Disabled woman took her own life after benefits wrongly cut off, coroner rules
Jodey Whiting, 42, who suffered from chronic pain and mental health issues, left notes for her family detailing her struggles to pay bills and afford food, a second inquest into her death heard.
The initial 2017 inquest did not consider the DWP's role in halting her benefits.
Ms Whiting's mother, Joy Dove, pursued a lengthy legal battle, ultimately reaching the Court of Appeal, to secure a second inquest.
Coroner Clare Bailey recorded a conclusion that Ms Whiting's death was suicide 'in the context of a deteriorating mental state, precipitated by the withdrawal of state benefits'.
An Independent Case Examiner report into the decision to remove Ms Whiting's benefits found that a number of mistakes had been made, that her payments should not have been withdrawn and it recommended that the DWP pay £10,000 to her family.
The court heard that Ms Whiting, a mother of nine, had a curvature of the spine and a brain cyst.
Extracts from notes found alongside prescription drugs in her flat were read in court.
Bridget Dolan KC, coroner's counsel, said: 'She wrote about not being able to pay her bills and having no food.
'In some she wrote about feeling breathless and having back pain and trying to pay her bills and being in debt.'
Another note stated: 'I have had enough.'
Ms Whiting's father Eric Whiting said in his tribute in court that his daughter 'always saw the fun side of life until her health issues started'.
Her mother agreed that Ms Whiting, who had six grandchildren, became increasingly housebound in the last years of her life.
She had a hospital stay in December 2016 after contracting pneumonia and that meant she missed a letter about her benefits, saying she needed to be medically assessed.
Ms Dove said she reassured her daughter that she would help, telling the inquest: 'I said, 'don't you worry, we will write in and we will explain how you have been in hospital and you are still convalescing'.'
But in January 2017, Ms Whiting was told she had missed the medical assessment and she was therefore judged to be fit to work.
As well as losing her Employment and Support Allowance, she would also lose housing and council tax benefits.
Ms Dove said when she saw her daughter, two days before her death, she was 'shaking and crying' and had threatened to kill herself.
Ms Dove said she was sure that the stress of losing her benefits was the trigger for her to decide to kill herself.
'I know my daughter and I know it was (that),' she told the inquest.
'It was the fact she couldn't find a job, the worry of paying bills and being pushed out after being so vulnerable all those years and years.'
Helga Swidenbank, a DWP director for disability services, said the organisation should have recognised that Ms Whiting had 'good cause' not to attend a health assessment, given her illnesses and mental health concerns.
The witness told the hearing: 'I was not in post at the time but those who I have spoken to are deeply regretful and sorry about what happened.
'There were a number of opportunities to have picked up concerns about Jodey and we are very sorry about that.'
Ms Swidenbank said the organisation was now more focused on people's vulnerabilities, although this remained a 'work in progress'.
She added: 'I understand that there is a culture shift from being process-driven to being much more compassionate.
'We are not there yet, we still have more work to do.'
The coroner cited evidence from psychiatrist Dr Trevor Turner who looked into the background of the case and who said Ms Whiting losing her benefits was the 'straw that broke the camel's back'.
Ms Bailey said: 'Dr Turner says, and I accept, that withdrawal of her benefits would have had an acute and pervasive effect on Jodey's mental state given her vulnerability and her emotional instability.'
The coroner added: 'Her actions were in the context of her benefits having been wrongly withdrawn by the DWP in circumstances where there had been five missed opportunities to avoid the significant errors.
'This had the effect of negatively impacting upon her mental health, and was the trigger to her taking a fatal overdose.'
The coroner praised the family's determined campaign to bring about justice, describing their 'perseverance, resilience and dignity.'
After the hearing, Ms Dove said: 'It has been an uphill battle trying to get answers and accountability, but I would never give up.
'I was determined to keep fighting for justice for Jodey.'
If you are experiencing feelings of distress, or are struggling to cope, you can speak to the Samaritans, in confidence, on 116 123 (UK and ROI), email jo@samaritans.org, or visit the Samaritans website to find details of your nearest branch.
