Council leaders weigh up legal challenges to asylum seeker hotels
A council in England has won a temporary legal block on aslyum seekers being housed in a hotel
Nigel Farage has urged councils where his party Reform UK holds sway to follow Epping's legal challenge
The Home Office has warned that injunctions could incite further unrest and hinder its legal duty to house asylum seekers
Local authorities across England are considering launching their own legal actions after a district council in Essex secured a High Court victory temporarily blocking asylum seekers from being housed in a hotel in the area.
It comes after demonstrations have erupted in Scotland and England outside hotels housing asylum seekers – leading to arrests and fears of rising tensions.
Conservative-run Broxbourne Council in Hertfordshire said it was taking legal advice 'as a matter of urgency' about whether it could take similar action to Epping Forest District Council, which is also run by the Tories. Stand Up to Racism The demonstrations outside Scottish hotels were met by counter-protests.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage indicated the 12 councils where Reform UK was the largest party would consider legal challenges following Tuesday's ruling.
Writing in the Daily Telegraph, Farage said the local authorities would do 'everything in their power to follow Epping's lead'.
On Tuesday, a High Court judge ruled the former Bell Hotel in Epping must stop housing asylum seekers by September 12.
Farage added: 'The good people of Epping must inspire similar protests around Britain. Wherever people are concerned about the threat posed by young undocumented males living in local hotels and who are free to walk their streets, they should follow the example of the town in Essex.'
Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said ending crossings into the country would 'stop the hotels'.
Writing in the Daily Express, he said: 'Every illegal arrival must be removed, every loophole must be closed, every community must be protected so towns like Epping are never put in this position again.'
The area had seen thousands of people turn out in protest about the housing of migrants in the Bell Hotel.
Protests have also taken place in Scotland with the group Save Our Future & Our Kids Futures holding a demonstration outside Falkirk's Cladhan hotel.
On August 9, a demonstration was held outside the former Patio Hotel in Aberdeen. A hotel in the Summerhill area of the north-east city was also the subject to a recent demonstration.
The protests were met by counter-demonstrations.
STV News has contacted all 32 councils in Scotland to ask if they are looking to challenge the housing of asylum seekers in hotels.
Epping Forest District Council had asked a judge to issue an interim injunction stopping migrants from being accommodated at the Bell Hotel.
The hotel has been at the centre of a series of protests in recent weeks after an asylum seeker who was staying there was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl.
In a post on Facebook, Broxbourne Council said: 'Broxbourne Council will now take legal advice as a matter of urgency about whether it could take similar action.'
Meanwhile, the leader of South Norfolk District Council, which covers the town of Diss where a hotel housing asylum seekers has also been the subject of protests, said the council would not go down the same route.
Conservative leader Daniel Elmer said the council was using planning rules to try to ensure it was families being housed in the area rather than single adult males. He said to do so, which would effectively convert the hotels into hostels, should require a change of use.
Two men have been arrested and charged in connection with a protest in July outside the hotel in Diss, which houses more than 40 children.
Cllr Elmer told the PA news agency: 'We make a big play about integration, and to replace families who have children in the local school system and have integrated into the local community would make no sense.'
He added: 'If we can punish people who have put up sheds in their gardens without permission, then we can take action against hotels being converted into hostels without planning consent.'
Border security minister Dame Angela Eagle said the Government will 'continue working with local authorities and communities to address legitimate concerns'.
She added: 'Our work continues to close all asylum hotels by the end of this Parliament.'
Lawyers for the Home Office had warned the court that an injunction 'runs the risk of acting as an impetus for further violent protests'.
Edward Brown KC also said the injunction would 'substantially interfere' with the Home Office's statutory duty in potentially avoiding a breach of the asylum seekers' human rights.
Several protests and counter-protests have been held in Epping since a then-resident at the hotel was accused of trying to kiss a teenage girl.
Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu has denied the charges against him and is due to stand trial later this month.
A second man who resides at the hotel, Syrian national Mohammed Sharwarq, has separately been charged with seven offences, while several other men have been charged over disorder outside the hotel.
In a ruling on Tuesday, Justice Eyre granted the temporary injunction, but extended the time limit by which the hotel must stop housing asylum seekers to September 12.
