'SC had legitimised martial laws'
A seven-member CB led by Justice Aminuddin Khan on Thursday resumed hearing the intra-court appeals filed against October 2023 order of a Supreme Court bench that declared trial of May 9 rioters in military courts null and void.
During the proceedings, the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) submitted its written arguments to the court. According to the submissions, the SCBA held a meeting on March 5 to deliberate on its stance regarding military courts.
The association stated that, in principle, civilian trials should not be conducted in military courts. It further noted that the provisions of the Pakistan Army Act, 1952 have been upheld as constitutional in judicial interpretations and cannot be declared void at this stage.
The SCBA said terrorism has intensified and that Pakistani citizens deserve peace and harmony. Therefore, all constitutional and legal measures should be directed toward eradicating terrorism.
Representing the Lahore Bar Association and the Lahore High Court Bar Association, lawyer Hamid Khan argued that the Pakistan Army Act was introduced in May 1952 when Pakistan was governed under the Government of India Act.
He said the country's first constitution was enacted in 1956, introducing fundamental rights for the first time, adding that the Pakistan Army Act, 1952 was first amended in 1967.
He said the first conspiracy case in Pakistan, the Rawalpindi Conspiracy Case, was initiated in 1951.
Justice Hasan Azhar Rizvi noted that even figures like poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz were implicated in the Rawalpindi Conspiracy Case. Continuing his arguments, Hamid Khan stated that to prosecute the accused, the Rawalpindi Conspiracy Special Trial Act of 1951 was introduced.
The objective of the conspiracy was to establish a communist system in Pakistan. The accused included both military personnel, such as General Akbar Khan, and civilians. However, their trial was not conducted in a military court but under a special tribunal.
At this point, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail questioned the relevance of these historical examples to the current military trial case, asking what connection the imposition of martial law had with the present case. "The Constitution does not allow for martial law," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
No Air Force One yet; optics secured
The writer is an Economist based in Islamabad. For insights and updates, follow on Twitter: @SalmanAneel or reach out via email at aneelsalman@ Is he coming or not? The question is hanging in Islamabad's diplomatic air like smog before monsoon. No official itinerary. No confirmation. And yet, the entire capital is abuzz with speculation, prepping for the possibility that Donald J Trump may soon be setting foot on Pakistani soil — with a camera crew in tow. Top media outlets have already done the classic Islamabad two-step: break the story, then retract it. The White House issued a dry-as-toast denial: "No trip scheduled at this time." But with Trump, absence of confirmation often is the confirmation. Denial, after all, is part of the build-up. Because Trump is not a president in the conventional sense. He is a performer playing a president, on a stage where policy is the prop and optics are the plot. Let's rewind the show. In June, Trump rolled out the red carpet for Pakistan's Army Chief at the White House — a move so unorthodox under a civilian government that even the most seasoned analysts blinked twice. Then came the hammer on India. First a 25% tariff, and then an additional 25% blow for Delhi's ongoing flirtation with Russian oil. And in the same breath, Trump was touting a "massive oil exploration deal" with Pakistan. He even brokered the Indo-Pak ceasefire in May which he keeps mentioning in his speeches. This isn't diplomacy. It's pageantry, choreographed to disrupt the old order while staging a new one — centred entirely around Trump. If the visit materialises, expect theatre. Not handshakes over policy documents, but a fireworks display of "deals" and declarations. A press conference about American companies exploring Pakistan's untapped oil reserves — even if the oil's more rumour than resource. Trump doesn't care about whether deals are signed or implemented. He cares that the announcement makes a splash. And he'll certainly paint the Pakistan visit as a strategic masterstroke. "We punished India, and look — Pakistan welcomed us." Expect a trade narrative: crypto, IT, minerals. Expect energy promises. Expect vintage Trump logic, where tariffs on one partner prove that another was the better option all along. He may even try to revive his peace-broker persona. Cue a speech at a local university, maybe even a soundbite about deserving the Nobel Prize. But beneath the showmanship, Pakistan must ask: what's really on offer? This is where we need to be careful. Trump is not pivoting to Pakistan because of shared values or vision. He's pivoting because we're currently the convenient headline. In this