FIFA moves ahead with new human rights strategy for World Cup games, but advocates are skeptical
With the games less than a year away, though, FIFA's commitment to upholding human rights is still under scrutiny. Human rights advocates who wanted more enforceable standards and clearer directions for local officials say FIFA watered down a more robust model for the plans.
'Even though where we landed is very different than what we had consulted them on, the existence of the framework is in many ways unprecedented. Sports bodies have not had human rights frameworks that reflected the breadth of issues covered across so many jurisdictions. But the plan is just a plan. It's not self-executing,' said Jennifer Li, director of the O'Neill Institute's Center for Community Health Innovation at Georgetown Law and national coordinator of the Dignity 2026 Coalition, which is working with FIFA on human rights.
Adding to advocates' unease, several U.S. host committees said they couldn't meet a March deadline for an early draft of their plans. A FIFA spokesperson said the governing body has been working closely with host cities and counties, which they say are on track to develop final action plans by the Aug. 29 deadline. Sixteen North American sites will host games, including 11 in the U.S.
Human rights concerns in North America look different from those in other countries where FIFA has come under fire, which had few protections for workers and massive stadium and transportation construction projects. Migrant workers labored in Qatar's scorching heat for more than a decade before the 2022 World Cup there, and human rights advocates worry migrant workers' lives are again at risk in Saudi Arabia, which will host the games in 2034.
FIFA's suggestions for the 2026 plans include guidelines on nondiscrimination, security, preventing trafficking, protecting unhoused people and workers' rights, including for migrant workers.
'The host communities are quite invested in their legacy, so they've stepped up,' said labor rights expert Deborah Greenfield, who is in an expert advisory group supporting FIFA's human rights work for 2026.
Local tensions rise
U.S. President Donald Trump has ramped up immigration enforcement across the country, stirring fears that federal law enforcement officers will arrest workers and even travelers during the games. Trump imposed a travel ban on 12 countries in June, and seven face restrictions.
FIFA President Gianni Infantino has close ties to Trump. A FIFA spokesperson said it is working with a White House task force to 'bring millions of people from different nations and communities' together in the U.S.
Protesters in Miami-Dade County gathered outside FIFA's offices in June to demand that the governing body protect travelers and workers and speak out against Trump's immigration moves. That came after a Club World Cup event hosted in the area by Spanish-language TV network Telemundo was canceled after an unexpected Coast Guard inspection involving at least one Border Patrol agent, local outlets reported.
'There's no guarantee that you might not have ICE posted up at the World Cup," South Florida AFL-CIO President Jeff Mitchell said.
Local organizers don't seem to have their human rights plan ready and haven't agreed to meet with the union, Mitchell said. He noted that the region has a history of wage theft in a state with weak heat protection laws for workers.
'Organizations like FIFA like to say that they have these human rights efforts, but they aren't pushing it,' Mitchell said. 'They're leaving it up to the locals to do it. What tends to happen is everybody gets their bag and then they turn a blind eye to making sure people are getting paid properly or not being harassed.'
Miami-Dade officials referred The Associated Press to the local host committee, which did not respond to requests for comment.
More than 9,000 unhoused people were arrested when Atlanta prepared to host the Olympics in 1996, and a plan to eliminate homelessness downtown before the World Cup worries advocates that unhoused people will be jailed again.
Atlanta officials and partners say the Downtown Rising plan is a part of the mayor's larger investments in reducing homelessness and building affordable housing. The goal is to house people, not put them in jail, officials say.
In California, Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom called on cities to ban encampments in May and offered money for mental health and substance use treatment. Cities with impending sporting events have ramped up enforcement, including San Jose, where unhoused people who reject three offers of shelter will now be eligible for arrest on trespassing charges. The mayor said the policy would encourage people to move inside.
'This panic rush to disappear visible signs of poverty is very concerning,' said Dr. Mark Spencer, an Atlanta hospital physician involved in local advocacy. 'Politicians and the business community know that visible signs of poverty are unpopular, and that's the driving force behind what is happening. It's not about human rights in any meaningful way.'
