As heritage violations ruin Old Goa, why the ball is in Centre's court
It is a historic landmark and a must-visit on the itinerary of tourists or pilgrims to Goa. However, Old Goa, the former capital of Portuguese India and a UNESCO World Heritage Site, is increasingly under threat due to rampant construction and urbanisation.Heritage enthusiasts have now sought the intervention of the Union ministry of culture, expressing apprehension over the 'the loss of history and heritage of Old Goa'. The forum 'Citizens for Democracy Goa', which includes former bureaucrat and Congress leader Elvis Gomes; Prajal Sakhardande, a professor of history; and entrepreneur Yogesh Nagvenkar, has written to Vivek Aggarwal, secretary, Union ministry of culture, drawing attention to 'the bizarre situation arising out of the acts of omission by the very state authorities entrusted with responsibilities to preserve the priceless heritage in Goa'.advertisementIn 1986, UNESCO granted world Heritage Site status to the churches and convents of Old Goa. This includes the Basilica of Bom Jesus, which contains the tomb of the Jesuist missionary St Francis Xavier. Old Goa is located 10 km east of state capital Panaji. It was developed from the previous village of Ella after being taken over by the Portuguese, who designated the city as the capital for their occupied territories in Asia in 1730.Present-day Old Goa was also known as Goa Dourada (Golden Goa), Rome of the East, and Pearl of the East, since the 16th century, and this has been documented in the accounts of numerous foreign travelers, including Ludovico di Varthema, Domingo Paes and Jan Huygen van Linschoten.
The city has been described as a port city on the banks of the Mandovi river, which was a hub of horse trade. This brought in substantial revenue for the Adilshahi Sultans of Bijapur in Karnataka, who ruled Goa from 1498. This drew the Portuguese general Afonso De Albuquerque to Goa in 1510. The precinct also has a rich pre-Portuguese history and heritage. In the 11th century, the Kadamba King Jayakeshi-I connected his capital Govapuri-Gopakapattan on the banks of the Zuari to the port of Old Goa through a 9-km-long road known as the 'Rajbid' or Rajbidh.advertisementToday, the surviving churches and convents of Old Goa are the Chapel of St Catherine (1510), which was raised to the status of cathedral by Pope Paul III in 1534; the Church and Convent of St Francis of Assisi (1517), rebuilt in 1521 and 1661; the Church of Our Lady of the Rosary (1549), S Cathedral (1652), the Church of St Augustine (1602), a complex that fell into ruins, with only one-third of the bell tower standing; the Basilica of Bom Jesus (1605), with its prominent Classical orders; and the Chapel of St Cajetan (1661), modelled on the original design of St Peter's Basilica in Rome.These monuments exerted great influence in the 16th to 18th centuries by spreading forms of Manueline, Mannerist and Baroque art and architecture throughout the countries of Asia where Catholic missions were established. In doing so, they eminently illustrated the work of missionaries in Asia, says the UNESCO website.In their letter to Aggarwal, the group 'Citizens for Democracy Goa' red-flagged 'unstopped constructions near the heritage monuments in violation of heritage laws'. The letter cited a huge bungalow by a Mumbai-based politician within the very precinct of the World Heritage Site, in close proximity to the office of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), as the 'most egregious and visible example of this disregard'advertisement'Despite numerous protests by heritage activists, this illegal construction continues to stand as a defiant challenge to all agencies mandated to preserve and protect this significant World Heritage Site. This constitutes a major heritage violation occurring under the direct purview of the ASI. Repeated appeals have regrettably failed to halt this egregious violation. This bungalow, situated next to the World Heritage Church of St. Cajetan, within the vicinity of the Adilshahi Palace gate and the Kadamba-era temple gate, and abutting the Viceroy's Arch, should have been demolished, but for the ASI's laxity and the local government's apathy,' the letter pointed out.The group stated that by the ASI's own admission, there were over 70 structures that are reportedly illegal but still standing. 