A philosophical war over the iPhone camera app
Project Indigo, on its part, emerges from an impressive pedigree, having been developed by Marc Levoy and Florian Kainz, who were instrumental in establishing the Pixel phones as the benchmark smartphone cameras for many years (and many consider that to be the case even now as well). It wasn't plain sailing, as competition caught up, but Pixel phones made a smart pivot towards computational photography capabilities, when the time was right. With Project Indigo, Levoy and Kainz, have access to the iPhone photography hardware. I've used it to a certain extent, and all I'll say for now is that it is simply not a reimagined version of the Pixel Camera app. This is something that is going much beyond what the default Camera app can do. But here's the thing — not all the time. As a user, there's choice, but for now perhaps not an undeniably definitive one.
Project Indigo has a unique computational photography pipeline. 'First, we under-expose more strongly than most cameras. Second, we capture, align, and combine more frames when producing each photo — up to 32 frames as in the example above. This means that our photos have fewer blown-out highlights and less noise in the shadows. Taking a photo with our app may require slightly more patience after pressing the shutter button than you're used to, but after a few seconds you'll be rewarded with a better picture,' Adobe says.
This is where the big change lies — an aggressive multi-frame approach that's a more intensive computational strategy than many competitor apps, with insistence that priority is on image quality (requiring a dash of patience). This should work as well for casual users, as for the more enthusiastic demographic (I wouldn't call them professional, that side of the table has their own preferences), with the option of enabling the full array of manual controls, as well as both JPEG and raw formats.
Strength in diversity?
The third-party camera app landscape as it stands, reveals a fascinating philosophical divide between different approaches to smartphone photography. Halide Mark II, Camera+ 2 and VSCO, some prime names, and Final Cut Camera and Leica Lux some very likeable ones too. The idea for third-party camera apps has always been to offer a little more in terms of functionality and perhaps unlock certain functionality that the default camera app doesn't have. That's before we get to the main bit — image processing and the differing approaches.
At one end of the spectrum lies the 'zero processing' movement. Halide's Process Zero, is an example. This basically means something that has no AI input and no computational photography pipeline in image processing. There are two distinct schools of thought on this — one that believes shunning AI is a better bet to produce beautiful, film-like natural photos, while the other believes AI does enough to accentuate detailing that may otherwise have been missed. It is a philosophical tension.
VSCO, for instance, puts forward a proposition of blending the camera app with extensive editing capabilities as well as quick access to social media apps. Halide Mark II positions itself with professional-grade manual controls, and a tech called Neural Macro that allows iPhones without a dedicated macro lens to get photos with that effect. Camera+ 2 uses AI extensively, for scene detection and automatic optimisation while still providing full manual control when needed.
I'd say Project Indigo is embracing a bit of the latter, but with certain diversions towards improvement, like they have explained.
The fundamental disagreement about image processing is perhaps why we have differing approaches, and thereby preference based choice for users. A user perhaps has to ask themselves which side they lean on. Is the intent to capture reality as accurately as possible, or to create the most visually appealing image regardless of any computational gymnastics required? There will not be a one-size-fits-all answer.
Project Indigo's entry into this ecosystem represents more than just another camera app — it signals Adobe's serious interest in mobile photography and computational imaging. Of course they pitch for closer integration with their creative apps, including the Lightroom app for smartphones. I do see Adobe with the biggest trump card up their sleeve — the mix of their own approach to research, in-house AI development which Firefly resoundingly testifies to, and the expertise of former Pixel engineers who know what they're doing.
We seem to be at a point where philosophy will provide a foundation for more sophistication.
Vishal Mathur is the Technology Editor at HT. Tech Tonic is a weekly column that looks at the impact of personal technology on the way we live, and vice-versa. The views expressed are personal.
Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines to 100 year archives.
