Woman found guilty in mushroom murder mystery that left three family members dead after meal
Erin Patterson invited her estranged husband's mother, father, aunt and uncle to lunch at her home in the southern state of Victoria in Australia in July 2023 and served them beef Wellington made with death cap mushrooms.
Patterson, aged 50, told police she must have included the deadly fungi in her recipe by accident. But the trial proved she had lied and tried to hide evidence of her culinary crime by disposing of incriminating evidence.
During the 10-week trial, which dominated headlines Down Under, the jury heard how Patterson had invited the family for lunch under the pretext of revealing a cancer diagnosis.
What To Know About The Fda's Paralytic Shellfish Poisoning Warning
Estranged husband Simon decided at the last minute not to attend, and Patterson was originally also accused of his attempted murder, although she never faced those charges in court.
Read On The Fox News App
Google searches for beef Wellington recipes have soared in Australia over the last few months, as the trial captivated the country.
During Patterson's trial, the jury saw pictures of the leftover beef Wellington and heard how family members had gotten sick and gone to the local hospital, where mushroom poisoning was quickly diagnosed.
They also heard from the sole survivor, her estranged husband's uncle Ian Wilkinson, who testified that Erin had served them beef Wellington with green beans and mashed potatoes in individual portions, but served herself on a different plate.
No traces of the deadly mushrooms were found in her system, and she told police that she was bulimic and had vomited after eating the food.
A doctor who treated the poisoning victims says he had taken one look at her and known something was wrong.
In an interview with Australia's ABC News, Doctor Chris Webster said he had asked Erin Patterson where she had gotten the mushrooms.
Couple Charged In Alleged Cyanide Plot To Kill Ex-girlfriends; Agents Hospitalized During Search
"When she didn't respond in a way that instantly would have explained it as a tragic accident, that's it, from that moment in my mind, she was guilty," he said.
"She was evil and very smart to have planned it all and carried it out, but didn't quite dot every 'i' and cross every 't.'"
Although prosecutors couldn't find a specific motive for the murders, Australian media outlets have reported that Erin, who had worked as an accountant and also an air traffic controller, had resented her ex-husband, Simon, for not doing his share of household chores. In messages to online friends, the triple-murderer said she had had to hire a cleaner because of Simon's refusal to help out around the house. The couple have two children together.
Prosecutors untangled her web of lies about the poisonings, including her claims that she had never been foraging for mushrooms, and that she didn't own a food dehydrator. The kitchen appliance was later found at a nearby landfill site, where Erin had taken it to try and dispose of evidence. Police found death cap mushroom residue inside.
Patterson's legal team has 28 days to appeal the conviction. If there is no appeal, she will likely be sentenced in August and faces life behind bars.Original article source: Woman found guilty in mushroom murder mystery that left three family members dead after meal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Idaho four murder victim's sister reveals 'weird' three-word text message hours before stabbings
Print Close By Audrey Conklin Published July 14, 2025 Idaho murder victim Ethan Chapin's sister shared the last text the University of Idaho freshman sent her just before he was killed in a home near campus on Nov. 13, 2022. Bryan Kohberger, 30, recently accepted a plea deal and confessed to killing Madison Mogen, 21, Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, 20, in a 4 a.m. home invasion attack nearly two-and-a-half years ago. The night before the murders, Mazie Chapin — the triplet sister of Ethan and Hunter Chapin — had her sorority formal on Saturday evening and invited Ethan to be her date since she did not have one and his friends were going, Mazie says in a new Amazon Prime documentary series about the murders titled, "One Night in Idaho: The College Murders." "I don't usually invite anyone to formals, but some of Ethan's friends were going, and he wasn't going," Maizie says in the docuseries. "So, I was like, 'OK, you can just be my date.' It was super fun." READ BRYAN KOHBERGER'S SIGNED KILLER CONFESSION They left the formal around 9 p.m., and while some students went on to Ethan and Hunter's fraternity house, Mazie stayed behind. "For some reason, I stayed and went to bed," she says in the docuseries. "Ethan kept texting me, 'Maizie, come hang out.' I went to sleep, so I wasn't responding to any of them. Last one said, 'I love you,' which was also weird because we don't say that to each other." IDAHO MURDERS TIMELINE: BRYAN KOHBERGER PLEA