You are the head coach: Guardian writers choose their own Lions squads

Yahoo

07-05-2025

Ugo Monye
Build the team around The majority of my spine players come in the pack. In some areas the leading candidate is a cut above the rest and none more so than Dan Sheehan at hooker. He's nailed on as first choice. I'd put Maro Itoje in that bracket too and, due to lack of alternatives, I would've had Caelan Doris before news of his shoulder injury emerged. Perhaps the most important player is the one back I've selected in this category, however. Jamison Gibson-Park has been so exceptionally consistent and is someone you can look to build around. You build a team around your players of influence and, for me, they are Sheehan, Itoje and Gibson-Park.
Advertisement
Related: The Breakdown | Andy Farrell faces Owen question as selection debates pile up for Lions squad
Definitely maybes Henry Pollock is the obvious candidate. What a 12 months he has had. He won the junior World Cup last summer, has starred in Northampton's European campaign to the extent he's been nominated for player of the year, scored two tries on his England debut and just went toe to toe with the best back-row contingent in the club game. Every challenge he is presented with he is rising to and I'd expect no different on a Lions tour. I'm not sure bolter is the right term, but in terms of someone who has come late to the conversation, I'd also include George Ford. I'd have him on the tour. He is as close to a player-coach as you are likely to see. He's having to come up the rails because he appeared only once in the Six Nations – but what a cameo that was against Wales – and his Premiership form has galvanised Sale.
Captain Maro Itoje. He has become a better player since he has taken on the responsibility for club and country. There are so many ways to compliment him but I look to his durability. He has played every minute of every England Six Nations match in the past six years. Tight matches are won and lost in the last 20 minutes and knowing your captain will be there till the end makes such a difference.
Starting Test fly-half Finn Russell. He's been there and he'd be the only fly-half in this squad who has been on a Lions tour before. There's a step up from club rugby to European rugby, another to international rugby and another still to the Lions. As a result, experience matters. It helps he has knockout matches and he can sharpen the tools at the sharp end of the season.
Advertisement
What would keep me awake Injuries to big players between now and the end of the season. It's the harsh reality of the sport. There are some players you just can't afford to lose. I can vividly remember our last training session before we went to South Africa in 2009 and Jerry Flannery dislocated an elbow. It's just so tough.
My key strategy to beat Wallabies We're in an era of ball movement that suits a fast-paced game. France have won the Six Nations scoring more tries and points than anyone, while we're seeing it in Super Rugby and domestically, that's the trend. I can talk about the fundamentals, set-piece, defence and so on but the Lions have to be a fearless team that want to move the ball.
My Lions 37
Hookers Jamie George Eng, Ronan Kelleher Ire, Dan Sheehan Ire.
Props Ellis Genge Eng, Zander Fagerson Sco, Tadhg Furlong Ire, Andrew Porter Ire, Pierre Schoeman Sco, Will Stuart Eng.
Second-rows Tadhg Beirne Ire, Ollie Chessum Eng, Maro Itoje Eng, Joe McCarthy Ire.
Back-rows Tom Curry Eng, Caelan Doris Ire, Ben Earl Eng, Matt Fagerson Sco, Jac Morgan Wal, Henry Pollock Eng, Josh van der Flier Ire.
Scrum-halves Jamison Gibson-Park Ire, Alex Mitchell Eng, Tomos Williams Wal.
Fly-halves George Ford Eng, Finn Russell Sco, Fin Smith Eng.
Centres Bundee Aki Ire, Huw Jones Sco, Garry Ringrose Ire, Sione Tuipulotu Sco.
Back three Elliot Daly Eng, Tommy Freeman Eng, Hugo Keenan Ire, Blair Kinghorn Sco, James Lowe Ire, Marcus Smith Eng, Duhan van der Merwe Sco.
Robert Kitson
Build the team around The spine of any successful Lions team has to be super strong. And if Dan Sheehan, Maro Itoje, Tadhg Beirne, Taulupe Faletau, Jamison Gibson-Park, Finn Russell, Sione Tuipulotu and Blair Kinghorn are all fit and firing, the Test XV will take some subduing. Caelan Doris's probable absence is a blow but Henry Pollock has leapfrogged into contention at the right time. The Lions will need to compete hard at the breakdown, to win turnovers for their talented backs and to stop the Wallabies from gathering momentum.
