logo
Calls for cyber charter reform intensify after audit found ballooning revenue, surpluses

Calls for cyber charter reform intensify after audit found ballooning revenue, surpluses

Yahoo04-03-2025

Spotlight PA is an independent, nonpartisan, and nonprofit newsroom producing investigative and public-service journalism that holds power to account and drives positive change in Pennsylvania. Sign up for our free newsletters.
HARRISBURG — Key Republicans say they are increasingly convinced they must reform Pennsylvania's quickly growing cyber charter schools after an audit identified ballooning revenue and surpluses and 'uncommon' spending.
For years, efforts to overhaul the way these schools are funded and overseen have foundered amid Harrisburg's complicated education politics. Republicans, in particular, have been torn between fiscal accountability and ensuring families have considerable alternatives to public schools.
But the audit, from Republican Auditor General Tim DeFoor, may have cut through some of the political noise. Echoing past reviews, DeFoor identified big surpluses and schools spending taxpayer dollars in questionable ways, including on gift cards, staff bonuses, and vehicle payments.
'The message to me was, we need to do something,' said state Sen. Lynda Schlegel Culver (R., Snyder), who took over this session as chair of the Senate's Education Committee.
Culver said she's aware that the last several chairs of her committee have also tried to work on this issue.
'They would get so close, and it just didn't happen — I had heard at one point, they were walking into the meeting, and it just fell apart as they were walking into the meeting,' Culver said. 'It's my hope with this report, which is very factual … that we have some consensus.'
DeFoor is the third auditor general to review cyber charter finances. In an interview with Spotlight PA, he said that while school funding and oversight can be highly political, 'Politics had nothing to do with taking this on.
'We're simply following up with what was done previously by other auditor generals, and also following up with how our schools are spending our tax dollars,' he said.
DeFoor's audit, the first since enrollment ballooned during the pandemic, looked at five of the commonwealth's 14 cyber charters.
He found the revenue that these charters take in nearly doubled from 2020 to 2023, from $473 million to $898 million. He also found that those schools' financial reserves increased by nearly 150% in that period.
As in previous audits, DeFoor also looked at the ways cyber charters were spending their considerable budgets.
Along with spending on things like gift cards and bonuses, there were also much bigger outlays. Commonwealth Charter Academy, the state's largest cyber charter operator, also spent $196 million to buy, renovate, or do both to 21 buildings over the period of the audit. In his news conference announcing his findings, DeFoor said the expenditure 'seems a bit out of the ordinary for a public school that is based in online instruction.'
All of this is legal under Pennsylvania's charter school law, DeFoor noted.
'These were taxpayer dollars,' DeFoor said. 'And cyber charter schools are able to do this legally because we have an old and outdated formula that really hasn't been changed since 2002.'
The law that dictates state funding for charters is the same for both brick-and-mortar and cyber schools. Public districts pay per-student tuition directly to charters, and that tuition is based on the district's per-student spending, with some deductions like facilities expenses.
If a student has a disability, their tuition is built on that base rate for the district, plus a standard percentage of its spending for all disability services — regardless of the kind of disability the student has.
In recent state House and Senate budget hearings on education policy, this state of affairs came up again and again.
Acting Education Secretary Carrie Rowe, who is newly in charge of the department, told lawmakers in the state House that 'to say that I was anything less than exceptionally concerned by the auditor general's report would be an understatement.'
In particular, she noted, she sees a real need to reduce the surpluses that cyber charters are allowed to carry, noting that 'when you juxtapose the 41% fund balances that … cyber schools have with the approximately 10% fund balances that [traditional] school districts have, it certainly is concerning.'
What has not been forthcoming, so far, is a consensus on a solution.
In his most recent budget proposal, Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, asked lawmakers to overhaul cyber charter funding by instituting a statewide, per-student base rate of $8,000 for all cyber charters, rather than the widely variable district-based spending that currently exists.
He also pitched that approach last year, and Republicans have so far been noncommittal on it.
The issue is complicated by several other, interconnected education policy debates. State lawmakers are currently operating under a court order to fix the funding system for traditional public schools, after a judge found the previous system unconstitutionally inequitable. That's creating a significant need for revenue.
As part of this debate, Republicans have pushed hard for programs aimed at creating more alternatives to public schools, including a taxpayer-funded voucher proposal that would send children to private and parochial schools. Culver noted that's still a priority for her caucus.
'Everything is interconnected to everything else,' she said.
A spokesperson for state Senate Republicans did not respond to a request for comment.
In his audit, DeFoor stopped short of calling for a particular fix for the cyber charter funding system, saying instead that Shapiro should convene a task force to review the current formula and recommend a new one that is 'equitable, reasonable and sustainable.'
Culver said she's open to a task force but noted that assembling one and then waiting for its reports will take months.
'I don't know that anybody wants to wait that long,' she said.
She added, 'My concern would be, do we already have enough data, enough studies on this issue? I'm still there, and we're still looking at it, but I think over the next, say, two or three months, you'll see a lot more movement on this issue.'
If you learned something from this article, pay it forward and contribute to Spotlight PA at spotlightpa.org/donate. Spotlight PA is funded by foundations and readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Biden admin evacuated 55 Afghans on terror watchlist to US during botched withdrawal: DOJ watchdog
Biden admin evacuated 55 Afghans on terror watchlist to US during botched withdrawal: DOJ watchdog

