Apple or Samsung? Hong Kong Consumer Council test shows deviations in smartwatches
Advertisement
The Consumer Council revealed on Thursday that three models out of 44 tested smartwatches and fitness trackers which were locally available had deviations of between 59 per cent and 74 per cent when counting steps taken by the user, which may be caused by including minor hand movements.
The heart rate measurement also varied, with two models showing deviations of over 11 per cent in most activities and as much as 21 per cent during cycling.
'The health and fitness data collected by smartwatches or fitness trackers was for estimation only and not necessarily accurate. Thus, they are suitable only for reference and not for medical use,' said Chung Chi-yung, the chairman of the council's Committee on Research and Testing.
The test, conducted by a European laboratory, included 38 smartwatch models with prices ranging from HK$199 to HK$9,799 (US$25 to US$1,255) and six fitness trackers priced from HK$139 to HK$498.
Advertisement
Three assessors wore a sample of each model during various activities, including resting, low-intensity walking, high-intensity running and cycling. The recorded data were then compared against those obtained from precision instruments used at the same time.
The test found that most models performed well in estimating walking and running steps, with deviations not exceeding 7 per cent. Among them, 25 smartwatch models had deviations of no more than 3 per cent, and were lower during running.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
8 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong records first case of Japanese encephalitis in 6 years
Hong Kong has recorded its first case of Japanese encephalitis in six years after a 49-year-old woman was diagnosed with the potentially fatal mosquito-borne disease upon returning from the Philippines. The Centre for Health Protection said on Wednesday that the imported case involved a foreign woman who was in a stable condition. She had travelled to the Philippines between July 21 and August 4, including visiting rural areas. 'Since the patient stayed in the Philippines during the incubation period, the centre considered that she was infected during travel, and the case was classified as an imported one,' it said. The centre said the woman suffered from a fever, headache and vomiting from August 10 and had sought medical help from the accident and emergency department of Prince of Wales Hospital in Sha Tin two days later. The Japanese encephalitis virus is principally transmitted by the bites of infected mosquitoes. Photo: Shutterstock. She was hospitalised last Thursday when she visited the hospital for a second time due to persistent symptoms.
South China Morning Post
12 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Knee surgery patients with ‘penicillin allergy' face higher infection risk: study
Patients labelled as allergic to penicillin – usually incorrectly – are three times more likely to develop a serious joint infection after knee surgery as they receive weaker antibiotics, a Hong Kong study has found, with researchers urging them to seek an evaluation especially before their operation. A team from the University of Hong Kong, which released the findings of the study on Wednesday, said that about 90 per cent of patients recorded as being allergic to the commonly used antibiotic were wrongly labelled. 'We found that if patients are wrongly labelled as allergic to penicillin, there can be a very serious consequence, which is infection,' said study co-leader Dr Steve Cheung Man-hong, an honorary clinical assistant professor in the department of orthopaedics and traumatology at HKU. 'There should be appropriate and timely evaluation on allergy labels.' The study analysed 4,730 patients who had undergone knee replacement surgery at Queen Mary Hospital in Pok Fu Lam between 1993 and 2001. Among them, 165 were labelled allergic to penicillin, the most common and first-line antibiotic used by doctors before joint surgery to prevent infections.
South China Morning Post
12 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Pricey dental care, lack of options on Sundays leave Hong Kong helpers desperate
Pricey dental care and a lack of services on Sundays have left Hong Kong's foreign domestic helpers desperate for affordable options, NGOs and unions have said, following the arrest of six women earlier this week for allegedly operating an illegal clinic. A lawmaker also said on Wednesday that one solution was for the city to adopt a similar policy to Singapore, where employers are required to buy comprehensive medical insurance, including dental care, for their helpers. Earlier this week, Hong Kong immigration authorities arrested six domestic helpers on suspicion of running an unlicensed dental clinic at a tenement flat in Sham Shui Po. The suspects, aged 34 to 60, were all from the Philippines. Two allegedly worked as unlicensed dentists, while the rest were believed to have acted as assistants and provided services such as scaling, orthodontic treatment and denture production. The Immigration Department said its investigations suggested that the suspects had learned dentistry from watching online videos, as none of them had any formal training or qualifications. Adequate medical coverage for the city's estimated 370,000 foreign domestic helpers has been a long-standing concern among organisations supporting such workers, with groups saying the arrests had shone a spotlight on the lack of accessible dental care options.
