Senedd Member calls for restrictions on bottom trawling
The Conservatives' shadow climate secretary told the Senedd: 'It is a national disgrace that this Welsh Government is allowing such destructive and wasteful practices to take place.'
Ms Finch-Saunders warned: 'These practices effectively bulldoze through and destroy seabed habitats. They release high levels of carbon and they catch untargeted marine life.'
She stated bottom trawling is excluded in less than 1 per cent of seas, with restrictions around Skomer Island – only one of the 139 marine protected areas (MPAs) surrounding Wales.
Ms Finch-Saunders described the 'destructive' method of fishing as 'incompatible' with MPAs, which are meant to be sanctuaries for marine life.
She urged Welsh ministers to follow Westminster's lead, with the UK Government consulting on proposals to ban bottom trawling in 41 MPAs – an area spanning 30,000km2.
Ms Finch-Saunders pointed to the example of a ban in Lyme Bay in south-west England leading to a 430 per cent increase in the richness of the species mix.
Contributing to the debate on July 9, Joyce Watson raised long-held concerns about the impact of scallop dredging in the special area of conservation in Cardigan Bay.
She said: 'Scallop dredging, like other forms of dredging, is an incredibly destructive fishing practice – the entire structure of the seabed is damaged as rakes are dragged along.'
Her Labour colleague Carolyn Thomas said she was horrified to watch Sir David Attenborough's Ocean documentary film. But she added: 'It did say there was hope, that if bottom trawling ended – the ecosystems, the biodiversity could soon recover.'
Huw Irranca-Davies, the deputy first minister who is responsible for environment policy, described the use of bottom trawling around Wales as relatively limited.
He told the Senedd the main king scallop fishery in Wales is managed under a joint fisheries management plan with England to ensure long-term sustainability.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
22 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Woman banned from driving after travelling at 46mph on the M4
Woman banned from driving after travelling at 46mph on the M4 Lorraine Peel was convicted after an automatic speed camera in an area of roadworks caught her doing 46mph The woman was caught by an automatic speed camera, a court heard (Image: Traffic Wales) A woman was caught driving at 46mph on the eastbound M4 by an automatic speed camera in a roadworks area with a temporary 40mph limit. Lorraine Peel, from Newbury, was travelling through this stretch of road when she was caught, High Wycombe Magistrates' Court was told. Following the incident on August 14, 2024, the 60-year-old driver admitted to exceeding a temporary speed restriction. As a result, Peel was disqualified from driving for six months and received six points on her licence. She was also fined £154, ordered to pay £120 in court costs and a £62 surcharge, all due by August 12. Meanwhile, drivers are calling for a "referendum" on a new UK traffic law concerning the 20mph speed limits in Wales, insisting that "all limits need to be restored". This follows a previous petition urging the Welsh Government to abolish 20mph limits, which gathered over 469,000 signatures. A fresh petition has now been launched demanding a "public poll" on 20mph speed limits across Wales. Martyn Evans, who started the petition, stated: " We require a public poll on 20 mph speed limits as the Welsh people are being ignored.", reports Birmingham Live. He added: "The speed limit petition has been ignored by those in power, the only way to properly gauge feeling from the people would be to have a public poll of all Welsh voters, and, when it is realised how hated the 20 mph limits are, then they should be changed back to 30mph immediately. Don't miss a court report by signing up to our crime newsletter here "The promise of the Senedd listening was yet another lie from politicians too self-absorbed to listen to the voters. We have now seen many other speed limits also reduced, which also need returning to the previous limits. "Since the petition against the 20mph speed limit closed, there has been a lot of talk but very little visible action on this matter, and more speed limits have been reduced. "All limits need to be restored, including the M4 back to 70mph, as the pollution excuse is now redundant as a large part of Port Talbot steelworks has been shut down. "In my opinion, the safety reason for these limits is being proved wrong every day as there now appear to be more accidents than ever. "This law has targeted the wrong people, the people speeding excessively are still speeding, but now I believe the accidents are more severe as when the speeders hit those who wish to keep their licenses, the speed difference is now far greater. Article continues below "It is also causing more road rage incidents than I've seen in 35 years of driving, and has reduced the significance of the areas that had, and actually needed, 20mph limits. "It has been and continues to be a waste of time and money, forced on us by zealots that have no idea how this country needs to be run."
