logo
‘I was the first person to survive rabies without a vaccination'

‘I was the first person to survive rabies without a vaccination'

Metro14 hours ago

It was a normal Sunday for Jeanna Giese in her hometown of Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, and began in the same manner as it usually did, with a trip to church with her family.
However, an unexpected turn of events that day in September 2004 left the 15-year-old fighting for her life against a fatal disease.
A wild bat had got into the church and caused havoc as it tried to escape through the stained glass windows. As worshippers listened to the sermon, they swatted at the bat with their hats as it frantically flew over their heads. One usher's powerful hit saw the bat crash to the floor.
Jeanna had always loved animals and the teenager felt sorry for the 'stunned' creature, so after gaining her mum's permission, carried it outside.
'I found a pine tree I thought would be perfect to let it rest on, but before I could, it clamped down hard on my finger. The puncture mark was no bigger than a pinprick, but it oozed blood and was very painful,' Jeanna recalled in an interview with The Guardian.
She pulled the bat's fang out of her left index finger, and once home, her mother cleaned the wound with antiseptic. The incident was surreal, but they never suspected for a moment that things would spiral far out of their control.
It was around three weeks later, that Jeanna felt severely unwell. 'I woke up and I could not get out of bed, my face was flush, I could hardly move,' she later told Fox News.
As she began vomiting uncontrollably and suffering double vision, her concerned parents took Jeanna to the nearby St. Agnes Hospital, where doctors were baffled as to what was wrong with her. Tests for diseases, including meningitis and Lyme Disease, provided negative results, so eventually Jeanna was sent home.
However, her symptoms only got worse and two days later she returned to hospital with her parents and was kept in overnight. When her mother mentioned the bat bite to a doctor, he looked visibly concerned.
Quickly, Jeanna was transferred to the Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, where she met Dr. Rodney Willoughby, a pediatric doctor specialising in infectious diseases, who tested her for rabies.
The next day it was confirmed that she had contracted the deadly disease- but it was too late for the life-saving rabies vaccine, which needs to be administered before symptoms. Nobody had ever survived without it.
Talking about his patient, Dr Willoughby later admitted to Fox News: 'I thought she was going to die. That's what they all did. That's about the extent of my knowledge of rabies at the time, that there wasn't much to do. It's really 100% fatal.'
Jeanna's mother and father were given the stark choice of leaving their daughter to die in the hospital or at home, 'My parents were devastated. The whole thing happened so quickly that they couldn't process it,' she would recall later.
However, Dr. Rodney refused to give up and suggested putting Jeanna into a coma to suppress her brain function, which would give her immune system a chance to fight the rabies virus.
Usually, the virus travels to the brain through the nerves and spinal cord, causing the body to shut down, but it was hoped his radical treatment plan could slow the process.
Almost exactly one month after the bite, Jeanna was placed into a coma on October 10, and was woken up two weeks later.
'I tried to scream, but no sound came out. I couldn't walk, talk, sit up or do anything,' she remembered. 'I was basically a newborn baby at the age of 15. I couldn't do anything.'.
The teenager spent 11 weeks in the hospital and then two years at the outpatient therapy unit so she could relearn the basic skills. It took two months to walk again, and two years without any help.
'Since I was, at that point, the only person to have survived rabies without a vaccine, I became a global news sensation and had to work on my recovery with film crews documenting every minute. It was overwhelming. What helped was the support from my family and the doctors, as well as letters from all over the world,' she explained.