Working to address standards
FIFA's human rights policy published in 2017 mandates bidders for the men's 2026 World Cup to respect 'international human rights and labor standards according to the United Nations' guiding principles.'
A group of international lawyers filed a formal complaint to FIFA in May claiming the soccer body is failing to uphold its human rights policy with 2034 World Cup host Saudi Arabia.
In North America, Greenfield said FIFA is taking the goal of having a tournament 'that respects and promotes human rights" seriously and she wouldn't be participating in the effort if she didn't think that was possible.
Candace Stanciel, Atlanta's chief equity officer, said the city was committed to human rights work before FIFA came in and launched efforts to combat human trafficking in airports, hotels and public transport. Officials are working on potential language tools, accessibility measures for people with disabilities and an app to report issues including human rights abuses.
One of Seattle's largest labor organizations and the city's organizing committee signed a labor standards agreement last year. The International Labour Organization called FIFA's human rights framework "an important step forward in harnessing the power of sport to advance decent work globally,' adding that it aligns with international labor standards.
___
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
11 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Charisma seen from space' - Britain's Davis stuns Rabadanov
Britain's Alfie Davis stunned defending champion Gadzhi Rabadanov to win the PFL lightweight tournament by unanimous decision in Charlotte, North Davis landed the more damaging strikes to edge a close contest with all three judges scoring it 48-47 in the 33-year-old's was overcome with emotion as the result was read out as he won $500,000 (£369,000) - a prize he described as "life-changing".He becomes the third Briton to win an annual PFL tournament after featherweight Brendan Loughnane in 2022 and women's flyweight Dakota Ditcheva last year."I don't know what to say, I've worked so hard for this," said Davis."To be a champion like Gadzhi, I respect him and have watched him for so many years – he and his team are amazing. To beat someone like that is a dream come true."Davis reached the final after enjoying the best spell of his 11-year career with wins over Clay Collard and Brent Russia's 32-year-old Rabadanov, however, he was facing last year's champion and a fighter on a 12-fight win said he had suffered from a lack of confidence in the past, but has put that behind him with a string of impressive new-found confidence was on full display as he danced his way to the cage, before being introduced as someone whose "charisma can be seen from space". Following a tentative first round, Rabadanov took control, earning the first takedown of the fight and controlling the action on the who had been on the back foot, started to open up in the third by stifling Rabadanov's pressure with a number of counter the crowd rallied, chanting "Alfie, Alfie", Davis landed an eye-catching spinning elbow, before spending the fourth round on his back following another takedown by the fifth could decide the fight, Davis' team said "win this round, change your life" before the final five minutes, and he delivered by landing the more damaging of victory, Davis ran around the cage with his arms aloft after the final bell before calling for the winner of Russia's Usman Nurmagomedov and Irishman Paul Hughes. Nurmagomedov defends his PFL lightweight belt, which was formerly the Bellator title, in a rematch against Hughes in Dubai on 3 the women's flyweight final, Liz Carmouche knocked out fellow American Jena Bishop before calling for a fight with who has won the first 15 fights of her career, beat Sumiko Inaba in July but is currently recovering from surgery after injuring her hand during the bout. Britain's Fabian Edwards competes in the middleweight final later this month when he faces American Dalton Rosta on 21 August in Hollywood, Florida.
