Residents object to new cell tower in Sea Point
Image: File
The City of Cape Town is considering the lease of municipal-owned property to facilitate telecommunication infrastructure - a move that has drawn significant objection from residents in the upscale suburbs of Sea Point and Fresnaye.
Ward councillor, Nicola Jowell, in May called on residents to participate and comment on the proposal for the cell tower at 10A Avenue Marseilles, Sea Point.
But irate residents have demanded the immediate rejection of the lease, citing concerns regarding health implications.
Gill Taylor, a resident who started the online petition titled 'Stop the cell tower installation at Ave Marseilles, Fresnaye – Protect Our Homes and Heritage,' said they submitted reports on the health risks of such an installation to the City as part of their objection.
'This proposed installation, on a small portion of ±4.4m², is not just a technical upgrade, it is a decision that will affect the health, safety, property values, and character of our neighbourhood for years to come.
"The City's own guidelines discourage this type of installation in close proximity to homes, yet this proposal does exactly that.
'Those living with autoimmune diseases, children, the elderly, and other vulnerable individuals face heightened risk. Why is the City gambling with our health?'
'The majority of residents were not informed about the planned mast. The burden of awareness and mobilisation has fallen on individuals who happened to discover the proposal via social media by chance. There has been no meaningful community consultation or notice placed in shared apartment spaces or public walkways.'
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Health risks and community consultation: Residents object to new cell tower in Sea Point Residents of Sea Point and Fresnaye are rallying against a proposed cell tower installation, citing health risks, reduced property values, and a lack of community consultation. This article explores their concerns and the ongoing debate surrounding the project.
Image: Facebook
She said via the petition that it would also have an impact on visual pollution and heritage.
In a health report shared with the Cape Argus, Dr Marion Weston, a homeopathic practitioner, echoed the medical concerns by residents.
'Given the current evidence and the potential for long-term health effects, I do not recommend residing in close proximity to telecommunications towers, especially where high levels of RF-EMFs are consistently present.'
Jowell said they were aware of the residents' objections, which have been sent to the leasing coordinator, adding that that all protocols were followed.
'The advert for the proposed leasing of the 4m2 section was advertised in line with the legislation for leasing of space from the City,' she said.
'This included an advert in the media. Given that many people may not see it in that format, I ensured that it was placed on social media for a wider reach within the community, and ensured that the local ratepayers association was also made aware of it.
"All regulatory processes have been followed. I am aware that the City has received a large number of objections to the lease from the surrounding community and these have been sent through to the leasing coordinator.
"All of this input will then be collated into a consolidated report that will then be presented at our sub-council meeting sometime during the third quarter.
"It will be there that myself and the sub-council will make a recommendation on the application based on all the input receive.'
The City of Cape Town in their response, said: 'The zoning designation for 10A Avenue Marseilles, Sea Point permits only a minor freestanding base telecommunication station and a minor rooftop base telecommunication station, subject to the City's consent.
'To date, no application for such consent has been received.
'Please note that if the proposed 'cell tower' is intended for the property adjacent to 10A Avenue Marseilles in Sea Point, the zoning regulations allow for the erection of both a minor freestanding base telecommunication station and a minor rooftop base telecommunication station as of right.' Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel.
