Court paves way for Trump to yank billions of dollars worth of foreign aid
The three-judge panel – which includes judges appointed by Trump and George H.W. Bush — overturned a district court's injunction that ordered the administration to fork over money for food, medicine and other aid that the president blocked on his first day in office.
Aid groups that sued the administration to unfreeze foreign assistance did not have standing to bring the case, and 'the district court erred in granting that relief because the grantees lack a cause of action to press their claims,' judges wrote.
The court's only Democrat-appointed judge on the panel accused the court of supporting the president's 'unlawful behavior.'
'At bottom, the court's acquiescence in and facilitation of the Executive's unlawful behavior derails the 'carefully crafted system of checked and balanced power' that serves as the 'greatest security against tyranny — the accumulation of excessive authority in a single branch,'' wrote Judge Florence Y. Pan, who was appointed by Joe Biden.
The administration 'immediately suspended and subsequently terminated thousands of foreign-aid grants, with catastrophic consequences for the grantees and the people that they serve,' Pan wrote.
Plaintiffs in the case will now ask for the full 15-member appeals court panel to review the case, which could then land at the Supreme Court.
'Today's decision is a significant setback for the rule of law and risks further erosion of basic separation of powers principles,' Public Citizen Litigation Group attorney Lauren Bateman said in a statement. 'In the meantime, countless people will suffer disease, starvation and death.'
A recent study in The Lancet estimated Trump's cuts could contribute to the deaths of 14 million million people by 2030, including as many as 5 million children under the age of 5.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
a minute ago
- Times
Trump-Putin meeting summary: four key moments from press conference
After private talks lasting almost three hours, President Putin and President Trump's press conference at the Elmendorf airbase in Alaska was uncharacteristically brief. Trump has almost-daily exchanges with journalists in the full glare of the cameras. Putin has been known to speak to the media for more than four and a half hours while hosting his annual marathon phone-ins. But in Alaska, the two leaders refused to accept questions from journalists and they made a prompt exit after only 12 minutes. Putin stuck closely to his scripted comments while Trump made vague remarks about 'extremely productive talks'. Putin repeated his insistence that the war in Ukraine would only end when the 'root causes' of the conflict were addressed.
Telegraph
a minute ago
- Telegraph
‘What the f--- was that?' My nine hours at Trump's bewildering summit
After travelling 2,000 miles, enduring a three-hour security screening and arguing over seating arrangements with the Russian media, expectations were high for the meeting between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. The early signs were positive – a warm handshake, a ride along in 'The Beast' and the claim by Russia that talks could last 'six or seven hours'. But that feeling came to a screeching halt inside the press tent at the Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage, when a press conference was called just three hours in – and it emerged that the wider bilateral talks had been scrapped. The two leaders appeared on stage for just 12 minutes. There was no ceasefire and they did not take a single question. 'What the f--- was that?' one American journalist exclaimed. 'Is that all?' Indeed, it was. The first surprise of Mr Trump and Putin's post-summit press conference was that the Russian leader was the first to speak. After the two men had taken their place behind their respective podiums, almost the entire room had their eyes fixed on Mr Trump, assuming that the US host would lead the conversation. So when Putin first opened his mouth, you could almost hear the sounds of heads whipping towards the Russian leader. Mr Trump eventually followed suit, and for the first time in his second term, spoke very briefly. Twelve minutes later, it was all over. The press pack, who had flown more than 2,000 miles to the most remote state capital in America in the hopes of witnessing history, were left shouting into the abyss. Colleagues looked around in bewilderment. Almost immediately, chatter between journalists turned from astonishment to frustration, as we realised that the pair had spoken for a twentieth of the painstaking time that it took for us to each be individually screened by the Secret Service that morning. In the few days before the highly-anticipated summit, we had scrambled to secure hire cars and accommodation in Anchorage, which turned out to be as scarce as details of what the two leaders agreed in their talks. Space in Anchorage was precious. With a handful of hotels already bursting with anglers capitalising on the peak salmon season, there was no room at the inn. Some of the Russian delegation were relegated to dorms normally reserved for university students. We also faced accommodation woes. But my colleague, Dom Nicholls, managed to secure us a 26-foot-long Winnebago, affectionately nicknamed the 'Tel Force One', which became an office, recording studio and our sleeping quarters. Some were not so lucky. Angry members of the Russian press pack shared pictures of military camp cots erected on bare hardwood gym floors, prompting taunts about the state of American hospitality. Frustrations were compounded when, upon arriving at the media tents, our Russian counterparts found that their mobile data roaming did not work. In the end, they were able to connect to the special WiFi generously provided by the US Air Force. Security delays prompted outcry from some American journalists who were concerned that Russian reporters would get better seats at the briefing. 'Can we make sure Americans are seated before the Russians?' one disgruntled journalist asked. 'This is America, after all,' another added. The two media camps were being kept apart on separate buses. In the press tent, it was a similar scene. With Russian media lodged on one side, cables hidden under blue and yellow rubber covers acted as a de facto border. A smoking area beside a handful of portable toilets appeared to be exclusively used by chain-smoking Russians. But even they appeared bewildered by the underwhelming press conference, immediately scampering from the press tent via the snack bar to their awaiting bus once it had concluded. After Mr Trump left the venue and the roar of Air Force One receded, we were left wondering how the most consequential diplomatic summit in recent memory could produce so little. Ukraine was shut out of the talks, with no invite for Volodymyr Zelensky, much to the chagrin of his European allies. Given what a non-event the whole thing turned out to be, they may be relieved that they were not required to make the journey.
