Chief accused of ‘half-hearted' defence of review body after Malkinson case
Karen Kneller, chief executive of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) which investigates potential miscarriages of justice, insisted she and her colleagues were the right people for the job as she faced questions from MPs on Tuesday.
It comes as chairwoman of the body, Helen Pitcher, eventually resigned from her role in January following Mr Malkinson's case, but claimed she had been scapegoated.
Giving evidence to the Commons' Justice Committee, she appeared alongside the CCRC's casework operations director Amanda Pearce.
Chairman of the committee Andy Slaughter said: 'I'm afraid I found your defence of what is to us a hugely important organisation, I'm sure it's hugely important to you, has been pretty half-hearted, and has been really a reflection that things are going pretty well, apart from one or two difficult cases.
'And where that leaves me, comment or not as you wish, to ask whether you really feel now, given everything that's happened, that you are the right people to lead this organisation forward.'
Ms Kneller said on behalf of herself and Ms Pearce that 'I think we are absolutely the right people to lead this organisation'.
During the hearing, the legal boss urged the committee to judge the CCRC's performance across all its casework, and 'not only those cases which get into the headlines, which is a tiny, tiny minority of our casework'.
The independent body, currently tasked with reviewing the convictions of serial child killer Lucy Letby, was heavily criticised for its handling of Mr Malkinson's case, one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history.
Mr Malkinson served 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, and was knocked back twice by the CCRC until his legal team carried out crucial DNA testing that was then repeated by the commission and led to his release.
A review found that he could have been released 10 years earlier if the CCRC had obtained new DNA evidence as early as 2009, and thousands of cases are being reviewed in the wake of the bungled handling of the case.
Before Ms Pitcher's resignation, she had apologised to Mr Malkinson in April 2024, nine months after his conviction was quashed by the Court of Appeal in July 2023.
The committee heard from the CCRC chiefs that they did not know when they would be getting an interim chairperson as they are not involved in the process.
On Tuesday, Ms Kneller also personally apologised to Mr Malkinson for the first time during the hearing.
Asked whether she would like to apologise, she said: 'Without doubt, we got that case wrong. Mr Malkinson was failed.
'We made mistakes in that case. We apologised, the organisation apologised.
'I think the decisions made then around when to apologise are probably decisions that would not be made today.
'So absolutely, I extend my apology to Mr Malkinson. Everyone in the organisation deeply regrets what happened on that case.
'I can't begin to think of the impact that this has had on him.
'I mean the double impact of, you know, serving a sentence, suffering miscarriage of justice, and then the way we handled his case.'
At 2.30pm today, we will hold our evidence session on the work of the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
You can watch it on Parliament Live: https://t.co/sR61XRXYxE https://t.co/8gd85f1UdI
— Justice Committee (@CommonsJustice) April 29, 2025
Following the evidence, Mr Slaughter also told the CCRC chief he was 'quite shocked' by the remote working structure of the organisation.
Ms Kneller had told the committee the CCRC is no longer an office-based organisation which has boosted its ability to recruit for specialist roles from across the UK.
Instead she spends one or two days in the Birmingham-based office every two months.
But Mr Slaughter said: 'But given what's happened with your previous chair, the Malkinson case and other matters that have come to light, if I were the chief executive here, I would be in every day when there's issues, I'd be asking my staff to be there, I'd be working with those staff.
'I'd be trying to rebuild the organisation so that the commissioners and the board had a much more hands on role in that way.
'And that doesn't seem to have happened at all.'
But Ms Kneller defended the move, saying without remote working the CCRC would not be doing the amount of casework needed to make referrals because the vacancies would not have been filled.
Ms Pearce added: 'There is no magic to working in the office. Our staff are connected. They can speak to each other at any time.
