Erin Patterson thought cancer lie ‘would die' with lunch guests, prosecution says
The prosecution told the court on Monday that Erin Patterson deliberately lied to her in-laws about having cancer, fabricating medical appointments and test results.
'She knew how to tell convincing lies when it came to the cancer because she had put in the research,' chief prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC told the court.
'The prosecution says the accused put considerable thought and effort into this fake cancer claim and she deliberately set the trail in motion with Don and Gail.'
She said that Ms Patterson had carefully crafted the false claim.
According to the prosecution, Ms Patterson had no intention of ever being questioned about the lie, because she believed her lunch guests would not survive.
'Her lie would die with them,' Dr Rogers said, adding that Ms Patterson admitted in court she was never diagnosed with cancer.
Ms Patterson has admitted that death cap mushrooms were in the meal but claimed they were added accidentally and denied any intent to harm her guests.
On 29 July 2023, Ms Patterson had her in-laws, Gail and Don Patterson, and local pastor Ian Wilkinson and his wife Heather (Gail's sister) over for lunch. Ms Patterson served beef Wellington to the Pattersons and Wilkinsons, after which the four guests became ill with vomiting and diarrhea.
By 30 July, all four were hospitalised, and within the next day they were transferred to Melbourne hospitals where doctors diagnosed them with death cap mushroom poisoning.
On 31 July, Ms Patterson herself went to the hospital reporting she had eaten the same meal and felt unwell but discharged herself without treatment.
Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson died on 4 August, followed by Don Patterson on 5 August. Ian Wilkinson was released from the hospital on 19 September 2023 after seven weeks, most of which he spent in a coma.
Ms Patterson is being tried for three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder. She has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
On Monday, in closing arguments, prosecutors in Ms Patterson's triple-murder trial outlined four calculated deceptions at the heart of their case: a fabricated cancer diagnosis used to lure her guests, the deliberate poisoning of their meal with lethal death cap mushrooms, a false claim that she too had fallen ill, and an ongoing cover-up to hide the truth.
Dr Rogers called the alleged poisoning 'the critical deception' in the case.
However, the prosecution argued she had full control over the lunch, from the guest list to the ingredients, and deliberately made individual beef Wellingtons instead of a single dish, suggesting she wanted precise control over who ate what.
'It is a control she exercised, the prosecution says, with devastating effect,' Dr Rogers said.
Prosecutors also argued that Ms Patterson failed to help identify the source of the poisoning that left her family critically ill. Instead of aiding investigators, she gave inconsistent accounts about where she bought the dried mushrooms, claiming they came from an Asian grocer but offering vague and shifting details, Ms Rogers told the court.
'For the sake of your very ill family members ... you'd do everything you could to try and remember the store, but the accused sat on her hands while Don, Gail, Ian and Heather were all in comas,' she said.
'She was slow to respond to the Department of Health, even totally non-responsive at times.
'As time passed, her description of the Chinese food store [where she allegedly bought dried mushrooms] shifted and grew broader.'
Dr Rogers told the jury: 'The evidence shows that the accused had the knowledge to locate death cap mushrooms, the opportunity to have sourced death cap mushrooms at a time proximate or close to the lunch, the knowledge, skill and equipment to dehydrate mushrooms, blitz them into powder and hide them into food.'
'She had complete control over the ingredients that went into the lunch,' she added.
The prosecution alleged that Ms Patterson deliberately framed the lunch as a serious, adults-only gathering, even arranging for her children to be away at McDonald's and the cinema to avoid them being harmed.
When her ex-husband Simon declined to attend, Ms Patterson tried to persuade him by stressing the lunch's importance and rarity, Dr Rogers told the court.
'This was an elaborate lie. The evidence shows the accused planted the seed of this lie far in advance, she told Don and Gail well before the lunch that she had been having medical tests on her elbow,' Dr Rogers said.
'She knew how to tell convincing lies when it came to cancer because she put in the research.'