Advertisement
Definitely maybes Pollock would have been a bolter last month, but his stunning display against Leinster has retired that definition. Courtney Lawes may seem a retro choice, but the intense tour schedule suits a tough, versatile forward with Lions experience. A long trek around, say, New Zealand might have necessitated a third specialist fly-half but Blair Kinghorn and Tom Jordan can wear 10 if required. The alternative is to pick Owen Farrell and Elliot Daly: if Kinghorn's tour arrival is delayed, there needs to be full-back cover.
Captain Maro Itoje. Captaincy seems to enhance his game and Doris's untimely shoulder injury has cruelly derailed the Irishman's bid.
Starting Test fly-half Finn Russell. That said, it would be no huge surprise if the steadily improving Fin Smith ends up starting at some stage.
What would keep me awake What, apart from the snakes, the spiders and the sharks? Probably the certain knowledge that the ex-Ireland coach Joe Schmidt, now in charge of the Wallabies, will have a wily tactical plan up his sleeve. And the ominous spectre of Australia's new star, Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii, soaring above every Lion to poach the series' first high ball.
Advertisement
My key strategy to beat the Wallabies Win the first Test at all costs. Australia are liable to improve as the series progresses. And put some serious pressure on the Wallaby half-backs. Hassle their playmakers and there will be less scope for the aforementioned Suaalii and co to run free and cause potential havoc.
My Lions 37
Hookers Jamie George Eng, Luke Cowan-Dickie Eng, Dan Sheehan Ire.
Props Zander Fagerson Sco, Tadhg Furlong Ire, Ellis Genge Eng, Andrew Porter Ire, Pierre Schoeman Sco, Nicky Smith Wal, Will Stuart Eng.
Second-rows Tadhg Beirne Ire, Ollie Chessum Eng, Maro Itoje Eng, Joe McCarthy Ire, Courtney Lawes Eng.
Back-rows Tom Curry Eng, Ben Earl Eng, Taulupe Faletau Wal, Jac Morgan Wal, Henry Pollock Eng, Sam Underhill Eng.
Scrum-halves Jamison Gibson-Park Ire, Alex Mitchell Eng, Tomos Williams Wal.
Fly-halves Finn Russell Sco, Fin Smith Eng, Tom Jordan Sco.
Centres Bundee Aki Ire, Huw Jones Sco, Sione Tuipulotu Sco, Garry Ringrose Ire.
Wings Tommy Freeman Eng, Darcy Graham Sco, James Lowe Ire, Duhan van der Merwe Sco.
Full-backs Hugo Keenan Ire, Blair Kinghorn Sco.
Gerard Meagher
Build the team around Before the Six Nations the short answer was Ireland's forward pack and Scotland's back division. England's resurgence as the competition went on ensures they will be well represented, however, and in Maro Itoje and Tom Curry provide two players around whom to build the team. Dan Sheehan at hooker and the scrum-half Jamison Gibson-Park are others. Gibson-Park's game management is such a strength that he is arguably the most influential player set to make the trip. For all the back-row options, there is not a great deal of No 8s so Caelan Doris is included if fully fit. It's a big if, though.
Advertisement
Definitely maybes Henry Pollock has emerged as the most likely bolter in the true sense of the word and deserves a place on the plane. Would Owen Farrell be a bolter given he hasn't played Test rugby since 2023? His pedigree ensures he makes the trip but the difficulty in selecting players based in France means that while he, Blair Kinghorn and David Ribbans are picked, Jack Willis, Kyle Sinckler and Ben White are not. The back row is the hardest area of the field to select but Scotland's Jamie Ritchie deserves a call for his form during the Six Nations.
Captain Jamie George. The England hooker is universally popular and though he would not start in the Test team – maybe even not make the bench – he would be an excellent tour captain. Itoje, Doris if fit or Farrell can assume the role on the field but how the captain leads the squad off the field is more important and there is no better candidate than George.