'We discovered that it is perfectly possible to do a good job working remotely. That has allowed us to attract talent from across the UK.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
38 minutes ago
- New York Post
BBC pressured to cut ties with author Sally Rooney over support for terrorist group Palestine Action
The BBC faces mounting pressure to sever ties with bestselling Irish author Sally Rooney who recently said she would donate money to a pro-Palestinian organization that British authorities have categorized as terrorists. Rooney, the controversial author of a book that was adapted to a popular movie streamed on the British public broadcaster, stunned critics last weekend by announcing she would give a percentage of proceeds from book sales to Palestine Action. 'I want to be clear that I intend to use these proceeds of my work, as well as my public platform generally, to go on supporting Palestine Action and direct action against genocide in whatever way I can,' the 34-year-old Rooney told The Irish Times. Advertisement 4 The BBC faces mounting pressure to sever ties with bestselling Irish author Sally Rooney. Getty Images The defiant novelist, who lives in Ireland and has declared a boycott of Israel, said if that branded her a 'supporter of terrorism' under British law, 'so be it.' Her bombshell declaration triggered fierce backlash from Jewish groups and legal experts who warned the BBC could face criminal liability for continuing to profit from her work. Advertisement Palestine Action, which was founded in 2020, has generated headlines for targeting British arms companies that conduct business with Israel. The group's members have engaged in blockades, occupied facilities and inflicted property damage at weapons factories and military installations. On July 5, the UK government officially banned Palestine Action as a proscribed terrorist organization under the Terrorism Act 2000, making membership punishable by up to 14 years in prison and criminalizing any form of support including fundraising, statements or displaying associated materials. 4 Rooney stunned critics this past weekend by announcing she would give a percentage of proceeds from book sales to Palestine Action. Getty Images for Hulu Advertisement Since the ban took effect, over 744 individuals have been arrested for showing support for the group, including a record-breaking single-day arrest of 522 people at a London Parliament Square protest on Aug. 9 The Campaign Against Antisemitism, a UK-based nonprofit, torched Rooney's stance as 'utterly indefensible' and demanded platforms cut ties immediately. 'This goes far beyond political activism — it is a deliberate statement of intent to channel money towards a group that vandalized RAF jets and terrorized the Jewish community,' the organization said. Advertisement 'Platforms and publishers profiting from her work must urgently review their relationship with her, as they now risk enabling the flow of funds to a terrorist organization.' The BBC has hosted 'Normal People' on iPlayer since its 2020 launch and aired another Rooney adaptation, 'Conversations with Friends,' in 2022. The corporation scrambled to distance itself from the controversy. 4 Rooney has declared a boycott of Israel over its policies in the Palestinian territories. She has refused to have her books translated into Hebrew. Nasser Ishtayeh/SOPA Images/Shutterstock 'Matters relating to proscribed organizations are for the relevant authorities,' the BBC stated tersely, noting Rooney was never a staff member and what authors do with previously received money is 'a matter for them.' But several BBC insiders expressed dismay privately, with some remarking that Rooney 'had form' for courting controversy, according to the UK-based Times. The timing couldn't be worse for the broadcaster. Netflix began streaming 'Normal People' just two weeks ago, with the 12-part drama immediately cracking the platform's top-ten UK chart. Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post's signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here! Advertisement Downing Street fired back Monday, warning donors to Palestine Action they were committing terror offenses under the Terrorism Act. 'There's a difference between showing support for a proscribed organization, which depends on the Terrorism Act, and legitimate protest,' a government spokesman said. 'Where activity breaks the law, then obviously the police will take action.' Rooney has been reported to counterterrorism police, though no action is expected since Palestine Action isn't banned in Ireland, where she made her comments. Advertisement 4 Jewish groups have demanded that the BBC sever ties with Rooney. REUTERS A law enforcement official told the Times that arresting Rooney would be complicated given jurisdictional considerations. 'Ordinarily, offenses occur based on where the person is at the time,' the official told the newspaper. Advertisement 'If you're in the UK and you're sending money to a proscribed terrorist organization then yes, it would likely be an offense.' But legal experts told the Times that they believe Rooney could still face prosecution under UK terror finance laws that cover overseas actions. Jonathan Turner, chief executive of UK Lawyers for Israel, argued the author along with the BBC and booksellers could have broken the law. 