Michael Vaughan Questions ICCs Double Standards As England Docked WTC Points For Over-rate But India Avoids Penalty
England Penalised Despite Lord's Victory
The ICC announced that England were two overs short after considering time allowances, triggering penalties under Article 16.11.2 of the WTC playing conditions. As a result, England lost two crucial WTC points and were fined 10% of their match fee under Article 2.22 of the ICC Code of Conduct.
The sanctions came as a significant blow, particularly as England had moved up to second in the WTC standings following their win. The deduction dropped their tally from 24 to 22 points, reducing their points percentage from 66.67% to 61.11% and pushing them down to third place.
Vaughan Calls Out ICC's Double Standards
Vaughan expressed his discontent on X (formerly Twitter), writing,
'Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lord's were very very poor… How only one team has been reprimanded is beyond me.'
Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lords were very very poor .. How only 1 team has been reprimanded is beyond me .. #ENGvsIND — Michael Vaughan (@MichaelVaughan) July 16, 2025
The former captain's remarks have sparked fresh debate about the transparency and fairness of the ICC's disciplinary procedures, especially given that no penalty was announced for India, who were also perceived to be lagging in over rates during the same Test.
India Escape Sanctions, Remain in Fourth
India, despite having a similar over-rate issue according to Vaughan and other observers, faced no official penalty from the ICC. The team currently sits in fourth place on the WTC standings with one win in three matches and a points percentage of 33.33%.
This discrepancy has added fuel to concerns among fans and former players over the consistency of over-rate rulings and their long-term impact on WTC standings.
Sri Lanka Benefit from England's Slip
England's points deduction helped Sri Lanka leapfrog into second place on the WTC table behind leaders Australia. With each point holding significant value in the tightly contested WTC race, especially with the final often determined by slim margins, the sanctions have already begun to influence the dynamics of the championship.
Calls for Greater Transparency in WTC Rules
Vaughan's criticism has reignited calls for the ICC to implement more consistent enforcement and clearer communication regarding over-rate penalties. With teams vying for a coveted spot in the WTC final, stakeholders are urging the governing body to ensure a level playing field in terms of disciplinary actions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
14 minutes ago
- First Post
Pant was 'milking' injury, should have been 'timed out': England icon reveals sensational chatter at Old Trafford
Rishabh Pant had heroically walked out to bat on Thursday, a day after suffered a fracture on his foot while attempting to reverse sweep a Chris Woakes yorker, with the wicketkeeper-batter going on to complete his fifty. Some, however, chose to view Pant's brave gesture in a different light. read more Rishabh Pant walked out to bat on Day 2 of the fourth Test at Old Trafford despite nursing a fracture on his right foot. Image: JioStar India wicketkeeper-batter Rishabh Pant was widely praised for his brave gesture of walking out to bat a day after suffering a fracture on his right foot during the fourth Test against England in Manchester. Pant, who was batting on 37 when he was struck by a yorker from Chris Woakes that he was attempting to reverse sweep, ended up completing his 18th Test half-century and also helped India cross the 350-mark in the process. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD There are, however, those who don't buy into Pant's heroics in Manchester, with some believing that he was 'milking' his injury, and that he should have been 'timed out'. English cricketer-turned-commentator David Lloyd revealed hearing some of these sensational comments on Pant at 'Bumble Legends Lounge' – Lancashire Cricket's special hospitality experience where guests can spend time with the former all-rounder at Old Trafford's 1864 Suite during international games. 'I've never had a metatarsal, which I think is somewhere in the foot, seeing Rishabh Pant. I have had a smashed hand against Andy Roberts and a broken cheekbone. I couldn't bat on after either, although I think I did continue when I had a broken finger,' Lloyd said on talkSPORT Cricket. 'Pant looked in pain; pretty heroic of him to come out, though. Northerners, whether they are tough enough, but I was in that legends lounge today, and the consensus was 'He has milking that injury. It can't be that bad. He's milked it, coming down those steps, and one or two said, 'He should be timed out,'' the former England head coach added. Lloyd voices support for substitutes in cricket Lloyd also chimed in on the discussion of substitutes in cricket, which gained traction following Pant's injury that has ruled him out of the fifth and final Test against England that takes place at The Oval next week. While the 78-year-old disagreed with the concept of a runner, he felt that situations like that of the Indian vice-captain did call for a substitute. 