were not part of the demonstrations, the report quoted family members as saying. The organisation said the military declined to comment on its findings. The non-profit also said authorities had made "mass arrests during combing operations, including in areas that had not been involved in the clashes, including that of 18 children." Some of the children were imprisoned under the anti-terrorism law, the report added. The interim government under Muhammad Yunus has formed an inquiry commission to investigate the violence.


Economic Times
3 hours ago
- Economic Times
Thailand vs Cambodia: As border fight escalates, one army resembles a toy against the other's war machine; Military mismatch explained
Synopsis Recent armed clashes between Cambodia and Thailand, the worst in over a decade, have spotlighted their military disparity. Thailand, with a $5.73 billion defence budget and 360,000 personnel, dwarfs Cambodia's $1.3 billion budget and 124,300 troops. Thailand's air force boasts F-16 fighters, while Cambodia lacks fighter jets. Thailand vs Cambodia: One has fighter jets, the other doesn't, the military gap that could decide the clash Tensions that had been simmering for months between Cambodia and Thailand erupted into armed conflict on Thursday, the worst skirmish between the two Southeast Asian neighbours in over a decade. With even a Thai F-16 fighter jet reportedly deployed, the latest flare-up has reignited interest in how the two countries compare a breakdown of the military capabilities of Cambodia and Thailand, based on data from the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS). Cambodia maintains a defence budget of $1.3 billion and fields 124,300 active personnel. The Royal Cambodian Armed Forces, formed in 1993 through a merger of former Communist and resistance groups, rely heavily on ground troops. The Cambodian army consists of around 75,000 soldiers, supported by 200+ battle tanks and 480 artillery contrast, Thailand boasts a significantly larger and better-funded force. With a 2024 defence budget of $5.73 billion and over 360,000 active personnel, Thailand's military dwarfs its neighbour's. The Thai army alone has 245,000 personnel, including 115,000 conscripts, and is equipped with 400 tanks, 1,200+ armoured personnel carriers, and 2,600 artillery air force is relatively modest, just 1,500 personnel, 10 transport planes, and 10 helicopters. It doesn't operate any fighter jets. The most notable aircraft in its fleet include 16 multi-role helicopters, with six Soviet-era Mi-17s and 10 Chinese Z-9s. On the other hand, Thailand's air force is among the best equipped in the region. With 46,000 personnel, it commands 112 combat-capable aircraft, including 28 F-16 Fighting Falcons and 11 Swedish Gripens. Its arsenal also includes surveillance drones and a fleet of transport and attack helicopters, including several U.S.-made Black navy is modest, with 2,800 personnel (including 1,500 naval infantry), 13 patrol/coastal vessels, and a single amphibious landing navy is a maritime heavyweight by comparison. With nearly 70,000 personnel, it includes naval aviation, coastal defence units, marines, and conscripts. Its fleet features: 1 aircraft carrier 7 frigates 68 patrol and coastal vessels Amphibious ships and landing craft capable of transporting hundreds of troops Its marine corps alone has 23,000 troops, supported by armoured vehicles and aviation assets such as helicopters and UAVs. While Cambodia has made steady investments in its armed forces, it remains significantly outmatched by Thailand in terms of manpower, equipment, and budget. Thailand's position as a major non-NATO ally of the United States ensures access to high-end military hardware and training. Inputs from Reuters

Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Saudi, Qatar, Kuwait Praise France's Palestine Move; GCC Backs Macron's Recognition Plan
'As Deep As the Sea': Modi's BIG 'Mahasagar' Diplomacy Message To China With Mega Maldives Deals Prime Minister Narendra Modi, speaking alongside Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu, declared that India's friendship with Maldives runs 'deep as the sea.' As both nations celebrate 60 years of diplomatic ties, PM Modi announced a $565 million Line of Credit, pledged continued defence support, and launched talks for a landmark Free Trade Agreement (FTA). With initiatives like direct Rupee-Rufiyaa trade and UPI-based transactions expanding rapidly, India is cementing its economic and cultural footprint in the Indian Ocean. A commemorative stamp release, showcasing traditional boats, reflected shared heritage. PM Modi declared 'Friendship First' as the guiding spirit of ties, even as President Muizzu praised India's vital role. This visit marks a strategic reboot in South Asia's geopolitics and soft power diplomacy, sending a strong message to rivals in the region. Watch how Modi turned a cultural celebration into a powerful policy pitch.#pmmodi #narendramodi #modispeech #pmmodilive #modiinmaldives #indiamaldives #maldives #mohamedmuizzu #modimuizzu #lineofcredit #freetradeagreement #diplomacy #strategicaid #indianoceanstrategy #housingprojects #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews 95 views | 1 hour ago