If you are based in the USA, and you or someone you know needs mental health assistance right now, call or text 988, or visit 988lifeline.org to access online chat from the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. This is a free, confidential crisis hotline that is available to everyone 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
39 minutes ago
- Sky News
Electronic tags and 'tougher' unpaid work will reduce prison overcrowding, govt claims
Increases in the use of electronic tagging and "toughening up" unpaid work will help reduce prison overcrowding, according to the Ministry of Justice. The independent review of the current sentencing framework published in February called for an increased focus on utilising punishment outside of prison to reduce reoffending, freeing up capacity in jails. In response, Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood says she's determined to toughen community punishment - and make sure unpaid work truly pays back communities harmed by crime. The work done by offenders at the Nene Valley Railway near Peterborough is certainly tough. A group of low to medium-risk offenders have been sent to help re-lay track for the charity that runs the heritage railway, famous for being home to the engine that inspired Rev W Awdry's Thomas The Tank Engine. "We've been working with the probation service for over 20 years," says Michael Purcell, chair of the Nene Valley Railway. "Most of the work here is done by volunteers, and many of them are quite old. "So to have a team of younger workers that can come here and do the physical work under an experienced supervisor as a community service is massively helpful to us." Visually, there are echoes of the prison chain gangs of old. But the hard labour involved in this unpaid work is very much a part of contemporary plans to reduce reoffending. The Ministry of Justice says its analysis indicates that community-based sentences are more effective at reducing reoffending than custodial sentences lasting under a year. Supervising the work on the railway is Michael Barry, who believes the hard work gives the offenders on the programme a feeling of achievement. "You do notice that the men and women who come to work here don't tend to come back," Mr Berry explains. "I've been supervising groups here for 20 years, and many of the offenders who have worked here seem to have gone back to working. "So I do believe it helps people return to work after offending." The MoJ says being tough on crime means always having the prison capacity to incarcerate the most dangerous offenders. And it says that as well as "toughening up" unpaid work, probation funding will be increased by up to £700m (nearly 45%), allowing it to "substantially boost" the number of offenders on electronic monitoring. The MoJ has also said an increase in the use of curfews and exclusion zones, where offenders are prohibited from visiting certain areas, will help reduce prison overcrowding. A spokesperson added: "Offenders should be made to give back to the communities they've harmed. That is why we are toughening up unpaid work as a punishment so it can continue to act as a deterrent and make our streets safer.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
'Double standards': Police tell anti-Semitic abuse victim 'to just stop posting' online
An antisemitism advocate abused online and called an 'ugly Zionist' has accused the police of double standards and victim blaming after officers said she had made herself 'a target' by posting about Gaza. Heidi Bachram, from Brighton, East Sussex, was bombarded with offensive terms, including 'scumbag' and 'genocidal Zionist pig' from an X account that has since been suspended. She claimed that Sussex Police seemed reluctant to investigate who was behind the racist posts and advised her to simply stop posting about 'politically sensitive subjects'. But Ms Bachram said this was in stark contrast to a recent post written by a far-Right troll - that the force had proactively alerted her to and asked her to report. She was contacted by police after she shared an image of a hostage memorial in Brighton that had been smeared with faeces. One user wrote: 'None of these people died in Brighton. F*** off, Jew'. Over the last two years, Ms Bachram has established herself on X as a voice against antisemitism with more than 42,000 followers. She was spurred on to grow her online presence after close relatives of her Israeli-Jewish husband were murdered and taken hostage by Hamas terrorists on October 7, 2023. Antisemitism advocate Heidi Bachram has accused the police of double standards and victim blaming after officers said she had made herself 'a target' by posting about Gaza Ms Bachram was especially distressed by posts referencing the Hamas hostages, because of her family connection. Tsachi Idan - the first cousin of Heidi's husband, Adam Ma'anit - and his daughter Mayan, 18, were both murdered by Hamas terrorists She was contacted by police after she shared this image of a hostage memorial in Brighton that had been smeared with faeces - and a far-Right troll made a racist comment In the latest case of abuse, Ms Bachram said she was trolled by another account and the antisemitism was 'relentless'. The troll created offensive posts referencing stereotypes about Jewish men and women with large noses. Another showed a photograph of released hostage Mia Shem, who was kidnapped at the Nova festival, accompanied by the caption: 'Check out the beak on this one.' Ms Bachram was especially distressed by posts referencing the Hamas hostages, because of her family connection. Tsachi Idan - the first cousin of Heidi's husband, Adam Ma'anit - alongside his wife and two children were held at gunpoint at their home in Kibbutz Nahal Oz. Tsachi's daughter Mayan, 18, was murdered, while he was taken hostage into Gaza. In February, Tsachi's remains were among the four bodies of Israeli hostages handed over by Hamas. When Ms Bachram reported the abuse to a police officer she claimed that she was met by some resistance. She told The Telegraph: 'He said I was making myself a target.' Ms Bachram added that she believes the police had shown double standards in their treatment of the two offenders. She added: 'I feel like I've been victimised twice. Once by this cruel troll and secondly by the police.' Sussex Police said it was aware of concerns raised by Ms Bachram and confirmed the force had received a formal complaint.