New York Post

time24 minutes ago

  • New York Post

Biden admin evacuated 55 Afghans on terror watchlist to US during botched withdrawal: DOJ watchdog

US officials encountered 55 Afghan evacuees on the terrorist watchlist after the Biden administration's chaotic 2021 withdrawal from the Middle Eastern country, according to a Justice Department inspector general report. The report, released Tuesday, confirmed longstanding suspicions from Republican lawmakers that the Biden administration failed to properly vet US-bound refugees as the Taliban retook control of Afghanistan. 'I've sounded the alarm about the need to thoroughly vet Afghan evacuee applicants since August 2021,' Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) said in a statement, reacting to the DOJ IG report. 'The Biden-Harris administration, my Democrat colleagues in Congress and many in the media were quick to dismiss glaring red flags that a nonpartisan national security analysis now confirms.' 3 Grassley charged that the Biden administration endangered the lives of Americans by allowing improperly vetted Afghan refugees into the US. AP The FBI's Terrorist Screening Center (TSC) identified 55 Afghans that were either already on the terrorist watchlist and made it to a US port of entry or were added to the database during the evacuation and resettlement process, the report found. Of those, at least 21 were added to the terror list after they had already entered the US. After investigations, the FBI eventually removed 46 evacuees from the watchlist, determining that they posed no threat to the homeland. However, nine remained in the terror database as of July 2024 and eight were in the US. 'As if it wasn't already obvious, the Biden-Harris administration endangered American lives by allowing suspected terrorists to enter the United States and roam free for years,' Grassley argued, noting that his 'oversight of this matter will continue.' Roughly 90,000 Afghans were allowed entry into the US and became eligible for Special immigrant Visas under the Biden administration's Operation Allies Refuge (OAR) and Operation Allies Welcome (OAW) programs, which provided the foreign nationals immigration processing and resettlement support. 'According to the FBI, the need to immediately evacuate Afghans overtook the normal processes required to determine whether individuals attempting to enter the United States pose a threat to national security, which increased the risk that bad actors could try to exploit the expedited evacuation,' the DOJ IG report stated. Despite the 55 individuals flagged, the DOJ inspector general determined that overall 'each of the responsible elements of the FBI effectively communicated and addressed any potential national security risks identified.' 3 The Biden administration hastily evacuated tens of thousands of Afghans as the country fell to the Taliban in 2021. AFP via Getty Images 3 As of July 2024, eight Afghans on the FBI's terror watchlist were still in the United States. AP Last October, the DOJ charged an Afghan national brought into the US during the chaotic withdrawal with plotting an ISIS-inspired Election Day terror attack. Nasir Ahmad Tawhedi, 27, was living in Oklahoma City on a Special Immigrant Visa as he took steps to stockpile AK-47 rifles and ammunition to carry out an attack on US soil 'in the name of ISIS,' according to the Justice Department. Tawhedi entered the US on Sept. 9, 2021, just weeks after the Taliban regained control of Afghanistan and the last US troops departed from the war-torn nation. Tawhedi was charged with conspiring and attempting to provide material support to ISIS and is currently awaiting trial.