CAPS YEARSLONG QUEST FOR JUSTICE The next morning, Ethan was found dead, along with Kernodle, his girlfriend; Goncalves; and Mogen. The four students had been stabbed to death in their rental home just steps from campus in the early morning hours of Nov. 13, a Sunday. Two-and-a-half years later, on July 1, Kohberger signed a confession as part of his plea deal to avoid the death penalty. He admitted to breaking into the off-campus house at 1122 King Road, in Moscow, Idaho, on Nov. 13, 2022, with the intent to commit murder. Then, with premeditation and malice aforethought, he stabbed Ethan Chapin, Kerndole, Mogen and Goncalves. BRYAN KOHBERGER EXPECTED TO OFFICIALLY PLEAD GUILTY: WHAT'S NEXT Ethan's mother, Stacy Chapin, was in court on July 2, when Kohberger pleaded guilty to his crimes in person, a day after signing the confession. "It was cold and calculated and weirdly, like an automated phone message," Stacy Chapin told "TODAY" of seeing Kohberger in court and hearing his plea. "I mean, it was just like you expected some, I don't know, remorse, emotion, something. And there was zero." FAMILY OF VICTIM IN BRYAN KOHBERGER CASE SAY THEY WERE SENT INTO 'PANIC MODE' AFTER PLEA DEAL The Goncalves family has been vocal in their disapproval of the plea deal, while the Chapin and Mogen families have supported the move. But despite their differing opinions, the families have expressed that Kohberger's deal with prosecutors caught them off guard. "If I could physically do a handstand, I'd probably do one, because I am so ready," Jim Chapin, Ethan's father, told "TODAY." "I'm ready for my kids to move on. I'm ready for us to move on. I mean, it's been almost two-and-a-half years, and it's, just, it's over." Stacy Chapin said their first response in terms of the judicial process for Kohberger was "an eye for an eye," but after speaking with prosecutors, they agreed "this was a better deal." "He gets put away, and there's no appeal system to it," Stacy Chapin told the outlet. "And there were so many kids, including our own, that had been subpoenaed that no longer have this hanging over their heads." BRYAN KOHBERGER ACCEPTS PLEA DEAL IN IDAHO STUDENT MURDERS CASE Kohbeger is expected to receive four consecutive terms of life in prison without parole, plus another 10 years. CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP As part of the deal, he waived his right to appeal and the right to move for a future sentence reduction. Kohberger's trial would have begun in August. Fox News Digital's Michael Ruiz contributed to this report. Print Close URL
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Preppy party murder suspect's lawyer says client's testimony key to acquittal
The attorney for the man who stood accused of murdering suburban Connecticut prep school lacrosse player James "Jimmy" McGrath in 2023 revealed the critical key to his client's acquittal. Raul Valle, 20, took the stand in his own defense, which attorney Kevin Smith said was necessary for proving his client's innocence. "He was going to have to take the stand in a self-defense case when you are telling folks you felt a certain way, and you were in such danger," Smith told WFSB. "I can think of few instances where there would be enough other evidence to put it on and say you had a self-defense claim." "Nobody ever wants to have to take another life," Smith said. "Mr. Valle certainly never wanted to do that. I think the evidence is clear." Smith noted that, like Valle, he was relieved that the trial had finished. He said that he lost 15 pounds during the ordeal. The trial lasted eight days, and was followed by two-and-a-half days of jury deliberation. He told his client to keep a low profile after the acquittal. "I've told him to avoid public places where he may be subjected to some behavior he doesn't need, doesn't need people harassing him, keeping a low profile, which he did during the trial," he stated. On Wednesday, Valle was found not guilty of first-degree murder in the stabbing death of McGrath, which stemmed from a booze-fueled party in May 2022 where a brawl broke out between 25 students on the lawn of a suburban Connecticut home. He was also cleared on charges of intentional manslaughter and intentional assault. The jury deadlocked on reckless manslaughter and reckless assault charges, and a partial mistrial was declared. Valle could be retried on those charges. Valle was 16 at the time of the stabbing, and McGrath was 17. Jury foreman Jim Stuhlman said ultimately, prosecutors didn not provide enough evidence to prove their case. He said the jury spent very little time deliberating on whether Valle had acted in self-defense because the jury believed that the state had failed to prove that he intended to kill McGrath. "There was so much inconsistencies and contradictions," he continued. "Not everyone will be happy with the conclusion, we weren't happy we couldn't find an agreement on the final counts, but we did everything we could have to get as far as we did."
