Can Israel Disable Iran's Fordow Without US Help? Some Say Yes.
Its military lacks the heavy bombs and B-2 stealth jets needed to penetrate the uranium enrichment hall at the Fordow site hidden deep under a mountain near the holy city of Qom, whose destruction is viewed as key.
But there is a competing view and it was expressed by a top Israeli official, speaking on condition of anonymity: There are many options still on the table, this official replied, when asked how the mission could be achieved without the bunker busters in the US arsenal.
Yaakov Amidror, a former Israeli national security adviser to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said the same on Wednesday — without providing details — that without the US, Israel will find a creative solution to taking out Fordow.
A more official version of this was uttered by Israeli National Security Adviser Tzachi Hanegbi in a radio interview this week. He said Israel can and will do it alone.
Some outside experts agree. One is David Albright, founder and president of the Institute for Science and International Security in Washington.
Asked by Tablet Magazine this week whether Israel could do the job alone, he replied:
'Yeah, I think so. They could mine it during a commando raid. They could potentially crack the ceiling or undermine the support structure of the halls. They can make it very difficult to get into. Effectively that's destroying it, if you can't get in without months and months of work. Then when you get in, it's more than likely most of the centrifuges are going to be broken.'
His reference to a commando raid is something others have focused on, including Kenneth Pollack of the Middle East Institute. They point to an operation Israeli troops carried out last September in Syria before former President Bashar al-Assad was driven from power.
What Bloomberg Analysts Say...
'If the US won't enter the conflict, Israel could still choose to pursue a high-risk ground operation to breach and destroy Fordow from within. Any such operation would face enormous challenges — logistical complexity, long-distance travel deep into Iranian territory, and the risk of engagement with well-armed Iranian forces.'
— By Adam Farrar and Jennifer Welch
— to read more click here
The raid wasn't publicly revealed till four months later. Then, the Israeli military offered details along with video taken during the raid. According to military spokesmen, 120 special forces were accompanied by dozens of aircraft striking deep in Syria. The raid eliminated what they said was an Iranian missile-production site deep in a mountainside.
The footage showed Israeli troops moving through a concrete-lined tunnel while being overseen by military officials inside an Israeli command center.
The raid has been widely praised for its daring in Israel, including by Netanyahu, and has been suggested as a model for a Fordow hit.
Another possibility: if Israel eliminates Iran's air defense system around Fordow, as it says it's doing, its own F-35s and F-15s, carrying not 30,000-pound but 2,000- and 4,000-lb bombs, could carry out repeated strikes over the site, eventually penetrating it.
All options involve risks, including US aircraft with their massive loads. But Israel argues that the greatest risk is leaving Iran's nuclear facilities intact and in the hands of the current government. And it says no matter what the US decides, its own operation won't stop until it achieves its goal.
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
9 minutes ago
- India.com
Indian Rupee Strengthens Against Us Dollar Despite Tariff Concerns
New Delhi: The Indian rupee opened stronger on Monday, amid additional 25 per cent tariff proposed by US President Donald Trump on India, which is set to take effect from August 27. The rupee likely inched up higher on optimism that the Russia-Ukraine war will end following the upcoming US-Russia negotiations on August 15, leading to removal of additional tariffs on India. The local currency opened 13 paise stronger at 87.53 against the US dollar up from 87.66 on Friday. The immediate trading range is expected to be between 87.25 and 87.80, according to analysts. The Indian rupee was expected to open with small gains today at 87.51, while markets are awaiting US and domestic inflation data. Indian markets are focused on domestic CPI and WPI inflation data, set to be released on August 12 and August 14. Additional tariffs, if implemented, are expected to put pressure on the Indian rupee against the US dollar in the short term due to reduced export revenues, capital outflows, and inflationary pressures. US' new tariffs on India are expected to affect sectors such as textiles, leather, and seafood. India sharply criticised the tariffs, calling it "unfair and unreasonable". US has singled out India for the harshest tariff rate of 50 per cent, compared to 30 per cent for China and 15 per cent for Turkey, despite all three countries importing Russian oil. Brent oil prices dropped to $66.25 per barrel in Asian trade on Monday morning, continuing last week's significant declines as traders anticipated upcoming talks between Russia and the US will ease the Ukraine conflict. China released soft inflation data and economic indicators in July, indicating that the economy was recovering slowly, leaving oil markets largely pessimistic about future demand. FII selling persisted during the week in Indian equity markets, indicating broader risk aversion in emerging markets. However, ongoing purchases by DIIs helped mitigate losses.
