Michael Ross still in 'no man's land' as Prime Video drops Orkney Assassin documentary
Michael Ross' solicitor has claimed that his client, who maintains his innocence, is stuck in "no man's land" three decades after being convicted of murder.
Back in June 1994, a masked figure donning a balaclava entered the Mumataz Restaurant in Kirwall at about 7.10pm and fatally shot 26-year-old waiter Shamsuddin Mahmood before exiting the scene.
Despite 14 years going by, Ross, then aged 15, was apprehended and found guilty of the crime in 2008.
Following his conviction at the High Court in Glasgow, Ross notoriously attempted to flee but was thwarted and now remains incarcerated for life at HMP Shotts in Lanarkshire, as reported by the BBC.
Prime Video has recently unveiled a one-off special titled The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles, which includes interviews with officers, eyewitnesses, journalists, and Ross' parents,.
In an exclusive chat with Screen Time prior to the documentary airing, Ross' lawyer Aamer Anwar provided an insight into his client's current plight.
(Image: PRIME VIDEO/ORKNEY PHOTOGRAPHIC)
"I suppose he's very much in no man's land," he commented.
"The difficulty with an appeal is...if you've ever watched Shawshank Redemption and Andy comes into prison and Morgan Freeman tells him 'Don't you know everyone's innocent inside'.
"But I've come to learn from over 25 years of being a lawyer that the reality is there are lots of innocent people inside prison.
"How to prove it is another matter, because the system is almost a raid against human rights throughout the United Kingdom, to be able to fight your appeal and to prove your innocence.
"And even if you say you have five pinnacles of evidence, five issues, and one is so critical.
"For instance, someone comes in and lies about you and says 'I saw him, that's definitely him.'
"But that person is ruled out, 'well we'll still rely on the other four afterwards.'
"The damage is already done. So therein lies the problem, as in people remain convicted."
Anwar then highlighted the crucial role of DNA in cases like Ross', stating: "The idea that someone could walk into a restaurant, shoot someone at point blank range and not leave anything of themselves, beggar's belief.
"I always say to my lecture students, to commit a murder is extremely difficult.
"To not leave anything of yourself: footprints, DNA, CCTV maybe, whatever it may be.
"Fair enough, this is a remote island but there were still people there.
"The idea that this person then disappears into the darkness? Then begs the question that people always said, 'well they never closed the ports of entry and exit.'
"Is it somebody from off the island that came on, well how do they know? They didn't."
Even though three decades have passed, Ross maintains his innocence, with the former Army sniper having attempted to break out of prison thrice, the latest being in 2018 when he tried to scale a fence.
"You still have someone who claims he is innocent, who has never given up that he is innocent, who is still fighting to prove his innocence," Anwar added.
"He could have made his life a lot easier by saying 'I did it.' A lot more chance of parole then, a lot more chance of getting out earlier."
The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles is available to watch on Prime Video.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
Keir Starmer won me a £300k payout from police but I don't recognise him anymore
Keir Starmer won me a £300k payout from police but I don't recognise him anymore Michael O'Brien, who was victim to a horrendous miscarriage of justice, once believed the Prime Minister was 'a very compassionate man' Michael O'Brien, who was wrongly convicted of Phillip Saunders' murder (Image: John Myers / WalesOnline) A Welshman who was wrongfully imprisoned for 11 years has voiced a searing accusation of hypocrisy against his former barrister, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, after losing a legal fight against the UK Government's decision to charge him "bed and board" for his time in jail. Michael O'Brien and two other men — known as the Cardiff Newsagent Three — were jailed for the 1987 killing of newsagent Phillip Saunders but later had their convictions quashed after police misconduct in the case emerged. Following his release Mr O'Brien, of Aberdare, was awarded £650,000 in compensation for the time he spent in prison, though an independent assessor decided £37,000 should be deducted from the payout to account for living costs like rent and food that he would have had to pay for if he hadn't been jailed. Mr O'Brien, 55, recently partnered with Paul Blackburn — who spent 25 years in jail for an attempted murder he did not commit and then had £100,000 bed and board cut from his compensation — to apply for a judicial review of the deduction. This week a High Court judge threw out their application, concluding: "Failing to reopen and increase past lawful compensation awards is not arguably irrational." Speaking to WalesOnline after the outcome, Mr O'Brien said it felt strange to have fought the Government in court given that its leader allegedly once told him the bed and board charge was "outrageous". During his time as a human rights barrister Sir Keir represented Mr O'Brien in a case against South Wales Police over the Cardiff Newsagent Three scandal, and in 2006 won a £300,000 settlement for his client — at the time described by the BBC as "the highest payout of its kind in a case of false imprisonment and malicious prosecution". That case was separate to the bed and board charge, but Mr O'Brien alleges the topic of the deduction came up during his conversations with Sir Keir at the time. "When we won the case he took me up to London," said Mr O'Brien. "He bought me dinner and everything. "We spoke about the bed and board charge and he told me it was outrageous and it should never have happened. He was a very compassionate man at one stage. I don't recognise the guy anymore. "Look at him now. He's allowing his Government to uphold bed and board charges against people who were wrongly imprisoned. I think that's disgraceful. Guilty people aren't charged when they are imprisoned, so why should innocent people be after miscarriages of justice?" 