'While not every case has had the same positive outcome, it is incredible that there is now a chance of surviving a disease once considered fatal without a vaccination. I am overjoyed to know that I helped pave the way for that change.'
Following Jeanna's case, there have been 45 known survivors of rabies – 18 of whom went through what's now called the Milwaukee Protocol, a medically induced coma and antiviral drugs.
However, while the method was celebrated for saving the teenager's life, it was also deemed controversial by some, who questioned the ethics of using an unproven treatment on a child without truly knowing the potential risks and side effects of the treatment.
Dr Suzanne Wylie, GP and medical adviser for IQdoctor, told Metro: 'Multiple attempts to reproduce this outcome have failed. In at least three documented cases, patients who received the same treatment have died.
'The virus uses sophisticated tactics to avoid immune detection. Interestingly, wild strains of rabies replicate more slowly than lab-altered ones, which may help them spread silently and avoid triggering a full immune response.
'Given these complexities, many experts now view the Milwaukee Protocol as a drastic and unreliable measure. The survival of the original patient may have had more to do with a weaker form of the virus or unusual genetic resistance than with the treatment itself.' More Trending
Dr Wylie adds that the key takeaway is that rabies is preventable, but through immediate vaccination after exposure: 'Public education, animal vaccination, and timely medical care are the most reliable ways to stop this deadly virus before it takes hold.'
Now 36 and a mother of three, Jeanna still suffers from nerve damage following her ordeal. However, she manages to live a happy life, working at the Children's Museum of Fond du Lac and raising awareness about rabies in the hope of reducing the number of cases.
Jeanna also volunteers for bat conservation charities.
View More »
'One might have nearly taken my life, but I feel it's still my duty to protect theirs,' she has since explained, adding, 'A lot of people are astonished that I actually love bats.'
'Rabies is a fatal but preventable disease. Although cases in UK travellers are very rare, a recent tragic case underscores the importance of awareness and timely treatment,' says Dr Chris Smith of the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine (LSHTM). This week, British grandmother Yvonne Ford, 59, died of rabies after she was scratched by a puppy while on a Morocco holiday in February.
'The disease is endemic in many parts of the world, including popular holiday destinations such as Morocco, Turkey, India, Thailand, the Philippines, and Indonesia.
All human rabies cases reported in the UK since 1902 have been acquired abroad: typically through dog bites. Since 1946, 26 imported cases have been reported, with the most recent prior to this being in 2018, following a bite from a cat in Morocco.
'Travellers to countries where rabies is present should seek pre-travel advice regarding vaccination.
'Rabies is usually transmitted to humans through the bite or scratch of an infected animal, most often dogs, but also cats and bats. Even a minor scratch or lick on broken skin can pose a risk.
'If exposed, immediate first aid is essential: the wound should be thoroughly washed with soap and water, and prompt post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) – including a course of rabies vaccinations and, in some cases, rabies immunoglobulin – should be sought. These interventions are highly effective when started early.'
Do you have a story you'd like to share? Get in touch by emailing Josie.Copson@metro.co.uk
Share your views in the comments below.
MORE: I'm twice my daughter's age but everyone thinks we're sisters
MORE: I never gave up on my Olympic dream – even when fleeing my home
MORE: Urgent recall for chicken fettuccine alfredo 'linked to three deaths and a pregnancy loss'
Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘I was the first person to survive rabies without a vaccination'
‘I was the first person to survive rabies without a vaccination'

