Former children's home employee dismisses abuse claims as ‘absolute nonsense'
The inquiry was hearing evidence on Wednesday from a witness known as 'Toby', who worked at Linwood Hall in Leven from 1975 to 1995, initially working for a house parent and later becoming a senior house parent.
He was given an alias as he was given anonymity by the inquiry.
Toby was asked about allegations made against him in 2001 by a former resident, who claimed Toby had sexually assaulted him while he was a child at the home.
He also alleged that Toby had 'dragged' him out of bed in the middle of the night and taken him to the staffroom on two occasions, once as a punishment for disobeying his foster parents.
He also alleged that while on a school trip to a beach area near the school he was given 'about three cans' of beer by two members of staff, and that he was drugged and raped.
Toby dismissed the allegations as an 'absolute fabrication', and told the inquiry he had 'no idea why he would say all those things'.
'It's absolute nonsense,' he said.
'There is nothing in me that would ever want or dream of wanting to do anything like that towards a child or towards anybody.'
He also pointed out a number of problems with the allegations, including that they would have been witnessed by other children or staff who would, he said, have reported them at the time.
The former senior house parent also denied the allegation that staff 'made' boys fight one another, but acknowledged that on occasions staff allowed children to have a short fight to get a disagreement out of their systems.
'It was just a couple of young kids trying to sort something out themselves. It was just an opportunity for them to have a wee thump at each other.' he said.
The former employee was also asked about David Murphy, another staff member at the home who started at about the same time as Toby, who has since been convicted of abusing children at the facility.
Toby told the inquiry he was 'absolutely gutted' and 'disgusted' when he learned of Murphy's wrongdoing, and that he had now 'cut off all contact with him'.
When asked whether he was aware of how abuse could have been carried out at the home, he replied: 'I do not really know,' and added that he had 'never heard' about any children who were abused by Murphy.
Toby was also asked about his more general experience of the home, which was operated by Fife Council.
The former employee said he he had not need any qualifications when he applied for the role in 1975, and did not know whether his referees were contacted.
He said that when he started he did not receive any training in his role, and that he was expected to 'pick up' what to do from other staff.
He was also critical of training staff received in how to restrain young people, using a method he described as 'more of an assault that a restraint'.
He described the technique as involving two members of staff holding a child by each arm, taking a step forward and pulling them to the floor, which he said risked breaking the child's arm.
'It was a based on a restraint method that was developed in the prison sector for dealing with adults,' he explained.
'You cannot change that over and use it for young people.'
The inquiry is investigating abuse in residential settings including boarding schools, religious establishments and foster care.
The inquiry continues in front of Lady Smith.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
33 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE I was overjoyed to marry the handsome love of my life Paul but after 22 years he dropped a bombshell that shattered our family - he was living a double life as a trans woman named Elizabeth... this is what happened next
When Una Jane-Winfield met dashing Paul she thought she had found the love of her life - and they soon married. Then, for more than two decades, the couple appeared to have a normal marriage, raising two children in a pretty home by the Thames in west London. But one day all that changed. Paul abruptly told Una and their children that he now identified as a woman. And after dropping that bombshell Paul - now using new pronouns and going by the new name Elizabeth - moved out of the family home, changing Una Jane's life in a moment. The experience led her to start a campaign group, TransWidows, to support women who find herself in the same difficult situation. Elizabeth made her startling admission after her secret was starting to come out. Una made the discovery about her then husband's new identity one spring afternoon, where she found a Dorothy Perkins dress, a pair of size nine heels and two credit cards - one had Paul's name while the other said Elizabeth, with the surname spelt slightly differently. 'I brought them down and put them on the kitchen table and asked who do these belong to? I was thinking he had a girlfriend, as you do. 'But instead he said "they're mine" and nothing more than that. 'And then, a few days later, we were walking past the Tube station when he just blurted out "It's true, I'm a transexual". 'We had been walking side by side but I stopped. I was absolutly rooted to the ground. I had no idea what those words meant back then. I didn't realise, in his mind, that it was a release, that it was an explanation.' Sitting next to a half torn-up picture Elizabeth sent their ex-wife a year after they separated, Una said: 'I ripped that up in anger but really there was no point because by then the deed was done. 