‘Broader investigation overdue' – ActionSA lodges criminal complaint against medical aids
ActionSA MP and member of the Health Portfolio Committee Dr Kgosi Letlape has lodged a criminal complaints against medical aid schemes.
This follows a report, commissioned by Minister of Health Aaron Motsoaledi, that found racial discrimination against black service providers by the schemes
Chairperson of the independent investigative panel, Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, presented the report's key findings to the minister on Monday, 7 July.
Findings
The panel was tasked with determining if there were any racial undertones in the medical aid schemes' treatment of practitioners.
ALSO READ: Medical aids slammed for procedural unfairness in new report
'The risk ratio is a tool we developed to work out the likelihood that a black practitioner would be subjected to an investigation, a finding and a penalty, versus a white practitioner,' explained Ngcukaitobi.
'What we did have the power to do was make findings of fact, and that finding of fact simply leads to one conclusion: the evidence of risk ratios showed racial discrimination against black service providers by the schemes.'
Ngcukaitobi noted how, in 2017, one private medical aid scheme found black psychiatrists guilty of fraud, waste and abuse (FWA) at more than three times the rate of their white counterparts.
ALSO READ: More than half of Discovery's medical aid plans saw declines in members last year
Another private scheme was shown to have found black anaesthetists guilty of FWA over six times more often than other groups in 2018.
In the government employee medical scheme, black dental therapists were generally three times more likely than non-black dental therapists to be found guilty of FWA in 2014.
'Critical step' against medical aid schemes
On Monday, ActionSA said that laying formal criminal complaints was a crucial step to enable investigators to lawfully access the relevant records, communications and case files.
ALSO READ: Trio of medical aids fail to maintain required liquidity
'These materials are essential to uncovering the full extent of any wrongdoing and ensuring that those implicated are held to account, including both medical schemes and practitioners who may have engaged in criminal conduct,' said ActionSA.
'ActionSA is of the considered view that a broader investigation into the conduct of these schemes is both necessary and overdue.'
The party said a criminal investigation would go a long way in exposing the 'deep-seated rot' within the health sector, 'ensuring that criminal conduct is rooted out and that discriminatory practices which undermine the very principles of South Africa's constitutional democracy are brought to an end'.
Additional reporting by Jarryd Westerdale
READ NEXT: Medical schemes risk ruining their reputations through greed
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
5 days ago
- IOL News
Investigations demanded against KZN MECs amid corruption claims
THE MEC of Education in KwaZulu-Natal, Sipho Hlomuka whose department is embroiled in allegations of tender irregularities regarding the school nutrition programme THE MEC of Health in KwaZulu-Natal, Nomagugu Simelane, has distanced herself from allegations that she had a hand in the abrupt termination of Vuma FM presenter, Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma's contract. TRIBUNE REPORTER ACTIONSA has written to KwaZulu-Natal Premier Thami Ntuli, urging him to investigate Health MEC Nomagugu Simelane and Education MEC Sipho Hlomuka on various allegations levelled against them. The DA has also joined the fray and asked the Minister of Basic Education Siviwe Gqurube to take over the R2.9 billion National School Nutrition Programme (NSNP). The party also welcomed the commitment by KZN Finance MEC, Francois Rodgers, to initiate a preliminary investigation following serious allegations of corruption implicating Hlomuka and several ANC-linked figures within the administration of the NSNP. Simelane is facing allegations of abuse of power and interfering in the abrupt termination of Vuma FM presenter Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma's contract. The allegations surfaced earlier this week, and KZN Health was swift in quelling the rumours, issuing a statement after hours on Monday distancing the MEC from the allegations, adding that as a woman she would never do such a thing against another woman. Ngobese-Zuma is the founder of the anti-illegal immigration movement, March and March, which has had a few brushes with the health department over the members of the movement blocking undocumented immigrants from accessing public healthcare facilities. ActionSA leader in KZN, Zwakele Mncwango, said the premier shouldn't hide behind the deals of the government of provincial unity (GPU) to drag his feet at launching an investigation against the MECs. Hlomuka is embroiled in the school nutrition tender of his department, with his wife's company being one of the chosen bidders to supply food at various schools. "We are writing to you to express our deep concern regarding the serious allegations of irregularities, corruption, and abuse of power within the Department of Health and Education. These allegations undermine the public's trust in the provincial department and its commitment to good governance, accountability, and transparency," reads ActionSA's letter. "Specifically the allegations against the MEC of Health regarding the abuse of power in relation to Vuma FM and the presenter Jacinta Ngobese, as well as the allegations of interference in the tender process for the nutrition programme by the MEC of Education, are grave and require immediate attention. "It is particularly concerning that you have remained silent on these matters, despite your previous rhetoric on issues such as illegal immigration. Notably, Jacinta Ngobese has been a vocal