Metro

time14 hours ago

  • Metro

‘I was the first person to survive rabies without a vaccination'

It was a normal Sunday for Jeanna Giese in her hometown of Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, and began in the same manner as it usually did, with a trip to church with her family. However, an unexpected turn of events that day in September 2004 left the 15-year-old fighting for her life against a fatal disease. A wild bat had got into the church and caused havoc as it tried to escape through the stained glass windows. As worshippers listened to the sermon, they swatted at the bat with their hats as it frantically flew over their heads. One usher's powerful hit saw the bat crash to the floor. Jeanna had always loved animals and the teenager felt sorry for the 'stunned' creature, so after gaining her mum's permission, carried it outside. 'I found a pine tree I thought would be perfect to let it rest on, but before I could, it clamped down hard on my finger. The puncture mark was no bigger than a pinprick, but it oozed blood and was very painful,' Jeanna recalled in an interview with The Guardian. She pulled the bat's fang out of her left index finger, and once home, her mother cleaned the wound with antiseptic. The incident was surreal, but they never suspected for a moment that things would spiral far out of their control. It was around three weeks later, that Jeanna felt severely unwell. 'I woke up and I could not get out of bed, my face was flush, I could hardly move,' she later told Fox News. As she began vomiting uncontrollably and suffering double vision, her concerned parents took Jeanna to the nearby St. Agnes Hospital, where doctors were baffled as to what was wrong with her. Tests for diseases, including meningitis and Lyme Disease, provided negative results, so eventually Jeanna was sent home. However, her symptoms only got worse and two days later she returned to hospital with her parents and was kept in overnight. When her mother mentioned the bat bite to a doctor, he looked visibly concerned. Quickly, Jeanna was transferred to the Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, where she met Dr. Rodney Willoughby, a pediatric doctor specialising in infectious diseases, who tested her for rabies. The next day it was confirmed that she had contracted the deadly disease- but it was too late for the life-saving rabies vaccine, which needs to be administered before symptoms. Nobody had ever survived without it. Talking about his patient, Dr Willoughby later admitted to Fox News: 'I thought she was going to die. That's what they all did. That's about the extent of my knowledge of rabies at the time, that there wasn't much to do. It's really 100% fatal.' Jeanna's mother and father were given the stark choice of leaving their daughter to die in the hospital or at home, 'My parents were devastated. The whole thing happened so quickly that they couldn't process it,' she would recall later. However, Dr. Rodney refused to give up and suggested putting Jeanna into a coma to suppress her brain function, which would give her immune system a chance to fight the rabies virus. Usually, the virus travels to the brain through the nerves and spinal cord, causing the body to shut down, but it was hoped his radical treatment plan could slow the process. Almost exactly one month after the bite, Jeanna was placed into a coma on October 10, and was woken up two weeks later. 'I tried to scream, but no sound came out. I couldn't walk, talk, sit up or do anything,' she remembered. 'I was basically a newborn baby at the age of 15. I couldn't do anything.'. The teenager spent 11 weeks in the hospital and then two years at the outpatient therapy unit so she could relearn the basic skills. It took two months to walk again, and two years without any help. 'Since I was, at that point, the only person to have survived rabies without a vaccine, I became a global news sensation and had to work on my recovery with film crews documenting every minute. It was overwhelming. What helped was the support from my family and the doctors, as well as letters from all over the world,' she explained. 'While not every case has had the same positive outcome, it is incredible that there is now a chance of surviving a disease once considered fatal without a vaccination. I am overjoyed to know that I helped pave the way for that change.' Following Jeanna's case, there have been 45 known survivors of rabies – 18 of whom went through what's now called the Milwaukee Protocol, a medically induced coma and antiviral drugs. However, while the method was celebrated for saving the teenager's life, it was also deemed controversial by some, who questioned the ethics of using an unproven treatment on a child without truly knowing the potential risks and side effects of the treatment. Dr Suzanne Wylie, GP and medical adviser for IQdoctor, told Metro: 'Multiple attempts to reproduce this outcome have failed. In at least three documented cases, patients who received the same treatment have died. 'The virus uses sophisticated tactics to avoid immune detection. Interestingly, wild strains of rabies replicate more slowly than lab-altered ones, which may help them spread silently and avoid triggering a full immune response. 'Given these complexities, many experts now view the Milwaukee Protocol as a drastic and unreliable measure. The survival of the original patient may have had more to do with a weaker form of the virus or unusual genetic resistance than with the treatment itself.' More Trending Dr Wylie adds that the key takeaway is that rabies is preventable, but through immediate vaccination after exposure: 'Public education, animal vaccination, and timely medical care are the most reliable ways to stop this deadly virus before it takes hold.' Now 36 and a mother of three, Jeanna still suffers from nerve damage following her ordeal. However, she manages to live a happy life, working at the Children's Museum of Fond du Lac and raising awareness about rabies in the hope of reducing the number of cases. Jeanna also volunteers for bat conservation charities. View More » 'One might have nearly taken my life, but I feel it's still my duty to protect theirs,' she has since explained, adding, 'A lot of people are astonished that I actually love bats.' 'Rabies is a fatal but preventable disease. Although cases in UK travellers are very rare, a recent tragic case underscores the importance of awareness and timely treatment,' says Dr Chris Smith of the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine (LSHTM). This week, British grandmother Yvonne Ford, 59, died of rabies after she was scratched by a puppy while on a Morocco holiday in February. 'The disease is endemic in many parts of the world, including popular holiday destinations such as Morocco, Turkey, India, Thailand, the Philippines, and Indonesia. All human rabies cases reported in the UK since 1902 have been acquired abroad: typically through dog bites. Since 1946, 26 imported cases have been reported, with the most recent prior to this being in 2018, following a bite from a cat in Morocco. 'Travellers to countries where rabies is present should seek pre-travel advice regarding vaccination. 'Rabies is usually transmitted to humans through the bite or scratch of an infected animal, most often dogs, but also cats and bats. Even a minor scratch or lick on broken skin can pose a risk. 'If exposed, immediate first aid is essential: the wound should be thoroughly washed with soap and water, and prompt post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) – including a course of rabies vaccinations and, in some cases, rabies immunoglobulin – should be sought. These interventions are highly effective when started early.' Do you have a story you'd like to share? Get in touch by emailing Share your views in the comments below. MORE: I'm twice my daughter's age but everyone thinks we're sisters MORE: I never gave up on my Olympic dream – even when fleeing my home MORE: Urgent recall for chicken fettuccine alfredo 'linked to three deaths and a pregnancy loss' Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.