'I still get upset about it. The thing that makes me the most angry is all the secrecy, I felt completely deceived.' After years of grappling with how her former husband's bombshell revelation affected her, Una has now created the TransWidows group - for women whose husband's have changed gender. Una describes herself as a staunch feminist supporting the same gender-critical views that people such as JK Rowling and Maya Forstater. She wants to see the Gender Recognition Act 2004, which recognises a transgender person's acquired gender, to be removed claiming Tony Blair should 'never have passed it'. She also wants Gender Reassignment to be removed from the Protected Characteristics of the Equality Act. The mother-of-two feels most strongly about children being told while still of school age that 'they might be born in the wrong body'. 'Sorry kids, you only have one body for the rest of your life,' the campaigner said. 'You can chop bits off but it will still be the same body every day because every single one of the cells in your body has either got XX or XY chromosomes.' Her controversial views have, in the past, got her in trouble. Una had plastered pictures of a 13-year-old girl who had just undergone a female-to-male reconstruction, also known as top surgery. After passersby reported the poster to Hammersmith and Fulham Council, she was handed a Community Protection Notice (CPN). The Labour-run authority threatened the pensioner with a £2,500 and prosecution last year, however, eventually backed down instead just insisting Una removed the most graphic images. Now the pinboard, which hangs on the front of her yellow door, is filled with news clippings highlighting wins for activists like Una, such as the Supreme Court ruling that legally the term 'woman' means a biological woman. It was after seeing the power of campaigning from activists groups like For Women Scotland, who pushed for the definition to be clarified in court, that Una decided to set up her own group. At 69-years-old, Una told MailOnline, almost two decades after the separation she finally has the courage to speak out about how her husband's changed identity affected her. 'Women are the bedrock of life and this trans-agenda is destroying all that makes women special or different to men,' she said. Una had met Paul, a budding architect who was 19 years her senior, through mutual friends at their well-to-do sail club. Paul had been married twice before but Una, then in her mid-30s, had not yet had a serious relationship. When she met Paul she felt she had finally met her match. 'He was lovely from the first moment I met him,' she said as she looked back on those first hopeful years. 'I met him through sailing friends and Paul was a good handsman and had a part share in a yacht with a childhood friend. 'I wrongly believed at the time that if you met someone who behaved well, who had the same interests of you even if they were impoverished, he had excellent prospects. I did not see any reason not to marry him.' The first four years of their marriage had been a happy one. Being an older couple, they rushed to have two children, a boy and a girl, within three years. During those first years of marital life, Una was puzzled as to why Paul's first marriage, which lasted 11 years ended, as well as his second marriage, which last four years. Paul had always said his second marriage had ended after his ex-wife 'threw plates at him' in a fit of rage. She said: 'He was physically very attractive to me and we fitted together well so I was very puzzled as to why his previous marriage had failed. 'Four years into my marriage with Paul I know exactly why she threw plates at him. 'He had control over his emotions, he was inherently irresponsible in close personal relationships but couldn't sustain them.' As the years passed, Una and Paul's relationship became more distant, with the campaigner saying he would relentlessly 'taunt' her and degrade her feelings. Una said: 'He changed gradually over the years into a totally different person from someone who teased gently into really taunting words that were really hurting me. 'It was like he was trying to drive a wedge in between us and to destroy my thoughts of myself.' Despite this Una said she wanted to strive to make their marriage work. 'I was very patient with our marriage and I wasn't going to give up until it became absolutely impossible to continue,' she said. Una claims during most of the final 10 years of their marriage, Paul spent locked away in the dining room on the computer, claiming he was watching pornography. She claims he would refuse to help pay for various bills around the house and he stopped wanting to do 'normal' things as a family. 'He was just so mean and so hostile at the end,' she said. 'His behaviour towards me was absolutely unbearable. No confidence, no explanation as to why he wanted me out of his life.' Then suddenly that fateful afternoon in March 2006 where Una stumbled upon her husband's female clothing she finally got an explanation to what had been causing the ongoing, unexplained rift in their marriage. Three months later, Paul moved out of the family home. I was in total shock for about a year, a year and a bit,' Una said. 