Daily Mail
11 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Teachers applying for jobs in conservative state must sit test to root out 'woke indoctrinators'
Oklahoma is demanding new teachers from liberal states to take a first-of-its-kind assessment aimed at filtering out what officials call ' woke indoctrinators'. The new certification test, developed by conservative media company PragerU, is being administered for the first time ever on Friday and targets aspiring teachers who have relocated from California and New York. State Superintendent Ryan Walters told CNN that any applicant who fails the assessment will be denied a teaching certificate and barred from working in Oklahoma public schools this academic year. 'This keeps away woke indoctrinators,' Walters said. 'We will not allow these leftists' plans and schemes to take place here in Oklahoma. They are trying to warp the minds of our kids to turn them into social justice warriors.' The 50-question, multiple-choice test covers topics ranging from basic U.S. civics to more politically charged issues. One question asks which chromosomes determine biological sex, while another probes the importance of religious freedom in American identity, CNN reported. Walters, 40, said the test reflects Oklahoma's 'standards and values' and is designed to ensure new teachers 'teach history appropriately' and acknowledge the influence of Christianity in the nation's founding. PragerU, which is not an accredited university despite its name, has gained traction among Republican-led states in recent years. Its content has now been approved for use in public schools in ten states - including Alaska, Idaho, South Carolina, Louisiana, Arizona, New Hampshire, Montana, Texas and Florida - and its videos, which are often criticized for promoting misinformation, are widely used in conservative circles. Jonathan Zimmerman, a historian at the University of Pennsylvania, described the move as a 'watershed moment' for PragerU. 'It's actually giving Prager an explicit role. It's official and it's institutionalized,' Zimmerman said. So far, the test applies only to incoming teachers from California and New York, but Walters said it could soon extend to applicants from as many as eight additional states. An aide to the superintendent told CNN that the test will affect a 'fairly large' number of applicants, though specific figures were not provided. The initiative comes amid a teacher shortage in Oklahoma and increased scrutiny of the state's education system, which ranks near the bottom nationally. Critics have argued that the assessment amounts to a 'political loyalty test,' not an evaluation of teaching ability. 'You don't sign up to teach schools because you hate America,' John Waldron, chairman of the Oklahoma Democratic Party and a former teacher, said. 'That's not who's teaching in our classrooms,' he said while calling the test an 'insult to our profession.' At a recent State Board of Education meeting, members raised legal concerns and requested to review the assessment before its rollout. However, Walters declined, insisting he had full authority. 'Every teacher that teaches in the state of Oklahoma will have to have a certificate that goes through my office,' he said. 'It has my signature on it. So those will not move forward until this is done.' According to CNN, who obtained a partial look at the assessment, the test includes questions about the Constitution, U.S. Senate composition, and civics basics, alongside more ideological content. In July, the state education department shared Oklahoma's certification standards with PragerU, which then compared them with California and New York requirements to build the test. 'You're gonna teach that there's biological differences between males and females, period,' Walters said. 'We want our students to be patriots. Here in Oklahoma, our academics are going to be grounded in fact.' PragerU CEO Marissa Streit said the goal is to 'undo the damage of gender ideology' and align with the values of Oklahoma's parent community. Walters, a vocal supporter of President Donald Trump, has also previously mandated the teaching of the Bible in schools as a historical document.
Reuters
11 minutes ago
- Reuters
X-rays negative on Phillies RHP Jhoan Duran's ankle
August 16 - Philadelphia Phillies closer Jhoan Duran, carted off the field on Friday in Washington after being hit by a one-hopper on his right ankle, underwent X-rays that were negative. The team announced that Duran would undergo further evaluation on Saturday. Duran entered in the ninth inning of the Phillies' road game against the Washington Nationals, with Philadelphia up 6-2. On Duran's fourth pitch, Paul DeJong hit a hard grounder that struck the pitcher and bounced toward the first base line. Duran came off the mound and raced toward the ball before slowing down and then stopping. He spoke with manager Rob Thomson and the club's trainers before finally exiting the field after a long delay. "He ran like a shot over to retrieve the ball, and then once he got there, I think the adrenaline wore off and the pain set in," Thomson said. "Before the cart came out, it took a long time and he said, 'I feel better, I think I can walk over to the dugout.' But there's all these steps here and we wanted to use the cart." David Robertson took over on the mound and allowed a double to Luis Garcia Jr. before retiring the next three batters to end the game. Duran, 27, was acquired by the Phillies on July 30 from the Minnesota Twins in exchange for right-handed reliever Mick Abel and minor league catcher Eduardo Tait. One of the majors' hardest-throwing pitchers, Duran is 4-for-4 in save chances for his new club with a 0.00 ERA in four innings. Overall this year, he has 20 saves in 22 opportunities with a 1.86 ERA in 54 appearances. He has 56 strikeouts and 18 walks in 53 1/3 innings. In four major league seasons, the first 3 1/2 with the Twins, Duran is 78-for-87 on save chances with a 17-23 record and a 2.42 ERA in 227 appearances, all in relief. --Field Level Media
