Sandie Peggie welcomes Supreme Court judgment on biological sex
Ms Peggie, who has worked at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy for 30 years, was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at the hospital where they both worked.
Ms Peggie took the health board and Dr Beth Upton, centre, to a tribunal (Image: NQ)
She took the health board and Dr Upton to tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under section 26 of the Equality Act 2010 regarding three incidents when they shared a changing room: indirect harassment, victimisation and whistleblowing.
Ms Peggie was suspended on January 3 2024 after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment, the tribunal in Dundee heard earlier this year.
The tribunal has adjourned until July but the case prompted the Equality and Human Rights Commissioner to write to NHS Fife and the Scottish Government to remind them about workplace legislation around single-sex spaces – which Ms Peggie urged them to comply with, in a statement on Tuesday.
READ MORE:
Ms Peggie also publicly welcomed the UK Supreme Court judgment which in April made clear the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the 2010 Equality Act 'refer to a biological woman and biological sex'.
She said that she 'expects NHS Fife to immediately stop permitting any man who identifies as a woman access to female-only single-sex spaces in the workplace'.
A statement issued via her solicitor Margaret Gribbon said that Ms Peggie was 'determined to continue with her legal claim in an effort to obtain accountability for the way she has been treated by Fife Health Board', and thanked the public, politicians and her lawyers.
Ms Gribbon said: 'Sandie Peggie very much welcomes the recent Supreme Court's judgment that 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex.
'She salutes the courage and tenacity of For Women Scotland for doggedly pursuing this strategically important case and is extremely grateful to them for their support with her own legal case.
Sandie Peggie (centre), 'continues to draw strength' from the support she receives from around the world, her solicitor said (Image: (Andrew Milligan/PA))
'She continues to draw strength and inspiration from the overwhelming support she continues to get from the public in this country and around the world.
'She is determined to continue with her legal claim in an effort to obtain accountability for the way she has been treated by Fife Health Board, simply because she objected to sharing a female-only workplace changing room with a man.
'She now expects NHS Fife to immediately stop permitting any man who identifies as a woman access to female-only single-sex spaces in the workplace.
'Sandie also wishes to place on record her gratitude to those elected members from across the political divide who have demonstrated their public support for her from the outset.
'She plans to visit the Scottish Parliament before her employment tribunal resumes in July and looks forward to meeting many of those politicians in person.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Edinburgh to host The Great British Care Cycle Relay
Cycling adventure begins at Glencairn Care Home to shine a light on the care services at the heart of every community Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The Great British Care Cycle Relay, which celebrates the care services at the heart of every community, is set kick off at Glencairn Care Home in The Grange, Edinburgh at 9am on Thursday, June 12. It includes five individual, day-long cycle rides in Scotland, England and Wales totalling around 500km, with colleagues, supporters and families of all ages and abilities taking part and visiting care services enroute. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Eleven cyclists, including one from Renaissance Care, are taking part in the Scottish leg of the relay. The group will cycle a 123km loop, passing through Stenhousemuir and Winchburgh and visiting care homes such as Canmore Lodge Care Home in Dunfermline, Caledonian Court in Larbert and Linlithgow Care Home. The cyclists will also stop off at Alzheimer Scotland's new and expanded facilities in the city. The Great British Care Cycle Relay The Great British Care Cycle Relay also takes in a 94km York route through North Yorkshire, a 103km Nottingham route in the Midlands, a 125km route through Cardiff and South Wales and a 110km finale from Brighton to London on 16 June. By the end, Championing Social Care expects over 70 cyclists to have been involved. The end of the relay marks the start of Care Home Open Week 2025 (16 to 22 June), which aims to highlight the amazing work that is modern care. Ian Condie from Dunfermline is taking part in the race with his wife Jenny, he said: 'We're looking forward to the cycle, but with a little trepidation! At 123 kilometres, it'll be the longest distance we've ridden on our tandem this year, although as part of the route goes through Fife, it will be familiar territory for us. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'This is a cause close to our hearts, as having lost my 98-year-old mum in January after a short illness, we've had first-hand experience of the fantastic job those involved in the care sector do for both those receiving care and their families. Mum as a resident at Orchardhead Care Home in Rosyth for the last couple of years and had been happy and well looked after there. It's good to give something back.' Organiser of The Great British Care Cycle Relay, Championing Social Care, is encouraging those people who want to take part, but are not cyclists, to instead to cheer the riders on as pass by or help give them a warm reception when they visit care homes enroute. The care home gatherings will provide an opportunity for the cyclists to connect with fellow colleagues, share stories, and enjoy the contagious enthusiasm that radiates throughout the relay. Championing Social Care Trustee and Founder and Chair of the Great British Care Cycle Relay, Vishal Shah said: 'The Great British Care Cycle Race is a fabulous precursor to Care Home Open Week. It's now its third year and our largest one yet. It connects the joy of cycling with visiting the incredible care services at the heart of communities up and down the country. The aim is to bring more of the general public closer to understanding what it's actually like to live and work in care and help dispel the negative narratives that often are shared. 'As a keen cyclist, any opportunity to get on a bike is always taken, but this relay is particularly special. My motivation for taking part stems from a deeply personal connection, as my grandmother lived with dementia and received incredible support from social care, which enabled her to live a life of quality and purpose. We were supported as family to not only navigate this journey but also enjoy the special connections and memories that we continued to create and share together.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Robert Kilgour, Chairman of Renaissance Care said: 'We're proud to host the launch event here at Glencairn Care Home. Care homes play a vital role within communities, delivering essential support to older adults and easing pressure on the wider health and social care system. "Every day, our dedicated staff bring compassion, expertise, and commitment to promoting the physical and emotional wellbeing of our residents. We're extremely proud of the work they do, and this event is a welcomed opportunity to shine a light on the outstanding work happening across the social care sector.'
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Swinney defends Wishaw NICU downgrade after by-election row
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said the proposed changes to neonatal care showed the health service was 'simply not safe in John Swinney's hands'. He cited local opposition, including an online petition that has attracted more than 25,000 signatures. READ MORE Under the plans, the Wishaw unit will be downgraded to a level two facility, meaning babies born before 27 weeks will have to be transferred to one of three specialist centres in Aberdeen, Edinburgh or Glasgow. The Scottish Government insists the move is based on expert clinical advice and will improve outcomes for the most premature and vulnerable babies. Campaigners, however, warn it risks separating families and placing unnecessary stress on mothers. Mr Sarwar highlighted the case of Tammy Johnston, who was unable to hold her premature son Kai for four weeks after birth. 'Under these plans, she could be forced to travel to Aberdeen or even further,' he warned. He also cited Amanda Todd, who he said had been told she may need to give birth in Dublin due to bed shortages. 'Is it not the case that the NHS is simply not safe in John Swinney's hands?' he asked. Mr Swinney rejected the claims, saying the proposals were about saving lives, not saving money. 'There is nothing in the proposal about Wishaw General Hospital that is about saving money,' he said. 'It is about maximising the chances of saving babies' lives. That is what the proposal is about — informed by expert opinion.' He pushed back against suggestions that frontline voices were being ignored, insisting the Government was acting on the best available medical evidence. Meanwhile, Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay warned that Scotland was in the grip of an 'out of control' organised crime wave. He referenced Operation Portaledge — the ongoing police investigation into a violent gangland feud that has seen shootings, firebombings and assaults across central Scotland. Police have so far arrested 41 people in connection with the incidents. 'These parasites grow rich by preying on society's most vulnerable,' Mr Findlay said. 'These cowards cause terror and death with guns, knives and fire bombs. They go after journalists, politicians, businessmen, police and prison officers. Organised crime is out of control and communities are living in fear.' Mr Findlay, who worked as a journalist who covered gangland crime before entering Holyrood, was the victim of an acid attack in 2015 when William Burns threw sulphuric acid into his face. He asked the First Minister: 'Does John Swinney accept that the Scottish Parliament has failed to tackle organised crime in Scotland?' Mr Swinney denied the claim. 'Organised crime is intolerable — it is unacceptable,' he said. 'It requires the forensic attention of our police and criminal justice authorities to tackle it, and that is being undertaken within Scotland on a relentless basis by Police Scotland and by the criminal justice authorities. 