Sick notes add to pressure on health-care system, Manitoba doctors say
A doctor tends to patients in his office in Illinois on Oct. 30, 2012. (Jeff Roberson / AP)
WINNIPEG — The group that represents physicians across Manitoba is stepping up its campaign to restrict the use of sick notes.
Doctors Manitoba says physicians field requests for more than 600,000 sick notes every year from employees who take time off work, and that takes time away from treating patients.
The group is asking the Manitoba government to follow most other provinces and set limits on how employers can demand sick notes.
The Saskatchewan government passed a law this year that prohibits employers from asking for a sick note unless the employee has been absent for more than five consecutive working days, or has been absent twice for two or more days within a year.
The Manitoba government has said it is considering changes but has not made any commitments.
Doctors Manitoba has launched a new web page and social media video on the topic, along with advice for employers.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 17, 2025
Steve Lambert, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Employers should ditch sick notes to free up physicians, save taxpayers millions: Doctors Manitoba
A physician advocacy organization is underscoring the role Manitoba employers can play in freeing up physicians to spend more time on patient care and less on paperwork by no longer requiring their workers to get sick notes. Eliminating sick notes in cases of short-term illness would add an equivalent of 50 doctors — or 300,000 more patient appointments — to Manitoba's health-care system per year, Doctors Manitoba president Dr. Nichelle Desilets said during a news conference Tuesday. "Every sick note takes time away from patients who need medical care," Desilets said. "That's concerning, because Manitoba currently has the second-worst doctor shortage in the country." More than 600,000 sick notes are requested annually in Manitoba — many of which aren't medically necessary — and they cost taxpayers about $8 million per year, she said. "We are all paying for sick notes, whether it's through our taxes or by waiting longer for the care that we need," said Desilets. The "Sick of Sick Notes" campaign is the latest push from Doctors Manitoba to "make Manitoba more doctor-friendly," in part by reducing administrative burdens. The associated website, created by Doctors Manitoba, includes guidance to help employers navigate cases involving short-term employee absences. A commercial for the campaign critiques and contrasts the current system by showing employees of a fictional business divulging personal health issues to a visibly uncomfortable corporate human resources professional. That's followed by the message, "We don't send medical problems to HR, so why do we send HR issues to the doctor?" Similar sick note campaigns have been launched recently by other Canadian physician advocacy organizations. Earlier this year, Doctors Manitoba recommended the provincial government pass legislation limiting the need for sick notes in cases involving employee absences less than 10 days. In March, Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said they had met with the organization and the province was considering the proposal. Desilets said instituting the change would align Manitoba with other provinces. Newfoundland and Labrador has revised provincial Labour Standards Act provisions that previously required a sick note after three days. Beyond that, employers are allowed to craft their own in-house sick leave protocols. Employers in Nova Scotia can't ask for a note until a worker has been off with an illness for more than five consecutive days. Quebec and Ontario have similar legislation, where the limit is three days. Saskatchewan proposed legislative amendments late last year restricting employers from demanding a note, unless a worker has been absent for five days in a row, or has missed two or more days in a row twice in a calendar year. Encouraging a more 'trusting' workplace culture Desilets said employers want clear legislation to help standardize approaches to legitimate cases involving employees seeking accommodations, return-to-work requests and conditions of recurring illnesses. Tory McNally, a human resources expert and vice-president with Legacy Bowes, said removing the need for routine sick notes also encourages a more "trusting, accountable workplace culture." "From an HR perspective, sick notes have long been seen as a necessary formality, but in practice, they often create more problems than they solve," McNally said. "They don't offer real insight into an employee's ability to work, and they rarely prevent misuse. Instead they add administrative burdens for employers, increase pressure on our health-care system and can even discourage employees from staying at home when they're unwell." The Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, Interlake-Eastern Regional Health Authority and Canada Life are some of the organizations that have already done away with sick notes for short-term illnesses, said Doctors Manitoba. The NDP government has heeded previous calls from Doctors Manitoba to reduce paperwork for physicians, including a commitment shortly after being elected in 2023 to a system-wide overhaul and transition from paper medical records to digital documents.
