logo
BYD unleashes an EV industry reckoning that alarms Beijing

BYD unleashes an EV industry reckoning that alarms Beijing

Business Times7 hours ago

[BEIJING] The price war engulfing China's electric vehicle (EV) industry has sent share prices tumbling and prompted an unusual level of intervention from Beijing. The shakeout may just be getting started.
For all the Chinese government's efforts to prevent price cuts by market leader BYD from turning into a vicious spiral, analysts say a combination of weaker demand and extreme overcapacity will slice into profits at the strongest brands and force feebler competitors to fold. Even after the number of EV makers starting shrinking for the first time last year, the industry is still using less than half its production capacity.
Chinese authorities are trying to minimise the fallout, chiding the sector for 'rat race competition' and summoning heads of major brands to Beijing last week. Yet previous attempts to intervene have had little success. For the short term at least, investors are betting few automakers will escape unscathed. BYD, arguably the biggest winner from industry consolidation, has lost US$21.5 billion in market value since its shares peaked in late May.
'What you are seeing in China is disturbing, because there's a lack of demand and extreme price cutting,' said John Murphy, a senior automotive analyst at Bank of America. Eventually, there will be 'massive consolidation' to soak up the excess capacity, Murphy said.
For automakers, relentless discounting erodes profit margins, undermines brand value and forces even well-capitalised companies into unsustainable financial positions. Low-priced and low-quality products can seriously damage the international reputation of 'Made-in-China' cars, the People's Daily, an outlet controlled by the Communist Party, said. And that knock would come just as models from BYD to Geely, Zeekr and Xpeng start to collect accolades on the world stage.
For consumers, price drops may seem beneficial but they mask deeper risks. Unpredictable pricing discourages long-term trust – already people are complaining on China's social media, wondering why they should buy a car now when it may be cheaper next week – while there's a chance automakers, as they cut costs to stay afloat, may reduce investment in quality, safety and after-sales service.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Auto CEOs were told last week they must 'self-regulate' and should not sell cars below cost or offer unreasonable price cuts, according to sources familiar with the matter. The issue of zero-mileage cars also came up – where vehicles with no distance on their odometers are sold by dealers into the second-hand market, seen widely as a way for automakers to artificially inflate sales and clear inventory.
Chinese automakers have been discounting a lot more aggressively than their foreign counterparts.
Murphy said US automakers should just get out. 'Tesla probably needs to be there to compete with those companies and understand what's going on, but there's a lot of risk there for them.'
Others leave no room for doubt that BYD, China's No 1 selling car brand, is the culprit.
'It's obvious to everyone that the biggest player is doing this,' Jochen Siebert, managing director at auto consultancy JSC Automotive, said. 'They want a monopoly where everybody else gives up.' BYD's aggressive tactics are raising concerns over the potential dumping of cars, dealership management issues and 'squeezing out suppliers', he said.
The pricing turmoil is also unfolding against a backdrop of significant overcapacity. The average production utilisation rate in China's automotive industry was a mere 49.5 per cent in 2024, data compiled by Shanghai-based Gasgoo Automotive Research Institute show.
An April report by AlixPartners meanwhile highlights the intense competition that's starting to emerge among new energy vehicle (NEV) makers or companies that produce pure battery cars and plug-in hybrids. In 2024, the market saw its first ever consolidation among NEV-dedicated brands, with 16 exiting and 13 launching.
'The Chinese automotive market, despite its substantial scale, is growing at a slower speed. Automakers have to put top priority now on grabbing more market share,' Ron Zheng, a partner at global consultancy Roland Berger GmbH, said.
Jiyue Auto shows how quickly things can change. A little over a year after launching its first car, the automaker jointly backed by big names Zhejiang Geely Holding Group and technology giant Baidu, began to scale down production and seek fresh funds.
It's a dilemma for all carmakers, but especially smaller ones. 'If you don't follow suit once a leading company makes a price move, you might lose the chance to stay at the table,' AlixPartners consultant Zhang Yichao said. He added that China's low capacity utilisation rate, which is 'fundamentally fuelling' the competition, is now even under more pressure from export uncertainties.
While the push to find an outlet for excess production is thrusting more Chinese brands to export, international markets can only offer some relief.
'The US market is completely closed and Japan and Korea may close very soon if they see an invasion of Chinese carmakers,' Siebert said. 'Russia, which was the biggest export market last year, is now becoming very difficult. I also don't see South-east Asia as an opportunity anymore.'
The pressure of cost-cutting has also led analysts to express concern over supply chain finance risks.
A price cut demand by BYD to one of its suppliers late last year attracted scrutiny around how the car giant may be using supply chain financing to mask its ballooning debt. A report by accounting consultancy GMT Research put BYD's true net debt at closer to 323 billion yuan (S$58 billion), compared with the 27.7 billion yuan officially on its books as at the end of June 2024.
The pain is also bleeding into China's dealership network. Dealership groups in two provinces have gone out of business since April, both of them ones that were selling BYD cars.
Beijing's meeting with automakers last week was not the first attempt at a ceasefire. Two years ago, in mid-2023, 16 major automakers, including Tesla, BYD and Geely signed a pact, witnessed by the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers (CAAM), to avoid 'abnormal pricing'.
Within days though, CAAM deleted one of the four commitments, saying that a reference to pricing in the pledge was inappropriate and in breach of a principle enshrined in the nation's antitrust laws.
The discounting continued unabated. BLOOMBERG

