Transgender debate is more complex than some realise
Scientists agree that the way transgender people develop is a combination of genetics, biology and upbringing, with upbringing the least significant of the three.
One example: With identical twins, if one turns out to be transgender, the chances of the other twin being likewise is 13 times higher than with non-identical twins.
That's genetics for you.
There is plenty more evidence; transgender people can no more help being transgender than others can help being gay.
I'm not advocating for specific rights transgender people should, or should not, have.
Merely pointing out that continuing to refer to them as "men" (which also puts trans men under the spotlight – what are they?), is demeaning and insulting, and only accurate as far as their sex is concerned.
It's completely and scientifically inaccurate in terms of their gender.
Iain Cope, Glasgow.
Letters: Trans people have a right to privacy that includes filling in census forms
Letters: Hiroshima was devastating opening shot in the Cold War
Letters: Health benefit from a Brexit deal
War… what is it good for?
EIGHTY years on from Hiroshima ('Hundreds gather to mark dropping of Hiroshima bomb', The Herald, August 7) I find myself reflecting not just on history, but on the continuity of weapons, fear, and the industries built around them.
I left Dumbarton in the early 1970s, at a time when protest against Faslane was strong and people believed there could be alternatives to war and weapons production on the Clyde.
There were serious efforts to imagine different economic futures for West Dunbartonshire and other struggling regions; futures based on peace, not militarism.
Now living in Adelaide, I see the same patterns repeating.
Once a hub for cars, whitegoods and domestic manufacturing, South Australia is now turning increasingly to weapons production, submarines, missiles, surveillance technologies, tied tightly to AUKUS and a declining United States.
The feared threat of the USSR has become the imagined threat of China. The Cold War turns warm, the actors change, and the cycle continues.
What doesn't change is the moral clarity of those who say: never again. I salute the church leaders and citizens who stood in witness at Faslane last weekend. In a world addicted to militarism, their quiet stand for peace speaks louder than ever.
Stewart Sweeney, Adelaide, South Australia.
Vanity, all is vanity
Modern cosmetic procedures, with their unavoidable fillers, are touted as being the road to glamour and the eradication of facial and physical flaws.
Such presentations attract ladies who always want to look their best, and who can blame them?
Down through the centuries women have made use of externally applied cosmetics, known in the game as war-paint, to present their best side.
However, the modern practice of injecting foreign substances into different areas of the body should be considered a step too far and banned outright. Even when governed by what would be considered practical regulation.
We have already seen too many examples of botched cosmetic procedures, involving fillers, at the hands of the poorly trained and virtually unskilled operators in that field.
There are horror stories aplenty about the life threatening and life changing outcomes for patients who have chosen to improve themselves in the UK, or have gone abroad to combine a holiday with cheaper offers of cosmetic procedures.
Consider yourselves lucky if you come out of such cosmetic encounters unscathed and without experiencing problems further down the line.
Surgical operations may be necessary to correct serious physical infirmities. But why subject yourself to filler procedures supposedly designed to make you more appealing, though with every likelihood that you become one of the unlucky ones condemned to suffer botched beauty treatments.
Learn to grow old gracefully and continue to apply the more recognised glamour products for nights out and daily appearances.
Denis Bruce, Bishopbriggs
Taxing situation
Ian McNair's letter 'Poor SNP decision' (Letters, August 7), is not quite factual.
Prescription charges were abolished in Scotland in 2011, and were not free to the majority before that date as Mr McNair claims.
Those who had long term conditions and were unable to work were not automatically exempt from charges, because if you did not have a condition covered by the exemption list (like a heart condition), then whether you got free prescriptions was dependant on the income of the household. In other words, it was a means tested benefit.
The SNP in Government recognised that this was a tax on the sick paid through the household income and abolished prescription charges.
Catriona C Clark, Falkirk.
Thistle do nicely
THANKS and congratulations to my old work colleague Ian W Thomson for speaking up in support of Milngavie (Letters, Aug 07).
Ian has been a staunch ambassador in these pages for his home town of Paisley for many years, and as a native of Maryhill, now in very happy retirement in Milngavie, I am grateful for his support.
Crail may be a very pleasant place, but for someone like me who likes to have easy access to trains and boats and planes, not to mention Partick Thistle, it does not tick many boxes.
Willie Maclean, Milngavie.
Shoot first
THE mention of American comic book superhero, Spiderman, swinging his way effortlessly through Glasgow city centre while the traffic down below is in permanent gridlock (Letters, Aug 7), makes me suspicious that Spidey (as his numerous fans label him) is not as heroic as he at first would seem.
If he truly was one of the 'good guys' surely he would provide us all with web-shooters, so we don't have to use cars or buses, and thus won't be left facing the daily road blockages caused by the Marvel movie clogging up the thoroughfares?
