EU stays quiet as Greek top court appointment row deepens
Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Greek judges are up in arms after the conservative government bypassed their input on Supreme Court appointments. Yet, Brussels remains silent despite flagging rule of law concerns in its annual report on such matters this year.
According to the European Commission's 2025 Rule of Law Report, public trust in the Greek justice system remains low, with citizens and businesses consistently believing that the judiciary is politically influenced.
At the centre of the dispute lies the process of appointing top judges, which, unlike in other EU countries, remains under the government's complete control.
Following a Commission recommendation, the Greek government passed legislation in 2024 enabling judges to express a non-binding opinion on their preferred candidates for senior judicial roles - a move the EU executive welcomed just last month.
But earlier this week, the conservative Mitsotakis government disregarded the results of a secret ballot conducted among judges on eight vice-presidential candidates to the Supreme Court, excluding all those endorsed by the judiciary.
The Commission, however, has so far refused to comment on the situation.
'We do not comment on individual cases,' a spokesperson told Euractiv, referring to the Rule of Law Report and adding that the Commission will "continue monitoring development".
Meanwhile, the Greek Association of Judges and Prosecutors issued a statement accusing the government of trying to preserve its unchecked authority over judicial appointments once again. The judges also said the new law serves no purpose if judicial opinions are ignored.
Justice Minister Giorgos Floridis hit back on Wednesday, saying Greece would 'not become a state of judges.'
He also warned that judicial autonomy could lead to a system 'that has nothing to do with democracy,' and stressed that nowhere in the world do judges alone select their top officials.
Judicial appointment systems vary across the EU. In most member states, governments do not have exclusive control as parliaments and judicial bodies are also involved.
In Italy, for example, five of the 15 Constitutional Court judges are appointed by the president, five are elected by parliament, and five come from high courts.
In France, top judges are appointed by the president based on proposals from the High Council of the Judiciary, a body composed of judges, legal professionals, and political appointees.
In Germany, judges of the Federal Constitutional Court are elected by a two-thirds majority in both houses of parliament, ensuring broad political consensus.
(cs, de)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euractiv
3 hours ago
- Euractiv
Commission seeks EU court nod for ECHR bid after years of gridlock
Commission moves to break 15-year impasse on EU's accession to Strasbourg-based human rights court Euractiv is part of the Trust Project Nicoletta Ionta Euractiv Jul 25, 2025 20:14 2 min. read News Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. The European Commission has decided to seek a formal opinion from the EU's top court to clear the path for the bloc's long-overdue accession to the European Court of Human Rights, after years of deadlock. (aw) Euractiv is part of the Trust Project Topics
Euractiv
3 hours ago
- Euractiv
EU says it can't kick Russia out of flagship nuclear fusion project
Moscow cannot be expelled from Europe's top nuclear fusion project, EU energy commissioner Dan Jørgensen has confirmed in response to concerns raised by members of the European Parliament. The project, called the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER), is intended to prove that the Holy Grail of clean energy can be achieved: an emissions-free source based on the same reactions that power the stars. ITER is an international collaboration based in the south of France, to which Europe contributes almost half of the costs, with the rest shared equally by China, India, Japan, the Republic of Korea, the Russian Federation and the United States. Russia has faced international condemnation and growing isolation, as well as a raft of Western sanctions, since launching its unprovoked, full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The EU has significantly reduced its energy dependency on Russia. In May, three members of the centre-right European People's Party asked what the European Commission was planning to do to end Russia's participation in ITER, noting the recent plan to end the bloc's dependency on Russia for nuclear power (as well as fossil fuels) was 'silent on fusion energy". Jørgensen replied today that the EU does not have the authority to force Russia out of the project. "The ITER Agreement does not provide for the possibility of terminating the participation or suspension of the rights of any ITER Member, including the participation in the ITER Council – the governing body," the EU's most senior energy official wrote. Acountry can leave only 'on its own accord," he said. Russia, like the other international partners in the project, contributes 9.1% to the construction of the experimental fusion reactor. Consortium members' contributions are mainly 'in-kind', in the form of components and systems technology, with only 10% in cash. 'This unique procurement sharing program has an important purpose, allowing all members to gain direct industrial experience in key fusion technologies,' ITER's website reads. Russia 'has fulfilled all its in-kind contributions', Jørgensen said in his statement. As a consequence, the dependency on Moscow was 'now reduced in this regard', he said, adding that 'bilateral contacts and engagement with Russia are minimised' and that the reactor's operations won't depend on Russian intellectual property rights. (rh, aw)
