‘You'll be a rich little girl'; Sydney woman sues parents over real estate empire promise, loses in court
A long-running family dispute over a real estate business and home ownership in Sydney's eastern suburbs has been settled in court, with the daughter losing her legal claim. Paula-Marie Penya took her father, Paul Penya, to the NSW Supreme Court, arguing that she was promised by her father and mother, Therese, the family's real estate agency, and their Eastlakes home in return for working unpaid for over 20 years. She told the court she relied on repeated assurances she would end up a "rich little girl."
Also Read: Why do we really get wrinkles? Scientists finally explain it's not just age or sun exposure, it's physicsHowever, in Penya v Penya [2025] NSWSC 805, Justice Kate Williams found no evidence of a 'clear and unequivocal' promise that either asset would be transferred to her during her parents' lifetimes. The court ruled the statements amounted to inheritance hopes, not a binding agreement. Paul Penya sold the business to Century 21 in 2018, and Paula-Marie received $5,000 from the sale. The legal dispute began when Paul later moved to sell the Eastlakes home he co-owns with Therese to fund his retirement.
Paula-Marie, who lives in the house with her partner and children, opposed the sale. She said she couldn't afford to buy him out and argued she had been promised the property. But the court allowed the sale to go ahead under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW).
Justice Williams dismissed Paula-Marie's claims of proprietary estoppel, common intention trust, and joint endeavour. The court noted that although she had worked for years at the family business, she had not shown a concrete agreement that gave her legal rights over the assets.
Also Read: She was smart, popular, and different; so why was Tiffany Salmond let go? The judge also pointed out that Paula-Marie had declined or postponed taking over the business before it was sold, despite her father's requests.Paula-Marie and her partner were able to purchase multiple investment properties over the years, aided by the fact they lived rent-free at the Eastlakes home. The court saw this as significant and inconsistent with claims of financial sacrifice.As reported by news.com.au, Paul Penya revoked his earlier will, which left his estate to Paula-Marie, and instead named his long-term partner, Irene, as beneficiary. In court, he said, 'I made them millionaires; they were useless.'
Also Read: Widespread rainfall to drench Southeast Australia, heaviest in over two years to last until Thursday The court ruled that Paula-Marie and her family must vacate the Eastlakes home at least seven days before the property's sale. Trustees will be appointed to carry out the sale as permitted by law.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
42 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Haryana CM Nayab Singh Saini distributes appointment letters to newly selected Group D employees
ANI Haryana CM Nayab Singh Saini distributes appointment letters to newly selected Group D employees Haryana Chief Minister Nayab Singh Saini distributed appointment letters to newly selected Group D employees at a ceremony held in the state capital on Chief Minister Nayab Saini on X posted his best wishes to the newly selected Group D employees upon receiving their appointment letters during an introductory program held in Panchkula, at the revered site of Mansa his X post, he wrote, "Best wishes to the newly selected employees of Group D for their appointment letters and new responsibilities! This 'introductory program' organised on the sacred land of Panchkula, situated at the feet of Mother Mansa Devi, marks the day of a new beginning for the new employees. Today's youth is full of new ideas and energy. My appeal is that you adopt new technologies and work with honesty and transparency at the grassroots level because every small step you take, every honest effort, can bring about a significant change. If Haryana is reaching new heights in every field today, this success is not only due to policymakers but also to the youth. Make public service the goal of your life. I hope that all of you will live up to the expectations of the state's citizens."On Thursday, the Chief Minister unveiled the new official website of the Revenue & Disaster Management stated that through this initiative, transparency will be ensured in the department, and the scope of leakages will be eliminated. He emphasised the transformative impact of the new website. "The Revenue Department will now be even closer to the people. With this new website, all revenue services are consolidated onto a single platform, eliminating the need for citizens to make repeated visits to revenue offices."The technologically advanced website boasts features such as Single Sign-On (SSO), which allows users to access multiple applications and websites with a single set of login credentials. It also offers online slot booking, real-time digital display systems, dedicated help desks, and information available in local languages, according to a release.A key highlight is the ability for citizens to submit registration applications from the ease of their homes, requiring only a single biometric presence for finalisation, thereby significantly accelerating and simplifying the process. With the launch of this new website, all 26 services will be under one roof. The State Government will modernise all registration offices across the state by restructuring them on the model of Passport Seva Kendras, the Chief Minister added. He stated that the Haryana government has ushered in a new era for revenue records, which are now fully GIS-based, enabling real-time monitoring of land status.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'He has his reasons': Shashi Tharoor sidesteps Rahul Gandhi's 'dead economy' remark; raises trade concerns