Mark Bailey, Paisley.
Some chips, with their old friend, a slice of battered fish.
Food for thought
I NOTE that eating three or more portions of French fries increases the risk of type 2 diabetes ('Eating fries over boiled potatoes significantly increases type 2 diabetes risk', The Herald, August 7).
Boiled, mashed or baked potatoes are innocent of this crime.
Are chips okay?
Alastair Clark, Stranraer.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
29 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
KEVIN MAGUIRE: 'Brexit was a giant con by plastic patriots – we need a plan to get back in EU'
The Mirror's Kevin Maguire argues the only way for Britain to return to its former prosperity is with a plan to return to the EU after Brexit proved to be a giant con that only leaves us poorer and weaker Brexit is a self-inflicted assault on the UK economy that will prove more than twice as expensive as abolishing slavery in the British Empire. Ending the shameful, terrible, cruel bondage of Africa's kidnapped men, women and children branded and clapped in irons to sweat on plantations in the West Indies and Americas was undoubtedly a noble cause. Disastrously wrenching our country out of the European Union was a cranky obsession of relatively few plastic patriots who hoodwinked a minor majority subsequently regretting the giant con. I'd also wager a disturbing number of Brextremist agitators, had they been shouting their mouths off at the end of the 18th and start of the 19th centuries, would've argued we couldn't afford to free slaves earning a fortune for their owners. READ MORE: Brexit is a 'complete disaster' and referendum 'should have been repeated' Mercifully the moral Britons won back then and on holiday in Spain I read in Adam Hochchild's ultimately inspiring Bury The Chains, the history of Britain's struggle to axe slavery, that scholars estimate stopping the trade then ceasing slavery itself cost the nation 1.8% of national income over more than half a century. The bill for Brexit will be 4% in less than half that time, calculates the Office for Budget Responsibility, and the extremists who masterminded the 2016 referendum heist are unable to claim any superiority. Highlighting any Brexit benefits is nigh on impossible, which is why the likes of Nigel Farage, Boris Johnson, Kemi Badenoch like to talk about almost anything else and shouldn't be trusted on issues such as migration. How many refugees, asylum seekers and migrants crossed the Channel in small boats before that referendum, a period when the UK could trigger the EU Dublin convention return arrangement? Zilch or virtually none. The 40,000 or so annually arriving in small boats is, in one of those startling coincidences, around the number of seized slaves yearly transported in British ships to their dreadful fate across the Atlantic. Before anybody, including Keir Starmer, shouts about trade deals, those between Labour and the EU, India and US are mere pennies for lost pound - as were Tory agreements with Australia and New Zealand. Even the 10% Trump tax on exports to the US isn't worth much more than his 15% tariff slapped on the EU when we trade twice as much with Europe as we do Donaldland. Regular exchange rate fluctuations can wipe it out easily. Deceiving Brexitremists pretended turning our backs on our EU neighbours was freedom. The freedom to be poorer and weaker? No thanks. Brexit remains the elephant in the room, deliberately ignored by the Prime Minister and others. If we want Britain to be more prosperous and stronger on the global stage then we need a plan to be back in the EU. At the moment, they're not even making the argument. More than one way to skin a Fat Cat Rachel Reeves is justified in stressing hers was a dreadful economic inheritance when more than three-quarters, £111billion - which is 77% - of this financial year's projected £143bn UK government borrowing covers interest on past debts - much of them Tory. Labour's Methodists want higher taxes on bookies and Marxists on banks (son of the manse and fairness champion Gordon Brown advocates both) to fund key public services and avoid breaking election promises to most workers and families. The Chancellor of the Exchequer could do much worse than dust off advice from the likes of out-of-the-box thinkers like Tax Justice UK and Patriotic Millionaires, including 10 reforms to raise £60billion by, among other changes, limiting pension tax relief handouts for higher earners to those of average earners and stop the South's richest paying less council tax than typical Northerners. Just because Reeves is against a wealth tax on the few with more than £10million doesn't mean she can't help ordinary folk. There's more than one way to skin a Fat Cat. Let's hear 'up the workers!' in classrooms The massacre of seven people during a seafarers' strike 200 years ago in Sunderland was unknown to me, and I'm from South Shields up the road. Bicentennial commemoration lead organiser David Scott was right: we should never let these events be 'lost from the history books' because we stand on the shoulders of giants - everyday men and women who challenged grave injustices. The seven murdered by soldiers on North Sands, now Sunderland Uni's St Peter's campus, were resisting pay cuts (Hello P&O Ferries in Dover) and the slain included Mary Wilson, 76, in a crowd of more than 100, including women and kids, on the beach. People's history, our history, is what establishment lackeys fear most in prioritising the teaching in schools of the supposed greatness of oppressive warlord kings and