Cape Argus
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Relief efforts underway after Briardene fire
A FIRE that tore through a part of the Briardene informal settlement recently has left around 25 families destitute. Ward 36 committee member Innocentia Happiness Mkhwanazi described the moment she arrived on the scene. 'I just saw flames. It was frightening. We started breaking down houses that hadn't yet caught alight to stop the fire from spreading. Houses here are built very close together, so the fire spread quickly,' she said. Also read: Two arrested in theft incidents in Durban North She added that when eThekwini Fire and Rescue arrived, the challenge was accessing water as there are no hydrants close by. 'The firefighters worked very hard to extinguish the flames. Thankfully nobody was injured and no lives were lost,' she added. While the cause has yet to be confirmed, many residents lost all their belongings, escaping with only the clothes on their backs. In the aftermath, Mkhwanazi converted her soup kitchen into a daily feeding point for the displaced families, with meals provided by organisations including the North Durban Lions Club. Relief efforts have been co-ordinated by community leader Sam Reddy, with support from the North Durban Lions Club and Leos of North Durban, Round Table of Durban 2, Gift of the Givers, the Slime Workshop, Anchorguard Insurance Brokers, Afrism Foundation, and the Help Me SA App. A suspected illegal electricity connection is believed to have caused the devastating fire. Ward 36 councillor Heinz de Boer said the incident has once again highlighted the urgent need to formalise the area. He has called on officials for a long-term plan to formalise Briardene, drawing on housing models like Cornubia and Waterloo, to provide proper infrastructure, alleviate fire risks, and address social challenges in the area. 'Briardene has been left by the City for far too long. It's a main transport and access route, and more and more people are moving in. We need proper housing, like Cornubia and Waterloo, with formal infrastructure in place. That's the only way to reduce the risk of fires, address social issues, and instil a sense of pride and ownership,' said De Boer. Following the blaze, the councillor said he has requested that the City and the National Department of Human Settlements conduct an audit of residents living in the informal settlement and that long-term plans be discussed to transform Briardene into a formal suburb that would be fully integrated into Umgeni Park. This would require significant budget allocation but could ultimately help address not only fire hazards, but also crime, drug use, and unregulated alcohol sales in the area. 'Efforts should go into building formal homes. We can't continue with a cycle where a candle falls over or an illegal connection sparks a fire, and people lose everything.' He added that building materials are expected to be delivered soon so that residents can rebuild their homes in the interim. De Boer added that the support from the people of Durban North, businesses and organisations has been heart-warming. 'The relief effort has been spearheaded by community leader Sam Reddy, with significant support from the Durban North Lions, Round Table, Gift of the Givers, and individual residents. Donations of clothing, household items, and food have poured in, with hot meals prepared daily,' he said. Donations of clothing, furniture, food, toiletries, and school supplies have poured in from religious groups, non-profits, and individuals across Durban. The community is urged to drop off donations at Durban North Pharmacy or SPAR Brownsdrift. For more from Northglen News, follow us on Facebook , X or Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok. Click to subscribe to our newsletter – here
Mail & Guardian
17-07-2025
- Mail & Guardian
How a geographic environment shapes a child's learning
Geography dictates not only resources but also exposure. (Delwyn Verasamy/M&G) Does a child's future depend on where they are born? In South Africa, the answer is 'yes.' We speak of education as the 'great equaliser', yet the truth is that a child's environment, whether they live in a village or a city, a suburb or an informal settlement, shapes how and what they learn before they even step into a classroom. In some communities, a child might arrive at a colourful preschool, where trained teachers guide them through puzzles, books and creative play, planting the seeds of critical thinking, numeracy and language development. They may play outdoors safely, observe insects, ask endless 'why' questions, and be met with patient, curious adults who guide exploration with stories and songs. In contrast, a child in a remote village may spend their day looking after younger siblings, fetching water or sitting in a classroom with no books, no toys and a single teacher managing four age groups at once. Their questions may go unanswered, their hunger may overshadow their curiosity, and their opportunities to learn through play may be scarce. Research shows that 90% of brain development happens before the age of five, yet the quality of stimulation children receive in these critical years depends largely on their environment. Access to clean water, safe spaces to play, nutritious food and parents or caregivers who have time to talk to them and tell stories are not just 'nice to haves'. They are the building blocks of literacy, problem-solving skills, emotional well-being and the foundations of lifelong learning. Geography dictates not only resources but also exposure. A child growing up in a community where adults read, where libraries are within walking distance and where children can safely explore nature, enter grade 1 with an advantage that cannot be captured by standardised tests alone. They arrive at school with a broader vocabulary, an ability to concentrate and a curiosity that drives them to learn. Conversely, for many children in under-resourced areas, the world remains small, their vocabulary limited and their curiosity dampened by the daily issue of survival. It is easy to blame schools when children cannot read for meaning by the age of 10, but we forget that learning starts long before that. Children learn by observing, listening, touching and interacting with the world around them. If a child's environment is one of deprivation, where caregivers are too burdened to talk or play with children, or where there are no safe spaces to explore, the learning gap starts early and deepens over time. In South Africa, only a fraction of children under the age of five attend early childhood development (ECD) programmes that meet the standards necessary for optimal development, with rural and informal settlements lagging furthest behind. Nutrition and health are deeply tied to geography. A child who is malnourished struggles to concentrate and is more susceptible to illness, leading to absenteeism from