Democrat Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli to face off in race for New Jersey governor
Democrat Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli to face off in race for New Jersey governor

Washington Post

time26 minutes ago

  • Washington Post

Democrat Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli to face off in race for New Jersey governor

TRENTON, N.J. — Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli, who had President Donald Trump's endorsement, won their primary elections in New Jersey's race for governor, setting the stage for a November election, poised to be fought in part over affordability and the president's policies. Sherrill emerged from a crowded field of five experienced rivals on the strength of her biography as a Navy pilot and former prosecutor who has been a vocal critic of President Donald Trump.

Takeaways from New Jersey election: Trump looms large and signs of Democratic enthusiasm
Takeaways from New Jersey election: Trump looms large and signs of Democratic enthusiasm

Washington Post

time26 minutes ago

  • Washington Post

Takeaways from New Jersey election: Trump looms large and signs of Democratic enthusiasm

NORTH BERGEN, N.J. — New Jersey primary voters chose their nominees — and President Donald Trump notched a win in his endorsement belt — in one of two high-stakes governor's races being held this year. While officials from both parties say November's general election will hinge on local, pocketbook issues, the outcome will also be closely watched as a harbinger of how both parties might fare in next year's midterm elections, and as a test of both Democratic enthusiasm and how the GOP fares without Trump on the ballot. Here are five takeaways from Tuesday's primary results: 2025's off-year elections have been rough for Republicans and Trump. The president went all in on Wisconsin's state Supreme Court race this spring, backing conservative Brad Schimel, even as polls showed Schimel lagging his Democratic-backed rival. Schimel went on to lose by a whopping 10 points , even after billionaire Elon Musk and groups he backed poured $21 million into the race. This time, Trump's chosen candidate, Republican front-runner Jack Ciattarelli, easily won the nomination. 'Jack Ciattarelli is a WINNER, and has my Complete and Total Endorsement – HE WILL NOT LET YOU DOWN,' Trump wrote in a social media post announcing his endorsement last month. 'MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN, ELECT JACK CIATTARELLI!' After losing in 2021 to term-limited Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy by the slimmest of margins, Ciattarelli is hoping his third try for the office will be the charm. The endorsement was a blow, in particular, to Ciattarelli rival Bill Spadea, a conservative radio host who ran by vowing to enthusiastically back the president's agenda. Ciattarelli, he complained in one ad, 'did more than disagree with the president. He disrespected him. Me? I've been a supporter of President Trump since he came down the escalator.' He said voters should feel free to flout Trump's advice: 'I've disagreed with him in the past. It's ok for you to disagree with him now.' Trump, who spends many summer weekends in the state at his Bedminister golf club, alluded to the name dropping during a tele-rally he held on Ciattarelli's behalf . 'Other people are going around saying I endorsed them. That's not true,' he said. Candidates on both sides of the aisle vowed to tackle pocketbook issues, from high property taxes to grocery prices, to housing and health care costs. But Trump loomed large. On the GOP side, most of the candidates professed their allegiances to the president. Ciattarelli said in ads that he would work with Trump and end New Jersey's status as a sanctuary state 'on Day One.' (Currently, the state's attorney general has directed local law enforcement not to assist federal agents in civil immigration matters.) He also pledged to direct his attorney general to end lawsuits filed against the Trump administration, including one challenging Trump's effort to end birthright citizenship . Democrats featured him heavily, too. In one ad, Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill — who won the Democratic primary Tuesday and will take on Ciattarelli in November — featured an armada of pickup trucks waving giant Trump flags and warned that, 'Trump's coming for New Jersey with Trump-endorsed Republican Jack Ciattarelli.' 