Mint
9 minutes ago
- Mint
Nvidia, AMD agree to pay 15% of Chinese AI chip revenues to US for export licenses
(Bloomberg) -- Nvidia Corp. and Advanced Micro Devices Inc. agreed to pay 15% of their revenues from Chinese AI chip sales to the US government in a deal to secure export licenses, an unusual arrangement that may unnerve both US companies and Beijing. Nvidia plans to share 15% of the revenue from sales of its H20 AI accelerator in China, according to a person familiar with the matter. AMD will deliver the same share from MI308 revenues, the person added, asking for anonymity to discuss internal deliberations. The arrangement reflects US President Donald Trump's consistent effort to engineer a financial payout for America in return for concessions on trade. His administration has shown a willingness to relax trade conditions like tariffs in return for giant investment in the US — as with Apple Inc.'s pledge to spend $600 billion on domestic manufacturing. But such a narrow, select export tax has little precedent in modern corporate history. Beijing, which has grown increasingly hostile to the idea of Chinese firms deploying the H20, is unlikely to warm to the idea of a chip tax. Yuyuantantian, a social media account affiliated with state-run China Central Television that regularly signals Beijing's thinking about trade, on Sunday slammed the chip's supposed security vulnerabilities and inefficiency. 'This seeming quid pro quo is unprecedented from an export control perspective. The arrangement risks invalidating the national security rationale for U.S. export controls,' said Jacob Feldgoise, a researcher at the DC-based Center for Security and Emerging Technology. It 'will likely undermine the US' position when negotiating with allies to implement complementary controls,' he added. 'Allies may not believe U.S. policymakers if they are willing to trade away those same national security concerns for economic concessions — either from U.S. companies or foreign governments.' An Nvidia spokesperson said the company follows US export rules, adding that while it hasn't shipped H20 chips to China for months, it hopes the rules will allow US companies to compete in China. AMD didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. The Financial Times earlier reported the development. It followed a separate report from the same outlet that the Commerce Department had begun issuing H20 licenses last week, days after Nvidia Chief Executive Officer Jensen Huang met with Trump. Huang has lobbied long and hard for the lifting of restrictions, arguing that walling China off will only slow the spread of American technology and encourage local rivals such as Huawei Technologies Co. 'It's a strategic bargaining chip' that tightens Washington's grip on a critical tech sphere during trade negotiations with China, said Hebe Chen, an analyst with Vantage Markets in Melbourne. 'Over time, this hurdle for chips entering China will likely deter Nvidia and AMD from deeper expansion in the world's largest chip-importing market, while giving local Chinese producers a clear edge to capture market share and accelerate domestic semiconductor innovation.' If Washington goes ahead with the tax, it should funnel some capital to the US — but not an enormous amount in relative terms. Both Nvidia and AMD have said it'll take time to ramp back up production of their China-specific products — even if order levels return to previous levels, which is uncertain. Nvidia raked in $4.6 billion of revenue from the H20 in the fiscal quarter ended April 27 — days after new restrictions on shipping the AI accelerator to China were imposed. It also said it had been unable to ship $2.5 billion of H20 China revenue in that period because of the new rules. That implies it would have got more than $7 billion in H20 sales to China during the period. If it can return to that level, the US government will stand to get about a billion dollars a quarter from its deal. AMD could generate $3 billion to $5 billion of 2025 revenue if restrictions were lifted, Morgan Stanley estimates. Chinese alternatives such as Huawei's Ascend chips now account for 20% to 30% of domestic demand, it reckoned. 'The US government clearly needs the money given its deficits and eagerness to collect tariffs,' said Vey-Sern Ling, managing director at Union Bancaire Privee in Singapore. 'But the complication is China's accusations about H20 chips containing backdoors, which could be a negotiation tactic to highlight that the country is not 'hard up' for US chips.'
NDTV
12 minutes ago
- NDTV
Who Was Anas Al-Sharif, Al Jazeera Journalist Killed In Israeli Strike On Gaza
Palestinian journalist Anas Al-Sharif was killed late Sunday in an Israeli strike on a tent sheltering press members outside Gaza City's al-Shifa Hospital. The 28-year-old, a well-known correspondent for Al Jazeera Arabic, died alongside four colleagues. Moments before his death, Mr Al-Sharif was reporting on intense Israeli "fire belt" bombardments in Gaza City. A final post on his X account, described as his "last will and testament," read, "If these words reach you, Israel has succeeded in killing me and silencing my voice... I have never hesitated to convey the truth as it is, without falsification or distortion." Mr Al-Sharif reported extensively from northern Gaza. In his last message, he hoped to return to his family in Ashkelon but said, "God's will was supreme." Who Was Anas Al-Sharif? Born in Jabalia refugee camp, Anas Al-Sharif was a Palestinian journalist and videographer for Al Jazeera Arabic. He was known for his fearless frontline coverage from northern Gaza during Israel's ongoing war on Palestine. He graduated from Al-Aqsa University with a degree in mass communication, specialising in radio and television. He began as a volunteer at Al-Shamal Media Network before becoming Al Jazeera's northern Gaza correspondent. In November 2023, Mr Al-Sharif said he received phone calls from Israeli forces warning him to leave northern Gaza, along with WhatsApp messages and voice notes revealing his exact location. "Despite the threats, I will not leave the field. I will continue reporting from north Gaza," he said. A month later, his 90-year-old father was killed in an Israeli airstrike on their Jabalia home. In January this year, during live coverage of the Israel-Hamas ceasefire, he removed his protective gear to celebrate as cheering crowds lifted him onto their shoulders. For months, the Israeli military accused him of being a Hamas operative. These allegations, human rights groups and Al Jazeera said, were Israeli attempts to justify targeting journalists. The Committee to Protect Journalists urged global protection for him. Al Jazeera called him "one of Gaza's bravest journalists." He was married to Bayan Khalid and had two children - Sham and Salah. Israeli strikes have killed over 200 reporters and media workers in Gaza since October 2023.
