Michigan House Holds Secretary of State Benson in Contempt for Defying Subpoena
The contempt
The resolution was introduced by chairman of the House Oversight Committee Rep. Jay DeBoyer, a Republican, who said he put it forward after receiving word from the Michigan department of state that it would not be providing any additional materials.
'The Legislature is the body that determines how elections are run—the time, the manner, the place,' DeBoyer said in a May 22
Benson, a Democrat, responded on May 22 in a
'However, I also have a duty to protect the security of our elections from politicians seeking information that would enable someone to interfere with the chain of custody of ballots, tamper with election equipment, or impersonate a clerk on Election Day.'
Related Stories
6/4/2024
3/22/2024
The training materials in question are those provided to local clerks instructing them on ballot handling, voter file access, and equipment protocols across the state.
Rep. Joseph Fox, the Republican vice-chair of the House Election Integrity Committee, said in a
House Republicans suggested that elected representatives be granted secure
The department of state instead
According to Michigan
Michigan state Rep. Rachelle Smit.
Courtesy of Rachelle Smit
State Rep. Rachelle Smit, a Republican, said she has served as a clerk, 'and like thousands of other clerks, I had access to this information. My accessing it now shouldn't be controversial.'
'For seven months, we've given Secretary Benson every opportunity to sit down with us and discuss the training process for clerks and their staffs,' Smit said in a
Benson also said her office has 'repeatedly asked the members of the committee to meet with us over the last several months. They have refused.'
Disagreement Over Transparency and Security
The action follows numerous losses by Benson in state court rulings since 2020 that her guidance violated state and federal election law, as previously
Smit said legislative oversight of Benson's election administration is necessary because 'the training directives given by Secretary Benson have been deemed unlawful by Michigan courts seven times ... Secretary Benson has a proven record of failure, and the public deserves to check her work.'
Benson said the issue is a need to balance transparency and oversight with security.
'I do not work for the chair of the Oversight Committee. I do not work for the House Republicans. I work for the people of Michigan and I will not put their election security, or their votes, or their voices at risk,' she said.
'I look forward to now having this conversation in front of a judge in a court of law.'
House Democrat Leader Ranjeev Puri did not respond to a request for comment by publication time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
a minute ago
- Newsweek
Donald Trump Compares Himself to Richard Nixon in New Post
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. President Donald Trump drew comparisons with former Republican President Richard Nixon when he posted a photo of himself pointing at Russian President Vladimir Putin in a side-by-side with Nixon doing the same with Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev. Trump has previously compared himself publicly to Nixon in interviews, saying he learned from Nixon and contrasted his own political support to what he described as Nixon's lack of backing during his downfall, according to Forbes. Newsweek reached out to the White House by email on Thursday for comment. Why It Matters Trump met with Putin in Anchorage, Alaska, last week to discuss the invasion of Ukraine and seek a way towards a peace deal. Many criticized the president both for his red carpet rollout to greet the Russian president as well as the aftermath, which saw Trump walk away without a deal after saying that he would see such a result as a failure. The two world leaders spoke for two-and-a-half hours and addressed details of a potential ceasefire, and they took no questions immediately after the talks ended. US President Donald Trump smiles during a meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European leaders in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC, on August 18, 2025. US President Donald Trump smiles during a meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European leaders in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC, on August 18, 2025. Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP via Getty Images What To Know Trump has vigorously defended his summit with Putin, writing on Truth Social on Sunday: "It's incredible how the Fake News violently distorts the TRUTH when it comes to me. There is NOTHING I can say or do that would lead them to write or report honestly about me. I had a great meeting in Alaska on Biden's stupid War, a war that should have never happened!!!" However, the criticism has persisted even as Trump works towards a potential trilateral meeting that would bring Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky face-to-face for the first time since the invasion started in 2022. Trump again defended his "peace through strength" approach by posting a picture of himself and Putin in a mirror to one of Nixon and Khrushchev. He wrote nothing in the post. Photo comparison posted by President Donald Trump on Truth Social showing himself and Russian President Vladimir Putin in juxtaposition with a photo of President Richard Nixon meeting Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev. Photo comparison posted by President Donald Trump on Truth Social showing himself and Russian President Vladimir Putin in juxtaposition with a photo of President Richard Nixon meeting Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev. via President Donald Trump Truth Social On Truth Social, the president's native platform, many praised Trump with their own meme responses, with many of those posts repeating the "peace through strength" line that the president has used in the past while also denigrating