Starting Test fly-half Owen Farrell. He is a three-time Lion, finding some form for Racing 92 of late – last weekend notwithstanding – and he commands the respect of his peers. In terms of age-profile, George Ford should be his closest rival but, not for the first time, the Sale Shark misses out. Finn Russell wears No 22, Fin Smith plays in midweek.
What would keep me awake Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii. Any highlights reel of his debut at Twickenham would do the trick. He has the aerial ability, the deft hands and the athleticism to worry any Lions supporter but the temperament too, as shown with how he conducted himself during the autumn. The most troubling thing about him, however, is that he has a coach as canny as Joe Schmidt who will be perfecting his plans as to how best to deploy him.
Advertisement
My key strategy to beat Wallabies Beat them on the floor and keep their counterattacking opportunities to a minimum. It is why I would copy from Steve Borthwick's playbook and pick three dynamic, all-action back-rowers – Ritchie, Tom Curry and Doris if fit – with Pollock on the bench. A lack of exceptional pace out wide also means the Lions will have to rule the skies.
My Lions 37
Hookers Theo Dan Eng, Jamie George Eng, Dan Sheehan Ire.
Props Zander Fagerson Sco, Tadhg Furlong Ire, Ellis Genge Eng, Asher Opoku-Fordjour Eng, Andrew Porter Ire, Will Stuart Eng.
Second-rows Tadhg Beirne Ire, Scott Cummings Sco, Maro Itoje Eng, Joe McCarthy Ire, David Ribbans Eng.
Back-rows Ryan Baird Ire, Jack Conan Ire, Tom Curry Eng, Caelan Doris Ire, Henry Pollock Eng, Jamie Ritchie Sco, Josh van der Flier Ire.
Scrum-halves Jamison Gibson-Park Ire, Alex Mitchell Eng, Tomos Williams Wal.
Fly-halves Owen Farrell Eng, Finn Russell Sco, Fin Smith Eng.
Centres Bundee Aki Ire, Huw Jones Sco, Tom Jordan Sco, Sione Tuipulotu Sco.
Back three Elliot Daly Eng, Tommy Freeman Eng, Hugo Keenan Ire, Blair Kinghorn Sco, James Lowe Ire, Duhan van der Merwe Sco.
Andy Bull
Build the team around An all-action front row of Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan and Will Stuart, who has improved out of sight this season, and the utterly formidable locking combination of Maro Itoje and Tadhg Beirne. Behind them, Jamison Gibson-Park's smarts at scrum-half, and Finn Russell's finely honed partnership with the electric centre pairing of Sione Tuipoltu and Huw Jones. Truth is, the Lions are a hell of a lot stronger than the Wallabies. If they lose, it will be because they have failed to come together as a unit, which is why I've gone for the three familiar Scots in midfield.
Advertisement
Definitely maybes Dewi Lake squeezes in even after missing the Six Nations because the Lions is an exercise in team-building and you want to fill the squad with leaders. George Ford goes for similar reasons. If they were definitely fit, Immanuel Feyi-Waboso and Caelan Doris would make it, but why take the risk?
Captain Maro Itoje will be first among equals. You don't lead players as good as these by what you say in the huddle, but by the standards you maintain every day, and Itoje's have been unimpeachable for years.
Starting Test fly-half Don't you want to find out just how much fun Finn Russell could have orchestrating all that talent?
What would keep me awake Worrying about where Blair Kinghorn fits in. He ought to be nailed on to play at full-back but the delay while he finishes his club season does no one any favours. Otherwise, you'd hope the only thing that would make you lose sleep would be the sound of everyone enjoying themselves.
Advertisement
My key strategy to beat Wallabies The Lions are in the unique position of having two world-class starting XVs in one squad. Australia just don't have the playing resources to match that strength in depth, so the replacements are going to make the difference. Load the bench with six forwards and set them loose together when there are 25 minutes left to play.
My Lions 37
Hookers Dan Sheehan Ire, Jamie George Eng, Dewi Lake Wal.
Props Andrew Porter Ire, Tadhg Furlong Ire, Will Stuart Eng, Ellis Genge Eng, Zander Fagerson Sco, Pierre Schoeman Sco.
Second-rows Maro Itoje Eng, Tadhg Beirne Ire, Ollie Chessum Eng, Joe McCarthy Ire, George Martin Eng.