Houseplant clinic: why has my aloe vera gone floppy?
Houseplant clinic: why has my aloe vera gone floppy?

The Guardian

time3 days ago

  • The Guardian

Houseplant clinic: why has my aloe vera gone floppy?

What's the problem? I thought it was nearly impossible to kill aloe plants, but mine looks very pale and limp. Diagnosis You're right; aloe vera is famously resilient and seen as an easy plant to care for. But all plants are living entities with specific care needs. Pale, floppy leaves usually indicate overwatering, inadequate sunlight, or poor drainage, which all cause the same problem: too much moisture in the soil. Aloe plants store water in their thick leaves, so any excess easily causes root rot and weak growth. Prescription Check the soil; if wet and dense, repot your aloe in fresh, free-draining compost mixed with perlite or pumice. Move it to a brighter location with indirect sunlight, as too little light will result in the soil being wetter for longer. It also causes weak, stretched growth. Finally, allow the soil to dry thoroughly between waterings. Prevention Ideally, plant your aloe in cacti and succulent soil in a pot with a drainage hole. Place it in a bright spot with indirect sunlight, and water sparingly. Your aloe should regain its sturdy, vibrant form. Green fingers crossed! Got a plant dilemma? Email saturday@ with 'Houseplant clinic' in the subject line

Is drinking tap water bad for you? Wellness influencers say yes, but here's what the experts think
Is drinking tap water bad for you? Wellness influencers say yes, but here's what the experts think

The Independent

time4 days ago

  • The Independent

Is drinking tap water bad for you? Wellness influencers say yes, but here's what the experts think