an hour ago
B.C. court certifies Canada-wide class-action suit against McKinsey for alleged opioid promotion
The B.C. Supreme Court has certified a Canada-wide class-action lawsuit against consultancy firm McKinsey & Company as part of ongoing legal efforts by the province to recover health-care costs relating to the toxic drug crisis. In a judgment posted Friday (new window) , the province alleges the company advised opioid manufacturers and helped design advertising campaigns that led to the over-prescription of opioids. The class-action lawsuit sought by the provincial government — in which it would act as a lead plaintiff, on behalf of other provinces and the federal government — is closely related to another similar lawsuit (new window) that the province is pursuing against pharmaceutical companies for their alleged role in the illicit drug crisis. The poisoned drug epidemic was declared a public health emergency in the province in April 2016, and more than 16,000 people have died in B.C. since then. This photograph taken in April 2022 shows a sign of U.S.-based McKinsey & Company management consulting firm in Geneva. The consultancy firm says it will defend itself against the lawsuit in court. (Fabrice Coffrini/AFP via Getty Images) Photo: (Fabrice Coffrini/AFP via Getty Images) According to the province, McKinsey helped design campaigns for Canadian pharmaceutical companies that made false claims about opioids to prescribers and the public — ultimately causing an over-prescription of addictive drugs and harming those who used them. While Justice Michael Brundrett didn't agree with all of the province's arguments, he found there was enough in its case for it to proceed to a full class-action hearing. While I acknowledge the importance of individual issues, I nevertheless assess that the joint litigation of the proposed common issues will significantly advance judicial economy, he wrote in his judgment. B.C. Attorney General Niki Sharma alleges that McKinsey was underselling the risks associated with opioids and what addictive qualities they had. (Ben Nelms/CBC) Photo: Radio-Canada / Ben Nelms The province, on behalf of other jurisdictions, and McKinsey will now proceed to a trial where the province seeks to recover health-care, pharmaceutical and treatment costs. For its part, McKinsey said the complaint was without merit and it would defend itself in court. McKinsey & Company did not undertake any work in Canada related to the sale or marketing of opioids, a spokesperson said in an email. Province alleges conspiracy In seeking to certify a class-action lawsuit, a plaintiff must prove that the alleged damages done to them are shared by a group of others, and that the group's common issues must be heard in one sitting. The provincial government asserted to the court that McKinsey's actions and advice were consistent across the U.S. and Canada. McKinsey has already admitted to being involved in a U.S. lawsuit (new window) regarding promoting opioids in that country, in which it agreed to pay $600 million US over claims it aided Purdue Pharma in encouraging opioid over-prescription. In addition to linking McKinsey's actions to Purdue Canada, the province further alleged that McKinsey's consultancy north of the border included doing work for other opioid distributors Janssen, Endo, and McKesson. Justice Brundrett wrote that the province's theory was that McKinsey was the effective 'hand in the glove' for the improper promotion of opioid manufacturing. The judge noted that the consultancy firm had raised serious issues as to whether its actions had promoted prescription use in Canada or not. Certification does not involve an assessment of the merits and is not a pronouncement on the viability or strength of the action, the judge wrote. The outcome of certification is not predictive of the outcome of the common issues at trial. AG says lawsuit about accountability B.C. Attorney General Niki Sharma said the action, on behalf of other jurisdictions, was part of her job to hold companies accountable and recover damages on behalf of taxpayers. This is part of a large lawsuit so we can recover what taxpayers had to pay since 1996, because of the health impacts on so many people and the tragic losses that we've suffered in this province, she told CBC News. Leslie McBain, who lost her son Jordan to an oxycodone overdose in 2014, said companies that were marketing opioids in an irresponsible way should be held accountable. However, the advocate and founder of Moms Stop The Harm said governments should devote their attention to tackling the ongoing toxic drug crisis instead. On the one hand. I'm glad to hear this news, she said of the lawsuit. "But on the other hand, it doesn't solve anything right now. Akshay Kulkarni (new window) · CBC News
