Greenpeace in court: Romania takes aim at environmental NGOs
AI- Generated Image
The Romanian government is on the offensive against critical voices from civil society. In an unprecedented move, the state-owned energy company Romgaz has filed a lawsuit against Greenpeace Romania, arguing that the nongovernmental organization be disbanded.
Romgaz is 70% owned by the Romanian state and the lawsuit is supported by the Energy Ministry.
The lawsuit is part of a growing trend, said Romanian political scientist Cristian Pirvulescu. "Several environmental and human‑rights NGOs have faced increased scrutiny — whether through sudden inspections, burdensome reporting requirements or public rhetoric that questions their legitimacy. While each case has its own specifics, taken together they reveal a pattern of pressure that can discourage robust civic engagement," he said.
Natural gas in the Black Sea
This escalation is the latest chapter in a debate that has been going on for some time. Observers say it has its roots in the huge natural gas deposits in the Black Sea off the coast of Romania.
Romgaz, along with the Austrian company OMV, want to extract this natural gas, which amounts to around 100 billion cubic meters (3.5 trillion cubic feet), enough to make Romania the largest natural gas producer in the EU. The government is hoping for energy independence and earnings in the billions.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Giao dịch vàng CFDs với mức chênh lệch giá thấp nhất
IC Markets
Đăng ký
Undo
Production is due to start in 2027 and while investors have rejoiced, environmentalists are horrified. Critics, in particular Greenpeace, have said the venture will torpedo the European Union's climate targets. The Romanian branch of the NGO is organizing protests and taking legal action against the project. Several lawsuits have been filed in court.
In January, Greenpeace lost a case and was ordered to pay court costs of around €30,000 ($34,200) each to OMV and Romgaz.
In May, Greenpeace lost another case and now has to pay around €16,000 in court costs to the companies.
However, the NGO never received a demand for payment from the energy firms, said Greenpeace. Instead, Romgaz commissioned a bailiff, who stated that Greenpeace was insolvent.
"It's absurd. Of course we can pay the costs," said Mihnea Matache, spokesperson for Greenpeace Romania. The accusation is closely linked to a discovery that Romgaz claims to have made, namely that there are two different organizations with the name Greenpeace, with two different tax numbers.
Romgaz has accused Greenpeace of using these different organizations as a cover to sidestep fines.
In the light of this complaint, Romgaz is seeking to have Greenpeace dissolved.
A 'classic intimidation lawsuit'
Greenpeace has called the accusations laughable. Yes, Greenpeace has two tax numbers, said Matache, one for national and one for international affairs. "That's quite normal," he added.
He doesn't believe the lawsuit will be successful.
"They just want to unsettle our supporters, exhaust our resources, tire us out and intimidate us."
Political scientist Pirvulescu agrees. "The lawsuit seems more like retaliation against their activism and public communication than a legitimate legal claim," he told DW. In his view, it's a classic intimidation lawsuit.
This type of lawsuit is known by the abbreviation SLAPP, which stands for "strategic lawsuit against public participation."
The goal is to dissuade civil organizations from seeking legal recourse or operating in the public sphere altogether, by using steep compensation claims and lengthy court proceedings to place them under immense financial and emotional strain.
Energy minister accuses Greenpeace of 'fraudulent business practices'
The natural gas extraction project off the coast of Romania goes by the name Neptun Deep, and is considered one of the country's most important projects by Energy Minister Sebastian Burduja.
When asked by DW, the Energy Ministry said it had nothing to do with Romgaz's lawsuit against Greenpeace, but emphasized how crucial Neptun Deep is for the Romanian economy. On Facebook, Burduja has congratulated Romgaz on the lawsuit and accused Greenpeace of "fraudulent business practices."
Burduja recently piled pressure on environmental NGOs. Back in March, he called on company CEOs to sue environmental NGOs that filed lawsuits, and stated this constituted an act of "energy patriotism." In response, over 100 environmental organizations wrote an open letter demanding Burduja's resignation
The ministry, for its part, has said it is defending the country's economic interests, rejecting accusations of trying to silence civil society.
"We believe that [NGOs] do play and should play an important role in the social and public life of a country," it stated. "If the NGOs concerned have not acted abusively or unlawfully, they have nothing to fear."
In 2021, three environmental NGOs were summoned to a parliamentary inquiry. A commission was tasked with investigating whether energy prices had risen so sharply because the environmental organizations had prevented the construction of lignite and hydroelectric power plants.
The NGOs criticized this move, saying it soured their public reputation and turned them into scapegoats.
The UN's special rapporteur on environmental defenders, Michel Forst, intervened in 2024 and expressed serious concern to the Romanian state about a "campaign of harassment and intimidation."
Hefty legal costs, alleged ties to Russia
"They want to intimidate us — and they are succeeding. We are now thinking twice about suing Romgaz," said Vlad Catuna, Greenpeace's campaign manager for the Neptun Deep issue.
In part, they are worried about the hefty legal costs facing NGOs if they lose. In the previous lawsuit, Romgaz and OMV had originally demanded a total compensation of €250,000, making the five-figure final settlement appear paltry by comparison.