'Not a discrimination' After his conviction was overturned in 1999, Mr O'Brien successfully challenged the bed and board deduction in the High Court, but the UK Government then won in the Court of Appeal. At the time he decided not to appeal that ruling because of legal advice that he could face costs of around £140,000 if he lost again. But the debate returned to the headlines in 2023 when the rape conviction of Andrew Malkinson — who had spent 17 years in jail — was quashed and the then-Tory Government decided Mr Malkinson should not be charged for bed and board. The then-justice secretary Alex Chalk KC scrapped the policy of bed and board costs being deducted from payouts in such cases. But after coming into power last year the Labour government decided the change would not be applied retrospectively — meaning no refunds for people like Mr O'Brien whose compensation was paid before the new policy. In this week's ruling against Mr O'Brien and Mr Blackburn, the judge, Mr Justice Andrew Ritchie, said: "The fact that Government has recently changed the approach to be more generous to those applying after the policy change is not a 'discrimination'... [The ex-prisoners'] applications were dealt with and completed long before the time the policy changed." He added: "Failing to reopen and increase past lawful compensation awards is not arguably irrational. If it were, every time that a new head of compensatory damages was developed in the last 80 years (periodical payments for instance), all old claims would be arguably re-openable on the grounds that the change should have been retrospective." Michael O'Brien and supporters protesting 'bed and board' charge outside the Welsh Secretary's office in Cardiff in June 2025 (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne) Mr O'Brien has vowed not to give up the fight. More than 58,000 people have signed a petition against the deduction, and last year his campaigning led to 22 Senedd members signing a motion calling for retrospective repayment of bed and board deductions in cases like his. "I will be writing to every single MP calling on them to raise it in the UK Parliament as well," he said. "There's a lot of MPs who are outraged about it, we know that, but they need to speak up in Parliament." He added: "[This is] about every individual who has been wrongfully convicted and then charged for their stay in prison — a place they should never have been in the first place." The criticism of Sir Keir was not directly addressed by the UK Government, which told us living expenses have not been deducted from compensation since August 2023 but that "as is the case for most Government policy, this change does not apply retrospectively". Article continues below You can read more about the miscarriages of justice against the Cardiff Newsagent Three here.
Scottish Sun
11 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Nicola Sturgeon reveals she will forever be ‘in shadow' of Alex Salmond in bombshell admission
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NICOLA Sturgeon has admitted she will never escape Alex Salmond's shadow "even in death". The ex-First Minister, 55, makes the admission in her memoir Frankly - set to be released next week. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 4 Nicola Sturgeon, pictured with the late former FM & SNP leader Alex Salmond Credit: PA 4 Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon were close political partners before his sex assault charges - of which he was later cleared - caused a rift between the pair Credit: Reuters 4 Nicola Sturgeon was Alex Salmond's deputy and the pair campaigned together in the 2014 Independence Referendum Credit: Getty - Contributor The comments have been revealed in the latest extract from her upcoming book has been released this evening. Mr Salmond died aged 69 on October 12 last year while attending a conference in North Macedonia. Ms Sturgeon did not attend her former pal's funeral on October 29 and was pictured at comedian Janey Godley's funeral on the date of his November 30 memorial. As reported in The Times, she said: 'Before he died, I thought I had reached the point of feeling nothing and that I had come to terms with it, wholly and completely. 'The emotions I felt on hearing of his death suggested otherwise. "Yes, I have made peace with how things are, but it is an uneasy peace. I know I will never quite escape the shadow he casts, even in death.' Find out what's really going on Register now for our free weekly politics newsletter for an insightful and irreverent look at the (sometimes excruciating) world of Scottish Politics. Every Thursday our hotshot politics team goes behind the headlines to bring you a rundown of key events - plus insights and gossip from the corridors of power, including a 'Plonker' and 'Star' of the Week. Sign up now and make sure you don't miss a beat. The politicians would hate that. SIGN UP FOR FREE NOW The pair's fall out, after a decades long friendship, came after Mr Salmond learned of a Scottish Government probe into the former SNP leader over two internal complaints of alleged sexual misconduct in March 2018. Hundreds turn out for Alex Salmond's memorial including Gordon Brown, John Swinney and The Proclaimers Mr Salmond went on to launch a judicial review against the handling of the complaints process and was awarded more than £500,000 in legal expenses in August but soon after he was arrested and charged. He went on trial at the High Court in Edinburgh facing 14 charges, including two counts of alleged attempted rage and nine counts of alleged sexual assault. The high-profile trial got underway at the High Court in Edinburgh in March 2020 and Mr Salmond was found not guilty by a jury over the 12 sexual assault charges, one charge was found not proven and another dropped by the Crown. In January 2019, the Scottish Government admitted that it had breached its own guidelines, with judges ruling its probe into the complaints was 'unlawful' and 'tainted with apparent bias'. I have made peace with how things are, but it is an uneasy peace. I know I will never quite escape the shadow he casts, even in death Nicola Sturgeon She said she her former ally became 'determined to destroy' her and became driven by revenge. She said: 'For a while I told myself that the bonds between Alex and me would be stronger than his thirst for revenge. 'Eventually, though, I had to face the fact that he was determined to destroy me. I was now engaged in mortal political combat with someone I knew to be both ruthless and highly effective. It was a difficult reality to reconcile myself to.' Addressing the fallout in a BBC months before his death, Mr Salmond said: 'A big regret that Nicola and I are no longer on speaking terms, and I seriously doubt if that's going to improve. 'Now, that's a great pity because I did indicate that you shouldn't say anything's for ever, but that's the way it looks and that's just the way it's going to be.' Also discussing their relationship in the documentary, Ms Sturgeon said: 'One of the hardest things about the breakdown between me and Alex is the fact that so many of the best moments of my life, he is so integral to, and it's hard now to look back on them with just unallowed pleasure and joy.' In an extract released last night, Ms Sturgeon also claims her arrest during Operation Branchform, Police Scotland's probe into the SNP's finances, was the "worst day of my life". She described her life in the aftermath of her being nicked as "mental torture". Ms Sturgeon also reflects on her miscarriage after falling pregnant during her relationship with Peter Murrell. The now estranged couple tied the knot in July 2010, but in January, she announced they had split.