Photo/Agencies NEW DELHI: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor on Saturday refused to comment on Rahul Gandhi 's endorsement of US President Donald Trump 's remark calling the Indian economy "dead." Tharoor said the leader of opposition in Lok Sabha may have had his "own reasons" for saying so, but stressed that maintaining economic ties with the US is vital for India. When asked about Gandhi's statement, Tharoor said, "I don't want to comment on what my party leader has said. He has his reasons for saying so. My concern is that our relationship with the US, as a strategic partnership and economic relationship, is important for us. We are exporting around 90 billion worth of goods to America. We can't be in a position to lose that or have it diminish significantly." — ANI (@ANI) He added, "We must wish our negotiators strength to get a fair deal for India. We should also be talking to other regions for exporting our goods. Then we could make up for some of what we might lose in the US. We have to support our negotiators." Tharoor's response came after Rahul Gandhi, on Thursday, agreed with Trump's description of the Indian economy. Gandhi had said, "Yes, he is right. Everybody knows this except the prime minister and the finance minister. Everybody knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy. I am glad that President Trump has stated a fact. The entire world knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy. BJP has finished the economy to help Adani. " Trump had made the comment on Wednesday through his social media platform, Truth Social. In that post, he announced a 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods and warned of additional penalties in response to India importing oil from Russia.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
India's US crude oil imports surge over 50% in first half of 2025; LNG, LPG trade also expands: Report
AI-image India has significantly ramped up its crude oil imports from the United States during President Donald Trump's second term, marking a major shift in its energy sourcing strategy, according to official trade data, reported ANI- quoting sources. Imports of US crude rose over 50 per cent in the first half of 2025 compared to the same period last year. From January to June 25, India imported an average of 0.271 million barrels per day (mb/d), up from 0.18 mb/d during the same timeframe in 2024. The uptick has been especially sharp in recent months. Imports during the April-June 2025 quarter soared 114 per cent year-on-year, with the value rising from $1.73 billion in Q1 of FY24-25 to $3.7 billion in Q1 of FY25-26. 'So, in July 2025, India imported 23 per cent more crude oil from the US compared to June 2025. In India's overall crude imports, while the US share was only 3 per cent, it increased to 8 per cent in July. Furthermore, in the financial year (2025-2026), Indian companies would increase their crude oil import by 150 per cent,' the ANI sources said. The energy trade expansion is not limited to crude. Imports of liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the US nearly doubled — rising from $1.41 billion in FY2023-24 to $2.46 billion in FY2024-25. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villas Prices In Dubai Might Be More Affordable Than You Think Villas In Dubai | Search Ads Get Quote Undo Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) imports have also grown significantly. Negotiations are reportedly underway for a multi-billion dollar long-term LNG supply agreement. The growth in bilateral energy trade comes amid continued affirmations of strong diplomatic ties between the two nations. Ministry of External Affairs on Friday, reiterated its confidence in the strength of the Indo-US partnership. 'India and the United States share a comprehensive global strategic partnership anchored in shared interests, democratic values, and robust people-to-people ties. This partnership has weathered several transitions and challenges. We remain focused on the substantive agenda that our two countries have committed to and are confident that the relationship will continue to move forward,' MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said at a scheduled press conference. However, this trade relation faced a setback when Trump announced 25 per cent tariffs on India. He said that India would face a 25 per cent tariff, "plus a penalty for the above, starting on August 1"; later changed to August 7. The White House justified the move by citing India's 'obnoxious non-monetary trade barriers,' persistent trade imbalances, and strong energy and defence ties with Russia. In another remark posted on Truth Social, Trump said, "I don't care what India does with Russia. They can take their dead economies down together, for all I care. We have done very little business with India, their Tariffs are too high, among the highest in the World. Likewise, Russia and the USA do almost no business together. Let's keep it that way..." Also read: India continuing to buy oil from Russia- Report rebuts Donald Trump's 'good steps' claim Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . Discover stories of India's leading eco-innovators at Ecopreneur Honours 2025
