logo
88% of Israeli war crimes investigations end without charges, watchdog says

88% of Israeli war crimes investigations end without charges, watchdog says

Yahoo03-08-2025
Israel has closed nearly nine out of ten investigations into alleged war crimes and abuses by its forces in Gaza and the West Bank without any charges or findings of wrongdoing, according to a report by a conflict monitor.
Data from conflict monitor Action on Armed Violence (AOAV) shows Israel has closed 88 per cent of cases into alleged war crimes and abuses by its forces in Gaza and the occupied West Bank without filing charges or finding wrongdoing.
The organisation examined 52 incidents publicly acknowledged by the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) or reported in international media between October 2023 and June 2025. These cases accounted for 1,303 Palestinian deaths, 1,880 injuries and two allegations of torture.
AOAV found only one investigation resulted in a prison sentence – a seven-month term for a reservist filmed abusing detainees at Sde Teiman detention centre in February this year.
Five other inquiries concluded violations had occurred, but led only to internal reprimands. The remaining 46 cases – seven closed with no findings of fault and 39 still unresolved – 'suggest a pattern of impunity', AOAV said in its report.
'These figures show a system that overwhelmingly shields its forces from accountability even in the most serious, public cases,' Iain Overton and Lucas Tsantzouris, the team at AOAV, wrote.
Among the high-profile cases still under review is the February 2024 killing of at least 112 Palestinians queueing for flour in Gaza City, a May strike on a Rafah tent camp that killed 45 people, and the 1 June deaths of 31 civilians heading to a food distribution point in Rafah.
The IDF said all 'exceptional incidents' where laws of war may have been breached are assessed by a dedicated fact-finding team before any referral to military police.
In a statement included in AOAV's analysis, the army said: 'Any report, complaint or allegation that suggests misconduct by IDF forces undergoes an initial examination process, irrespective of its source.'
However, critics say the system is slow, opaque and rarely leads to trials. Israeli rights group Yesh Din told AOAV that just one prosecution came from 664 complaints linked to previous Gaza operations between 2014 and 2021.
One of the most scrutinised cases in the current war involved the April 2024 drone strike that killed seven World Central Kitchen aid workers, despite them travelling in clearly marked vehicles with their movements coordinated in advance.
The IDF later called it 'a grave mistake', dismissed two officers and reprimanded others, but no criminal charges were brought.
AOAV said unresolved cases include four fatal incidents last month alone near food distribution points in Gaza.
The report concludes that Israel's investigations 'fall far short of international standards for independent, transparent inquiries into alleged war crimes', warning that internal reviews allow the country to resist external legal scrutiny while victims are left without justice.
The Independent has reached out to the IDF for comment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Trump administration wants to end the UN peacekeeping in Lebanon. Europe is pushing back
The Trump administration wants to end the UN peacekeeping in Lebanon. Europe is pushing back

San Francisco Chronicle​

time4 minutes ago

  • San Francisco Chronicle​

The Trump administration wants to end the UN peacekeeping in Lebanon. Europe is pushing back