ITV News
22 minutes ago
- ITV News
Chancellor defends UK Government funding for Wales
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves has defended the level of the UK Government's spending in Wales during a visit to a coal tip remediation site near Port Talbot. Meeting Welsh Finance Secretary Mark Drakeford MS, she pointed to £118m allocated in the recent Spending Review over three years to improve disused coal tips across Wales. "The whole of the United Kingdom has benefited from coal in Wales and therefore it's right that the UK make sure that these communities are now safe" she said. The visit comes just one day after Eluned Morgan completed one year as First Minister, during which time she insisted she would "call out" Labour MPs in Westminster if they "get it wrong for Wales". Reeves said she continues to work closely with the First Minister and said the partnership has provided money for rail improvements in North and South Wales, "the biggest settlement since devolution", and a fall in NHS waiting lists in England and Wales. She also defended the UK Government's controversial rise in employers' National Insurance contributions. Previously Mark Drakeford called out the decision and said it was "wrong" that Wales' public services faces a shortfall of up to £65m due to the increases. Reeves justified the move, saying it was necessary to improve public services in Wales and England. She said: "We have now delivered millions more appointments in England and Wales over the last year in our NHS but that was only possible because we raised the money..." "I do recognise the challenges raises in National Insurance creates but without that money we would not be able to secure our public finances."
Daily Record
22 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Labour homelessness minister accused of hiking rent by £700 after 'evicting tenants'
Rushanara Ali is under fire over the claims. Labour's homelessness minister is facing calls to resign over claims she hiked rent on a property she owns weeks after the previous tenants' contract ended. Four tenants who rented a house in east London from Rushanara Ali were sent an email last November saying their lease would not be renewed. The i Paper also reported they were given them four months' notice to leave. Ali's property was then re-listed with a £700 rent increase within weeks, the newspaper said. Kevin Hollinrake, the Conservative party chairman, called for the minister to stand down, accusing her of 'staggering hypocrisy' over her handling of the rental property. A spokesperson for the minister said: 'Rushanara takes her responsibilities seriously and complied with all relevant legal requirements.' The house, rented on a fixed-term contract, was put up for sale while the tenants were living there, and it was only re-listed as a rental because it had not sold, according to the i Paper. Tory frontbencher Hollinrake said: 'I think it shows staggering hypocrisy. Rushanara Ali has been somebody who's obviously a Government minister in charge of homelessness. 'She's spoken out about exploiting tenants, about providing more protections to tenants. 'You can't say those things, then do the opposite in practice, as a landlord. She's got to resign.' He said the conduct appeared to be ' unethical, not illegal ' but 'we can't just say one thing and do another'. Speaking to the i Paper, Ali's former tenant Laura Jackson said she was one of four tenants who received an email giving four months notice to leave the property, for which they collectively paid £3,300 in rent. Jackson, a self-employed restaurant owner, said she saw the house re-listed weeks after she and her fellow tenants had left, but with a rent of around £4,000. The 33-year-old told the i Paper: 'It's an absolute joke. Trying to get that much money from renters is extortion.' She also said two letting companies managing the property for Ali had attempted to charge £395 in cleaning fees and £2,000 to repaint the house when they left. The tenants successfully challenged this, as landlords are prohibited from charging tenants for professional cleaning, and from repainting costs unless serious damage has occurred. A Labour voter, Jackson suggested it was a 'conflict of interest' for MPs to be landlords, especially in their own constituencies. Jackson declined to comment further when approached by the PA news agency but confirmed the details of the i Paper 's story. The minister's actions have also faced scrutiny from rental rights campaigners, as the Government seeks to clamp down on what it sees as unfair rental practices. Ben Twomey, chief executive of Generation Rent, described the allegations as 'shocking and a wake-up call to Government on the need to push ahead as quickly as possible to improve protections for renters'. He added: 'It is bad enough when any landlord turfs out their tenant to hike up the rent, or tries their luck with unfair claims on the deposit, but the minister responsible for homelessness knows only too well about the harm caused by this behaviour. These allegations highlight common practices that the Government can eradicate. 'The Renters' Rights Bill would ban landlords who evict tenants to sell the property from re-letting it within 12 months, to deter this kind of abuse – but unfortunately members of the House of Lords have voted to reduce this to six months. 'The Government can also use its review of the deposit protection system to penalise landlords who make exaggerated claims at the end of the tenancy.' Tom Darling, director at the Renters' Reform Coalition, said: 'It's mind-boggling that we have a homelessness minister who has just evicted four people in order to rake in more rent – something that will soon be illegal under the Renters' Rights Bill her own department is bringing through Parliament."
