Mum who blames mesh implant for crippling pain blasts Government for continued use
Roseanna Clarkin is one of a number of women who blame mesh products for life-changing complications.
Roseanna Clarkin; Surgical Mesh campaigner from Clydebank.
A mum who blames a controversial plastic implant for her crippling pain has blasted the Scottish Government for continuing to use the products.
Roseanna Clarkin is one of a number of women who blame mesh products for life-changing complications.
In her case, it was used to treat an umbilical hernia in 2015.
Roseanna Clarkin said: 'Vaginal mesh is banned but mesh is still used for other procedures. Ultimately it's the same mesh. There has to be an alternative.'
Three years later, while the Scottish Government banned the use of trans vaginal mesh products, surgical mesh is still used for other procedures.
Studies suggest five to 20 per cent of hernia operations result in mesh failure. A study in the British Medical Journal, said the rate could be 12 to 30 per cent.
Campaigners have been calling for an independent review and patients including Roseanna want a ban on all surgical mesh and fixation devices.
Roseanna, 41, of Clydebank, said: 'Vaginal mesh is banned but mesh is still used for other procedures. Ultimately, it's the same mesh that can cause the same problems.'
Health Secretary Humza Yousaf has refused campaigners' call for an independent review into the use of mesh in all surgical procedures
In 2023, then First Minister Humza Yousaf said to suspend the use of hernia mesh would leave some people with limited or no treatment options.
Last year, Roseanna was diagnosed with a rectocele – a prolapse of the wall between the rectum and vagina – but was shocked doctors wanted to use mesh.
She said: 'I was outraged. Mesh has caused devastating effects to my life and body. There was no way I was having any more.' From the late 90s to 2018, women in Scotland were treated with polypropylene mesh implants for stress urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse.
For some, it caused pain and life-changing side-effects. Affected patients can travel to England and the US for mesh removal surgery, funded by NHS Scotland and Scottish Government.
Campaign group Sling the Mesh accused governments of 'dragging their feet' five years after the review. The group's Kath Sansom said: 'Traditional surgical repairs without mesh, and high-quality pelvic floor physiotherapy, should always be the first line of treatment for bladder leaks, prolapse and some bowel conditions.'
The Scottish Government said it takes the concerns raised seriously and commissioned two reviews of hernia mesh use.
Article continues below
It added the reviews 'recommended the continued availability of surgical mesh as an option for repair of hernias, while stressing the importance of informed consent and the availability of alternative treatments where appropriate'.
Don't miss the latest news from around Scotland and beyond - Sign up to our daily newsletter here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
an hour ago
- ITV News
Jersey women forced to travel for abortion face no financial help unless it is 'medically necessary'
Campaigners have hit out at Jersey's government as it was revealed that while proposed changes to the island's abortion law will allow longer for terminations, women will have to travel off-island for treatment after 13 weeks and pay for it themselves unless it is deemed "medically necessary". Those seeking an abortion from 13 weeks to 21 weeks and six days, which is the suggested new limit for most terminations, would have to foot the bill for the procedure, as well as travel to the UK and accommodation. The draft law states this is because abortions can only be performed in Jersey before 13 weeks due to "workforce constraints and the need to provide safe services" - there is an exception for urgent medical situations. Rachael Clarke from the UK's leading abortion care charity, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, says Jersey lags behind other British Islands. She explains: "Unfortunately, Jersey seems to have made this decision that they don't want to help those women, even though their abortions would be legal if there were someone on island who could provide them. "That's an incredibly different position from what's in place in Guernsey and the Isle of Man, where if a woman needs an abortion that she can't access locally, she's funded to travel to England. "That's exactly what happens with all other forms of healthcare ... so the decision not to fund abortions seems to be specific and only because women's choices are being judged. "What we really need is government to step up and take responsibility." Ms Clarke says aspects of the proposed changes, such as legislating for women to access abortions later, are positive, but they only work if they can be put into practice. She adds: "In essence, it's completely pointless to change the law for women if you're not going to enable them to access the services that the law allows. "We're talking about such a small number but for those women, the impact on their lives of having to continue a pregnancy and raise a child that they really would have preferred not to is incredibly difficult." Ms Clarke says private abortions can cost up to £1,500 in the UK, without factoring in travel and accommodation, as the Government has confirmed that Jersey residents are not entitled to free NHS terminations. Abortions under 13 weeks can be carried out in Jersey and cost £185 for women who have lived in the island for at least six months. Some can also receive this on-island treatment for free, such as those on income support, aged under 18, in full-time education, or pregnant as a result of rape or incest. However, these groups are not covered after 13 weeks and would face the same travel and treatment fees, unless there is a medical exemption. In response to concerns over the draft law, Deputy Andy Howell, Jersey's Assistant Health Minister, says: "I'm really sorry but we just can't pay for everything, but we want people to know that if you go early then it's much less traumatic and we've got a really lovely councillor who can help you and is there at all times. "Try to go early, try to recognise that you might be pregnant early and then seek help." Deputy Howell adds: "I understand the concerns some islanders may have, however, very few Jersey residents have non-medically necessary terminations in the UK. "In 2022, the last available data, fewer than five Jersey residents had terminations in the UK, which includes women having medically necessary terminations. "Women are, instead, opting for earlier stage terminations in Jersey, which are lower risk than later-stage terminations, so our priority is to support access to those terminations." The proposition is expected to be brought to the States for debate by the end of the year.