advocate against illegal immigration, and it is alarming that she is allegedly being victimised for her stance. Your silence on this matter raises questions about your commitment to protecting those who speak out against issues you have publicly condemned." Vuma FM issued a statement yesterday denying the Health MEC's involvement in the termination of Ngobese-Zuma's contract; however, just last month the station unveiled its new lineup with her still being the presenter of the midmorning show, The Cruise. The allegation was that Simelane had threatened to pull out all Department of Health advertising from the station, and she would also encourage other departments to do the same if Ngobese-Zuma was not removed. Yesterday, the Health MEC was on Ukhozi FM and clarified that the March and March movement, like every person, has a right to protest; however, every person in South Africa has a right to access health services if they are sick. She said her department can't turn away sick people from their facilities regardless of their immigration status, as it would open floodgates of legal action against the department. Simelane explained their conundrum as the department on undocumented immigrants citing the example of turning away a TB patient and the ripple effect it would have on them travelling by taxis and infecting other passengers who in turn infect others. She said there are discussions underway at the national level on a plan to have the immigrants' countries of origin help South Africa fund their healthcare. The DA's spokesperson on education, Sakhile Mngadi, who's also a member of the provincial legislature, said, "In the event that the allegations prove true, MEC Sipho Hlomuka must be removed from office without delay. Corruption cannot be tolerated at the expense of hungry children and the future of our province." And businesses that operate under the NSNP have also complained about irregularities and favouritism in the bidding process. The spokesperson for the Department of Education, Muzi Mahlambi, said, "The process is underway and has not been finalised for anyone to cry foul." He said they have no knowledge of these allegations, and those bidders who feel aggrieved know the relevant platform where to report their allegations. The programme has always had challenges like budget constraints and payment delays to service providers. Yesterday the ANC in KwaZulu-Natal, in a statement, welcomed Vuma FM's clarification on Ngobese-Zuma's contract and said this should put to bed the unfounded allegations against Simelane. On the issue of the nutrition tender, the ANC said, "The ANC understands that this process is at an appeal stage where those who have made bids and seek to appeal must forward their appeals to the Treasury Department. The ANC has full confidence that the provincial government has adequate capacity to handle appeals in a just and transparent manner."
The Citizen
17-07-2025
- The Citizen
Top 10 Discovery medical claims paid in 2024 totalled R70m
To fund the highest claim would take 283 years' worth of contributions … The second highest claim was for 'major surgical procedures' in a newborn at R8.4m. Picture: Shutterstock Discovery Health Medical Scheme (DHMS) says 10 of the highest member claims paid in 2024 totalled R70.5 million. The highest, per its disclosure in a presentation at the scheme's AGM on Tuesday, was for a 75-year-old member who was paid out R9.6 million for 'care for [the] long-term use of a ventilator'. To fund this claim, it would take a theoretical 283 years' worth of contributions (nearly 3 400 months). Half of the top 10 claims were for the long-term use of a ventilator, with the youngest patient being a new-born (the second youngest was 16). There were two new-borns in the top 10 list. It says across the top 10 claims, 98% of the costs were covered by the scheme. Read more Parliament allocates R71m for medical aid for former MPs DHMS says 2 108 individuals claimed in excess of R1 million in the year. It paid a total of R45 billion in hospital claims last year, with a total of 714 000 hospital admissions. Of these, 35 000 of its members and beneficiaries were admitted to ICU. In total, it paid R83 billion in claims expenditure in 2024. A third (32%) was day-to-day, 4% was for chronic medication, 2% for maternity-related claims and 8% for oncology (nearly R7 billion). Scheme members made 2.3 million specialist visits in 2024, with 10.6 million dispensaries of over-the-counter and 14.2 million of prescribed medication. There were 28 000 babies born, 121 000 mammograms and 209 000 prostate checks conducted, and 435 000 health checks done across its members. ALSO READ: More than half of Discovery's medical aid plans saw declines in members last year Incentivising the prioritisation of health It incentivises the health checks through Vitality, which from this year has launched a far more personalised programme using Personal Health Pathways. Because this is unique to each member and dynamic, Discovery says there are more than seven million possible personal health pathways per member, across its base of 2.1 million members. Across its eligible member base, 13% have activated personal health pathways (the programme is not mandatory). In terms of so-called 'next best actions', 270 000 health actions had been completed by mid-June, with getting a flu vaccine being the top one. More than 1.1 million exercise actions had been completed, but these tend to be weekly challenges (either closing an exercise ring or walking more than a certain number of steps). More than a third of all actions had been completed by members with what Discovery calls 'emerging health risk'. This is precisely the point of personal health pathways – to make members healthier by getting them into shape to avoid chronic illnesses, or to get them to actively manage those chronic conditions actively. Completing actions