And it's not just in court that the Energy Ministry is challenging environmental NGOs. The minister and state-affiliated media have repeatedly suggested that Greenpeace and other environmental organizations have links to Russia.
They claim the Russian state wants to prevent Romania from extracting gas in a bid to make the nation more dependent on Russian gas.
Matache and Catuna reject these accusations. Greenpeace has been banned in Russia as an "undesirable organization" since 2023. But accusations such as these still leave a bitter aftertaste and dent the organization's standing with the public.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Anti-immigrant rioting stretches into second night in Northern Ireland
Ballymena in Northern Ireland witnessed a second night of rioting. Anti-immigrant protests spread to other areas. Police reported hate-fueled acts. Homes and vehicles were attacked. The violence followed a demonstration over an alleged sexual assault. Far-right groups amplified the unrest. Authorities are investigating the incidents. They are reviewing video footage to identify rioters. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads A second night of rioting struck the town of Ballymena in Northern Ireland on Tuesday, as anti-immigrant protests spread to several other areas and police warned of "hate-fueled acts."Homes, businesses and vehicles were again attacked in Ballymena, a town of about 31,000 people, where several properties were set on fire Monday night following a demonstration over the alleged sexual assault of a teenage outbreak of violence began after two 14-year-old boys appeared in a local court on Monday charged with attempted oral rape on Saturday night. The boys spoke through a Romanian translator, the BBC reported, and both denied the charges through their case triggered an outcry in the town, and tapped into a broader anti-immigrant movement that has resulted in several outbreaks of violence in recent years. Far-right groups and influencers on social media amplified news of the assault case and celebrated the ensuing Ireland has seen increased immigration in recent years, with the percentage of the population born outside of the United Kingdom rising from 6.5% in 2011 to 8.6% in 2021, according to the most recent census data. But the number of immigrants is still relatively low compared with many other countries in Europe, and emigration is high. Experts say that far-right activists have exploited a housing shortage and an ongoing cost of living crisis to incite violence against asylum-seekers and other Tuesday evening, police officers came under "sustained attack" with Molotov cocktails, bricks and fireworks, according to a statement from the Police Service of Northern Ireland, and 17 officers were injured.A heavily pregnant woman was evacuated from one of the houses set on fire, local politician Sian Mulholland told the BBC show "Good Morning Ulster," adding that the violence had been livestreamed on social media and that rioters had been directed on "how to get around the police barricades."On Wednesday morning, signs and flags had appeared on some homes in the area of Ballymena where the assault and riots took place, stating the nationality of those inside."British household," read one handwritten sign above a smashed window, while another home displayed a picture of the Philippine flag with the words: "Filipino lives here."Michelle O'Neill, the first minister of Northern Ireland, said in a statement Wednesday that the "racist and sectarian attacks on families" were "abhorrent and must stop immediately." She added: "No one, now or ever, should feel the need to place a sticker on their door to identify their ethnicity just to avoid being targeted."The police used a water cannon against crowds and fired plastic baton rounds in Ballymena, while unrest also took place in parts of Belfast and in the town of Carrickfergus. Earlier in the evening, protests had taken place in areas of Belfast, as well as in Lisburn, Coleraine and family of the victim of Saturday's sexual assault said they did not condone the violence and appealed for people to let "justice be served in the correct manner," through a statement released by Paul Frew, who represents the district covering Ballymena in the Northern Ireland in Parliament on Wednesday, Prime Minister Keir Starmer of Britain condemned the violence, saying it was vital that the police "are given the time they need to investigate the incidents concerned, rather than face mindless attacks as they seek to bring peace and order to keep people safe."Chief Constable Jon Boutcher, who leads the Police Service of Northern Ireland, said police were reviewing video footage and other evidence to identify rioters, and condemned what he called "hate-fueled acts and mob rule.""The mindless violence witnessed over the past two nights in Ballymena is deeply concerning and utterly unacceptable," he added. "These criminal acts not only endanger lives but also risk undermining the ongoing criminal justice process in support of a victim who deserves truth, justice and protection."A report published last month by the Committee on the Administration of Justice, an independent human rights group, analyzed seven incidents of anti-immigrant protests, social media activity, street activism and riots that have taken place in Northern Ireland since 2023. The report's author concluded that a "disturbing pattern of locally driven racist and anti-immigrant activity in Northern Ireland" was being escalated by international extremists who were amplifying "fabricated narratives" on social Donnelly, the author of the report, told The New York Times that some previous incidents had been sparked by criminal incidents involving migrants, while others "had all the hallmarks of made-up stories.""There is a deliberate strategy to build a narrative of incidents being perpetrated by the 'other' -- the immigrant communities -- against 'our' communities," he said. "Suddenly a lot of the crime, like sexual offenses, attempted abductions of children, are all laid at the doorstep of this immigrant 'other' living in our community. Whether these incidents are true or false doesn't really seem to matter online."Donnelly, who works for a Belfast-based technology research group, The Rabble Coop, said that police and government statistics showed that the "vast majority" of sex crimes in Northern Ireland were carried out by white men from the country, but that extremist messaging presenting migrants as a threat was "finding fertile ground."According to the most recent Northern Ireland census, 16% of Ballymena residents recorded a national identity outside British, Irish and Northern Irish groups in 2021, up from 10% at the previous census in largest nationality in the "other" group was Romanian in the most recent census, followed by Polish, Bulgarian and people were arrested on suspicion of rioting in Ballymena on Tuesday night, while another suspect was arrested on suspicion of disorder in police are also investigating a Molotov cocktail attack in the village of Cullybackey, around 3 miles away from Ballymena, shortly after midnight on Tuesday.A vehicle was set on fire and a nearby property, with a woman and two children inside, was damaged, in what investigators are treating as a racially motivated hate article originally appeared in The New York Times.