Concerns about the safety and purity of UK tap water are no longer confined to the comment sections of influencers with conspiratorial or fringe ideas. An increasing number of British consumers are now filtering their water, worried that it might be unsafe to drink. Investigations by The Guardian, Watershed Investigations, and the Drinking Water Inspectorate (DWI) have revealed the presence of potentially harmful substances – specifically PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, also known as 'forever chemicals ') – in drinking water sources used by 17 out of 18 English water companies. The findings have raised significant questions about long-term exposure to such contaminants and prompted renewed scrutiny of the UK's water infrastructure. From countertop filtration systems and under-sink reverse osmosis units to purifying showerheads and portable bottles, there are now several ways to filter your tap water at home. Some of these solutions are expensive – costing more than £2000 – but they claim to transform potentially harmful water into safe, drinkable, even health-boosting H2O. But is the concern around our tap water justified, and do these domestic filtration products offer any meaningful protection? I grew up in an old house, with my mum telling me never to drink from the hot tap in case there was a dead pigeon in the tank in the loft, or in case the hot water dislodged some slime in the Victorian pipes. We had a filter installed, and I assumed all people had these concerns around tap water – I was met with blank stares when I warned the room about the pigeon risk at a sleepover when I was 14. I love to drink water, but I've always been sensitive to its flavour – the mineral content, the provenance; as a health writer, these things interest me. For years, I used a Brita filter, but after reading a study about microplastics found in UK tap water – despite claims that treatment facilities are able to remove more than 99 per cent – I switched to some heavier-duty technology: the Skuma countertop water filter. The Skuma uses three-stage reverse osmosis to remove microplastics, chemicals, and heavy metals, and then infuses the water with the helpful, health-giving minerals it stripped out. I'm not so obsessive that I would start arguing with my dentist if handed a cup of tap water to rinse with, like I have seen some American wellness influencers do on Instagram. I wouldn't turn down a drink if it had been made with tap water, but I am more mindful about what I'm drinking when I can help it. Though the UK maintains some of the highest regulatory standards for drinking water globally, a growing body of research points to the presence of emerging contaminants – including microplastics, industrial chemicals, heavy metals, and pharmaceutical residues – in our water supply. Many of these substances are still not yet regulated under UK or EU law, despite growing evidence of potential links to hormonal disruption, developmental issues, liver toxicity, and certain cancers. 'I was really focused on microplastics, PFAS, and other substances that weren't being widely reported on,' says Charles Robinson, founder of water filtration company Water2. 'I remember asking scientists at UCL whether, if they were in charge, they would allow this – and the answer was a clear 'no'.' Robinson funded independent research through labs in Italy and the UK to develop a filtration system capable of removing contaminants at the sub-micron level. His first-generation filter launched in 2023 and was subsequently backed by survivalist and TV personality Bear Grylls. 'A standard filter jug may filter particles down to around 200 microns,' Robinson explains. 'A human hair is about 70 microns for comparison. Our filters work down to 0.1 microns, capturing most microplastics, which typically range from 1 to 10 microns.' A team of research scientists behind The Water Professor – an organisation offering laboratory water testing kits for home use – explain: 'Smaller particle size may be important for the blood-brain defences against microplastics. In the study on the cognitive decline of mice contaminated with microplastics, the particle sizes were between 0.1 and 2 microns. 'The current understanding of toxicity associated with microplastics suggests that size does matter; smaller microplastics will find it easier to pass through tissue layers and could be absorbed through the stomach and lungs, entering deep into the body.' They also point to early studies suggesting that particles below 25 microns can pass through biological barriers and accumulate in organs, causing adverse effects. Larger particle sizes are less likely to have toxic effects since they are unable to pass through biological membranes. Logic then follows that high-tech filters able to sift out smaller microplastics will be better for you than something like a filter jug. The Water Professor's research also suggests that bottled water, on average, contains a higher concentration of smaller microplastics and could be worse for humans than previously thought, which is why opting for glass or metal bottles might also be the healthier choice. However, filtration is not without trade-offs. It might sound like a perfect solution, but some high-powered systems, such as reverse osmosis units, can also strip water of essential minerals like magnesium and calcium. These nutrients are linked to bone health, cardiovascular function, and even skin health, so their presence in water is important. 'It would be easy to assume that pure H2O is the gold standard,' says Robinson. 