The Independent
16 hours ago
- The Independent
London protests live: Police swoop to make arrests as hundreds rally in support of Palestine Action
More than 50 people have been arrested at a demonstration against the terror ban of the group Palestine Action. Hundreds of people have gathered in Parliament Square in Westminster to hold up signs, which read: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action'. The Metropolitan Police has brought in scores of officers from other forces to help deal with a busy weekend of protests. Between 600 and 700 people are taking part in the demonstration against the terror ban, organisers of the action in Westminster said on Saturday. The government's proscription of Palestine Action as a terror group is currently being challenged in the High Court, with a court case expected later in the autumn. As a result of Palestine Action's proscription, it is now an offence to hold up a sign or wear a t-shirt in support of group under section 13 of the Terrorism Act. Home secretary says freedom to protest is 'cornerstone of democracy' Ahead of today's demonstration against the ban of Palestine Action, the Home Office said that the group's proscription as a terror organisation would not affect 'the freedom to protest on Palestinian rights'. A Home Office spokesperson said on Saturday: 'The home secretary has been clear that the proscription of Palestine Action is not about Palestine, nor does it affect the freedom to protest on Palestinian rights. 'It only applies to the specific and narrow organisation whose activities do not reflect or represent the thousands of people across the country who continue to exercise their fundamental rights to protest on different issues. 'Freedom to protest is a cornerstone of our democracy and we protect it fiercely'. Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 14:21 Who are Palestine Action? The proscribed 'terror' group taking the government to court Palestine Action is a direct action group that was banned by the Home Office after several of its members broke into an Oxfordshire RAF base to spray-paint military planes. Formed in 2020, Palestine Action has conducted a series of direct action protests over the past five years, largely against arms manufacturers operating in the UK and selling weapons to Israel. Unveiling the intention to ban the group following the incident on June 23, Ms Cooper said it was the latest in a 'long history of unacceptable criminal damage committed by Palestine Action'. Who are Palestine Action? The proscribed group taking the government to court The UK-based group has been targeting arms manufacturers in the UK since 2020 Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 14:10 What is it like at the Lift the Ban protest? The crowd, who gathered in Westminster at 1pm, could be seen writing "I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action" on white placards, with the vast majority remaining silent. Several demonstrators carrying placards that read "Palestine Action terrorises Britain while Hamas hides in hospitals, schools and mosques", briefly walked along the crowd before being led away by Metropolitan Police officers. Other clusters of protesters who were not holding placards gathered around the Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela statues in the square singing pro-Palestinian chants. The officers lifted the protesters - some sitting and some lying flat - off the ground before escorting them away. Onlookers applauded the protesters and shouted "Shame on you" at the police making arrests. Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 14:01 Bianca Jagger attends London protest against Palestine Action ban Bianca Jagger was among the demonstrators at Parliament Square, holding a sign quoting the words of UN human rights chief Volker Turk. Mr Turk has criticised the ban, saying that it was at odds with international human rights law. Ms Jagger wrote in The Independent that she would be at the demonstration 'to demand that the UK government uphold our right to freedom of speech and to denounce the genocide that the Israeli government is perpetrating in Gaza against the Palestinian people'. Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 14:00 Pictured: People take part in Lift the Ban protest in Westminster People protesting against Palestine Action's terror ban take part in a mass action in Parliament Square, Westminster, central London. Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 13:57 Police have started making arrests at protest against Palestine Action ban Police have started arresting demonstrators for holding up signs in support of banned terror group Palestine Action in Parliament Square, Westminster. Hundreds of people gathered in Westminster at 1pm today and wrote 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action' on cardboard signs. This is an offence under terror laws, as the law bans signs or t-shirts in support of terror groups. Home secretary Yvette Cooper recently proscribed the group Palestine Action, after an attack on UK military planes at RAF Brize Norton. Holly Bancroft9 August 2025 13:54