offers rewards for members, either in the form of benefits in a personal health fund or Discovery Miles. The fund can be used for day-to-day benefits as a 'booster' to cover on a member's medical aid plan. So far (to mid-June), members had accumulated R137 million in their personal health funds, with nearly half of this used for pharmacy visits. ALSO READ: Sanlam pays out R6.62 billion in death and disease claims Chronic conditions and complexities DHMS says that of those with chronic conditions, 51% have one, 22% have two, 15% three and 12% four. The overlap between chronic conditions such as cardiovascular, diabetes, oncology, and mental health 'leads to increasingly complex care needs'. A member with a chronic and mental health condition is 3.5 times more at risk of admission than one with no chronic condition. It has a number of care programmes for these conditions, the largest of which is cardio care (216 000 members), followed by oncology (101 000) and HIV (82 000). In total, more than one million members benefit from these tailored programmes. ALSO READ: Increasing medical aid scheme costs: What are the alternatives? Trustees The election of trustees for DHMS, which saw aggressive lobbying by various parties given that there were three vacant spots, was completed at the AGM. There were 77 candidates vying for these positions. Joan Adams, David Charles King and Dr Max Price were elected as trustees of the scheme. Adams and Price were re-elected as they had only served a single term as trustee. The other member whose term had come to an end, Marius du Toit, was not re-elected. The scheme's board of trustees must comprise at least five and at most eight members. DHMS has seven trustees. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
Mail & Guardian
15-07-2025
- Mail & Guardian
ActionSA pushes for constitutional change as Operation Dudula targets migrants at clinics
Operation Dudula preventing foreigners from using South African health faacilities. (Delwyn Verasamy/M&G) ActionSA parliamentary chief whip Lerato Ngobeni said the party had tabled constitutional amendment proposals in May, arguing that the public health system was 'buckling' under the pressure of providing free care to non-citizens. Ngobeni claimed that some clinics reported that up to 70% of patients seeking services were foreign nationals and this had led to South Africans being 'crowded out' of already overstretched facilities. 'South Africa is expected to carry this burden indefinitely, when other countries do not even allow entry without proof of medical insurance,' she said in a recent statement. The The commission voiced alarm about reports of intimidation by Operation Dudula at health facilities in Hillbrow and Rosettenville in Johannesburg. They demanded documentation at clinic entrances and turned away people without documents. In some cases, they inspected patient clinic cards and threatened hospital staff. 'The commission would like to remind members of the public and civic groups that access to healthcare is central to the right to dignity, the right to life, and the right to equality. The denial of healthcare on discriminatory grounds undermines the constitutional promise of a just, inclusive and caring society,' the SAHRC said. It cautioned citizens against taking the law into their own hands and making it difficult for people to get medical care because of their nationality. 'It is important to note that no civic group or individual has the legal authority to control access to public health facilities or to enforce immigration laws.' The power to inspect, arrest or detain undocumented people lies solely with the department of home affairs, supported by the South African Police Service when lawfully required, the commission said. Operation Dudula, now a registered political party, has said its actions are 'community interventions'. National organiser Zandile Dabula told public broadcaster SABC last week that migrants should only receive emergency care 'after they are arrested for violating immigration laws'. In an interview with the Mail & Guardian , she denied that Operation Dudula's Legal experts have said such actions could constitute violations of the Constitution and the National Health Act, which does not permit discrimination based on nationality or legal status. International human rights frameworks, including the United Nations Refugee Convention and the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, also obligate South Africa to provide basic healthcare to all people in its borders. Pierre de Vos, a constitutional law expert at the University of Cape Town, has previously argued that section 27's language is unambiguous and applies to all people, not just citizens. He said that amending this section would require a two-thirds majority in the National Assembly and approval from at least six provinces in the National Council of Provinces. In Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal, nurses and doctors have raised concerns about staff shortages, long queues and under-resourced clinics. The department of health has not endorsed ActionSA's stance, but it has acknowledged systemic pressure driven by increased demand, insufficient infrastructure and budget constraints. It says undocumented migrants can get primary care services, with more restricted access to specialised care. Civil society organisations, including Kopanang Africa Against Xenophobia and Section27, have called for urgent intervention to halt Operation Dudula-led disruptions at clinics. Legal proceedings have been launched in the Johannesburg high court seeking interdicts against the party's actions, with judgments expected later this year. As the 2026 local government The party argues that South Africa must 'rebalance' its humanitarian commitments with resource constraints, but critics warn that such rhetoric risks fuelling xenophobic violence.
