Some Manitoba school divisions cancelling field trips to U.S. due to tension over gender issues
The Seven Oaks School Division in northwest Winnipeg is among the divisions changing their travel plans this year to prioritize values involving inclusion, equity and diversity.
Their decision follows an executive order by U.S. President Donald Trump that terminated a range of policies aimed at protecting 2SLGBTQ+ rights, fulfilling a campaign promise he described as " restoring biological truth." Trump says the U.S. will recognize only two sexes — male and female.
"That is definitely a consideration — that we pay attention to when there are executive orders to the point of only recognizing certain people and essentially cancelling others," Seven Oaks superintendent Tony Kreml told reporters at a news conference on Friday. "That can certainly provide for an unsafe situation both for a student and staff member."
Since making the decision to pause education-related trips south of the border, he says he's heard "comments of appreciation" from people regarding concerns for their safety, Kreml told reporters at West St. Paul School on Friday.
Kreml says he doesn't have specific details about the school field trip, but he said its cancellation won't have a significant impact. The unpredictable cost of travel was also a factor in the decision, ensuring opportunities for families are equitable, he says.
Kreml touts Winnipeg's local attractions including The Forks, saying students can learn so much by travelling within the province, which further contributes to supporting the economy.
The decision to cancel the trip was not meant to be adversarial, he says.
Troy Scott, assistant superintendent at Pembina Trails School Division, sent out an email on Friday to parents, legal guardians and staff, saying the division is pausing all student field trips to the U.S. for the remainder of the school year, effective immediately.
"This decision prioritizes student safety and reaffirms our commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion," Scott said.
Pembina Trails, which serves communities in southwest Winnipeg, says it will re-evaluate this decision at the start of the 2025-26 year.
Pausing any trips to the U.S. aligns with the division's commitment on anti-racism, diversity and creating an inclusive learning environment where all students feel supported and valued, Scott said.
Tracy Schmidt, minister for education and early childhood learning, told reporters she is encouraging school divisions across the province to follow suit and focus on learning opportunities involving travel excursions in their own backyard.
The Louis Riel School Division has not issued any specific guidance to schools in their division regarding travel to the U.S., superintendent Christian Michalik said in an email statement on Thursday.
Glenlawn Collegiate had a trip to Florida in January that was cancelled due to Hurricane Milton, Michalik said, but none of the schools within the division have scheduled trips to the U.S. during this school year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Ottawa Citizen
a day ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Wilczynski: For a gay Jew, Capital Pride prompts hope and anxiety
For the first time in almost 40 years, I am anxious about participating in a celebration of Pride. Article content While there has been significant progress in addressing the Jewish community's concern stemming from last year's conflict with Capital Pride, the winds of exclusion are blowing strongly through many queer and progressive spaces. Article content Article content As a gay man and a Jew, I was disappointed when Capital Pride 2024 took a biased stance on the Israel-Hamas War and ignored the safety concerns of Ottawa's Jewish community. The effect of Capital Pride's decision was that members of the Ottawa Jewish community, including Jewish members of the 2SLGBTQ+ community, felt unsafe and unwelcome. Article content Article content The resulting debate not only compounded Jewish sense of exclusion. It also damaged Capital Pride's reputation as an inclusive space for all. Boycotts of Capital Pride by many institutions and organizations harmed the pursuit of equality rights for 2SLGBTQ+ persons. Article content Over the past few months, much work has been done to bring communities together. We who live in the intersectional space between the queer and Jewish communities are hopeful and grateful that we can rebuild trust and sense of belonging that are an essential to Capital Pride. Article content Pride is a protest. It is a protest about the lack of human rights for sexual and gender minorities. There is much to protest. Backsliding of our rights in Hungary and Russia are cause for deep concern. Legislation further criminalizing and targeting the LGBTQ+ community in Uganda and other parts of Africa harms our community. The relentless attacks on transgender rights and the threats to the recently won right to marriage in the United States must be confronted by 2SLGBTQ+ persons around the world. Article content Article content This fight unites all of us. This fight is urgent. It is a struggle for the rights of sexual and gender minorities often lost in a complex world where the universality of human rights and human dignity is under threat. Article content Article content This is why over most of my adult life, I participated in Pride and other 2SLGBTQ+ protests in Ottawa, Montreal, Vancouver, New York, Washington, Oslo, and Tel Aviv. Yet the past few weeks have reinforced how precarious my presence as a gay Jew is in these spaces. Article content Fierte Montreal, with which I worked for the past two years, first banned and then allowed the participation of Jewish groups. Jewish organizations did participate in Montreal's Pride parade, but not without incident. Noxious substances were thrown at the Jewish contingent. Article content The sense of vulnerability in advance of Capital Pride's parade on Sunday is real. The fight over an Israeli film to be shown at TIFF about the attacks of Oct. 7 faced the same back and forth that reinforced the precariousness of Jewish experience in progressive spaces.