'At first he answered the phone, then didn't. I hesitated to use emails because it was even more of a distance.' Grappling with the separation, which eventually took four years as Una fought to keep the family home she inherited in her name, the mother-of-two had a few run-ins with her ex-husband. On one occasion she turned up with the children on Paul's doorstep in hope of catching a picture of him dressed in his new identity on camera. Paul, at that time, was still dressing as a man but Una rummaged through his house to find female clothes and took pictures of them. Whilst she was there, Una begged Paul to cut his now long hair, reaching for a pair of small scissors that were in the sink, however, her former husband saw this as a threat. 'I foolishly thought I'd give him one last change and asked him to please get your hair cut,' she said. 'There was a small pair of scissors in the sink and I lifted them up and showed him. I was not threatening him but he flung into an absolute rage, that I had never seen before, from across the room. 'He pushed me against the wall, caused me actual bodily harm, ripped my trousers and said he was going to call the police. 'I said we are going, we are going and I thought I had calmed things down.' But three weeks later, Una was called down from London to a police station by Sussex Police where she was held in custody accused of assault. Una said that Paul, a few days after the incident, had gone to the police and filed a report while identifying as Elizabeth. She said: 'I turned up unprotected in a total state of bewilderment, anger, abandonment, not knowing the first thing about the severity, so they arrested me. 'I was extremely angry as it was a Wednesday afternoon and I had to get back to London to pick the children up from school. 'But they put me in a cell. I had no police record and I thought what the f*** are Sussex Police doing prosecuting the oinly person keeping these kids safe. 'Eventually they arrested me for domestic assault, common assault and forced me to take a caution. 'What I should have done was ask if he could come to court and prove it. Now I have the courage and strength to fight it. It felt like a 10 tonne rock had been dropped on me by Paul.' A few years later Paul recieved his interim gender recognition certificate to identify legally as Elizabeth and the couple finally legally divorced in 2014. During the proceedings, Elizabeth had sent Una the copy of the gender recognition certificate along with some harrowing childhood memories. Elizabeth said they had been sexually abused as a child by a headteacher while attending an all-boys school and that his aunt had told her to dress in his mother's clothes as a child. She also spoke of the painful, acrimonious divorce, her parents had and how her mother had been kicked out of the family home. 'There were a lot of strong emotions in his life but to say nothing about this. In the years we were married. I had no idea about any of this,' Una reflected. At age 70, Elizabeth underwent gender reassignment surgery and moved to Brighton, having very little contact with the two children from her marriage to Una. In 2022, Elizabeth, who had now remarried his second wife in a civil partnership, died at age 84 after falling out of a second-floor window headfirst after cleaning a window. The coroner ruled it had been an accidental death after Elizabeth's partner and son from second marriage argued she had been cleaning insects from a dangerous window. Una, however, submitted a letter to the coroner detailing why she believed it had been suicide. In a final twist of the knife, Una revealed how hurt her children had been after being left entirely out of their father's will. 'They did not ask to be born but now they are left with no inheritance from their own father,' Una said. Una is amongst women who have found themselves in a similar predicament. Her campaign group has a number of aims, including recognising transwidows 'unique roles as mothers in holding our children's welfare and peaceful development as our first concern – above our own mental welfare'. The group also calls for prosecution the prosecution of abusive husbands and ex-husbands to include 'psychological torture'. Another aim of the group includes ending of 'cancel culture' and argues for the 'hate crime' legislation to amended so people discussing 'gender dysphoria' are not criminally prosecuted. *'Una was not paid for this interview which she gave in order to publicise her group and reach other women who may be affected
Wales Online
34 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Protesters arrested in Cardiff amid UK-wide anger over Palestine Action
