logo
Greens leadership hopeful says 'soundbitey' nature of FMQs must end

Greens leadership hopeful says 'soundbitey' nature of FMQs must end

The National11-05-2025

The Green MSP, who launched her bid to become a co-leader on Friday, has called for more collaboration at Holyrood as a way of seeing off the rise of Reform UK, who according to a poll released last week could become the main opposition.
She insisted both the 'soundbitey' and 'formulaic' nature of sessions in the Parliament have led to people distrusting politicians and MSPs need to accept that to turn that around, they need to show they can work together amicably.
'There has been a reluctance in successive parliaments for politicians to show who they are as people. It's very soundbitey, it's very formulaic in some cases,' she told the Sunday National.
She went on: 'I think this has been one of those sessions where everybody hasn't necessarily always worked nicely together. For this final year of Parliament, finding our way through some of the issues that are facing people in the biggest way is an absolute duty for all of us.
READ MORE: Scottish Labour London MSP hopeful squirms in 'paper candidate' grilling
'People do respond well when their politicians speak to one another and collaborate and disagree in a way that at least makes everybody feel we're all trying to make it better. If someone just tuned into FMQs every week, I don't think they'd think we're all in there trying to make everything better.
'I think we need to face up to the fact that to restore that trust in our politicians, we need to demonstrate there is a way to work collaboratively.'
Mackay has become a well-known face in the Scottish Parliament having spearheaded the passage of the Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Act last year.
The law – which was only rejected by one MSP – makes it illegal for anti-abortion protests to be staged within 200m of a clinic in Scotland.
She has now thrown her hat in the ring to become a co-leader, insisting she is "happy to work with anyone".
Current co-leader Lorna Slater has also announced she will be running again.
Slater's fellow co-leader and veteran MSP Patrick Harvie announced last month he would be stepping down from the role after almost 17 years.
It opens the door to a new generation of hopefuls to lead the party and Mackay said she is keen to show the Greens are about more than just climate.
(Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire) She said wants to demonstrate how left-wing politics 'makes people's lives better' and make the party's policies around cutting emissions more 'tangible' to the public, which she thinks is another method of tackling the threat of Nigel Farage's party.
The party marked a victory last week as the SNP Government U-turned to announce peak rail fares would end from September.
'We need to make sure that people understand Green politics is more than just climate and gardening,' she said.
'I really want the Greens to offer that left-wing view and show how left politics makes people's lives better, and how the right-wing offering doesn't.
'It's about making sure people understand that cutting emissions means we want to make their journeys on the buses and train cheaper. It's not about making it more difficult to get around their local areas.
'And that's just one tiny bit. I've been doing some stuff around the environmental impact of medicines for example and how that interacts with prescribing.
READ MORE: SNP U-turn on peak train fares must spark full transport revolution
'It's not very sexy but it does have an impact on people so making those policies easy to understand but also easy for people to follow as to how it makes their lives better is the real thing there to unlock.
'I don't think we're unique in that as a party. I think there's a whole load of parties that can get tied up in technical things that are going on in Parliament and it ends up that no one can understand it except the 129 of us. That's how people lose trust in what's happening.'
A poll by Survation last week predicted Reform UK are set to form the main opposition at Holyrood behind the SNP with Scottish Labour remaining in third place.
Another reason why Mackay believes support has surged for Reform is from many politicians not interacting enough with their communities.
She believes getting MSPs back to the nuts and bolts of being elected representatives is key to plugging the gap Reform have muscled their way into.
'I think we've heard a lot that people are distrustful of their politicians and I think that stems from the public's desire to have a connection with their elected reps,' she said.
'I think that's something we've potentially gotten away from giving them and Reform are trying to say 'we're the good guys, we're just like you'.
'I grew up in Grangemouth, I do not come from a middle-class community so [I feel I can deliver that] level of interaction and understanding of what people are dealing with on a daily basis.
'I could talk the hind legs off a donkey if I needed to and I think that's my strength, I would rather be speaking to people out in communities than spending hours in the chamber.
'I think we need to get back to politicians being in their communities and speaking to people about real issues and giving them that alternative.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Jonathan Reynolds mocks Nigel Farage's coal mines plan as an ‘absolute parody'
Jonathan Reynolds mocks Nigel Farage's coal mines plan as an ‘absolute parody'

The Independent

time4 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Jonathan Reynolds mocks Nigel Farage's coal mines plan as an ‘absolute parody'