WASHINGTON (AP) — The future of U.N. peacekeepers in Lebanon has split the United States and its European allies, raising implications for security in the Middle East and becoming the latest snag to vex relations between the U.S. and key partners like France, Britain and Italy. At issue is the peacekeeping operation known as UNIFIL, whose mandate expires at the end of August and will need to be renewed by the U.N. Security Council to continue. It was created to oversee the withdrawal of Israeli troops from southern Lebanon after Israel's 1978 invasion, and its mission was expanded following the monthlong 2006 war between Israel and the militant group Hezbollah. The multinational force has played a significant role in monitoring the security situation in southern Lebanon for decades, including during the Israel-Hezbollah war last year, but has drawn criticism from both sides and numerous U.S. lawmakers, some of whom now hold prominent roles in President Donald Trump's administration or wield new influence with the White House. Trump administration political appointees came into office this year with the aim of shutting down UNIFIL as soon as possible. They regard the operation as an ineffectual waste of money that is merely delaying the goal of eliminating Hezbollah's influence and restoring full security control to the Lebanese Armed Forces that the government says it is not yet capable of doing. After securing major cuts in U.S. funding to the peacekeeping force, Secretary of State Marco Rubio signed off early last week on a plan that would wind down and end UNIFIL in the next six months, according to Trump administration officials and congressional aides familiar with the discussions. It's another step as the Trump administration drastically pares back its foreign affairs priorities and budget, including expressing skepticism of international alliances and cutting funding to U.N. agencies and missions. The transatlantic divide also has been apparent on issues ranging from Israel's war against Hamas in Gaza and the Russia-Ukraine conflict to trade, technology and free speech issues. Israel has for years sought an end to UNIFIL's mandate, and renewal votes have often come after weeks of political wrangling. Now, the stakes are particularly high after last year's war and more vigorous opposition in Washington. European nations, notably France and Italy, have objected to winding down UNIFIL. With the support of Tom Barrack, U.S. ambassador to Turkey and envoy to Lebanon, they successfully lobbied Rubio and others to support a one-year extension of the peacekeeping mandate followed by a time-certain wind-down period of six months, according to the administration officials and congressional aides, who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss private diplomatic negotiations. Israel also reluctantly agreed to an extension, they said. The European argument was that prematurely ending UNIFIL before the Lebanese army is able to fully secure the border area would create a vacuum that Hezbollah could easily exploit. The French noted that when a U.N. peacekeeping mission in Mali was terminated before government troops were ready to deal with security threats, Islamic extremists moved in. With the U.S. easing off, the issue ahead of the U.N. vote expected at the end of August now appears to be resistance by France and others to setting a firm deadline for the operation to end after the one-year extension, according to the officials and congressional aides. French officials did not respond to requests for comment. The final French draft resolution, obtained by The Associated Press, does not include a date for UNIFIL's withdrawal, which U.S. officials say is required for their support. Instead, it would extend the peacekeeping mission for one year and indicates the U.N. Security Council's 'intention to work on a withdrawal.' But even if the mandate is renewed, the peacekeeping mission might be scaled down for financial reasons, with the U.N. system likely facing drastic budget cuts, said a U.N. official, who was not authorized to comment to the media and spoke on condition of anonymity. One of the U.S. officials said an option being considered was reducing UNIFIL's numbers while boosting its technological means to monitor the situation on the ground. The peacekeeping force has faced criticism There are about 10,000 peacekeepers in southern Lebanon, while the Lebanese army has around 6,000 soldiers, a number that is supposed to increase to 10,000. Hezbollah supporters in Lebanon have frequently accused the U.N. mission of collusion with Israel and sometimes attacked peacekeepers on patrol. Israel, meanwhile, has accused the peacekeepers of turning a blind eye to Hezbollah's military activities in southern Lebanon and lobbied for its mandate to end. Sarit Zehavi, a former Israeli military intelligence analyst and founder of the Israeli think tank Alma Research and Education Center, said UNIFIL has played a 'damaging role with regard to the mission of disarming Hezbollah in south Lebanon.' She pointed to the discovery of Hezbollah tunnels and weapons caches close to UNIFIL facilities during and after last year's Israel-Hezbollah war, when much of the militant group's senior leadership was killed and much of its arsenal destroyed. Hezbollah is now under increasing pressure to give up the rest of its weapons. U.N. spokesman Stephane Dujarric said UNIFIL continues to discover unauthorized weapons, including rocket launchers, mortar rounds and bomb fuses, this week, which it reported to the Lebanese army. Under the U.S.- and France-brokered ceasefire, Israel and Hezbollah were to withdraw from southern Lebanon, with the Lebanese army taking control in conjunction with UNIFIL. Israel has continued to occupy five strategic points on the Lebanese side and carry out near-daily airstrikes that it says aim to stop Hezbollah from regrouping. Lebanon supports keeping UN peacekeepers Lebanese officials have called for UNIFIL to remain, saying the country's cash-strapped and overstretched army is not yet able to patrol the full area on its own until it. Retired Lebanese Army Gen. Khalil Helou said that if UNIFIL's mandate were to abruptly end, soldiers would need to be pulled away from the porous border with Syria, where smuggling is rife, or from other areas inside of Lebanon — 'and this could have consequences for the stability' of the country. UNIFIL 'is maybe not fulfilling 100% what the Western powers or Israel desire. But for Lebanon, their presence is important,' he said. The United Nations also calls the peacekeepers critical to regional stability, Dujarric said. UNIFIL spokesperson Andrea Tenenti said deciding on the renewal of the mandate is the prerogative of the U.N. Security Council. 'We are here to assist the parties in implementation of the mission's mandate and we're waiting for the final decision,' he said.