'I probably am against runners, but I am pro substitutes for an external injury. It opens up a can of worms, it really does. But if it is an external injury, a break and medically he isn't going to be fit for six weeks, you could have a like-for-like substitute. So that's something else that you've got to consider. Not like replace a batter with a spinner though,' he added. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The injury has forced reserve keeper Dhruv Jurel to fill in for Pant during England's innings, with the former having also kept wickets for the better part of the third Test at Lord's – where Pant had suffered an finger injury.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Joe Root's 38th Test hundred laces England's domination over tired India
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Joe Root produced a batting masterclass on way to a milestone 38th hundred as England exploited a jaded Indian bowling attack to stamp their dominance on the fourth Test here on stumps on day three, England were 544 for seven, stretching their first innings lead to 186 made a sublime 150 off 248 balls while the other contributions came from Ben Stokes (77 batting off 134) and Ollie Pope (71 off 128), a day after the openers put a pedestrian looking Indian attack to has been a long tour with another Test to go in a week's time but considering the body language of Indian pacers in the field on Friday, lasting the whole series would be a visitors have already been hit by a series of injuries with the latest one being X-factor cricketer Rishabh Pant's toe Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj seemed to be bowling with a niggle while debutant Anshul Kamboj hit underwhelming speeds in the range 125-130 kmph. Even Bumrah, who usually bowls in the range of 140 kmph, clocked speeds in the lower bowled just one over in the afternoon session, Bumrah was seen holding his ankle and even had to leave the field his 24th over, he managed to procure the wicket of Jamie Smith (9).Siraj too seemed to be in discomfort like Bumrah, but he bowled with more intensity in the final session and was rewarded the wicket of Chris sun was out for the majority of the day, making conditions better for batting. Root made full use of that and in the process surpassed the great Ricky Ponting to become the second highest run-getter in Tests, only behind Sachin Tendulkar, who tallied 15921 lone positive for India was the performance of Washington Sundar who struck twice in the afternoon session after being questionably brought in as late as the 69th Thakur was used for 11 overs, raising questions on the presence of three all-rounders in the would take a special effort from the Indians to bounce back and keep the series the afternoon session, Root reached his 12th hundred against India as England extended their dominance over India, reaching 433 for four at got the ball to drift and got rid of Pope (71 off 128) and Harry Brook (3 off 12) after lunch, providing a much needed relief for India following a wicketless morning however, continued to pile on the runs and reached thee figures with a four down the leg side off employed spinners Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja from both ends despite taking the new ball. The move worked as Sundar had Pope caught at first slip before having Brook stumped as he could not connect on the chose to play on the backfoot when the spinners were in operation and used the reverse sweep the end of the session, Root took a single off Kamboj to get past the great Ponting in the all time leading run getters was worrying for India was the sight of Bumrah bowling just one over with the new ball before leaving the field. When he finally returned to bowl, the umpires reminded him that he was only allowed to bowl post the morning, the Indian bowlers did not pose enough threat for Root and Pope who steered England to 332 for two at a forgettable evening session on day two, the Indian bowling attack once again failed to make inroads into the England an odd ball keeping low from the James Anderson end and another jumping from the opposite side, Bumrah and Co did not trouble Root and of offering too many freebies on the leg side on Thursday, the Indian pacers continued to offer loose balls to release pressure on the bowled a full ball into Root's pads to start his day and the England veteran duly flicked it for a four. Later in his spell, Pope andRoot were quick to pull Bumrah for a boundary each when the Indian pace spearhead pitched it the day at 225 for two, England eased to 266 for two in the first hour of created a chance in his opening spell but Dhruv Jurel could not hold on to a tough chance. Pope was on 48 that timeWashington was introduced post lunch and Root put him under pressure straightaway by reverse sweeping him for a boundary.