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Parents of slain Idaho student Ethan Chapin say they've found 'big-time closure'
Ethan Chapin, one of four University of Idaho students stabbed to death in the fall of 2022, had a lighthearted, sometimes goofy presence his family still feels today. The 6-foot-4-inch student rarely took things too seriously, they said, making their loss staggering and their recovery a daily battle against the weight of darkness. "The days do get better," Stacy Chapin, speaking alongside her husband, Jim, said for the couple's first major sit-down interview, airing Monday morning on "TODAY." The Chapins were present July 2 when defendant Bryan Kohberger pleaded guilty to four counts of first-degree murder under an agreement that will skip a painful trial, a godsend for the Chapins. He'll remain behind bars until his last breath. "It was cold and calculated and weirdly, like an automated phone message," Stacy Chapin said of seeing the defendant in person for the first time. "I mean, it was just like you expected some, I don't know, remorse, emotion, something. And there was zero." His plea has so far come without an explanation or a disclosure of a motive, but nearly three years after the violence, the Chapins say they don't need an explanation anymore. "If I could physically do a handstand, I'd probably do one, because I am so ready," Jim Chapin said. "I'm ready for my kids to move on. I'm ready for us to move on. I mean, it's been almost 2½ years, and it's, just, it's over." Sentencing is July 23 in Boise. The Chapins say that, even with the deal, it's possible that Kohberger will never explain what drove him to 1122 King Road early on Nov. 13, 2022, when he entered a home not his own and drove his knife repeatedly into the flesh of four University of Idaho students before a surviving roommate saw him leave wearing a ski mask, she said. Ethan Chapin was a 20-year-old freshman studying recreation, sport and tourism management. His minors? Bud Light Lime and Taco Bell, his parents say. In many ways, Kohberger contrasted his victims' optimism and fun with a demanding demeanor that got him into trouble at Washington State University Global Campus in Pullman, about 8 miles from King Road. Students there and other sources said Kohberger, a doctoral student in criminology, was under fire for his attitude in his teaching assistant role, grading papers and counseling students. Some students complained, they said, and he was called in for meetings. Kohberger's social media surfing in the fall of 2022, reviewed by NBC News, showed he binged on the imagery of some of the friends and followers of the three women killed in the attack. One of them, Xana Kernodle, 20, was Chapin's girlfriend and the reason he was at King Road that morning, authorities have said. Housemates Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves, both 21, were also slain. Motive might ultimately end up locked up for good with Kohberger, who hasn't spoken about it. "I don't believe that we will ever learn that, and I don't need to know," Stacy Chapin said. "It doesn't change the outcome. It's a horrific event. We've gotten through it. I mean, as best as we can, as we continue to heal every single day." The plea agreement saved their surviving children, Maizie and Hunter, born alongside Ethan as triplets, from possibly having to testify about him at trial, the Chapins said. The deal raised eyebrows among some of the victims' parents. "Our first, our initial response was like, the eye, an eye for an eye," Stacy Chapin said. But after speaking with prosecutors and family, the Chapins concluded "this was a better deal," she said. "He gets put away, and there's no appeal system to it, and there were so many kids, including our own, that had been subpoenaed that no longer have this hanging over their heads," Stacy added. Jim Chapin said locking the defendant away will prevent him from killing anyone, including college students, again. "I really don't care what happens to the guy," he said. "He's off the streets. He can't hurt any more kids." For the Chapins, the deal is done, and they're now happy with it. They're not even planning to attend sentencing because they feel the case wrapped the minute the defendant said "guilty." It was the point at which the couple was finally ready to move on, Jim Chapin said. "There's big-time closure," he said. Maizie and Hunter recently completed undergraduate studies at the University of Idaho, the couple said, and took part in commencement ceremonies as the Chapins beamed. Their parents hated the possibility of their children having to testify and endure "memory lane" style displays of imagery from Ethan's childhood, a painful prospect, they said. A successful prosecution wasn't guaranteed, opening up the possibility of a second trial and more pain, they said. And even if Kohberger were found guilty of capital murder, executions can take decades and involve hearings that would bring the Chapins right back to their ringside seats to relive their greatest loss. While relatives of other victims were unhappy with the way the plea agreement with the defendant was rolled out, the Chapins were ready to say goodbye to all of it. Their appearance on the Prime Video docuseries "One Night in Idaho: The College Murders," which debuted over the weekend, was calculated, the couple said. "We got to control the narrative when it comes to Ethan," Stacy Chapin said. "This is our version of Ethan, who was incredible. We set out consciously to make sure that it was our story, our Ethan." Directors Liz Garbus and Matthew Galkin "knocked it out of the park" in portraying Ethan's airy outlook, Jim Chapin said. The Chapins' loss nearly paralyzed the couple: "Crying in your coffee" every morning is how Stacy Chapin described their life. But the two consciously dug themselves out of sorrow and misery and eventually were able to establish a foundation in Ethan's name, Ethan's Smile, which has given scholarships to more than 80 students. And Stacy got moving literally, on her treadmill, step by step. "You hike your demons out," she said. It's clear that the couple have emerged and that they are happy not to have the daily tribulations of a trial filling up their heads. They've let go of much of that, but they say Ethan will always resonate in the household. "He just could just blow into any room and had something funny to say," Stacy said. "Elevated everything, you know, just the energy in a room. His Jeep is here. His things are here. He's here." This article was originally published on
