BYD unleashes an EV industry reckoning that alarms Beijing
[BEIJING] The price war engulfing China's electric vehicle (EV) industry has sent share prices tumbling and prompted an unusual level of intervention from Beijing. The shakeout may just be getting started.
For all the Chinese government's efforts to prevent price cuts by market leader BYD from turning into a vicious spiral, analysts say a combination of weaker demand and extreme overcapacity will slice into profits at the strongest brands and force feebler competitors to fold. Even after the number of EV makers starting shrinking for the first time last year, the industry is still using less than half its production capacity.
Chinese authorities are trying to minimise the fallout, chiding the sector for 'rat race competition' and summoning heads of major brands to Beijing last week. Yet previous attempts to intervene have had little success. For the short term at least, investors are betting few automakers will escape unscathed. BYD, arguably the biggest winner from industry consolidation, has lost US$21.5 billion in market value since its shares peaked in late May.
'What you are seeing in China is disturbing, because there's a lack of demand and extreme price cutting,' said John Murphy, a senior automotive analyst at Bank of America. Eventually, there will be 'massive consolidation' to soak up the excess capacity, Murphy said.
For automakers, relentless discounting erodes profit margins, undermines brand value and forces even well-capitalised companies into unsustainable financial positions. Low-priced and low-quality products can seriously damage the international reputation of 'Made-in-China' cars, the People's Daily, an outlet controlled by the Communist Party, said. And that knock would come just as models from BYD to Geely, Zeekr and Xpeng start to collect accolades on the world stage.
For consumers, price drops may seem beneficial but they mask deeper risks. Unpredictable pricing discourages long-term trust – already people are complaining on China's social media, wondering why they should buy a car now when it may be cheaper next week – while there's a chance automakers, as they cut costs to stay afloat, may reduce investment in quality, safety and after-sales service.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Auto CEOs were told last week they must 'self-regulate' and should not sell cars below cost or offer unreasonable price cuts, according to sources familiar with the matter. The issue of zero-mileage cars also came up – where vehicles with no distance on their odometers are sold by dealers into the second-hand market, seen widely as a way for automakers to artificially inflate sales and clear inventory.
Chinese automakers have been discounting a lot more aggressively than their foreign counterparts.
Murphy said US automakers should just get out. 'Tesla probably needs to be there to compete with those companies and understand what's going on, but there's a lot of risk there for them.'
Others leave no room for doubt that BYD, China's No 1 selling car brand, is the culprit.
'It's obvious to everyone that the biggest player is doing this,' Jochen Siebert, managing director at auto consultancy JSC Automotive, said. 'They want a monopoly where everybody else gives up.' BYD's aggressive tactics are raising concerns over the potential dumping of cars, dealership management issues and 'squeezing out suppliers', he said.
The pricing turmoil is also unfolding against a backdrop of significant overcapacity. The average production utilisation rate in China's automotive industry was a mere 49.5 per cent in 2024, data compiled by Shanghai-based Gasgoo Automotive Research Institute show.
An April report by AlixPartners meanwhile highlights the intense competition that's starting to emerge among new energy vehicle (NEV) makers or companies that produce pure battery cars and plug-in hybrids. In 2024, the market saw its first ever consolidation among NEV-dedicated brands, with 16 exiting and 13 launching.
'The Chinese automotive market, despite its substantial scale, is growing at a slower speed. Automakers have to put top priority now on grabbing more market share,' Ron Zheng, a partner at global consultancy Roland Berger GmbH, said.
Jiyue Auto shows how quickly things can change. A little over a year after launching its first car, the automaker jointly backed by big names Zhejiang Geely Holding Group and technology giant Baidu, began to scale down production and seek fresh funds.
It's a dilemma for all carmakers, but especially smaller ones. 'If you don't follow suit once a leading company makes a price move, you might lose the chance to stay at the table,' AlixPartners consultant Zhang Yichao said. He added that China's low capacity utilisation rate, which is 'fundamentally fuelling' the competition, is now even under more pressure from export uncertainties.
While the push to find an outlet for excess production is thrusting more Chinese brands to export, international markets can only offer some relief.
'The US market is completely closed and Japan and Korea may close very soon if they see an invasion of Chinese carmakers,' Siebert said. 'Russia, which was the biggest export market last year, is now becoming very difficult. I also don't see South-east Asia as an opportunity anymore.'
The pressure of cost-cutting has also led analysts to express concern over supply chain finance risks.