moment, Islamabad is not the favourite — it's the foil. And the minute the optics shift, so will the attention. So how should Pakistan play it? First, keep it real. If Trump wants a show, let him have it — but behind the curtains, ask for substance. Frame every conversation with facts, feasibility, and follow-up. Announcements are nice. Agreements are better. Second, use the spotlight. Push for serious engagement in energy, rare earths, Fintech. Pitch ourselves not as a hedge against India, but as a regional hub with value beyond geopolitics. Third, protect the sovereignty clause. This is not the moment to nod along to every soundbite. Make sure any cooperation is framed around mutual benefit — not someone else's election season optics. Finally, think beyond Trump. Engage Congress. Reconnect with think tanks. Make the case to American institutions that Pakistan isn't a wildcard, but a partner with a plan. Trump is just one act in the American playbook. We should be speaking to the full cast. Whether Air Force One lands or not, the stage is already set. The visit may be imaginary, but the impact isn't. For now, Trump has recast Pakistan not as a pariah, but as a possibility. For a transactional politician, that's as close to a compliment as it gets. And so we wait. For the motorcade that may never arrive. For the handshake that may remain hypothetical. But most of all, for the headlines that — confirmed visit or not — have already shifted the South Asian narrative. In the end, this is classic Trump. Promise big. Say little. Deliver drama. Whether or not Air Force One touches down at Nur Khan, one thing is clear: Trump's foreign policy was never about alliances. It was always about audience. And right now, Pakistan is in the spotlight. Let's not miss the cue.
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Pakistan joins 'Global Sumud Flotilla' for Gaza aid
A three–six member Pakistani delegation, comprising doctors, media professionals, and social leaders, is participating in the Global Sumud Flotilla—an international mission aimed at breaking the siege of Gaza and delivering urgent humanitarian and medical assistance to Palestinians. This was announced by Pakistan Palestine Forum leader Wahaj Ahmed during a press conference at the National Press Club Islamabad, alongside Dr Osama Riaz, Ismail Khan, Syed Aziz Nizami, and Fahad Ishtiaq, who are part of the delegation, according to a press release issued last week. Read More: Thousands evacuate homes as fears of Israeli ground offensive grow in Gaza Ahmed further said that several prominent and active pro-Palestinian organisations in Pakistan have formed an alliance called the Palestine Action Coalition of Pakistan, which includes Blockout Tehreek, Pak Palestine Forum, Shaab Abi Talib Foundation, Youth Link Pakistan, Pakistan for Palestine, Together for Al-Quds, and others. Delegation members pledged to highlight Israeli atrocities and stand in solidarity with Palestinians, expressing their readiness to make any sacrifice for the cause. Delegations from 44 countries are participating in the mission, which also includes human rights activists and medical experts.
Business Recorder
11 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan rupee registers 8th successive gain against US dollar
Rupee's Performance Against US Dollar Since 04 March 2025 The Pakistani rupee maintained its upward trend against the US dollar, appreciating 0.02% in the inter-bank market on Tuesday. At close, the rupee settled at 281.96, a gain of Re0.06. This is rupee's eighth successive gain agaisnt the greenback. On Monday, the local unit had closed the session at 282.02. Globally, the US dollar held steady against its major peers on Tuesday as global markets awaited the outcome of a White House summit with European nations that could determine the next phase of the war in Ukraine. The dollar index rose 0.31% to 98.122 with geopolitical events taking centre stage, after US President Donald Trump told President Volodymyr Zelenskiy on Monday that the United States would help guarantee Ukraine's security in any deal to end the war with Russia. The euro held steady at $1.1667 , up 0.06% so far in Asia, shuffling along the midpoint of the trading range it has sat in for the past two weeks. Markets are seeking direction this week from the Federal Reserve's annual symposium in Jackson Hole on the likely path of interest rates. Fed Chair Jerome Powell is due to speak on the economic outlook and the central bank's policy framework. Oil prices, a key indicator of currency parity, slipped in early Asian trade on Tuesday as market participants contemplated planned three-way talks among Russia, Ukraine and the US to end the war in Ukraine, which could lead to an end to sanctions on Russian crude. Brent crude futures fell 7 cents, or 0.11%, to $66.53 a barrel by 0000 GMT. US West Texas Intermediate crude futures for September delivery, set to expire on Wednesday, fell 6 cents, or 0.09%, to $63.36 per barrel. The more active October WTI contract was down 9 cents, or 0.14%, at $62.61 a barrel.