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Hong Kong to maintain US dollar peg despite geopolitical tensions
Hong Kong to maintain US dollar peg despite geopolitical tensions

Business Times

time27 minutes ago

  • Business Times

Hong Kong to maintain US dollar peg despite geopolitical tensions

[SHANGHAI] Hong Kong will maintain its currency peg to the US dollar, the financial hub's leader said in an interview published on Monday (Jun 9), despite escalating geopolitical tensions and some calls to shift to a Chinese yuan peg. The Hong Kong dollar has experienced sharp volatility over the past two months, strengthening to hit the strong end of the trading band and prompting the city's de-facto central bank to forcefully step up intervention, before the currency softened to near the weaker limit in recent sessions. 'Hong Kong's link with the US dollar has proven to be one of the fundamental success factors,' John Lee told the South China Morning Post, noting that the peg had always come under pressure, especially in uncertain times. In order to defend the currency's peg to move within the 7.75 and 7.85 per US dollar range, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority injected HK$129.4 billion (S$21.2 billion) into the market to purchase US$16.7 billion worth of US dollars in multiple interventions last month. Some market watchers have called for switching Hong Kong's US dollar peg to the yuan at a time when trade tensions between the world's two largest economies have created uncertainty. Lee said his administration would strengthen the city's role as the global offshore yuan hub, while continuing to defend the US dollar peg. 'We will do more (offshore yuan) product diversification, so that it will generate more trade,' he told the newspaper, noting that about 80 per cent of the offshore yuan payments were processed in Hong Kong. REUTERS

China exports slow as trade war takes toll
China exports slow as trade war takes toll

CNA

timean hour ago

  • CNA

China exports slow as trade war takes toll

BEIJING: Chinese exports grew slower than expected in May, according to official data on Monday (Jun 9), as shipments to the United States tumbled amid global trade turmoil triggered by Donald Trump's tariff blitz. The figures also showed imports suffered a forecast-beating drop, with weak domestic consumption in the world's number two economy highlighted by data earlier in the day revealing another month of falling prices. The 4.8 per cent year-on-year drop in overseas shipments last month was an improvement on April but bigger than the 6.0 per cent forecast in a survey of economists by Bloomberg. The reading included a 12.7 per cent plunge in exports to the US compared with April, when Trump unveiled his eye-watering tariffs on China. Imports from the US tanked 17.9 per cent after Beijing imposed tit-for-tat measures. Exports tumbled by a third year-on-year in May. In contrast, the data showed shipments to Vietnam increased from the previous month. Those to other Southeast Asian countries, including Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore and Indonesia, all declined slightly after soaring in April, the figures indicated. "The trade war between China and the US led to sharply lower exports to the US, but the damage was offset by stronger exports to other countries," Zhiwei Zhang, resident and Chief Economist at Pinpoint Asset Management, said in a note. "The trade outlook remains highly uncertain at this stage," he added, pointing to the impact of "frontloading", when overseas buyers increase shipments ahead of potentially higher tariffs. CONSUMER PRICES Monday's readings added to concerns about the Chinese economy, with a report from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) showing the consumer price index - a key measure of inflation - dropped 0.1 per cent year on year in May. The reading, which was slightly better than expected but marks the fourth straight month of falling prices, comes as Beijing struggles to boost the sluggish domestic consumption seen since the end of the pandemic. Leaders' failure to kickstart demand threatens their official growth targets and complicates their ability to shield their economy from Trump's tariff blitz. While deflation suggests the cost of goods is falling, it poses a threat to the broader economy as consumers tend to postpone purchases under such conditions, hoping for further reductions. A lack of demand can then force companies to cut production, freeze hiring or lay off workers, while potentially also having to discount existing stocks - dampening profitability even as costs remain the same. Deepening a slump that has now lasted more than two years, factory gate prices also dropped in May, the NBS said on Monday. The producer price index decline of 3.3 per cent - accelerating from a 2.7 per cent drop in April - was faster than the 3.2 per cent estimated in the Bloomberg survey. Representatives from China and the US are expected to meet on Monday in London for another round of high-stakes trade talks, markets hope will ease tensions between the economic superpowers. A key issue in the negotiations will be Beijing's shipments of rare earths, crucial to a range of goods including electric vehicle batteries and which have been a bone of contention between the two for some time. Figures Monday showed Chinese exports of 17 minerals rose last month to 5,865 from 4,785 tons in April. The London talks will be the second set of formal negotiations between the two since Trump launched his global trade blitz on Apr 2. They were announced after a phone call last week between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, which the US president described as "very good".