Euractiv
3 hours ago
- Euractiv
The Brief – 25 July 2025: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Good Friday afternoon, wherever you may be. Schuman was markedly quieter this morning, coffee shops are shuttered, and motorways are laden with holiday-makers heading south for the Grand Départ. Fear not, here at Euractiv HQ desks are still occupied and newsletters will still be delivered for two more weeks. And whilst the summer exodus empties a large part of the city, there's still plenty to report on. Including secluded parties in the depths of the European Parliament, where one young MEP has been hosting exclusive soirées, with DJs, beer on tap, and free pizza. Nicoletta Ionta got the invite and spilled the goods about this novel approach to politicking. The Asian tour EU leaders made a fleeting visit to the eastern hemisphere, stopping in Japan on Wednesday before piling back aboard the plane for a rather colder reception in China on Thursday. The Japan leg was a relatively amiable affair that secured an agreement to cooperate on procuring critical raw materials and strengthen business ties. Given the EU delegation's next stop, any mention of China was avoided, though the Japan mission clearly aims to reduce dependency on the world's manufacturing behemoth. Thursday's assignment – ostensibly a celebration of 50 years' diplomatic ties between the EU and China – was always going to be awkward, with Europe hooked on Chinese goods but also outraged by its support for Russia, its grip on rare earths, and disregard for human rights. Von der Leyen has hardened her tone towards this inconvenient trading partner and reiterated these grievances on the visit, though her Chinese counterparts showed little interest, leaving the Europeans to close the day with a press conference devoid of Chinese representatives. Gaza stirs European consciences The humanitarian emergency in Gaza has deteriorated for months as Israeli forces continue their ruthless assault on Hamas forces and render the war-torn region practically uninhabitable. With Palestinian civilians trapped in camps and precious little aid being delivered, acute starvation has become one more cause of death. For many in Europe, the situation has grown intolerable. But EU criticism of Israel's offensive has fallen short of sanctions, and agreements to provide more aid have failed to alleviate the crisis. In light of the situation, France announced Thursday that it will recognise the State of Palestine – a step taken by Spain and Ireland already last year. Whether this will significantly shift the dial on EU relations with Israel is not yet clear. An emergency call between France, Germany, and the United Kingdom takes place on Friday afternoon, though Merz has already said his government will not recognise a Palestinian state "in the short term". The European Parliament is also unsure whether to allow keffiyehs (the traditional Arab headdress now symbolic of solidarity with Palestine) in the building. The lack of clarity makes it likely that this will remain a point of contention – one that already has sparked skirmishes. Kids and social media A growing concern about the dangers of social media for minors has seen Brussels set guidelines for how platforms should protect children using their online services. Measures to restrict access vary between EU countries, with France leading the fight after coming down hard on porn websites last month. Under the auspices of the Digital Services Act, other countries are tightening access requirements and testing age verification. Much ado about veggie food If you thought 'Solmon' or 'Tu-nah' were inoffensive labels for non-fish alternatives, think again. The fish industry is in a flap about names that imitate the real thing and want to put an end to it (though it won't stop companies producing the actual products). "Call a spade a spade," an industry representative argued; one MEP supportive of the cause said that fish lovers should be "worried". The opposition follows a similar battle for the right to use terrestrial meat terms for plant-based alternatives. But the industry distress has done little to dent veggie appetites, as sales of non-meat delicacies continue to rise. Belgium-France nuclear cooperation The anti-nuclear sentiment whipped up by Green parties in Belgium has finally dissipated and the new government has overturned plans to phase out the country's reactors. But to make a "more sustainable, competitive and resilient Europe", Belgium will work closely with France to extend its nuclear capacity. Across Europe, attitudes towards the zero-emissions energy sources are changing as governments recognise their potential to deliver energy sovereignty and reduce dependence on natural gas imports.