Jonathan Reynolds has mocked Nigel Farage for wanting to reopen the coal mines in Wales, dubbing him an 'absolute parody'. The business secretary, whose grandfather was a coal miner, admitted that Reform UK are Labour's biggest opponents – but said Mr Farage fails to understand 'the pride in where we're from and what we represent, but also the aspiration for the future'. Speaking at a media lunch in Parliament, Mr Reynolds also defended the UK's plan for closer trade ties with the US, saying: 'We might have different views but we have to engage with them'. His comments come after Mr Farage announced his party wants to restart Port Talbot's blast furnaces and 're-industrialise Wales'. On a visit to South Wales, the leader of Reform UK said the resumption of traditional steelmaking and coal production is the party's long-term ambition if it comes to power. The speech came one year ahead of the Senedd elections in May next year, where the party is looking to end Labour's 26 years of domination. But Mr Reynolds shot down the plan, telling reporters: 'When I see someone like Nigel Farage go to Wales and say to those people, 'I'm going to reopen the coal mines' and he thinks that's what working class people want - that is an absolute parody of what someone like Nigel Farage thinks that people like I grew up actually want.' He added: 'My grandfather was a coal miner, kind of much like everyone where I grew up… It was a position of real responsibility and family pride. 'He went down the mine fourteen years ago. He had one message for my dad, and that was 'don't go down the mine'. And he became a fireman. 'That's the bit that our opponents don't understand: the pride in where we're from and what we represent, but also the aspiration for the future.' Acknowledging that Reform is currently Labour's biggest opponent, he said the challenge facing the government is to persuade voters that 'mainstream politics can deliver for them'. Turning to the US trade deal, Mr Reynolds said the UK was able to negotiate one before other countries because Britain has made an effort to understand America's mindset. 'This is not US politics disrupting global trade. This is how global trade has disrupted US politics', he said. 'We might have different views but we have to engage with them.' The business secretary also recounted one phone call with his US counterpart Howard Lutnick, where he said he was worried he was 'going to sell the NHS' because of poor phone signal. 'The Woodhead Pass between South Yorkshire and Manchester is probably the only place in Britain with worse mobile phone reception than working in Parliament…. 'Howard starts talking, but because of the reception, every fifth or sixth word is genuinely cutting out of signal. 'I'm literally slightly worried I'm going to sell the f***ing NHS because of Britain's telecommunications infrastructure. I didn't. And I'm pleased to say we were the first country to get a deal.' The deal, announced last month by Sir Keir Starmer and Donald Trump, will see British tariffs on steel and automotive exports to the US slashed in exchange for greater access to the UK for some American goods. But the deal has still not been implemented, with both Washington and London yet to take the necessary steps to reduce tariffs. Mr Reynolds said the UK is 'ready to go' on implementing it's the deal, but is waiting for the White House to finalise it on their side. The business secretary added he was 'very hopeful' that the agreement would come into effect 'very soon', but acknowledged negotiations had not 'always been easy'. A Reform UK spokesman said: 'Labour are continuing to deindustrialise our towns and communities across the country. They don't blink when we lose thousands of well paid jobs in these crucial industries. 'Labour simply don't understand working people. Reform will continue to call for the re-industrialisation of Britain and with it, bring back thousands of well paid jobs.'

Government ‘putting its money where its mouth is' with £200m for Acorn scheme
Government ‘putting its money where its mouth is' with £200m for Acorn scheme

South Wales Argus

time7 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Government ‘putting its money where its mouth is' with £200m for Acorn scheme