early learning opportunities. Access to healthcare services, including maternal health and immunisations, varies across geographic regions, further entrenching inequality. In areas where violence is common, children may experience toxic stress, which has been shown to disrupt brain architecture, leading to long-term difficulties in learning, emotional regulation and social skills. Safe, nurturing environments are essential to allow children to learn without fear, and geography often determines the level of safety a child experiences daily. Geography shapes not only physical environments but also cultural practices and community structures. In some rural communities, extended families and communal caregiving can provide rich opportunities for social learning and storytelling, while in others, poverty may force children into adult responsibilities, limiting time for play and learning. Urban environments, while often providing greater access to resources, can also be isolating for children, with limited safe outdoor spaces and parents working long hours, leaving children in the care of overstretched caregivers. The balance between resource availability and community support structures varies, and understanding these nuances is crucial in designing interventions that support early learning across different environments. Technology, community-based programmes and innovative mobile learning solutions are bridging some of these gaps. For example, mobile libraries, solar-powered digital learning stations and radio-based storytelling programmes have been used to bring early learning resources to under-resourced areas. Apps designed for early literacy and numeracy can provide children with access to engaging learning materials even in areas where schools are under-resourced. But these innovations cannot replace the need for safe, nurturing physical environments and the human interaction essential for young children's development. Technology should be seen as a tool to supplement, not replace, the need for community-based ECD centres, well-trained teachers and caregiver support. Despite progress, technology and innovation are not enough without the political will to prioritise early childhood development for every child, everywhere. Investment in ECD is not only a social imperative; it is an economic one. Studies show that for every rand invested in early childhood development, there is a significant return in terms of future productivity, reduced social welfare costs and improved societal outcomes. Imagine if every village had a safe, stimulating ECD centre. Imagine if parents in informal settlements had the support and tools to turn homes into learning spaces. Imagine if community health workers were equipped to support parents with practical strategies for early stimulation, nutrition and responsive caregiving. Imagine if geography did not decide a child's destiny. Addressing the geographic inequities that leave some children hungry, others neglected and many stuck in cycles of poverty without access to quality early learning requires a multi-faceted approach. This includes expanding access to quality ECD programmes, improving infrastructure in under-resourced areas, supporting parents and caregivers with practical tools for early learning, and integrating nutrition and health services into early childhood programmes. Theresa Michael is the chief executive of Afrika Tikkun Bambanani and leads a team that has implemented an early learning programme at more than 700 ECD centres in rural and under-resourced communities in South Africa.
IOL News
11-07-2025
- IOL News
Construction delays in Schaapkraal leave residents frustrated and vulnerable to flooding
Residents in Schaapkraal express their frustration over delays by contractors. Image: Supplied Residents of Schaapkraal who for years appealed for decent roads now have a new worry, as contractors hired by the City have delayed construction, causing further damage to their homes and vehicles. In several letters and correspondence shared with the Cape Argus, irate residents said excavations have been left wide open. They also said the four-month project is now six months behind schedule with no explanation or communication from the City regarding the delay. 'Residents often discover excavations outside their driveways only when attempting to leave, posing risks in emergencies,' said residents in a joint communication about their grievances. 'Despite meetings and the contractor's inclusion in a WhatsApp group, communication remains poor, with residents initiating most discussions. 'Construction has occurred daily, including weekends and late nights, without prior notification. "Recent rains have brought constant night work from pumps and generators, also unannounced. "Unforeseen water shutdowns left residents without alternatives, forcing water purchases." Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading The residents said they had to inquire about refuse collection during road closures, leading to instances where waste trucks couldn't access the road. 'The contractor had to assist in moving bins. The contractor admitted a poor initial pipeline installation, and despite multiple attempts, faces ongoing challenges without informing residents of the issues or mitigation plans,' they added. They said another risk was that children had to walk through active construction zones with heavy machinery due to inaccessible scholar transport. Ward councillor, Elton Jansen, said he was aware of the residents' grievances and that he had raised their concerns with officials. 'I note with the same concerns and urgency with the situation in 8th, 9th, and 10th Avenue as well as the flooding in various parts of Schaapkraal i.e. Schaap Road, Vlei Road,' he said in a letter shared with the Cape Argus. 'I understand the frustration and even though some of the insults are aimed at me as the councillor of the area I can assure you I am and have on an ongoing basis raised this with senior officials to deal with it and communicate with us on the ground what their plan of action is. 'I have inspected the pumping, and it is a waste of time. 'I drove the gravel roads, and it's unbearable to drive. 'I visited some residents who were affected by power outages as a result of the flooding and thanked them for their patience. 'I will be back in the area again to continue with my flooding inspections as various people, including informal settlements, have been severely affected.' Residents in Schaapkraal have been waiting for new roads and repairs. Image: supplied Last year the City's mayco member for Urban Mobility, Rob Quintas, said priority would be given to major roads such as Boundary Road, Vlei Road, Kraal Road, Boom Road, Middle Avenue, and Olieboom Road. In response, the City on Thursday said two departments will meet on Friday morning and provide feedback in the afternoon. Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel. Cape Argus