He also refused to give Somani Hotels Limited, the hotel's owner, the green light to challenge his ruling, but the company could still ask the Court of Appeal for the go-ahead to appeal against the judgment.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Press and Journal
24 minutes ago
- Press and Journal
Alex Salmond's north-east adviser rubbishes Nicola Sturgeon book claims
A north-east political adviser who worked closely with Alex Salmond in government claims Nicola Sturgeon has spread 'falsehoods' in her new book. Geoff Aberdein took aim at three allegations in Frankly, including that the late SNP leader was against same-sex marriage. 'That one really actually gets my goat,' he said on the Holyrood Sources podcast. Like Ms Sturgeon, he had a ring-side seat during the Mr Salmond's time as first minister. On her side of the story, Ms Sturgeon wrote: 'What started as a calm discussion very quickly descended into a shouting match. Alex very rarely raised his voice to me – or vice versa – so I knew that I had a real battle on my hands to get him to agree. He was implacably opposed. But Mr Aberdein, who went on to help set up strategic advisory firm True North in Aberdeen, says that claim was demonstrably false. Another claim he disputes is the allegation Mr Salmond did not read the pro-independence blueprint before the 2014 referendum, known as the 'white paper'. 'To suggest, as I think was the purpose of this story, that he wasn't engaged in the process of a prospectus for independence is utterly nonsense,' he added. Mr Aberdein also rejected the idea that Mr Salmond could have possibly leaked details of his own alleged sexual misconduct – something Ms Sturgeon speculated about in the run-up to her book publication. Asked if he read the memoirs, he said: 'No I haven't and no I won't.' On the excerpts he has read about, he told the podcast: 'There was falsehoods at worst, fabrications at best. 'I was brought up that you didn't speak ill of the dead. But if you are going to speak ill of the dead, at least make your claims are accurate.' The claims come days after Mr Salmond's widow, Moira Salmond, from Strichen in Aberdeenshire, is suing the Scottish Government over its botched handling of an investigation into sexual harassment allegations levelled against him. Mr Salmond died of a heart attack in North Macedonia in October last year, aged 69. He previously lodged a claim in the Court of Session alleging misfeasance – the wrongful exercise of lawful authority – by civil servants. In her book, Ms Sturgeon laments losing Mr Salmond as a friend, which she compared with a grieving process. 'I had occasional, vivid dreams in which we were still on good terms. I would wake up from these feeling utterly bereft,' she added.
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Former Salmond staffer rejects Sturgeon claims in book as ‘obviously false'
Geoff Aberdein, who worked for Mr Salmond when he was first minister, hit out at Ms Sturgeon, saying: 'I was brought up that you didn't speak ill of the dead. 'But I think if you're going to speak ill of the dead, at least make your claims accurate.' He told the Holyrood Sources podcast that Mr Salmond's widow Moira was 'particularly upset and frustrated at a lot of what has been said' about her late husband, who died suddenly in October 2024. Mr Aberdein continued: 'I think it was important to set out and correct the record not just because Alex is not in position to defend himself, but for myself as well and the series of other officials and civil servants that have contacted me.' Claims that Mr Salmond was the person who leaked the story of the sexual harassment allegations against him are 'obviously false', Mr Aberdein insisted. He said that when his former boss took the phone call to say the story about the allegations was being published by the Daily Record he was actually meeting lawyers to 'draft a legal summons to prevent Nicola Sturgeon's Government from making the allegations public'. Mr Aberdeen said: 'To suggest Alex was simultaneously leaking documents deeply damaging to his reputation whilst at the same time paying lawyers a lot of money to get a court order to prevent publication of the same material is just utterly absurd.' Mr Salmond went on to be acquitted of all the charges against him in a court case in 2020. Mr Aberdein also dismissed claims by Ms Sturgeon that Mr Salmond 'didn't read' the white paper on independence which had been produced by the Scottish government in the run up to the 2014 referendum. In her recently published memoir, Frankly, Ms Sturgeon spoke out about her 'cold fury' with her former leader over his 'abdication of responsibility' on the key document. Mr Aberdein – who said he would not be reading the book – accepted that his former boss 'delegated the responsibility for drafting the white paper to Nicola Sturgeon'. However he insisted: 'To suggest, as I think was the purpose of this story, that he wasn't engaged in the process of a prospectus for independence is utterly nonsense. The former Salmond chief of staff also rejected claims that Mr Salmond was 'apparently against same-sex marriage' – saying that