former Democratic Presidents Barack Obama and Joe Biden. On X, opinions varied more, with some finding the comparison unflattering – not because of Nixon's history, which saw him resign from the presidency after his involvement in the Watergate scandal emerged, but because of the way Nixon and Trump have each approached their respective Russian counterparts. Phillips P. Obrien, a professor of Strategic Studies at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, wrote that the "remarkable thing about these pictures Trump just tweeted is that he thinks people won't see the difference between Nixon and Khrushchev disagreeing and he and Putin joking. Putin is clearly laughing." Another user highlighted that Khrushchev and Putin themselves are representative of different geopolitical approaches, with Khruschev responsible for returning Crimea to Ukraine while Putin annexed the region in 2014. What People Are Saying President Donald Trump, in a subsequent Truth Social message, wrote: "It is very hard, if not impossible, to win a war without attacking an invader's country. It's like a great team in sports that has a fantastic defense, but is not allowed to play offense. There is no chance of winning! It is like that with Ukraine and Russia. Crooked and grossly incompetent Joe Biden would not let Ukraine FIGHT BACK, only DEFEND. How did that work out? Regardless, this is a war that would have NEVER happened if I were President - ZERO CHANCE. Interesting times ahead!!! President DJT." Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky wrote on X, in part: "Now, each day carves out the contours of future security architecture for Ukraine. Weapons, funds, cooperation with partners, forces on the ground, in the air, and at sea. And every day, there will be new steps taken by partners to support Ukraine. Thank you to everybody helping." French President Emmanuel Macron earlier this week wrote on X: "In Washington, alongside President Zelensky and with our partners, we reiterated to President Trump our commitment to continue uniting our efforts for a strong and lasting peace that preserves Ukraine's interests and the security of Europeans. This peace will necessarily involve providing Ukraine with robust security guarantees, on which we have decided to work very concretely with the United States. It is also clear in our minds that pressure on Russia must continue as long as this peace has not been established."
Buzz Feed
30 minutes ago
- Buzz Feed
Newsom Claps Back At Bed Bath & Beyond's California Boycott
One word to describe Gavin Newsom these days is — unfiltered. The Governor of California and his team have been openly mocking Republicans from his Press Office X account... And rage-baiting MAGA with culture war posts... Well, Newsom's latest target is the retail chain Bed Bath & Beyond, which is officially making a comeback after filing for bankruptcy and closing all 360 stores in 2023. The retail chain's executive chairman, Marcus Lemonis, recently announced that the franchise will not open any new stores in the state of California. Lemonis wrote in a recent X post that the decision wasn't about politics, but rather "reality," citing "higher taxes, higher fees, and higher wages" in California as the main issues. "California's system makes it nearly impossible for businesses to succeed, and I won't put our company, our employees, or our customers in that position," Lemonis wrote. Well, Newsom's response is going viral. People are loving it in the replies. "I just cackled I'm sorry," this person commented. "lmfaooooo idgaf just make him president already. We deserve to go down as a nation with a hot sassy bitch from California," another person wrote. What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments below.
The Hill
30 minutes ago
- The Hill
Vance bashes CBO report on Trump bill fueling inequality: ‘Very atrocious'
Vice President Vance bashed the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) on Thursday over a recent analysis that showed President Trump's 'big, beautiful bill' will make the poorest Americans even poorer, while benefiting the highest earners. While speaking at an industrial refrigeration manufacturing facility in Peachtree City, Ga., about the policy package, Vance criticized the CBO assessment in his response to a question on how he justifies the impact on the poorest Americans. 'First of all, the Congressional Budget Office, sometimes they put out reports that are absolutely atrocious and I think this is a good example of a very atrocious report,' he said to applause from the crowd. The CBO report, which was done at the request of Democrats, found that the top 10 percent of earners in the country will see an average boost of $13,600 per year over the next decade as a direct result of provisions in the law, while the bottom 10 percent will see an average annual decrease of $1,200. Vance continued to tout the benefits of the law, including no tax on tips and on overtime. 'The most important thing for people who are living at the bottom of the income ladder is that they not pay taxes on their income sources,' the vice president said. He added, 'So, if you're working hard and you're working overtime, you're going to get a big fat tax cut. If you're working at a restaurant or some other business where you're earning your wages primarily through tips, you're going to get a big fat tax cut. And most importantly, the president's economic policies are going to prevent your job from being shipped off to Asia or to Mexico. That is the very best thing for people at the bottom of the income ladder.' During his remarks in Georgia, Vance also said 'if you're working hard the government ought to leave you alone.' The CBO report challenges the Trump administration and congressional Republicans' argument that the law will benefit workers at all levels of wealth and income. The administration has been referring to it recently as Trump's 'working families tax cuts' instead of the 'big, beautiful bill.'