'Proliferation of diverse constructions is putting pressure of higher density of human settlement in Old Goa, resulting in issues such as rampant filling of low-lying areas, hill cutting, wanton littering, unregulated solid waste generation and its ineffective management,' the letter said. The proposed garbage treatment plant on the Kadamba plateau of Old Goa to treat the waste generated by Panaji has also faced strong opposition from the local community.advertisementThe letter has recommended a multi-pronged approach to protect the site. This includes coordination between Goa's Department of Archaeology and the ASI to formulate a protection policy. 'The Centre should impress upon the state government to prioritise the swift formulation and implementation of a comprehensive Heritage Masterplan specifically for Old Goa. This plan should clearly demarcate all protected zones, including an adequately sized buffer zone that respects the site's heritage and visual integrity. The masterplan must include specific and detailed guidelines for the preservation and sensitive restoration of all pre-Portuguese historical sites, integrating principles of sustainable tourism to ensure that tourism activities support, rather than detract, from the site's conservation,' it urged.A thorough survey of all existing structures located within the World Heritage Site and its designated buffer zone must be conducted to definitively identify all illegal constructions and encroachments, the letter said.'The time for decisive action is now, before the irreversible impacts of unchecked development further erode the 'Outstanding Universal Value' that makes Old Goa a treasure for all humanity,' the group urged.Subscribe to India Today Magazine
advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
60k cops to be inducted in presence of Amit Shah
Lucknow: More than 60,000 newly recruited constables of the Uttar Pradesh Police are likely to receive their appointment letters in the presence of Union home minister Amit Shah in Lucknow on June 15. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The grand ceremony will mark the completion of the largest single police recruitment drive ever undertaken by any state police in the country, said a senior officer at the DGP headquarters. The ceremony will be held at Sector 18 in Vrindavan Yojna, a sprawling venue where Defence Expo was held in 2020. Security arrangements are being reviewed by intelligence and law enforcement agencies, with special attention to nearby buildings and entry points. Senior UP Police officials are supervising the arrangements. A total of 60,244 constables, including 12,048 women recruits, will receive the appointment letters at the event. The recruitment process was started in Dec 2023. The Uttar Pradesh Police Recruitment and Promotion Board (UPPRPB) received more than 48 lakh applications for 60,000 posts. Meanwhile, the recruitment drive for 4,543 sub-inspector (SI) and equivalent posts will begin next week. Sources in the department said these posts will include 4,242 SIs (civil police), 135 platoon commanders (PAC), 60 platoon commanders (special forces), and 106 female platoon commanders (Badaun, Lucknow & Gorakhpur). The upcoming notification will invite candidates from all categories and backgrounds, with relaxed age criteria approved recently by the state cabinet. Under the Uttar Pradesh Public Service (Relaxation of Age Limit for Recruitment) Rules, 1992, the govt has granted a one-time relaxation of three years in the upper age limit for all candidates applying for SI posts for the 2020–2025 recruitment cycle. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now As a result, a general category candidate who was previously ineligible at 28 years can now apply until the age of 31. This move is expected to benefit nearly five lakh aspirants, many of whom became overage due to recruitment delays in previous years. Officials said the age relaxation will substantially increase the number of applicants and make the recruitment drive more inclusive. The advertisement, expected next week, will detail the eligibility criteria, application process, and selection stages, which will include a written test, physical fitness assessment, and document verification.