11% OFF
₹53,600
Check Details
6% OFF
₹135,900
Check Details
7% OFF
₹111,900
Check Details
8% OFF
₹82,900
Check Details
8% OFF
₹73,500
Check Details
14% OFF
₹59,900
Check Details
₹134,899
Check Details
₹7,999
Check Details
₹9,999
Check Details
5% OFF
₹54,999
Check Details
₹26,999
Check Details
₹15,999
Check Details
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
5 minutes ago
- Mint
Parents struggling with kids' screen time may finally get relief with iOS 26
Lately, there's been a massive rise in kids' screen time, leaving parents worried about the impact on studies, health, and social skills. Apple seems to have taken note. With iOS 26, the company is rolling out a set of powerful parental controls designed to help families take back control of digital habits. From stricter contact approvals to smarter screen time alerts, the update introduces tools that directly tackle the struggles parents face daily. Age-Appropriate Experiences built in With iOS 26, iPadOS 26, and macOS 26, Apple is introducing a feature called Age Appropriate Experiences. Parents can set their child's age range, and app developers will automatically adjust in-app content accordingly. This ensures that even if children download apps approved for their age, the content they see remains suitable. Parents can decide whether this information is always shared, shared with permission, or never shared, giving families greater flexibility in how controls are applied. Smarter contact approvals Protecting children from strangers online has long been a concern. iOS 26 adds a new approval system for messaging. If a child tries to add a new contact, they'll see a pop-up prompting them to ask a parent or guardian for approval. Parents then receive a notification with the contact's details and can accept, decline, or delay the request. This step aims to reduce the risk of kids being targeted by unknown individuals while giving parents visibility into who their children are communicating with. More transparency in screen time requests Screen time limits are already part of Apple's parental control suite, but iOS 26 strengthens them. Kids often request extra time on apps, which requires the parent's passcode. The upcoming update introduces a safeguard. Parents will now receive a notification whenever their passcode is used. This prevents children who may have memorised or guessed the code from secretly extending their screen time. Another useful addition is a new exception request button on App Store pages. If a child wants to download an app that's normally restricted, they can send a request directly to a parent. Once approved, the app becomes available for download, but parents can revoke access at any time. This option is particularly handy for temporary needs, such as using YouTube for a school project, without permanently changing restrictions. A stronger safety net for families Apple has been steadily building its parental control ecosystem, but the iOS 26 updates mark a notable step forward. By focusing on contact safety, content suitability, time management, and flexible permissions, these tools offer parents more practical ways to guide their child's digital habits. The changes will roll out with the public release of iOS 26 later this year, giving families a fresh set of tools to balance freedom and safety in an increasingly connected world.
Time of India
15 minutes ago
- Time of India
Google tweaks Google Play conditions following EU pressure
PARIS: Alphabet unit Google said on Tuesday it will make it easier for app developers to steer customers to channels other than Google after the European Union competition watchdog charged it with breaching EU regulations . In March, Google was hit with two charges of breaching the EU's landmark Digital Markets Act (DMA), which aims to rein in the power of Big Tech. Google has been in the European Commission 's crosshairs since early 2024 over whether it restricts app developers from informing users about offers outside its app store Google Play and whether it favours its vertical search services such as Google Flights. Regulators have said Alphabet technically prevents app developers from freely steering consumers to other channels for better offers. They said a service fee charged by the company for facilitating the initial acquisition of a new customer by an app developer via Google Play goes beyond what is justified. In a blog post, Google said that following discussions with the European Commission, developers, and other experts, Google is updating certain terms. "While we still have concerns that these changes could expose Android users to harmful content and make the app experience worse, we're updating our External Offers Program for the EU with revised fees and more options for Android developers, following DMA discussions with the European Commission," EMEA Senior Competition Counsel Clare Kelly said. The company, which has been fined more than 8 billion euros ($9.3 billion) by the EU for various antitrust violations, risks fines of up to 10% of its global annual sales if found guilty of breaching the DMA.
The Hindu
35 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Adobe launches Acrobat Studio that combines Adobe Express features with agentic AI
Adobe announced the launch of its new Acrobat Studio offering that brings together the company's media editing products and tools including Acrobat AI Assistant, PDF Spaces, Adobe Express Premium's content creation tools, and PDF tools in Acrobat Pro. Enhanced with AI agents, Acrobat Studio is aimed at allowing users to work with documents across file formats in one location rather than having to switch between platforms for their specific needs. Users of Acrobat Studio will be able to scan, e-sign, edit, and combine documents, as well as summarise scanned documents with AI 'Acrobat Studio is the place where your best work comes together, uniting the productivity of Acrobat, the creative power of Adobe Express and the value of AI to empower you to work smarter and faster. We're reinventing PDF for modern work, so whatever you need to get done, you can do that with Acrobat,' said Abhigyan Modi, senior vice president, Document Product Group, in a press release.