'By providing financial assistance to an organization which clearly intends to commit criminal damage in the UK, she is likely to be guilty under UK law for knowingly assisting the commission of criminal offenses,' Turner said. Advertisement 'I think the BBC and other sellers of her books could also be liable for assisting criminal offenses by Palestine Action as well as offenses under the Terrorism Act 2000 for transferring funds that may be used for the purposes of terrorism.' Home Secretary Yvette Cooper branded Palestine Action more than 'a regular protest group' this past weekend, citing its 'escalating campaign' of activities. The Post has sought comment from the BBC and Rooney.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Family of woman who took her own life in skydive tragedy release statement
The family of Jade Damarell has thanked the skydiving community after an inquest found the experienced jumper died by suicide when she did not deploy her parachute. Jade Damarell died on impact after not deploying her main or backup parachute during a skydive over Fleming Field, in Shotton Colliery, on April 27. An inquest into her death held at Crook Coroner's Court on Thursday (August 21) heard the incident took place the morning after her relationship ended with her boyfriend Ben, who she had met "through their shared love of skydiving". The inquest heard Jade was a "very experienced and competent" parachutist, and had skydived six times successfully the day before the incident took place, but on the fatal jump a report from the British Skydiving Association found there was "no attempt" to deploy the parachute. In a statement after the inquest her family said: 'We acknowledge and accept the conclusion of the coroner's inquest into our daughter Jade's death. 'Once again, we express our sincere thanks to all services involved for the care and compassion given. Jade Damarell. (Image: FACEBOOK) 'We would also like to express our heartfelt gratitude to Sky-High Skydiving and the fantastic 'SkyFam' community. 'You meant so much to Jade, and we're incredibly comforted by how admired, respected and deeply loved, she was. 'Jade loved the sport with a passion, and it brought her so much joy. 'Sky-High handled the tragedy and investigation into Jade's death professionally and with compassion that allowed us to all share in our grief. 'So much so, Sky-High Skydiving helped us to celebrate Jade's life with a very fitting tribute and final farewell, ending with Jade's mum, Liz, honouring Jade's memory with a final tandem jump. (Image: FACEBOOK) 'Our beloved daughter Jade was a brilliant, beautiful, brave and truly extraordinary person. A bright, adventurous, free spirit, she lived with immense energy, passion and love and touched countless lives with her warmth and kindness. 'By speaking openly and without shame, we hope to contribute to a culture where mental ill-health is met with kindness and support, and where people in deep distress, and those around them, feel seen, believed, and able to reach for support without fear of judgment. 'We miss Jade beyond words, but Jade's love, brilliance, courage and light will live on in our family and among all those who knew and loved her. 'Some stars are so bright, they burn through their time too quickly, but their light never truly fades. Read more: GCSE success in Bishop Auckland inspires cheers from British soldiers in Estonia Bishop Auckland schoolgirl celebrates 'brilliant' GCSE results Father and son accused of conspiring to supply cocaine with a third man 'Please respect our family's privacy at this time.' Assistant Coroner for County Durham and Darlington Leslie Hamilton concluded her death as suicide. The family has set up a GoFundMe page in support of the Make-a-Wish Foundation, which helps children with critical illnesses.- Samaritans is available, day or night, 365 days of the year. You can call them for free on 116 123, email them at jo@ or visit to find your nearest branch. - If U Care Share on 0191 387 5661 or text IUCS to 85258 - SANE on 07984 967 708, Calm on 0800 58 58 58
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
Fugitive father and kids living in wilderness
Fugitive father and kids living in wilderness Fugitive Thomas Callam Phillips vanished into the remote forests of New Zealand's North Island in 2021 with his three children—now 12-, 10-, and 9-years-old— sparking a four-year search that has gripped the country. Now, after years of silence, his family is making a heartfelt public appeal: they miss him and their grandchildren—and they're urging him to come home. 01:26 - Source: CNN Vertical World News 16 videos Fugitive father and kids living in wilderness Fugitive Thomas Callam Phillips vanished into the remote forests of New Zealand's North Island in 2021 with his three children—now 12-, 10-, and 9-years-old— sparking a four-year search that has gripped the country. Now, after years of silence, his family is making a heartfelt public appeal: they miss him and their grandchildren—and they're urging him to come home. 01:26 - Source: CNN Chinese troops train for massive parade Ahead of a massive military parade to mark the 80th anniversary of the end of WWII, the Chinese government invited foreign media to a practice session on the outskirts of Beijing. CNN Beijing Bureau Chief Steven Jiang reports from heavily guarded barracks and discusses what the event means for the world's biggest standing army under leader Xi Jinping. 