Protesters arrested in Cardiff amid UK-wide anger over Palestine Action Arrests were made on suspicion of supporting a proscribed terror organisation A protester being arrested in Cardiff (Image: Richard Swingler ) People protesting in Cardiff on Saturday were among around 70 across the UK arrested for showing support for a proscribed terror organisation. The protests outside the BBC Wales headquarters in the centre of Cardiff were held alongside parallel protests in London and Manchester. Some 13 people were arrested in Cardiff as well as 41 in London and 16 in Manchester. The protests were over the decision to class Palestine Action as a proscribed group under the Terrorism Act of 2000. The designation means that membership of or support for the group is a criminal offence. South Wales Police said that it arrested 13 people who had been protesting outside the BBC offices near Cardiff's Central Square. The protesters were lying on the floor and bore placards which read 'I oppose genocide' and 'I support Palestine Action'. The arrests were all on suspicion of supporting a proscribed organisation. Article continues below One said the designation of Palestine Action as a terror group was an "infringement of our democractic right to peaceful protest". South Wales Police said it "supports the right for people to make their voices heard through protest providing it is done lawfully". In her speech announcing the decision to make Palestine Action a proscribed body, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper referred to an attack on Brize Norton on Friday, June 20, in which two Voyager aircraft were sprayed with paint. She called it "the latest in a long history of unacceptable criminal damage committed by Palestine Action" and said the Government would not "tolerate those who put [national] security at risk". She said: "Since its inception in 2020, Palestine Action has orchestrated a nationwide campaign of direct criminal action against businesses and institutions, including key national infrastructure and defence firms that provide services and supplies to support Ukraine, NATO, Five Eyes allies and the UK defence enterprise. "Its activity has increased in frequency and severity since the start of 2024 and its methods have become more aggressive, with its members demonstrating a willingness to use violence. Article continues below "Palestine Action has also broadened its targets from the defence industry to include financial firms, charities, universities and Government buildings. Its activities meet the threshold set out in the statutory tests established under the Terrorism Act 2000. "This has been assessed through a robust, evidence-based process, by a wide range of experts from across Government, the police and the security services. "In several attacks, Palestine Action has committed acts of serious damage to property with the aim of progressing its political cause and influencing the Government."
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Pressure grows to strip shamed rugby star Stuart Hogg of his MBE award
HONOURS chiefs are under mounting pressure to strip shamed rugby star Stuart Hogg of his MBE. It comes six months after he was sentenced for inflicting five years of domestic abuse on his estranged wife Gillian. 3 Ex-Scotland rugby captain Stuart Hogg, 33, was given a community payback order for at Selkirk Sheriff Court for terrorising his wife Credit: Owen Humphreys/PA 3 The former national team skipper was awarded an MBE for services to the game only months before his conviction Credit: Adam Davy/PA Wire 3 Hogg abused spouse Gillian for five years We told in February how the Cabinet Office's honours bosses, the Forfeiture Committee, were asked to make a 'timely decision'. But the disgraced former Scotland captain, 33, is still clinging to the gong awarded to him in 2024 for services to rugby union. Last night Tory MSP Pam Gosal said: 'It's shameful Stuart Hogg has still not done the right thing and handed back his MBE. "His continued refusal is an insult to his victim and all domestic abuse victims across the country. Read more Scottish news BAD COP Jealous Scots cop facing jail after punching pregnant girlfriend and choking her 'It is high time this offender had his award stripped from him rather than trying to hide behind his previous reputation.' And clinical psychologist Dr Mairead Tagg, who has worked with domestic abuse survivors for more than 20 years, also urged the officials to act now. She said: 'Are they just hoping it will all go away? "Do they think we are so taken up with other issues that we will just let it go? "I don't think so. 'Stuart Hogg made his ex- partner's life a living hell. Rugby player Stuart Hogg sentenced for abusing estranged wife 'Do we really want to reward that? "This man has let his teammates down, he has let his country down and the good name of Scottish rugby down.' Dr Tagg added: 'He is not a role model. "We should not be rewarding domestic abusers.' We told how Hogg pleaded guilty last November to a charge of domestic abuse involving mum-of-four Gillian, 38. He admitted to shouting and swearing, tracking her movements and sending distressing messages. At Selkirk Sheriff Court in January he got a community supervision order and was barred from contacting his ex for five years. First Minister John Swinney previously said calls to take back Hogg's MBE were 'reasonable and understandable'. An honour can be withdrawn for a variety of reasons, including criminal convictions and bringing the honours system into disrepute. Former Crewe Alexandra footie manager Dario Gradi, 84, was stripped of his MBE in 2023 after failing to protect kids from sexual abuse at the club. A review found he 'should have done more' on claims about paedo coach Barry Bennell. Hogg, now at French side Montpellier, was approached for comment. The Cabinet Office said it didn't comment on individuals.