'But distilled or over-filtered water can actually be less beneficial if it lacks mineral content. The challenge is reducing harmful contaminants while preserving key elements.' Many people choose to add electrolytes to filtered water to ensure at least one glass contains a recommended daily allowance of vitamins and minerals. It's a smart workaround – and one that I personally employ every morning. However, there are concerns around these kinds of products too. Nutritionists frequently warn of the dangers of taking too many supplements and overloading the body, so be mindful of whether you actually need electrolytes and how much of a product you're using. Public health authorities continue to assert that UK mains water is safe to drink. But as Robinson and The Water Professor point out, 'safe' does not necessarily mean optimal, particularly given the pace at which chemical pollutants, synthetic compounds, and microplastics are entering the global water cycle. The Water Professor researchers explain that the most common plastic materials contributing to micro- and nanoplastics in water are polyvinyl chloride (PVC), polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polystyrene (PS) and polyethylene (PE), along with toxic chemicals such as per-and poly fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS ) and BPA. PFAS are commonly associated with non-stick cookware, as well as cosmetics, food packaging and outdoor clothing. These chemicals are also known as 'forever chemicals' because they don't break down easily and can build up in the environment, leading to potential risks for both wildlife and humans. Last year, researchers at Birmingham University found that the combined effects of PFAS with microplastics led to greater harm. After studying their effects on water fleas, they noted delays in sexual maturity and stunted growth. Their study paves the way for future research on how these chemicals might affect gene function, providing crucial insights into long-term biological impacts not only on aquatic species but on humans too. Menstrual health brand Asan recently reported that 2.4 million tampons are flushed down UK toilets each day, some of which end up in wastewater systems. Trace fibres and fragments from hygiene products, pharmaceuticals, and plastics are increasingly being detected in tap water, and while the long-term health impacts of these exposures are still under investigation, their ubiquity is raising alarm among environmental scientists and public health researchers. Stephanie Metzger, policy advisor at the Royal Society of Chemistry, has said: 'Here in the UK, we monitor for a long list of PFAS, but we're lagging far behind the US and the EU when it comes to the amount allowed in our drinking water and what is considered healthy. 'We know that PFAS can be filtered from drinking water – the technology exists – so increasing the level of filtration is just a matter of expense and political will. 'In [the regulator] Drinking Water Inspectorate's own words, levels above 10 nanograms per litre pose a medium or high risk to public health. We're seeing more and more studies that link PFAS to a range of very serious medical conditions, and so we urgently need a new approach for the sake of public health.' A 2024 study of London boroughs showed that in Harrow, a water sample had a PFOS (a type of PFAS) level of 14 nanograms per litre (ng/l) – 1.4 times the maximum limit for its presence in tap water under proposals put forward by the RSC. The answer as to whether you should be filtering your water largely depends on the level of risk you are willing to accept. For many, the regulated standard of UK tap water is sufficient. But for those concerned about cumulative exposure to emerging contaminants – or managing specific health conditions – additional filtration may be worth considering. 'It's about making informed choices,' says Robinson. 'Not everyone can afford an expensive system, but a well-made filter that costs under £100 a year can reduce your exposure significantly.' That said, experts caution against assuming that all filters are created equal. Filtering technologies vary significantly in their efficacy. While standard pitcher filters can improve taste and remove some chlorine, only high-performance filters operating below one micron are likely to capture smaller contaminants such as microplastics and certain PFAS. Consumers should look for independently verified performance data, consider the filter's lifespan and replacement costs, and weigh potential losses in mineral content against reductions in harmful substances. Of course, some people resort to filtration to soften hard water, which contains elevated levels of calcium and magnesium. These minerals not only cause the build-up of limescale on appliances and surfaces, but may also affect skin and hair. According to Karlee Oz, founder of Hello Klean, showering in unfiltered water may 'leave residue, contribute to dryness, and exacerbate conditions like eczema,' she explains. 'In addition, hot showers can vaporise chlorine and other disinfectant byproducts, increasing the risk of respiratory exposure and irritation.' Hello Klean's shower filters use KDF (Kinetic Degradation Fluxion) technology to convert chlorine into gentler compounds. Oz emphasises the importance of using filters that are clinically tested and certified for efficacy. 'Filtering reduces the burden on the skin and hair barrier and may improve tolerance over time.' Of course, not all areas in the UK have a hard water problem – and in some cases, softer water may be better for skin and hair – but a filter can still remove heavy metals like lead and cadmium and traces of harmful bacteria like E. coli. For the consumer, it can be complicated. UK tap water meets legal safety standards: it undergoes multiple filtration rounds and was ranked joint first for drinking water quality and sanitation in Yale University's 2022 Environmental Performance Index, along with Finland, Iceland, Norway, Switzerland, and the Netherlands. However, that doesn't mean there is no room for improvement. Research suggests that trace levels of PFAS, microplastics, and other contaminants are present in some supplies. Filtration can reduce exposure to these substances, but must be balanced against the potential loss of essential minerals. Research is still ongoing, but personally, I'll always reach for filtered water, glass bottles, and avoid ice if I can. A filter in my shower has made a noticeable difference too. It's a personal choice – but with microplastics now found in human blood, remote Antarctica, tea bags, and at the bottom of the ocean, I'll do what I can to avoid them in my morning glass of H2O.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store