'We've gotta stop them,' it said. In another, she tells viewers, 'I know the world feels like it is on fire right now,' and vows to 'stand up to Trump and Musk with all I've got.' Back in 2015, Ciattarelli labeled then-candidate Trump a 'charlatan' who was unfit for the office of the presidency and an embarrassment to the nation. 'Instead of providing the kind of leadership that appeals to the better angels of our nature in calling us to meaningful and just action, Mr. Trump preys upon our worst instincts and fears,' he wrote. When Ciattarelli ran in 2021, he distanced himself from Trump, without the outward insults. Trump nonetheless complained about the treatment on Spadea's radio show last year, saying Ciattarelli 'made some very big mistakes' and would have won had he sought Trump's support. But like Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, and so many others, past insults gave way to alliance. Trump offered his enthusiastic backing in a tele-rally, and in his endorsement, said that, 'after getting to know and understand MAGA,' Ciattarelli 'has gone ALL IN, and is now 100% (PLUS!).' November's presidential election offered warning signs for Democrats in the state. While Trump lost to Democrat Kamala Harris, he did so by only 6 points — a significantly smaller margin than in 2020, when President Joe Biden won by 16 points. 'New Jersey's ready to pop out of that blue horror show,' Trump said in the tele-rally held for Ciattarelli last week. Trump also made stunning gains in several longtime Democratic strongholds, including New Jersey's heavily Latino Passaic County. He carried the city of Passaic and significantly increased his support in Paterson, which is majority Latino and also has a large Muslim community. Indeed, 43% of Latino voters in the state supported Trump, up from 28% in 2020, according to AP VoteCast. November's election will serve as a crucial test for Democrats and whether they can regain Latino support — both in the state and nationally. In the primary, strategists, unions, organizers and candidates pivoted away from immigration and focused on pocketbook concerns in their appeals. 'At the end of the day, if you're worried about paying your bills and being safe at night, everything else is secondary,' Rep. Josh Gottheimer , one of the Democratic candidates, told the AP. 'I think that is front and center in the Latino community.' One exception was Newark Mayor Ras Baraka , who was arrested while trying to join an oversight tour of a 1,000-bed immigrant detention center. A trespass charge was later dropped, but he sued interim U.S. Attorney Alina Habba over the dropped prosecution. In one of his final campaign ads in Spanish, he used footage from the arrest to cast himself as a reluctant warrior, with text saying he is 'El Único,' Spanish for 'the only one,' who confronts Trump. Sherrill emerged from a crowded field that included two members of Congress, Baraka, Jersey City Mayor Steven Fulop , teacher's union president and former Montclair Mayor Sean Spiller and former state Senate President Steve Sweeney . Sherrill leaned heavily on her biography as a former Navy helicopter pilot, federal prosecutor and a mother of four, using images of herself in uniform in her ads. Her campaign logo features a mini helicopter. Democrats hope November's general election — along with a gubernatorial election in Virginia — will draw a swell of angry voters eager to show their disdain for Trump's sweeping second-term agenda, foreshadowing Democratic gains in next year's midterms. There were signs of strong Democratic enthusiasm in early voting numbers. As of the last day of early in-person voting Sunday, more than 330,000 Democratic ballots had been cast, well outpacing the number of votes cast prior to last year's Democratic presidential primary. That compares to just 130,000 ballots cast by Republicans during the same time — a number that also tops early votes cast in last year's Republican presidential primary and reflects the broader trend of Democrats being far more likely to vote early than Republicans, who tend to turn out in far greater numbers on Election Day.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store