Ministers confirmed they are meeting in full the request for development funding for the Acorn project in Aberdeenshire – the first time a government has provided funding of this scale for such a project to proceed. The scheme, which proposes storing emissions from across Scotland under the North Sea, had previously been overlooked for support despite repeated calls from the Scottish Government and others for it to be backed. With the UK Government also pledging to support the Viking carbon capture and storage (CCS) project in the Humber, Mr Miliband insisted the two schemes will 'support industrial renewal' with 'thousands of highly skilled jobs'. According to the sector, Acorn could support about 15,000 jobs at its peak, with up to 20,000 jobs at the Viking project. As it develops, it is planned the Acorn site will link up with the former oil refinery at Grangemouth via more than 200 miles of pipelines. An existing 175 miles of gas pipes will be repurposed for this, with 35 miles of new pipeline also being built, allowing CO2 from the Grangemouth site to be transported to Acorn's storage facilities under the North Sea. The move is seen by many as being key in securing a future for the facility, where some 400 workers were recently made redundant. Ed Miliband visited the Acorn project site near Peterhead, Aberdeenshire, on Thursday (Paul Campbell/PA) Speaking as he visited the site near Peterhead, Aberdeenshire, Mr Miliband said: 'This Government is putting its money where its mouth is and backing the trailblazing Acorn and Viking CCS projects. 'This will support industrial renewal in Scotland and the Humber with thousands of highly-skilled jobs at good wages to build Britain's clean energy future. 'Carbon capture will make working people in Britain's hard-working communities better off, breathing new life into their towns and cities and reindustrialising the country through our Plan for Change.' Mr Miliband visited the site the day after Rachel Reeves promised funding for Acorn in her spending review – although the Chancellor did not put a figure on how much support would be given in her statement to MPs. (PA Graphics) Tim Stedman, chief executive of Storegga, the lead developer of Acorn, said: 'We warmly welcome the UK Government's support for the Acorn project and the commitment to development funding that will enable the critical work needed to reach final investment decision.' He added the 'milestone' is 'key not only for Acorn but for establishing Scotland's essential CCS infrastructure needed to grow and scale the UK's wider carbon capture and storage industry'. Mr Stedman continued: 'We look forward to working with Government in the months ahead to understand the details of today's commitment, and to ensure the policy, regulatory and funding frameworks are in place to build and grow a world-leading UK CCS sector.' Graeme Davies, executive vice-president at Harbour Energy, which is leading the Viking project, said the commitment in the spending review 'sends a strong signal' that the project is 'an infrastructure-led economic growth priority' for the Parliament. He added: 'We will work with Government on the critical steps needed to progress Viking CCS towards a final investment decision.'

Swinney 'deeply concerned' over Alexander Dennis job cuts
Swinney 'deeply concerned' over Alexander Dennis job cuts

BBC News

time8 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Swinney 'deeply concerned' over Alexander Dennis job cuts

The first minister has said the Scottish government will do "everything it can" to support workers at bus manufacturer Alexander Swinney said he was "deeply concerned" the firm was planning to move its full operation to a site in Scarborough, North Yorkshire, putting 400 jobs at factories in Falkirk and Larbert at he faced criticism from Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar, who claimed his government had ordered more buses from China than it had from the said most bus ordering decisions in Scotland were made by private operators, and the government had to comply with state subsidy rules in the way it supported businesses. At First Minister's Questions Swinney said: "This issue has been occupying a great deal of the focus and the attention of the deputy first minister and I and the UK government ministers since we became aware of the situation over the last few weeks, and then ultimately to the decision that was announced yesterday."He quoted a joint letter from the UK and Scottish governments, which pledged to "work closely with Alexander Dennis at this challenging time". Alexander Dennis (ADL) cited strong competition from the China, which has seen its market share grow from 10% to 35%, among its reasons for the firm also criticised UK policy, and called for jobs and local economic benefit to be factored in when taxpayers money is invested. Earlier Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham pointed to an order of 160 ADL buses for the publicly-owned "Bee Network" in the city, and questioned why the Scottish government could not do the same. In a statement, Burnham - who has previously visited the Falkirk site - said: "Our iconic Bee Network buses are a bit of Scotland right here in Greater Manchester."We have over 160 Alexander Dennis buses criss-crossing our city-region every day - connecting our communities to opportunity."If Greater Manchester can invest in world-class Scottish bus manufacturing, then why can't the SNP Scottish government?"Sarwar claimed the Scottish government had secured just 44 buses from ADL as part of the Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund (ScotZEB) scheme last fund was initially established in 2022 to "disrupt the bus and coach market" and allow operators the chance to make the move to zero-emission vehicles. Sarwar said that number was "five times" less than the number of buses ordered by Greater that figure only covered the second phase of the first phase, in which 276 buses were procured at a cost of about £62m, saw 137 buses ordered from additional 116 buses were ordered from Chinese manufacturer Yutong, while the rest were built in the UK, Ireland and predecessor, known as the Scottish Ultra-Low Emission Bus Scheme, also saw 207 electric buses ordered from ADL by operators between September 2020 and March 2021. Swinney said state aid regulations - in the form of the UK-wide Subsidy Control Act - prevented the government from directly procuring from a single Scotland, most public service buses are procured by private operators, who then run them on routes across the said: "What I am doing, what the deputy first minister is doing, is how can we find a way in which we can remain legally compliant with the Subsidy Control Act and enable these obstacles to be overcome?"We are going to do everything we can to find a way through the Subsidy Control Act provision, so the government can continue to work within the law, and so we can support manufacturing in Scotland."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store