NDTV
6 hours ago
- NDTV
Joe Root Inflicts More Pain On India, Slams 150, As England Take Mammoth 186-Run Lead
Joe Root produced a batting masterclass on way to a milestone 38th hundred as England exploited a jaded Indian bowling attack to stamp their dominance on the fourth Test here on Friday. At stumps on day four, England were 544 for seven, stretching their first innings lead to 186 runs. Root made a sublime 150 off 248 balls while the other contributions came from Ben Stokes (77 batting off 134) and Ollie Pope (71 off 128), a day after the openers put a pedestrian looking Indian attack to sword. It has been a long tour with another Test to go in a week's time but considering the body language of Indian pacers in the field on Friday, lasting the whole series would be a challenge. The visitors have already been hit by a series of injuries with the latest one being X-factor cricketer Rishabh Pant's toe fracture. Both Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj seemed to be bowling with a niggle while debutant Anshul Kamboj hit underwhelming speeds in the range 125-130 kmph. Even Bumrah, who usually bowls in the range of 140 kmph, clocked speeds in the lower 130s. Having bowled just one over in the afternoon session, Bumrah was seen holding his ankle and even had to leave the field briefly. In his 24th over, he managed to procure the wicket of Jamie Smith (9). Siraj too seemed to be in discomfort like Bumrah, but he bowled with more intensity in the final session and was rewarded the wicket of Chris Woakes. The sun was out for the majority of the day, making conditions better for batting. Root made full use of that and in the process surpassed the great Ricky Ponting to become the second highest run-getter in Tests, only behind Sachin Tendulkar, who tallied 15921 runs. The lone positive for India was the performance of Washington Sundar who struck twice in the afternoon session after being questionably brought in as late as the 69th over. Shardul Thakur was used for 11 overs, raising questions on the presence of three all-rounders in the team. It would take a special effort from the Indians to bounce back and keep the series alive. In the afternoon session, Root reached his 12th hundred against India as England extended their dominance over India, reaching 433 for four at tea. Washington got the ball to drift and got rid of Pope (71 off 128) and Harry Brook (3 off 12) after lunch, providing a much needed relief for India following a wicketless morning session. Root, however, continued to pile on the runs and reached thee figures with a four down the leg side off Kamboj. India employed spinners Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja from both ends despite taking the new ball. The move worked as Sundar had Pope caught at first slip before having Brook stumped as he could not connect on the charge. Root chose to play on the backfoot when the spinners were in operation and used the reverse sweep effectively. Towards the end of the session, Root took a single off Kamboj to get past the great Ponting in the all time leading run getters list. What was worrying for India was the sight of Bumrah bowling just one over with the new ball before leaving the field. When he finally returned to bowl, the umpires reminded him that he was only allowed to bowl post tea. In the morning, the Indian bowlers did not pose enough threat for Root and Pope who steered England to 332 for two at lunch. After a forgettable evening session on day two, the Indian bowling attack once again failed to make inroads into the England batting. Besides an odd ball keeping low from the James Anderson end and another jumping from the opposite side, Bumrah and Co did not trouble Root and Pope. Guilty of offering too many freebies on the leg side on Thursday, the Indian pacers continued to offer loose balls to release pressure on the opposition. Bumrah bowled a full ball into Root's pads to start his day and the England veteran duly flicked it for a four. Later in his spell, Pope and Root were quick to pull Bumrah for a boundary each when the Indian pace spearhead pitched it short. Resuming the day at 225 for two, England eased to 266 for two in the first hour of play. Kamboj created a chance in his opening spell but Dhruv Jurel could not hold on to a tough chance. Pope was on 48 that time Washington was introduced post lunch and Root put him under pressure straightaway by reverse sweeping him for a boundary.