United News of India
a day ago
- United News of India
10 people, mostly students, killed in mass shooting in Austrian school, several injured
Graz, June 10 (UNI) At least 10 people, mostly students, were killed and several were badly injured in a shooting incident in a secondary school in the Austrian city of Graz. The suspected shooter reportedly committed suicide later in one of the school's toilets. As per The New York Times, Austria's elite COBRA police forces along with a police helicopter, arrived at the crime scene after shots were reported. The mayor of Graz, Elke Kahr, said that the suspected shooter, several students and another adult, thought to be a teacher, were among the fatalities in the attack, the deadliest in Austria's postwar history. The Austrian Press Agency reported that as many as 30 people were injured. According to preliminary reports, the perpetrator was a 22-year-old ex-student who had described himself as a victim of bullying in the past. He reportedly fired shots in two classrooms, using a pistol and a shotgun, killing and injuring multiple pupils and teachers. The dead reportedly included seven pupils and one adult. The incident occurred at about 10am local time (0900 BST). Ninety minutes later police said there was 'no further danger' after a major security operation involving special forces and police helicopters. The Austrian Chancellor, Christian Stocker, condemning the incident wrote on X 'The shooting rampage at a school in Graz is a national tragedy that has deeply shaken our entire country.' Austria's President, Alexander Van der Bellen, said: 'What happened today … strikes our country at the heart. These were young people who had their whole lives ahead of them. A teacher who accompanied them on their journey.' Families gathered at a nearby sports hall where crisis intervention teams were on hand. The area around the school was cordoned off and public transport was diverted, with all streets surrounding the school guarded by armed officers. A spokesperson for the Austrian Red Cross told the public broadcaster ORF that more than 160 responders were at the scene, including emergency doctors and paramedics. Two information points were available for the school's students and relatives. Austria last experienced a major mass attack such as this more than a decade ago, when a Bosnian man killed three people and wounded about three dozen others after driving a car into crowds on the streets of the city and then attacking bystanders with a knife.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Former pupil kills nine, then himself in shooting at Austrian school
A tragic school shooting in Graz, Austria, has left the nation in mourning after a former pupil killed nine people and himself. The 21-year-old shooter, armed with two guns, opened fire in the school, injuring twelve others. Authorities are investigating the motive behind the attack, which has been declared a national tragedy, prompting three days of mourning. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads A former pupil killed nine people and then himself at a secondary school in the southern Austrian city of Graz on Tuesday in the worst school shooting in the country's modern Minister Gerhard Karner said six of the victims were male and three were female, and that 12 people were also injured. He gave no further details to identify the victims but Austrian media said most were motive for an attack that shocked the nation was not yet known. But police said they assumed the 21-year-old Austrian shooter, who was found dead in a bathroom, was operating alone when he entered the school with two guns and opened fire."The rampage at a school in Graz is a national tragedy that has deeply shaken our entire country," Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said, calling it a "dark day in the history of our country"."There are no words for the pain and grief that we all - all of Austria - are feeling right now."Stocker travelled to Graz where, at a press conference alongside other officials including Karner, he announced three days of national mourning, with a minute's silence to be held at 10 a.m. (0800 GMT) on the scene, police had set up a perimeter a few hundred meters away from the school, barring access routes with police cars after evacuating the school. Relatives of the victims and pupils were being cared Salzburger Nachrichten newspaper said in an unconfirmed report that the suspect had been a victim of with a pistol and shotgun, he opened fire on pupils in two classrooms, one of which had once been his own, it said.'DARK HOUR'Police were called to the scene at around 10 a.m. after shots were heard at the school. Police and ambulances were on the scene in minutes."It is not yet possible to provide any information about the motive. Extensive criminal investigations are still required," a police spokesperson Ebner, an extremism expert at the Institute for Strategic Dialogue think-tank, said the incident appeared to be the worst school shooting in Austria's post-war history, describing such shootings as rare compared to some countries including the United States."I am deeply shaken that young people were torn from their lives so abruptly," German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, one of a number of foreign leaders who expressed shock at the shooting, said in a message to Stocker. "We hope that their loved ones can find comfort in the company of their families and friends in this dark hour."Austria has one of the most heavily armed civilian populations in Europe, with an estimated 30 firearms per 100 persons, according to the Small Arms Survey, an independent research people were killed and 22 injured when a convicted jihadist went on a shooting spree in the centre of Vienna in 2020. In November 1997, a 36-year-old mechanic shot dead six people in the town of Mauterndorf before killing himself.