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Glasgow restaurant filmed in new Marvel Spider-Man for sale
Jonathan Clough, of Smith and Clough Business Associates, said: 'I popped out of the office for a wander with my son to check out some of the filming for the new Spider-Man movie which is currently taking place on Bothwell Street in Glasgow city centre. 'It did not disappoint and it was incredible to see how they have transformed the street to look like New York city.' Filming in Glasgow city centre, passing the premises. (Image: Jonathan Clough) He added: 'What is even more exciting is that we have just been instructed to market the former Wolf Italian Street Food unit on Bothwell Street which is one of the frontages they have chosen not to change and will be featured in the Hollywood blockbuster. They are also using the inside for filming. READ MORE: 'If you want more information on this great coffee shop, deli or restaurant opportunity which will be part of Hollywood history then please get in touch or do what Spider-Man would do and get more info on the web.' The exterior. (Image: Smith & Clough Business Associates) The agent also said: 'There are a number of substantial office developments in the immediate vicinity and surrounding occupiers include the likes of JP Morgan, Esure, BT and NFU Mutual to name a few. The view in Glasgow. (Image: Jonathan Clough) 'There are also a number of hotels, bars and restaurants in close proximity ensuring the area is a hive of activity throughout the day and evening.' Offers over £40,000 are invited for the leasehold. Scottish technology in world-first robotic heart surgery Technology developed within the NHS in Glasgow has been used to carry out the first robot-assisted heart valve replacements in clinical patients. Following proof-of-concept procedures on human cadavers last year, the CoreVista Robot Enabling Platform has been successfully used in a small series of operations known as robot-assisted transcervical AVR procedures in live patients at the Cleveland Clinic in the US. Carried out by Dr Marijan Koprivanac and his team, the transcervical approach is intended to minimise risks associated with conventional open heart surgery with patients experiencing less pain and a faster recovery. It allows the implantation of either sutureless or conventional sutured valves through a tiny incision in the neck. BUSINESS HQ MONTHLY 📈 Scottish firms report performance boost after staff takeover Scottish firms that have been taken over by their workers are reporting an additional production boost. Companies that have switched to employee ownership are citing ripple effect benefits that are bolstering performance.
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Scottish Labour take £200k in private healthcare-linked donations
Welcome to this week's Branch Office Updates! Subscribe for free using the linked banner above. SCOTTISH Labour have been panned over research which finds its MPs have received nearly £200,000 from donors linked to private healthcare. The SNP have said that leader Anas Sarwar must 'come clean'. Earlier this year, EveryDoctor revealed that MPs had bagged more than £2.7m in donations from people with links to the private healthcare sector. READ MORE: Australian influencers 'damage' historic Jacobite site, as investigation launches Among those receiving the most donations was Health Secretary Wes Streeting who has pocketed a whopping £224,575. The organisation's research, however, also found that half of all Scottish Labour MPs – including Scottish Secretary Ian Murray (below) and Minister Kirsty McNeill – have received donations from companies or individuals linked directly or indirectly with private healthcare, worth a total of £192,071. The largest donor to Scottish MPs is the Labour Together Ltd think tank. It is primarily funded by Martin Taylor, who founded the hedge fund Crake Asset Management, as well as Trevor Chinn, a senior adviser to the private equity firm CVC Capital Partners. CVC has investments in dozens of private healthcare companies in the UK, Europe and Asia, whilst Taylor's firm has held millions worth of shares in firms including United Health and Elevance Health. Several Scottish Labour MPs – Gregor Poynton, Melanie Ward, and Martin McCluskey – have also benefited from donations from Danny Luhde-Thompson, who is an advisor to investment firm Quadrature Capital, which has had extensive shareholding in private healthcare firms. READ MORE: Ian Blackford to give shock return in Kate Forbes seat 'careful consideration' The donations have been declared in the proper manner and there is no suggestion of wrongdoing. But SNP MSP Clare Haughey has told The National that these figures are 'alarming to everyone who is serious about protecting the NHS". 'The volume and amount of donations involved show just how much influence these shadowy think tanks and hedge funds have within the Labour Party,' she added. 'Even before coming to power, Labour's Health Secretary Wes Streeting said that he would 'hold the door wide open' to private investment in the NHS. It doesn't take a brain surgeon to see why when you discover who is bankrolling the Labour Party.' Haughey went on: 'Anas Sarwar previously tried to dismiss Labour Together Ltd as a group on the 'fringes' of the Labour Party. The fact that they have funded half of his MPs would suggest they are far from being on the fringes but are in fact at the very heart of Labour. 'Sarwar must come clean on Scottish Labour's position on private healthcare, and whether his prospective MSPs will be getting bankrolled by groups with links to private healthcare. 'Whilst Labour has many questions to answer, one thing is clear – only the SNP will protect the NHS and ensure that healthcare is provided based on medical need rather than the ability to pay." A Scottish Labour spokesperson said: "All donations are declared in line with Parliamentary and Ministerial rules. "While one in six Scots are abandoned by the SNP on NHS waiting lists, the Labour Party – who created the NHS – will always make sure it remains free at the point of need on our watch."