'I would expect the authorities to pursue that level of scrutiny and activity, and that is what is happening. Mr Findlay also raised concerns about sentencing guidelines for young offenders. Current guidance encourages judges to consider rehabilitation rather than prison for those under 25 — a policy he described as open to abuse. READ MORE He quoted Detective Superintendent Andy Patrick, who warned last year that gangs were exploiting the rules by coercing young people into committing serious crimes in the belief they would avoid jail. Mr Swinney responded: 'Not for the first time, I cannot allow Mr Findlay's remarks to stand. It is misleading to say to members of the public that there are no consequences for criminal activity under the age of 25 — there are very serious consequences, which involve imprisonment.' However, there some was consensus at the end, with the First Minister signalling a willingness to review the Proceeds of Crime Act. The legislation is aimed at recovering assets from drug dealers and other criminals. Mr Findlay told MSPs "top-level crime bosses" were "making millions of pounds from killing vulnerable Scots with their drugs." He added: "We were told that the Mr Bigs would be bankrupted by the proceeds of crime law that was passed at the start of devolution, but the law has failed. "Criminals and their white-collar enablers no longer fear the proceeds of crime legislation, and, 18 months ago, the SNP rejected my call to review why that is not working." He highlighted the case of one dealer believed to have made £126 million through crime. However, the Crown Office was only able to recover only £118,000. "The proceeds of crime legislation needs an urgent and radical overhaul. We must turn the tables on the drug gangs so that they live in fear," Mr Findlay said, calling on the First Minister to "toughen the legislation to make it fit to tackle organised crime in 2025 and beyond." Mr Swinney said he was "open to ensuring that we have in place the correct legislative framework to deal with criminality in our country." "I am perfectly willing to consider that, because I do not want anybody to benefit from criminal activity in our society, and I want people to be punished accordingly," he added.
Scotsman
4 hours ago
- Scotsman
John Swinney defends SNP plan to downgrade award-winning neonatal unit
The First Minister said the Scottish Government is following expert clinical advice Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... John Swinney has defended plans to downgrade Wishaw neonatal unit despite warnings the decision will have a 'human cost'. The First Minister said the move followed expert clinical advice and was not simply 'conjured up' by ministers. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad But Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said it would force families to travel long distances to receive the care they need. First Minister John Swinney | PA He accused Mr Swinney of ignoring some experts and 'hiding behind' others. Mothers who have relied on the specialist services at Wishaw previously warned patients could be left with no choice but to travel to Aberdeen or England, or even as far as Ireland, because of the severe pressure the maternity units in Glasgow and Edinburgh are already under. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Speaking at First Minister's Questions in Holyrood, Mr Sarwar said: 'Wishaw neonatal has won awards for the standard of care it delivers, and even people in this chamber have relied on the unit in their time of need. 'So why does the SNP want to downgrade this life-saving unit?' Mr Swinney said the Government had sought clinical opinion from experts including the medical director of NHS Forth Valley and the Scottish Neonatal Nurses Group. Units cut from eight to three The plan will reduce the number of specialist units across Scotland from eight to three, with services provided at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow, Edinburgh Royal Infirmary and Aberdeen Maternity Hospital. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Swinney said: 'This has not been conjured up by the Government considering an issue on its own behalf. 'We have sought expert clinical opinion, which I've put on the record as to where that's come from, and there will be other occasions in parliament where members of parliament will take the government to task for not following expert opinion. 'And here Mr Sarwar wants me to ignore expert opinion, which has led us to the conclusions that we have [made].' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The First Minister said the unit at Wishaw will continue, but a 'very small number of babies, where there is a need for expert specialist care to maximise their chances of survival' will be treated elsewhere. Mr Sarwar said he understood the experts had recommended 'a range' of options 'and the government is choosing the lower level of that range rather than other options'. Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar and deputy Jackie Ballie join the party's candidate in the Hamilton by-election Davy Russell to meet local parents at the specialist neonatal care centre in Wishaw this week | Getty Images He said the plans to downgrade Wishaw are opposed by clinicians, experts and parents. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish Labour leader said: 'I think John Swinney is choosing to listen to certain experts and ignore other experts in the process, and hide behind experts when it comes to this Government's decision. 'The reality is that this is an award-winning unit that is giving life-saving care and the expertise exists there, but would not if this unit was downgraded, and the SNP's failure to support neonatal NHS services has a human cost.' He raised the case of Amanda Todd from South Lanarkshire, who faced the prospect of having to travel to Dublin to give birth in 2021 because of bed shortages. She only found out space was available in Scotland the day before her operation. Mr Sarwar said the NHS is not safe in Mr Swinney's hands.