queens... Let's hear more 'up the workers!' in classrooms. Labour voters entitled to feel cheated Labour Deputy PM Angela Rayner's landmark Renters' Rights Bill coming into force next year bans, among other scams, landlords ending tenancies to sell properties then relisting them charging more, so now very ex-Housing Minister Rushamara Ali should've been sacked instead of allowed to resign. Because the greedy extra £700 a month grab by the rentier class shamed MP for Bethnal Green and Stepney once again overshadows the great things a UK Labour government is doing and Rayner, as well as Starmer, down to every Labour member and voter, is entitled to feel cheated. She wasn't a distraction, as the self-serving MP claims. I'm afraid she was guilty as charged of grotesque hypocrisy. Going up Deporting most convicted foreign criminals immediately and barring re-entry into the UK is penny-wise Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood acting tough when it costs an average £54,000 a year to lock 'em up with 12% of inmates in stuffed jails from abroad. Going down STUPID, nasty and inflammatory MP Rupert Lowe mistaking a charity rowing crew for migrants in a boat off the ex-Reformer's Great Yarmouth constituency in Norfolk confirmed these dangerous Hard Right reactionaries speak first, think later when spreading their poison. Speaker's Corner 'I have to say that I really have become a good friend, and David has become a good friend of mine.' Ugh! Pass the sick bag when fishy JD Vance slavering over David Lammy, and the UK Foreign Secretary drooling over the US Vice President, turns the stomach. Vance is as vile as Trump with added menace and brains. I hope Lammy's anti-tetanus jab is up to date.
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
George Galloway to stand as candidate at Scottish Parliament
Journalist Yvonne Ridley, a previous member of Alex Salmond's Alba Party, will also contest the Glasgow Pollok seat, which is currently held by former first minister Humza Yousaf. Speaking exclusively to The Herald following a party summit meeting in Scotland, Mr Galloway said his party plans to contest Glasgow Southside, the seat of Nicola Sturgeon, who is stepping down in May. He said: "We're going all out for it and we've got a lot of support." Asked if he was confident of winning, he said: "I wouldn't say confident." He added: "We're hopeful that we can win in it. We're going to put everything into trying to do so." He added his party had a growing movement in Glasgow, but had also had people come forward to ask if they can stand in seats in Inverness and Edinburgh. "But these seats in Glasgow are our current and number one target," he told The Herald, adding: "We're strong there." Read more: Mr Galloway founded the Workers Party of Britain in 2019, have previously led the now defunct Respect Party. He was a number of the Labour Party until 2003 and had served as an MP across five different constituencies, including Glasgow Hillhead between 1987 and 1997 and Glasgow Kelvin from 1997 to 2005. He then was elected in the Bethnal Green and Bow constituency in 2005 before losing losing in the 2010 general election. He returned for a three-year stint as MP for Bradford West, winning a by-election with Respect. The 70-year-old shocked in February 2024 with a by-election with in Rochdale, after he focused his campaign at Muslim voters. He lost the seat at the July 2024 general election. His Holyrood campaign will strongly focus on the crisis in Gaza, and the end to Israel's campaign. The veteran politician has also said he would back a second referendum on Scottish independence. He has been a long-standing opponent of Scottish independence and toured the country in the run up to the 2014 referendum to back to 'no' campaign. While he still does not back independence, he said Scots have a right to a referendum, with Mr Galloway pledging his party would run the election on a mandate for the plebiscite. This is not the first time he has contested a seat in the Scottish Parliament. He stood as a candidate for a regional list seat in Glasgow in 2011. He is a close ally of former first minister Alex Salmond, writing on X that his Workers Party would "shake things up". He wrote: "After the demise of Alex Salmond Scottish politics became a dull place. Lilliputian politicians whom nobody would cross the street for. But we are back and ready to shake things up."
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
The government needs to face up to reality
Martin Kettle's analysis of the dysfunctionality of government is spot-on, but incomplete (The biggest problem for Starmer and co: the machinery of government is broken and they can't fix it, 7 August). The core problem is our unwillingness to face up to reality, whether it is on tax, the need to invest in reform, the impact of Brexit, the pros and cons of legal migration, the real steps necessary to stem illegal migration at source, the implications of the new cold war, or the new world order under Donald Trump. By biting our tongue and trying to fudge the hard choices, successive governments have both confused and misled. Now is the time to treat the public as adults and trust them to recognise the need to get real. We need to rebuild the country to make it relevant for both today and the future, and that means moving beyond the Widow Twankey politics of saying a lot but doing nothing. Now is the time for genuine leadership and a promise to lead, not follow, the KellyPrime minister's official spokesperson 2001-07 Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