The Guardian
8 minutes ago
- The Guardian
New Orleans mayor indicted for corruption over alleged bodyguard romance
The New Orleans mayor, LaToya Cantrell, was indicted by a federal grand jury Friday on corruption charges involving a purported romance with her former bodyguard. Cantrell, 53, thus became the first New Orleans mayor in the city's 307-year history to be charged by the US government with crimes while still in office. The indictment against Cantrell came after she drew scrutiny for an alleged affair with a now retired New Orleans police officer who had served as her bodyguard. Cantrell and the bodyguard, Jeffrey Vappie, allegedly plotted to foster their personal and romantic relationship while he was clocked in at work and being paid to provide her with protection. As Guardian reporting partner WWL Louisiana reported, Cantrell also allegedly arranged for Vappie to accompany her on at least 14 out-of-state trips, including to Scotland and the United Arab Emirates, claiming concerns about her safety that required protection. The trips cost the New Orleans' city government more than $70,000, not counting Cantrell's travel expenses, the charging documents filed on Friday said. The pair were also accused of using a city-owned apartment on the edge of New Orleans's Jackson Square, in its historic French Quarter neighborhood, to spend time together while Vappie was supposed to be on duty. Cantrell and Vappie, 52, are accused of then seeking to cover up the relationship by using an encrypted messaging program and deleting at least some of the 15,000 messages they exchanged, as well as lying to federal agents, grand jurors, colleagues and the public. When a New Orleans resident took photos of the Cantrell and Vappie dining together and drinking wine, the mayor filed a police report and temporarily obtained a restraining order, he said. Friday's charges also allege that Vappie 'attempted to persuade' New Orleans's interim police superintendent from December 2022 to October 2023, Michelle Woodfork, to 'make it right' and exonerate him as investigators circled. Cantrell then met with Woodfork – in front of Vappie – and told her she would not be offered the long-term superintendent's post, the indictment contended. Cantrell and Vappie are facing charges of wire fraud, obstruction of justice, conspiracy to commit both of those crimes, false statements and untrue declarations to a grand jury. Vappie had already been charged in July 2024 – shortly after he retired from the New Orleans police – with wire fraud and lying to FBI agents. The allegations against him and Cantrell called to mind the 2018 scandal that cost the Nashville mayor, Megan Barry, her job and centered on an affair with her bodyguard, Robert Forrest. Prosecutors who obtained the 2024 charges against Vappie alleged he researched that case online two years beforehand. Friday's charges against Cantrell also come after the September 2024 indictment of New Orleans businessman Randy Farrell. Farrell was charged with exchanging gifts with the mayor so she would allegedly fire a municipal employee who was investigating Farrell's building inspection company. Among the alleged gifts were tickets to a January 2019 New Orleans Saints football game, which was being played with a Super Bowl appearance on the line, a cellphone and lunch at an upscale Ruth's Chris Steak House in the city. Vappie and Farrell had pleaded not guilty to the charges previously filed against them. While the Donald Trump-led US justice department obtained the indictment against Cantrell about seven months into the Republican's second presidency, the federal investigation into the mayor began while Joe Biden – her fellow Democrat – was in his second full year in the Oval Office. The timing of Friday's indictment coincided with the grand jurors being scheduled to wind down their work. Such panels are typically in place for six months, but this one had been extended twice since first convening in February 2024. Cantrell's office issued a statement saying it would not comment on Friday's indictment until it had been reviewed by her defense attorney, Eddie Castaing. At a press briefing, the acting US attorney in New Orleans, Michael Simpson, accused Cantrell and Vappie of 'an incredible betrayal' of the public's trust in its own government. Cantrell, a native of Compton, California, had been a New Orleans city council member before winning election as its first-ever female mayor in November 2017. She succeeded Mitch Landrieu, who later worked for Biden's White House as its infrastructure czar. The Cantrell administration's first four-year term was partly marked by its guiding the city through the Covid-19 pandemic. And, in 2019, New Orleans registered a 47-year low of homicides. Cantrell was re-elected in November 2021, and her second term has been considerably turbulent. The federal investigation began with 2022 subpoenas issued regarding an image consultant she employed. Her husband – Jason, with whom she had a daughter – unexpectedly died in August 2023. And, as the AP noted, her civic profile receded as she locked herself into feuds with a hostile city council while alienating former confidantes as well as supporters. The city council responded by weakening the mayor's power through voter-approved changes to the municipal governing charter. Cantrell and her remaining allies maintain that, as a Black woman, she has been treated differently from her male predecessors. Simpson on Friday denied that race or gender factored into the investigation against Cantrell. Cantrell was term-limited from seeking another stint as mayor and is due to leave office in January. Several candidates have signed up to run to replace her in a primary election set for October. Only one other person who has served as New Orleans mayor has been charged with federal crimes: Ray Nagin. Nagin was the New Orleans mayor when the failure of federal levees there during Hurricane Katrina on 29 August 2005 destroyed the city and caused about 1,400 deaths. He was charged after leaving office and convicted in 2014 on charges of bribery, honest services wire fraud, money laundering, filing false tax returns and conspiracy. He then received a 10-year prison sentence. The Associated Press and WWL Louisiana contributed reporting