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
‘Up tick' in cases: Rising threat of Lyme disease in central Ontario
With summer in full swing many are outside enjoying the weather around Simcoe-Muskoka, and while the weather is nice, more residents are reporting finding ticks on them after a day outside. Dr. Charles Gardner, medical officer of health and CEO of Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit (SMDHU), said tick cases continue to increase. 'In 2023, they had 1,800 cases of Lyme disease just over that figure. And that's gone up about six-fold over a decade. So that shows you the trajectory, the upward swing of this and here in Simcoe Muskoka, we had 47 cases in 2024,' Gardner said. Lyme Disease and Symptoms A tick can be as small as a poppy seed and grow depending on how long the bug is latched onto someone's skin. A tick can also carry diseases like Lyme disease. 'Lyme disease is a bacterial infection transmitted by a tick. Blackleg tick, to be precise, and has been becoming more and more common in southern Ontario, specifically, here in Simcoe Muskoka, over the last two to three decades,' Gardner noted. If a tick is latched onto a person's skin it could take weeks for symptoms to develop, including a rash where the tick was. 'You can also develop broader symptoms, such as a fever, muscle aches and pains, joint inflammation, perhaps a stiff neck,' explained Gardner. 'If it remains longer, 30 days or more, you can end up with paralysis of the lower portion of your face, something they call a Bell's palsy that can be on one side or both sides, It can have inflammation of the heart, can develop something called a heart block with a slowing of the heart, arthritis and some neurological symptoms as well, inflammation of the brain, so it's quite serious as it progresses on.' The medical officer of health advised seeking medical attention if a tick has been latched longer than 24 hours. Prevention There are ways to help reduce the risk of a tick latching onto a person, including staying out of heavily weeded or long grass and covering yourself if you are outdoors in similar areas. Checking yourself and children is also heavily recommended. 'Typically, you take a device, tweezers and basically you're clamping at from the mouth parts that are right in - going into the skin and carefully with firm pressure, pulling it out so that you get it out entirely,' said Gardner. Ticks and Pets While tick cases are trending upwards in Simcoe-Muskoka, they are also becoming more common in pets. Dr. Virginia Cornell, veterinarian at Aldergrove Animal Clinic in Barrie, said the increase in ticks on dogs is increasing. 'The per cent of tick-transmitted disease that we're seeing this year has increased, probably about 400 per cent over what we saw in previous years.' She added that ticks are becoming larger in size and with climate becoming warmer there is no die-off. Unlike humans who can show symptoms over a few weeks, it's a different scenario for dogs. Symptoms in Pets 'If you don't find the tick right away on your dog, you probably aren't going to notice the symptoms yourself until your pet starts to show signs,' said Cornell. 'Vague signs of illness, and you end up here seeking medical attention as the symptoms could vary anywhere from your pet, just not feeling well. We might notice a fever. We might notice joint swelling or lameness.' During walks, dogs should avoid heavy brush and long grass. There are also vaccines to help your pets which Cornell said can be treated year-round. Tick Removal 'The most common place that you're going to find ticks are around the face, neck, feet area,' said Dr. Cornell. 'So, check well and if you find a tick, remove it right away. And then if you know that your pet has had a tick bite, a tick exposure about six to eight weeks later, bring your pet in for blood testing so we can see if your pet was exposed to any of the diseases that ticks can transmit.' When removing the tick, its important to remove the tick completely without killing it. 'Ticks are known to regurgitate as they die and the pathogens that they carry are usually contained in their saliva and their stomach contents, so you don't want to kill the tick during the removal process,' said Cornell. Once the tick is removed safely both Gardner and Cornell emphasized the importance of taking a picture of the tick and submit it online so it can be categorized by species and location where it was found.