01:58 - Source: CNN Why an Irish rapper is facing terror charges Hundreds of supporters turned out in central London to support an Irish rapper facing terror charges. Mo Chara, from the Irish language rap group Kneecap is accused by British authorities of displaying a flag supporting Hezbollah, a designated terror group in the UK. CNN's Niamh Kennedy reports. 02:02 - Source: CNN Mexican brothers arrested, one tased by federal agents Two brothers from Mexico were arrested by federal agents on Friday in Norwalk, Connecticut. Video shows two officers aggressively tugging Leonel Chavez's arm while he sits inside a car before saying he is under arrest. A second video filmed by a passerby shows Chavez's brother, Ricardo, running away from an agent before getting tased, prompting him to suddenly collapse on the ground. The DHS told CNN in a statement that ICE agents were operating in Norwalk last week, but they did not specify whether it was ICE officers who arrested the Chavez brothers. 01:58 - Source: CNN Activists fear China's 'Super Embassy' plans China wants to build a new embassy in the heart of historic London that would be the biggest in Europe. Many locals and activists say it would be a threat to security and privacy, with the UK government set to make a decision on the proposal in the coming days. CNN's Salma Abdelaziz speaks to one political dissident from Hong Kong who fears for her safety if plans are allowed to go ahead. 01:39 - Source: CNN Fireball lights up skies in Japan Cameras captured the moment a ball of light lit up the night sky over parts of Japan. 00:20 - Source: CNN This 95-year-old former prisoner of war wants to return to North Korea Captured during the Korean War and imprisoned for decades for refusing to renounce his political beliefs, 95-year-old Ahn Hak-sop now has a single dying wish: to return to North Korea and be buried alongside his comrades. CNN's Mike Valerio reports from outside the Korean Peninsula's Demilitarized Zone as Ahn tried to enter the North from the South. 01:40 - Source: CNN Hear from aid truck drivers waiting to enter Gaza Thousands of aid trucks are parked near the Rafah border crossing in Egypt, waiting to enter Gaza. Many convoys have remained idle for weeks causing essential food aid to spoil as starvation grips the blockaded strip. CNN Senior News Reporter Mostafa Salem speaks with truck drivers waiting in Rafah to deliver aid to Palestinians. 01:31 - Source: CNN Meet the Japanese 'doctor' who fixes toys for the elderly Fumiyoshi Sumi has repaired hundreds of toys for children. But these days, more and more elderly people are bringing in 'patients" to his toy hospital. 01:10 - Source: CNN Zelensky prepares for White House meeting In the wake of the Alaska summit between President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin, European leaders joined Ukraine's Volodymyr Zelensky for a conference call ahead of the leader's meeting with the US president at the White House on Monday. 01:24 - Source: CNN Nationwide demonstrations across Israel demanding hostage deal A planned nationwide strike in Israel on Sunday saw hundreds of thousands take part to call on the government to bring the remaining hostages in Gaza home. CNN's Oren Liebermann reports from Tel Aviv. 01:23 - Source: CNN Witkoff hopeful of trilateral meeting US envoy Steve Witkoff told CNN's Jake Tapper he believes a trilateral meeting between Donald Trump, Volodymyr Zelensky, and Vladimir Putin is possible. 00:39 - Source: CNN Canadian government orders end to Air Canada strike After more than 10,000 Air Canada flight attendants went on strike seeking wage increases and paid compensation for work when planes are on the ground, the Canada Industrial Relations Board has ordered them to return to work according to an announcement by Canadian Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu. 01:05 - Source: CNN Hong Kong's poorly housed bear the brunt of climate change Climate change is making Hong Kong's summers hotter. Yet tens of thousands of residents remain sardined into homes smaller than a parking space, where staying cool is a luxury few can afford as the climate warms. In small, enclosed spaces with little ventilation or cooling, indoor temperatures can soar past 100°F (37.7°C), posing serious health risks for the city's most vulnerable. 01:31 - Source: CNN London's toxic trash 'volcano' Arnolds Field landfill on Launders Lane in east London is better known to locals as the 'Rainham volcano.' The site was used as an illegal dump for years and now, every summer, it bursts into flames, sending plumes of acrid smoke over nearby homes, parks and schools. CNN's Laura Paddison speaks to residents who feel abandoned and trapped. 02:05 - Source: CNN Protesters condemn 'no deal' outcome of Trump-Putin talks Protesters in Alaska said they're not surprised that President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin didn't reach a deal on the war in Ukraine. 01:08 - Source: CNN