A price cut demand by BYD to one of its suppliers late last year attracted scrutiny around how the car giant may be using supply chain financing to mask its ballooning debt. A report by accounting consultancy GMT Research put BYD's true net debt at closer to 323 billion yuan (S$58 billion), compared with the 27.7 billion yuan officially on its books as at the end of June 2024.
The pain is also bleeding into China's dealership network. Dealership groups in two provinces have gone out of business since April, both of them ones that were selling BYD cars.
Beijing's meeting with automakers last week was not the first attempt at a ceasefire. Two years ago, in mid-2023, 16 major automakers, including Tesla, BYD and Geely signed a pact, witnessed by the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers (CAAM), to avoid 'abnormal pricing'.
Within days though, CAAM deleted one of the four commitments, saying that a reference to pricing in the pledge was inappropriate and in breach of a principle enshrined in the nation's antitrust laws.
The discounting continued unabated. BLOOMBERG
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CNA
43 minutes ago
- CNA
Rare earths: China's trump card in trade war with US
BEIJING: China is counting on one crucial advantage as it seeks to grind out a deal to ease its high-stakes trade war with the United States - dominance in rare earths. Used in electric vehicles, hard drives, wind turbines and missiles, rare earth elements are essential to the modern economy and national defence. AFP takes a look at how rare earths have become a key sticking point in talks between the US and China. MINING BOOM "The Middle East has oil. China has rare earths," Deng Xiaoping, the late Chinese leader whose pro-market reforms set the country on its path to becoming an economic powerhouse, said in 1992. Since then, Beijing's heavy investment in state-owned mining firms and lax environmental regulations compared to other industry players have turned China into the world's top supplier. The country now accounts for 92 per cent of global refined output, according to the International Energy Agency. But the flow of rare earths from China to manufacturers around the world has slowed after Beijing in early April began requiring domestic exporters to apply for a licence, widely seen as a response to US tariffs. Under the new requirements, which industry groups have said are complex and slow-moving, seven key elements and related magnets require Beijing's approval to be shipped to foreign buyers. DEEP IMPACT Ensuring access to the vital elements has become a top priority for US officials in talks with Chinese counterparts, with the two sides meeting this week in London. "The rare earth issue has clearly ... overpowered the other parts of the trade negotiations because of stoppages at plants in the US," said Paul Triolo, a technology expert at the Asia Society Policy Institute's Center for China Analysis, in an online seminar on Monday (Jun 9). That disruption, which forced US car giant Ford to temporarily halt production of its Explorer SUV, "really got the attention of the White House", said Triolo. Officials from the two countries said on Tuesday that they had agreed on a "framework" for moving forward on trade, with US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick expressing optimism that concerns over access to rare earths "will be resolved" eventually. RARE EARTH ADVANTAGE The slowing of licence issuance has raised fears that more automakers will be forced to halt production while they await shipments. China's commerce ministry said over the weekend that as a "responsible major country", it had approved a certain number of export applications, adding that it was willing to strengthen related dialogue with "relevant countries". But that bottleneck has highlighted Washington's reliance on Chinese rare earths for producing its defence equipment, even as trade and geopolitical tensions deepen. An F-35 fighter jet contains more than 400kg of rare earth elements, noted a recent analysis by Gracelin Baskaran and Meredith Schwartz of the Critical Minerals Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "Developing mining and processing capabilities requires a long-term effort, meaning the US will be on the back foot for the foreseeable future," they wrote. PLAYING CATCH UP The recent export control measures are not the first time China has leveraged its dominance of rare earths supply chains. After a 2010 maritime collision between a Chinese trawler and Japanese coast guard boats in disputed waters, Beijing briefly halted shipments of its rare earths to Tokyo. The episode spurred Japan to invest in alternative sources and improve stockpiling of the vital elements - with limited success. That is "a good illustration of the difficulty of actually reducing dependence on China", said Triolo, noting that in the 15 years since the incident, Japan has achieved only "marginal gains". The Pentagon is trying to catch up, with its "mine-to-magnet" strategy aiming to ensure an all-domestic supply chain for the key components by 2027. The challenge facing Washington to compete with Beijing in rare earths is compounded by sheer luck: China sits on the world's largest reserves. "Mineable concentrations are less common than for most other mineral commodities, making extraction more costly," wrote Rico Luman and Ewa Manthey of ING in an analysis published on Tuesday. "It is this complex and costly extraction and processing that make rare earths strategically significant," they wrote.


CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Asian markets rally after China-US framework on trade
HONG KONG: Asian stocks rose on Wednesday (Jun 11) as investors welcomed a China-United States agreement to lower trade tensions that stoked hopes the economic superpowers will eventually reach a broader tariff deal. After two days of high-profile, closely watched talks in London, the two sides said they had set up a framework to move towards a pact, following negotiations in Geneva last month that saw them slash tit-for-tat levies. The news provided some much-needed relief to markets after US President Donald Trump accused Beijing of violating that deal. The latest round of talks followed a phone call between Trump and his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping on Thursday. As well as tariffs, a key issue in the discussions was China's export of earth minerals and magnets used in a range of things, including smartphones and electric vehicle batteries, while Beijing was keen to see an easing of restrictions on its access to tech goods. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said he was upbeat that concerns over rare earths "will be resolved" eventually, as the agreement is implemented. Xi and Trump must approve the framework first. "We're moving as quickly as we can," US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer told reporters. "We would very much like to find an agreement that makes sense for both countries," he added. "We feel positive about engaging with the Chinese." Speaking separately to reporters, China International Trade Representative Li Chenggang expressed hope that progress made in London would help to boost trust on both sides. The deal, which was reached late on Tuesday, boosted Asian markets with Hong Kong and Shanghai among the best performers, while Tokyo, Sydney, Seoul, Wellington, Taipei and Manila were also up. However, analysts said investors would be keen to get a closer look at the details of the agreement. "The US-China trade circus wrapped with what can only be described as a diplomatic tautology," said Stephen Innes at SPI Asset Management. He called it "a late-night announcement that both sides have 'agreed in principle on a framework to implement the Geneva consensus' - a consensus that was ... already agreed upon weeks ago". And he warned that markets could run out of steam if nothing concrete came through. "If the next headline doesn't come with something tangible, such as cargo ships loaded with rare earths or an actual rollback of tariffs, expect risk assets to start demanding more photo opportunities," he wrote. "Until then, this rally relies on faith." And Saxo chief investment strategist Charu Chanana said before the deal was announced that while there was some hope for the talks, "the era of easy wins - tariff pauses and minor concessions - is over". "What's left are deeper, more entrenched challenges: tech restrictions, rare earth supply chains, student visas, and national security-linked concerns. These are strategic disputes, unlikely to be resolved in a few rounds of meetings." Still, she did say that "trade uncertainty has clearly faded since the peak chaos of early April", when Trump unleashed a tariff blitz that hammered worldwide stock and bond markets. Tuesday's news also overshadowed the World Bank's slashing of its 2025 forecast for global economic growth to 2.3 per cent, from the 2.7 per cent predicted in January, citing trade tensions and policy uncertainty. It also said the US economy would expand 1.4 per cent this year, half of its 2024 expansion.


New Paper
2 hours ago
- New Paper
Maids set up illegal side hustle outside mall, draws ire from nearby business owners
To make some extra cash on their rest day, a number of Indonesian maids gathered to set up a small food market outside City Plaza in Paya Lebar, despite knowing it is illegal. "Many maids gather for a few hours, and some of them sell food and beverages, so the others will not come to patronise us," said a nearby shop owner. Every weekend, the group of Indonesian maids seize the opportunity for a side hustle by selling food such as chicken rice, fruits and drinks outside the mall. Shin Min Daily News reported that a group of women carried reusable bags containing food items while walking around the area. Business was decent, as occasionally, people would pay to buy the food. Another group with a different strategy was also spotted nearby. Rather than approaching the public, these women placed their offerings in the open space for passers-by to choose from. Some maids placed their foods in the open. PHOTO: SHIN MIN DAILY NEWS When offered a $3 cup of lemon tea by a vendor, the reporter attempted to ask about her business. However, the woman was unwilling to respond and quickly packed the food before leaving. A maid who wished to remain anonymous told the Chinese daily that she was from Indonesia and knew touting was illegal. Every fortnight, she would sell food she and her friends prepared. However, she admitted that her employer was not aware of her business. Maids would gather outside the mall on their rest day, and some would come prepared with food for sale. PHOTO: SHIN MIN DAILY NEWS A chicken rice stall owner said that even though the maids' food prices were slightly higher, people still bought from them. "Our business was affected by about 20 per cent." The Singapore Food Agency told Shin Min Daily News that the authorities had begun investigating the case and will take action against food vendors without a licence. Under the Environmental Public Health Act 1987, a person must not hawk for sale any food or goods in a public place without first obtaining a licence. A spokesperson said that unregulated street food hawking not only poses environmental problems, but also may pose risks to public health. Illegally sold food may be unsafe for consumption as it does not meet the safety requirements of SFA. SFA will take appropriate action against illegal hawkers, and those with financial difficulties will be referred to social service agencies for assistance. The public can report the unlicensed sale of food on