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
'He never left Gaza in his mind': Israeli soldier died by suicide after being ordered to return
When your son is risking his life fighting in Gaza, you don't expect to hear news he's been killed on a rest period at home. Eliran Mizrahi had served 187 days as a reservist in Gaza since 8 October, before he died by suicide in June last year. His mother Jenny has turned Eliran's childhood bedroom into a shrine. The 40-year-old's combat vest hanging on the wall still has sand in it from Gaza. The cap he was wearing when he died, sits just above it on a shelf laden with memories of his life. Israel is seeing a wave of soldiers like Eliran taking their own lives - five died by suicide just last month. IDF (Israel Defence Forces) investigations have found it is what they have seen and done in Gaza that are the cause, according to reports by the Israeli public broadcaster. Eliran's mother told Sky News her son returned from Gaza a changed man and she fears there will be many more suicides among Israeli soldiers. "He never left Gaza in his mind," says Jenny. "When he came back he couldn't go back to work. He was a great father with a lot of patience. And he lost his patience with his children, with people. "He was very silent. He didn't sleep at night, he had nightmares. We didn't know anything about it. He didn't speak. Whenever we asked him he said everything is okay." Jenny describes Eliran as someone who was happy and friends with everyone. A father of four "with a big heart" and a big smile. But his experience of the war "injured his soul". Initially, he was deployed to clear bodies of people slaughtered by Hamas at the Nova Festival on 7 October and then deployed to Gaza a day later. Eliran was active on social media and shared videos of his time in Gaza. He was commander of a unit of D9 bulldozers that destroyed buildings and tunnel shafts. After his death, his D9 partner, Guy Zaken, told a parliamentary committee they were often shot at and they ran over hundreds of bodies. Yet they filmed themselves smiling and singing to send to their families. Eliran shared some of those videos on social media. Israel has levelled vast parts of Gaza. Eliran's actions were part of a systematic campaign the UN says has damaged or destroyed over 90% of Gaza's homes. Human rights experts warn this could be a war crime. Eliran was pulled out of Gaza after he sustained knee injuries in an RPG (rocket-propelled grenade) attack on his bulldozer. 'The bodies and the blood' He was later diagnosed with PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder) - we don't know the cause of his trauma but in the end he couldn't live with it. Two days before he was due to return to active duty, he took his own life. "What he saw over there in Gaza injured his soul. You see all the bodies over there and all the blood. It hurts your soul," says Eliran's mother. Israeli media is reporting at least 18 soldiers have taken their own lives so far this year. Thousands are suffering with PTSD. And more and more reservists are quietly refusing to turn up for duty. The IDF says supporting its service members is a top priority and it invests significant resources in doing so, including deploying mental health officers in all military units. Tuly Flint was one of those officers. A clinical social worker and expert in trauma therapy in his professional life, and a lieutenant colonel in the military reserves, he was deployed to offer psychological support to troops who served in Gaza. Last year, after treating many soldiers and becoming exposed to the extreme suffering of Gazans, Tuly came to the conclusion the war had no purpose and it was a crime against humanity. So he refused to continue to serve in the IDF. "At the beginning of the war what we usually saw was simple PTSD. People who talk about the horrors they saw in the first few weeks with the massacre of Hamas," says Tuly. "But since the second month of the war, people started talking about what takes place on the Palestinian side. "Even people that were not talking about Palestinians' rights, or anything like that, they started talking about the fact that they saw bodies of children, of old people, of women." 'You think, are they lying to me' I asked Tuly how soldiers feel hearing Benjamin Netanyahu 's narrative that there is no starvation in Gaza - that the images we see are a lie. The Israeli military bears witness to what is happening in Gaza in a way most of the world, including international journalists, still can't. "When you hear your government and your commanders telling things that are not true, you start thinking, are they lying to me also?" says Tuly. "When you hear your prime minister lying about things that you saw in Gaza, things that you did ... people talk about torching houses, people talk about a 'deadline' - not a metaphor - a deadline when people cross they will be killed no matter if they are children or women ... they see people starving and they also see the chaos." 2:20 After nearly two years of war, the human cost is weighing heavily on Israeli society. A majority of Israelis now believe that only a deal, not military pressure, will bring the remaining hostages home. And the humanitarian crisis unfolding just across the border is becoming a source of public unease. Former military and intelligence chiefs are also now against the war. The Commanders for Israel's Security group (CIS) has argued, in its professional judgement, "Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel" - and has written to Donald Trump asking him to compel Benjamin Netanyahu to end the war. Tuly Flint says there's an erosion of trust between soldiers and those leading them. "When you come back home and you hear so many people - former chiefs of staff, former heads of the security bodies of Israel - saying 'this war has no aim anymore' ... you say to yourself: 'I hear from former chiefs of staff that I'm killing hostages by waging war and my government is still sending me there?' "When you see the pictures that you've seen with your own eyes and your government says 'no this is a lie, no this is propaganda', this makes you distrust everyone. And when you distrust everyone, why would you ask for help?" The mental and moral burden on soldiers could be about to grow. Despite strong objections from the IDF's chief of staff, Israel is expanding military operations in Gaza with plans to take control of the entire territory. We understand that references to suicide in any context can be difficult for some people. We provide details of support available from the Samaritans where any such references are included. You can find these here: call Samaritans for help on 116 123 or email jo@ in the UK. In the US, call the Samaritans branch in your area or 1 (800) 273-TALK.