Back-rows Tom Curry Eng, Jac Morgan Wal, Josh van der Flier Ire, Ben Earl Eng, Taulupe Faletau Wal, Jack Conan Ire.
Scrum-halves Jamison Gibson-Park Ire, Tomos Williams Wal, Alex Mitchell Eng.
Fly-halves Finn Russell Sco, Fin Smith Eng, George Ford Eng.
Centres Sione Tuipulotu Sco, Huw Jones Sco, Bundee Aki Ire, Garry Ringrose Ire.
Wings James Lowe Ire, Tommy Freeman Eng, Duhan van der Merwe Sco, Elliot Daly Eng.
Full-backs Blair Kinghorn Sco, Hugo Keenan Ire, Marcus Smith Eng.
Michael Aylwin
Build team around Ugly forwards. And a proper game-manager at 10. Any strike runners beyond that, so much the better. It's a fairly standard formula for any team, but against Australia ugly forwards, in particular, come into their own. The Lions have options at tighthead, but Will Stuart is the pick of the scrummagers. Tadhg Beirne and Caelan Doris (if fit) are spine players, around whom the Lions could throw any number of punchy, ball-carrying forwards. George Ford is the best game-manager and always has been, as well as the best playmaker. But Blair Kinghorn, a fixture at full-back, could relieve him of place-kicking duties. With Bundee Aki and Duhan van der Merwe running riot around them …
Definitely maybes The great imponderable is how closely Andy Farrell has been monitoring form in France. There is practically a team's worth of contenders there. All eyes will be on his fly-half picks, but Courtney Lawes has played a full and successful season in Pro D2. If Zander Fagerson is not fit, Kyle Sinckler may yet feature. All of these might be negotiable for early release, but Blair Kinghorn and Jack Willis, at Toulouse, are likely to make the Top 14 final at the end of June.
Advertisement
Captain Maro Itoje. Doris's form and fitness mean his case has slipped. It has taken a while for Itoje to be anointed as captain anywhere, but he is in form and in the engine room.
Starting fly-half George Ford. Forget the Lions coach, if I'd been England coach he would have plenty more than 100 caps by now (it turns out he has 99, but he would have started more of them). Those fizzing passes across the face of defences, the variety of kicking, the eye for a gap. One of the great England fly-halves.
What would keep me awake? Lack of ruthlessness. And the fact that it's Australia, who may not be the force they were but can still sting. England's defeat by the Wallabies in the autumn springs to mind, evidence of a ridiculous inability to finish a team off. Ireland's failure at World Cups, too. Leinster's wobbles in Europe …
My key strategy to beat Wallabies Recruit Andy Farrell as coach. Maybe get his old mate Shaun Edwards across too. Forget the aura they brandish from their playing careers, these are good men who know how to manage and cajole. The loyalty and affection they inspire in their teams is obvious, and they work hard, as they did in their playing days, to maximise assets and identify weaknesses in the opposition. Just as well one of them is in charge.
My Lions 37
Hookers Theo Dan Eng, Jamie George Eng, Dan Sheehan Ire.
Props Zander Fagerson Sco, Tadhg Furlong Ire, Ellis Genge Eng, Andrew Porter Ire, Pierre Schoeman Sco, Will Stuart Eng.
Second-rows Tadhg Beirne Ire, Maro Itoje Eng, George Martin Eng, Joe McCarthy Ire, Ryan Baird Ire.
Back-rows Ben Curry Eng, Tom Curry Eng, Caelan Doris Ire, Ben Earl Eng, Courtney Lawes Eng, Josh van der Flier Ire, Tom Willis Eng.
Scrum-halves Jamison Gibson-Park Ire, Alex Mitchell Eng, Tomos Williams Wal.
Fly-halves George Ford Eng, Finn Russell Sco, Fin Smith Eng.
Centres Bundee Aki Ire, Huw Jones Sco, Garry Ringrose Ire, Sione Tuipulotu Sco.
Wings Tommy Freeman Eng, Darcy Graham Sco, James Lowe Ire, Duhan van der Merwe Sco.
Full-backs Tom Jordan Sco, Blair Kinghorn Sco.