Prosecutors alleged that Ms Patterson deliberately laced individual beef Wellington parcels with lethal doses of poison on 29 July 2023. Though she claimed to follow a recipe from RecipeTin Eats, the court heard she altered it by preparing individual servings, allegedly to avoid poisoning herself, without informing her guests that she had used wild mushrooms.
'The sinister deception was to use a nourishing meal as the vehicle to deliver the deadly poison,' Rogers said.
'Why deviate so significantly from an unfamiliar recipe for a special lunch?'
Dr Rogers said that computer records support the allegation that Ms Patterson accessed the iNaturalist website and looked up sightings of death cap mushrooms, suggesting she may have intentionally sought out the poisonous fungi.
Another element of the alleged lunch deception, Dr Rogers said, was Ms Patterson's use of a food dehydrator just days before the meal.
She reportedly did a 'test run' with button mushrooms, photographed the process, and shared it with online friends. Ms Rogers also pointed to survivor Ian Wilkinson's testimony, describing how Ms Patterson served the beef Wellington on matching grey plates for her guests, while plating her own meal separately on an orange-tan dish, suggesting an effort to avoid poisoning herself.
'You will have no trouble in being satisfied that he is a reliable witness and you can confidently accept what he told you about the details of the lunch, including the four grey plates,' Dr Rogers said.
'Ian was not the only person to notice the different plate. Heather said ... [she] saw Erin serve herself of a different coloured plate.'
The third alleged deception, according to Dr Rogers, was Ms Patterson's effort to falsely present herself as a victim of death cap mushroom poisoning. Dr Rogers said Ms Patterson pretended to be 'very unwell' to family and medical staff, in an attempt to suggest she had eaten the same meal as her four guests, a move designed to deflect suspicion.
'She did this to disguise her crimes,' Dr Rogers said.
The fourth alleged deception, Dr Rogers said, was Ms Patterson's ongoing cover-up to hide the truth. This included lying about giving her children leftovers from the lunch, the source of the mushrooms, disposing of the food dehydrator, and deliberately hiding her usual mobile phone from police.
Dr Rogers pointed out that Ms Patterson's claim of feeding the leftovers to her kids was one of her first lies and contradicted witness evidence that she knew her lunch guests were hospitalised sick before reheating the dish for her children.
Dr Rogers told the jury the children likely ate steak, mashed potatoes, and beans, not the mushroom-contaminated meal.
'People would more readily believe this was all a shocking accident if she'd fed it to her beloved children. This was a lie to help cover her tracks.'
The trial continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
South Africa spinner Subrayen cited for suspect bowling action
MELBOURNE, Aug 21 (Reuters) - South Africa spinner Prenelan Subrayen has been reported for a suspect bowling action in the first ODI against Australia, the International Cricket Council (ICC) said. The ICC said match officials reported concerns about the legality of the off-spinner's action during his ODI debut in Cairns on Tuesday where he took 1-46 in the Proteas' 98-run win. Subrayen must undergo an independent assessment of his action at an ICC-accredited testing facility within 14 days. He can continue bowling until the results of his test are known. Bowlers are permitted 15 degrees of elbow extension while delivering the ball. Reuters contacted Cricket South Africa for comment. The 31-year-old Subrayen has a record of bowling illegally in domestic and T20 cricket. He was suspended from bowling in domestic cricket in late-2015 after failing an assessment but was cleared to resume after another test a few months later. He was also suspended in late-2012 over his action but cleared to bowl again in early-2013 after remedial work. Subrayen made his test cricket debut last month against Zimbabwe in Bulawayo, picking up four first-innings wickets.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Frank Caprio, Rhode Island judge who drew a huge online audience with his compassion, dies at age 88