Auto companies ‘in full panic' over rare-earths bottleneck
Auto companies ‘in full panic' over rare-earths bottleneck

Straits Times

timean hour ago

  • Straits Times

Auto companies ‘in full panic' over rare-earths bottleneck

Car executives have once again been driven into their war rooms, concerned that China's tight export controls on rare-earth magnets could cripple production. PHOTO: REUTERS BERLIN/LONDON/DETROIT - Frank Eckard, chief executive of a German magnet maker, has been fielding a flood of calls in recent weeks. Exasperated automakers and parts suppliers have been desperate to find alternative sources of magnets, which are in short supply due to Chinese export curbs. Some told Mr Eckard their factories could be idled by mid-July without backup magnet supplies. 'The whole car industry is in full panic,' said Mr Eckard, CEO of Magnosphere, based in Troisdorf, Germany. 'They are willing to pay any price.' Car executives have once again been driven into their war rooms, concerned that China's tight export controls on rare-earth magnets – crucially needed to make cars – could cripple production. US President Donald Trump said on June 5 that Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to let rare earths minerals and magnets flow to the United States. A US trade team is scheduled to meet Chinese counterparts for talks in London on June 5. The industry worries that the rare-earths situation could cascade into the third massive supply chain shock in five years. A semiconductor shortage wiped away millions of cars from automakers' production plans, from roughly 2021 to 2023. Before that, the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020 shut factories for weeks. Those crises prompted the industry to fortify supply chain strategies. Executives have prioritized backup supplies for key components and reexamined the use of just-in-time inventories, which save money but can leave them without stockpiles when a crisis unfurls. Judging from Mr Eckard's inbound calls, though, 'nobody has learned from the past,' he said. This time, as the rare-earths bottleneck tightens, the industry has few good options, given the extent to which China dominates the market. The fate of automakers' assembly lines has been left to a small team of Chinese bureaucrats as it reviews hundreds of applications for export permits. Several European auto-supplier plants have already shut down, with more outages coming, said the region's auto supplier association, CLEPA. 'Sooner or later, this will confront everyone,' said CLEPA secretary-general Benjamin Krieger. Cars today use rare-earths-based motors in dozens of components – side mirrors, stereo speakers, oil pumps, windshield wipers, and sensors for fuel leakage and braking sensors. China controls up to 70 per cent of global rare-earths mining, 85 per cent of refining capacity and about 90 per cent of rare-earths metal alloy and magnet production, consultancy AlixPartners said. The average electric vehicle uses about .5 kg of rare earths elements, and a fossil-fuel car uses just half that, according to the International Energy Agency. China has clamped down before, including in a 2010 dispute with Japan, during which it curbed rare-earths exports. Japan had to find alternative suppliers, and by 2018, China accounted for only 58% of its rare earth imports. 'China has had a rare-earth card to play whenever they wanted to,' said Mark Smith, CEO of mining company NioCorp, which is developing a rare-earth project in Nebraska scheduled to start production within three years. Across the industry, automakers have been trying to wean off China for rare-earth magnets, or even develop magnets that do not need those elements. But most efforts are years away from the scale needed. 'It's really about identifying ... and finding alternative solutions' outside China, Joseph Palmieri, head of supply chain management at supplier Aptiv, said at a conference in Detroit last week. Automakers including General Motors and BMW and major suppliers such as ZF and BorgWarner are working on motors with low-to-zero rare-earth content, but few have managed to scale production enough to cut costs. The EU has launched initiatives including the Critical Raw Materials Act to boost European rare-earth sources. But it has not moved fast enough, said Noah Barkin, a senior advisor at Rhodium Group, a China-focused US think tank. Even players that have developed marketable products struggle to compete with Chinese producers on price. David Bender, co-head of German metal specialist Heraeus' magnet recycling business, said it is only operating at 1 per cent capacity and will have to close next year if sales do not increase. Minneapolis-based Niron has developed rare-earth free magnets and has raised more than US$250 million (S$322 million0 from investors including GM, Stellantis and auto supplier Magna. 'We've seen a step change in interest from investors and customers' since China's export controls took effect, CEO Jonathan Rowntree said. It is planning a US$1 billion plant scheduled to start production in 2029. UK-based Warwick Acoustics has developed rare-earth-free speakers expected to appear in a luxury car later this year. CEO Mike Grant said the company has been in talks with another dozen automakers, although the speakers are not expected to be available in mainstream models for about five years. As auto companies scout longer-term solutions, they are left scrambling to avert imminent factory shutdowns. Automakers must figure out which of their suppliers – and smaller ones a few links up the supply chain – need export permits. Mercedes-Benz, for example, is talking to suppliers about building rare-earth stockpiles. Analysts said the constraints could force automakers to make cars without certain parts and park them until they become available, as GM and others did during the semiconductor crisis. Automakers' reliance on China does not end with rare earth elements. A 2024 European Commission report said China controls more than 50 per cent of global supply of 19 key raw materials, including manganese, graphite and aluminum. Andy Leyland, co-founder of supply chain specialist SC Insights, said any of those elements could be used as leverage by China. 'This just is a warning shot,' he said. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store