CBC
07-08-2025
- CBC
U.S. air force to deny retirement benefits to transgender service members being forced out
The U.S. air force said Thursday it would deny all transgender service members who have served between 15 and 18 years the option to retire early, and would instead force them out without retirement benefits. The move means that transgender service members — who are already facing expulsion under Trump administration policy — will now be faced with the choice of either taking a lump-sum separation payment offered to junior troops or be removed from the service. An air force spokesperson told The Associated Press that "although service members with 15 to 18 years of honourable service were permitted to apply for an exception to policy, none of the exceptions to policy were approved." About a dozen service members had been "prematurely notified" that they would be able to retire before that decision was reversed, according to the spokesperson who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal air force policy. All transgender members of the air force are being separated from the service under the Trump administration's policies. U.S. President Donald Trump has issued a number of executive orders targeting the rights of the transgender community and dismantling anti-discrimination rules since his election, sparking widespread condemnation and fear among 2SLGBTQ+ groups. A Monday memo announcing the new policy, which was reviewed by The Associated Press, said that the choice to deny retirement benefits was made "after careful consideration of the individual applications." "It's devastating," said Shannon Minter of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights. "This is just a betrayal of a direct commitment made to these service members." The move comes after the Pentagon was given permission in early May by the Supreme Court to move forward with a ban on all transgender troops serving in the military. Days later, Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth announced a policy that would offer currently openly serving transgender troops the option to either volunteer to leave and take a large, one-time separation payout or be involuntarily separated at a later date. A Pentagon official told reporters in May that they viewed the policy as treating "anyone impacted by it with dignity and respect." However, in late July, transgender troops told that they were finding the entire separation process, which has included reverting their service records back to their birth gender, "dehumanizing" or "open cruelty." Minter said the financial impact on transgender service members would be severe, costing them hundreds of thousands of dollars over their lifetimes in denied benefits due to the Trump administration's policy.
CBC
05-08-2025
- CBC
Montreal Pride reinstates Jewish groups recently barred from parade
Two Jewish 2SLGBTQ+ groups recently barred from marching in Montreal's Pride parade have been reinstated. Fierté Montréal, the organization that manages Montreal's Pride festival, said in a statement posted to its website on Tuesday that it was reaffirming its invitation to all communities to take part in the celebrations. "Fierté Montréal wishes for every community, regardless of religious affiliation, to feel welcome at its events and to be able to participate in a safe and inclusive environment," the statement said. "In this spirit, the organization extends its apologies to the Jewish communities and especially to Jewish members of the 2SLGBTQIA+ community." The reinstatement comes one day after the chair of Fierté Montréal's board of directors resigned — citing personal reasons — and less than a week after the organization issued a statement both condemning "the ongoing genocide in Gaza" and saying it had denied participation in the parade to "organizations spreading hateful discourse." The statement had targeted both the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA) and Gaa'va, which calls itself "Canada's oldest and largest Jewish LGBTQ+ group." Last week, a CIJA representative said the groups had been kicked out of Pride for statements published in a Jewish community news outlet. The comments described protesters who interrupted last year's parade as "pro-Hamas" and people seeking to bar Zionists from the parade as "pro-terror." 'We don't want to condemn the whole community' In an interview with CBC, Marlot Marleau, the new head of the board of directors for Fierté Montréal, said the organization had acted to ban Gaa'va and CIJA after receiving complaints about hateful discourse. But he said they went back on their decision because they didn't want to make the Jewish community feel rejected. "The statements were deemed unacceptable, [but] we don't want to condemn the whole community because of unacceptable statements from a singular individual," Marleau said in an interview with CBC. Fierté Montréal had been facing a barrage of criticism for failing to take a stance on the situation in Gaza and at least one performer had said she would not perform at the festival due to the inclusion of a "Zionist LGBTQ+ group." But Fierté Montréal's move to bar Gaa'va and CIJA from the parade also drew condemnation. Five MPs penned an open letter to Fierté Montréal calling on the organization to reverse its decision. "This is entirely unacceptable and a devastating message to Montreal's Jewish community and, in particular, to Montreal Jews who belong to the 2LBGTQ+ community," said the letter, which was shared on X by Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather. Group calls initial ban 'a PR stunt' In a statement, CIJA said Tuesday that it had discussions with the "new chair of the board of Fierté Montréal," Marlot Marleau, who is taking over from the previous chair, Bernard Truong, who resigned on Monday. Following those discussions, CIJA said it welcomed the decision to reinstate both CIJA and Gaa'va in the parade. "The organization issued an apology to Jewish 2SLGBTQIA+ individuals in Quebec and the broader Jewish community for a decision that was felt as a message of rejection. Following constructive dialogue, we accepted their apology," the CIJA statement said. Yara Coussa, a board member with Helem Montréal, a group that advocates for Arabic-speaking LGBTQ+ people in Montreal, said Fierté Montréal's reinstatement of Gaa'va and CIJA showed that the organization's position was never genuine. "Their response just shows that their actions were never about caring for the community, but it was just a PR stunt to try to save face," she said. Helem Montréal is part of a coalition of 2SLGBTQ+ groups that cut ties with Fierté Montréal this year, saying the organization no longer represents them. Gaa'va and CIJA weren't the only groups barred from the Pride parade last week. The Iranian Montreal Rainbow Alliance (IMRA) was also excluded. Marleau did not say why, but said the organization was open to a dialogue with that group as well.