Frank Caprio, a retired municipal judge in Rhode Island who found online fame as a caring jurist and host of ' Caught in Providence,″ died. He was 88. His official social media accounts said Wednesday the he "passed away peacefully" after 'a long and courageous battle with pancreatic cancer.' Caprio billed his courtroom as a place 'where people and cases are met with kindness and compassion." He was known for dismissing tickets or showing kindness even when he handed out justice. Last week, Caprio posted a short video on Facebook about how he had 'a setback," was back in the hospital and was asking that people 'remember me in your prayers.' Caprio's show was filmed in his courtroom and featured his folksy humor and compassion. Clips from the show have had more than 1 billion views on social media. During his time on the bench, Caprio developed a persona at odds with many TV judges — more sympathetic and less confrontational and judgmental. In his bite-sized segments on YouTube, Caprio is often seen empathizing with those in his courtroom. Many of the infractions are also relatively minor, from failing to use a turn signal to a citation for a loud party. Caprio also used his fame to address issues like unequal access to the judicial system. 'The phrase 'With liberty and justice for all' represents the idea that justice should be accessible to everyone. However it is not,' Caprio said in one video. 'Almost 90% of low-income Americans are forced to battle civil issues like health care, unjust evictions, veterans benefits and, yes, even traffic violations, alone.' Caprio's upbeat take on the job of a judge drew him millions of views. His most popular videos have been those where he calls children to the bench to help pass judgment on their parents. One shows him listening sympathetically to a woman whose son was killed and then dismissing her tickets and fines of $400. In another clip, after dismissing a red-light violation for a bartender who was making $3.84 per hour, Caprio urged those watching the video not to duck out on their bills. 'If anyone's watching I want them to know you better not eat and run because you're going to get caught and the poor people who are working hard all day for three bucks an hour are going to have to pay your bill," he said. On social media, his family described Caprio 'as a devoted husband, father, grandfather, great grandfather and friend.' 'Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond,' the family wrote. 'His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him.' State and local politicians mourned his passing and celebrated his life. 'Judge Caprio not only served the public well, but he connected with them in a meaningful way, and people could not help but respond to his warmth and compassion,' Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee said in a statement. 'He was more than a jurist — he was a symbol of empathy on the bench, showing us what is possible when justice is tempered with humanity.' Robert Leonard, who co-owned a restaurant with Caprio, said he was 'going to be sorely missed' and was 'all around wonderful.' 'There is nothing he wouldn't do for you if he could do it,' Leonard said. Caprio retired from Providence Municipal Court in 2023 after nearly four decades behind the bench. According to his biography, Caprio came from humble beginnings, the second of three boys growing up in the Federal Hill neighborhood of Providence, Rhode Island. 'I hope that people will take away that the institutions of government can function very well by exercising kindness, fairness, and compassion in their deliberations. We live in a very contentious society,' he said in 2017. 'I would hope that people will see that we can dispense justice without being oppressive.' ___ LeBlanc, an Associated Press journalist who retired in January, was the primary writer of this obituary. Associated Press writers Michael Casey in Boston and Audrey McAvoy in Honolulu contributed to this report.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Woman assisting police after infant found dead in Perth storm water drain
A woman is assisting police after a baby boy was found dead inside a storm water drain. Two workers carrying out routine maintenance made the confronting discovery in Alexander Heights in Perth's northern suburbs on Monday afternoon. Western Australia police confirmed a woman in her 30s is assisting with their investigation into the newborn's death. 'The woman is receiving appropriate care and support,' police said in a statement on Wednesday evening. 'Given the sensitivities, we will be making no further comment at this time. Sign up: AU Breaking News email 'The Western Australia Police Force would like to thank the community for their concern, support and assistance.' Police had earlier confirmed the infant had been placed in the storm water drain in recent days. There was no evidence the baby had been washed through the drain system, Det Sen Sgt Stephen Cleal told reporters on Tuesday. Detectives had made a plea for the baby's mother to come forward amid concerns for her health. Police also urged people with information about the incident or CCTV recorded in the area to come forward. The WA premier, Roger Cook, had called it a 'horrifying series of events' that had rocked the community, with flowers and teddy bears being left at the drain site. 'This goes to the heart of everyone's sense of humanity, a small child whose life has passed under tragic circumstances,' he said.