Trump could trigger a financial crisis in Russia — if he wants to — but has backed off from his threat of ‘very severe consequences'
Trump could trigger a financial crisis in Russia — if he wants to — but has backed off from his threat of ‘very severe consequences'

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Trump could trigger a financial crisis in Russia — if he wants to — but has backed off from his threat of ‘very severe consequences'

President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin ended their meeting in Alaska on Friday without a ceasefire deal. Despite Trump's earlier threat that Moscow would face 'very severe consequences' if the summit didn't produce an agreement, he said he would hold off on imposing new sanctions. But a tougher U.S. crackdown on tankers delivering Russian oil would cripple Putin's war machine, an expert said. The U.S. holds immense leverage over Russia's economy and ability to continue waging war on Ukraine, but President Donald Trump has backed off from earlier warnings that lack of progress on a ceasefire would result in harsh penalties for Moscow. Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin ended their highly anticipated meeting in Alaska on Friday without a deal. On Saturday, Trump shifted his stance toward reaching a more comprehensive peace agreement between Russia and Ukraine, mirroring Putin's position, rather than a ceasefire. He also reportedly backed Putin's idea for Ukraine to give up territory it holds in exchange for a Russian promise that it won't attack again. That marked a big swing from his rhetoric leading up to the Alaska meeting, as he threatened 'very severe consequences' for Russia if Putin didn't agree to a ceasefire. When asked why he didn't follow through, Trump said he would hold off on any new penalties and suggested the threat remains on the table as diplomacy plays out. 'Because of what happened today, I think I don't have to think about that now,' he told Fox News. 'I may have to think about it in two weeks or three weeks or something, but we don't have to think about that right now.' Trump had previously warned Russia's oil sector could face secondary sanctions. Oil and gas generate the bulk of the Kremlin's revenue, and the U.S. could exploit this critical vulnerability. In particular, cutting off the 'shadow fleet' of tankers that deliver Russia's oil under the radar would send the war economy into a 'deep financial crisis,' according to Robin Brooks, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and former chief economist at the Institute of International Finance. After the Biden administration sanctioned nearly 200 ships in January, just before Trump returned to office, their activity collapsed, he pointed out in a Substack post on Saturday. But there are 359 more ships that have already been sanctioned by the European Union or United Kingdom, but haven't been targeted yet by the U.S. 'Sanctioning these ships would be a hammer blow to the Russian war machine,' Brooks wrote. 'There would undoubtedly be a sharp fall in the Urals oil price, reducing the flow of hard currency to the Russian state, and the Ruble would most likely depreciate significantly.' Meanwhile, foreign policy expects have called the Alaska meeting a success for Putin as he was able to avoid severe consequences from Trump while also buying time for his military to make more battlefield gains in Ukraine. But Melinda Haring, a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center, also noted that Trump has significant leverage over Russia. 'Let's hope that Trump sees through Putin's endless appetite to talk and tires of the Russian dictator's pseudo-historical lectures,' she wrote in a blog post. 'Trump can squeeze the Russians; he seems to forget that the United States holds the cards, not Moscow.' Oil and gas revenue tumbled 27% in July from a year ago, and Russia is running out of financial resources as war-related spending deepens its budget deficit. The National Wealth Fund, a key source of reserves, has dwindled from $135 billion in January 2022 to just $35 billion this past May and is expected to run out later this year. 'Russia's economy is fast approaching a fiscal crunch that will encumber its war effort,' economist and Russia expert Anders Åslund wrote in a Project Syndicate op-ed last week. 'Though that may not be enough to compel Putin to seek peace, it does suggest that the walls are closing in on him.' This story was originally featured on

IDF prepares to relocate residents to southern Gaza, spokesperson says
IDF prepares to relocate residents to southern Gaza, spokesperson says

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

IDF prepares to relocate residents to southern Gaza, spokesperson says

Defense Minister Israel Katz said on Saturday that the plans for the new offensive were still being formulated. Gaza residents will be provided with tents and other shelter equipment starting from Sunday ahead of relocating them from combat zones to safe ones in the south of the enclave, the IDF announced on Saturday. This comes days after Israel said it intended to launch a new offensive to seize control of northern Gaza City, the enclave's largest urban center, in a plan that raised international alarm over the fate of the demolished strip, home to about 2.2 million people. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday said that before launching the offensive, the civilian population will be evacuated to what he described as "safe zones" from Gaza City, which he called Hamas' last stronghold. The shelter equipment will be transferred via the Kerem Shalom crossing in southern Gaza by the United Nations and other international relief organizations after being inspected by defense ministry personnel, the military said. Resources for Palestinian civilians The military declined to comment when asked whether the shelter equipment was intended for Gaza City's population estimated at around one million people presently, and whether the site to which they will be relocated in southern Gaza would be the area of Rafah, which borders Egypt. Defense Minister Israel Katz said on Saturday that the plans for the new offensive were still being formulated. However, the IDF has already increased operations on the outskirts of Gaza City over the past week. Residents in the neighborhoods of Zeitorun and Shejaia have reported heavy Israeli aerial and tank fire which has destroyed many houses. The Israeli military on Friday said that it had begun a new operation in Zeitun to locate explosives, destroy tunnels and kill terrorists in the area. Solve the daily Crossword

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store