this was 'demonstrably false'. Mr Aberdein told the podcast Mr Salmond had 'declared his personal support for gay marriage for the first time' in a newspaper article in April 2011. And he added that while the SNP election manifesto that year had pledged to consult on the issue Mr Salmond 'chose to come out… excuse the pun, the turn of phrase, ahead of that result, to say that he personally supported it.' With the SNP having won the 2011 Holyrood election, Mr Aberdein recalled 'being in the room with advisors, civil servants and indeed ministers about how we would go about reassuring different sections of our society about that legislation, particularly religious leaders and other civic leaders'. He also made the 'obvious point' that 'if Alex Salmond didn't want legislation to be progressed, he was the first minister of a majority SNP government, it wouldn't have been progressed'. Mr Aberdeen said: 'The point falls down on that alone.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Government issues urgent appeal for 5,000 homes to house 20,000 migrants
The Home Office has issued an urgent appeal for 5,000 properties to house up to 20,000 migrants amid an accommodation crisis caused by a landmark High Court ruling. Asylum accommodation contractors working for the Home Office 'reached out' to property specialists earlier in August, seeking 5,000 residential units. Insiders suggested each flat would have two bedrooms on average, with space to house four migrants. The move emerged on Wednesday, a day after Epping Forest district council was granted a temporary injunction by the High Court to shut down the Bell Hotel in Essex over alleged planning breaches after it became a focus for anti-immigration protests. The hunt for alternative accommodation is part of Labour's pledge to end the use of hotels for asylum seekers by the close of this Parliament in 2029. However, some 200 hotels are still being used by the Home Office to house more than 32,000 asylum seekers, a similar number to summer 2024 – after Labour was forced to find accommodation for the record 27,997 migrants to have crossed the Channel so far in 2025. The Epping council ruling threatens to spark similar legal challenges by other councils seeking to shut asylum hotels in their areas. Two dozen have already signalled that they will consider following suit which, if successful, could worsen the asylum accommodation crisis. Ministers are seeking to partner councils to buy, lease or rent houses and vacant properties in which to place asylum seekers as an alternative to hotels. Officials are also targeting disused tower blocks, student accommodation and old teacher-training colleges for use as 'medium-sized' accommodation sites. The new appeal is understood to have been seeking shorter-term leases or rents, where migrants would be accommodated for 90 days with an additional 30 days' notice. Similar 'contingency' accommodation has also been commissioned at the former Wethersfield RAF base near Braintree, Essex, where the Home Office has raised the cap of 800 migrants to allow 1,225 to live on the site. Residents were told at a meeting on Tuesday that the numbers had already risen to 890, with two intakes of 50 more asylum seekers scheduled every week. Wethersfield is the only 'large' site that Labour inherited from the Tories and kept open, despite Sir Keir Starmer saying before the election that it 'needs to close'. The two other major sites identified by the Tories – the Bibby Stockholm barge and RAF Scampton in Lincolnshire – have both been abandoned by Labour. On Wednesday, Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, called on the Government to guarantee that none of the asylum seekers removed from the Bell Hotel would be transferred to hotels or any other accommodation 'much needed for British people'. He also urged Sir Keir to call an emergency Cabinet meeting to draw up plans to deport all illegal migrants on arrival. 'The previous government established alternative accommodation on current or former military sites and an accommodation barge, which are all alternative options while deportation plans are put in place,' he said. Robert Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, has launched the campaign Lawyers for Borders, which has already attracted top-flight barristers to advise councils on legal challenges to close asylum hotels. 'Every patriotic council, whether Conservative, Reform, whatever, should follow Epping's lead and seek an injunction. And if you are a council or a community group and you need our help, contact my office. If you're a lawyer and you want to join the fight, contact me,' he said in a video on X. 'Let's create a new movement, Lawyers for Borders… We need to put as much pressure as possible on Keir Starmer to change the law, to deport every single illegal migrant who's here, and to close all the hotels.' A Home Office spokesman said: 'This Government has consistently said the use of hotels to house asylum seekers is neither sustainable nor suitable as a long-term approach. 'We remain committed to working with our partners to identify more suitable and cost-effective alternatives.'