Time of India
22 minutes ago
- Time of India
Arunachal steps up crackdown on illegal B'deshi immigrants
Itanagar: The Arunachal Pradesh govt has launched a statewide crackdown to detect and deport illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, an official said on Thursday. Acting on directives issued by the Union ministry of home affairs (MHA), the state has instructed all districts to immediately constitute district task forces (DTFs) to identify undocumented immigrants and ensure strict enforcement of Inner Line Permit (ILP) provisions. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The decision was taken at a high-level meeting chaired by advisor to home minister Mutchu Mithi and DGP Anand Mohan on Wednesday. The meeting was attended by senior police officers, including inspector generals and superintendents of police. "Statewide crackdown on illegal Bangladeshi immigrants and ILP violations. A district task force will be immediately constituted in every district to carry out detection of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants and ensure strict enforcement of the Inner Line Permit regime," Mithi said. The MHA had last month issued a 30-day deadline for all states and Union Territories to verify the identity and documentation of individuals suspected to be illegal immigrants from Bangladesh and Myanmar. Those failing to produce valid documents would be liable for deportation, officials said. It also instructed states to invoke their statutory powers to detect, detain and deport illegal immigrants. PTI
NDTV
40 minutes ago
- NDTV
'Understanding Among Parties After Pahalgam Attack Should Continue': RSS Chief
Nagpur: RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat on Thursday said the mutual understanding displayed by the political class following the Pahalgam terror attack and action taken by India later should continue and become a permanent feature. After the April 22 massacre of tourists in Pahalgam, people were angry and wanted the culprits to be punished and the action followed, he said in an indirect reference to Operation Sindoor which saw Indian armed forces target terror hubs in Pakistan and PoK, and subsequent bombing of airbases in the neighbouring country in retaliatory strikes. The society also gave a message of unity, Mr Bhagwat noted, addressing the concluding event of the Karyakarta Vikas Varg for Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers in Nagpur. Coming out strongly against religious conversion using force and pressure, the RSS leader said, "Conversion is violence. We are not against it when done by choice. But luring, forcing and pressurising is something we are against. By telling people that their ancestors were wrong, it is an insult of them. We are against such practices." "We are with you (in fight against conversion),' Mr Bhagwat said, referring to tribal leader and former Union minister Arvind Netam, who was the chief guest at the event. Once again referring to the May 7-10 India-Pakistan military conflict, he emphasised everyone saw the grit of the country's decision-makers in the action taken after the Pahalgam terror attack. "Action was taken after the heinous terror attack in Pahalgam. The valour of our Army shone once again in it. The firmness of the administration was also seen. The political class also showed mutual understanding. The society gave the message of unity. This should continue and become a permanent feature," he averred. India should be self-dependent in matters of security, the RSS chief insisted. Without naming Pakistan, Mr Bhagwat said, "Those who can't win a direct fight with India want to bleed our country by the policy of a thousand cuts and waging a proxy war." During World War II, Hitler bombarded London for nearly a month, expecting Britain to surrender. In response, Prime Minister Winston Churchill addressed the nation and later told Parliament the British would fight on the "seas and on the beaches". Referring to this episode, Mr Bhagwat remarked that Churchill had said society was the true lion and he merely roared on its behalf. The RSS leader observed that one person's gain can sometimes mean another's loss, and a lack of understanding between individuals may lead to dissatisfaction. In the national interest, no group or class should come into conflict with another. Acting impulsively, engaging in unnecessary arguments, or taking the law into one's own hands was not in the country's interest, he stressed. He reflected on the time when India was not independent, saying (British) rulers then encouraged divisions and supported disruptive elements, forcing ordinary people to take up the fight. Today, however, he said, the government functions under the Constitution. Mr Bhagwat warned against the use of abusive language and overreactions, stating some individuals deliver provocative speeches for personal gain. "Our roots lie in unity, not in division," he said, adding that while people may speak different languages and follow different customs, unity stands above all differences. Mr Bhagwat argued that the idea of ethnic differences among Indians was a misconception fostered by British colonial rule. Tribal leader Netam, who served in the cabinets of former prime ministers Indira Gandhi and PV Narasimha Rao, was the chief guest at the concluding ceremony of the RSS volunteer training camp. The 25-day training camp, Karyakarta Vikas Varg Dwitiya, in which 840 volunteers from across the country participated, began on May 12 at Dr Hedgewar Smriti Mandir located in Reshimbag area of Nagpur. Mr Netam, who hails from Chhattisgarh, said no state government has so far taken the issue of religious conversions seriously. "I think RSS is the only institution which can help us in this area," he said. The RSS should pressure the central government to come out with an action plan after Maoism ends to ensure the menace does not raise its head again, the former Congress minister stated. Mr Netam said no government implemented the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 and added the central government is mum and even helping industrialists. The PESA Act aims to ensure self-governance in tribal areas through Gram Sabhas, empowering them to manage resources and make decisions related to their communities.
