Michael Vaughan Questions ICCs Double Standards As England Docked WTC Points For Over-rate But India Avoids Penalty
England Penalised Despite Lord's Victory
The ICC announced that England were two overs short after considering time allowances, triggering penalties under Article 16.11.2 of the WTC playing conditions. As a result, England lost two crucial WTC points and were fined 10% of their match fee under Article 2.22 of the ICC Code of Conduct.
The sanctions came as a significant blow, particularly as England had moved up to second in the WTC standings following their win. The deduction dropped their tally from 24 to 22 points, reducing their points percentage from 66.67% to 61.11% and pushing them down to third place.
Vaughan Calls Out ICC's Double Standards
Vaughan expressed his discontent on X (formerly Twitter), writing,
'Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lord's were very very poor… How only one team has been reprimanded is beyond me.'
Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lords were very very poor .. How only 1 team has been reprimanded is beyond me .. #ENGvsIND — Michael Vaughan (@MichaelVaughan) July 16, 2025
The former captain's remarks have sparked fresh debate about the transparency and fairness of the ICC's disciplinary procedures, especially given that no penalty was announced for India, who were also perceived to be lagging in over rates during the same Test.
India Escape Sanctions, Remain in Fourth
India, despite having a similar over-rate issue according to Vaughan and other observers, faced no official penalty from the ICC. The team currently sits in fourth place on the WTC standings with one win in three matches and a points percentage of 33.33%.
This discrepancy has added fuel to concerns among fans and former players over the consistency of over-rate rulings and their long-term impact on WTC standings.
Sri Lanka Benefit from England's Slip
England's points deduction helped Sri Lanka leapfrog into second place on the WTC table behind leaders Australia. With each point holding significant value in the tightly contested WTC race, especially with the final often determined by slim margins, the sanctions have already begun to influence the dynamics of the championship.
Calls for Greater Transparency in WTC Rules
Vaughan's criticism has reignited calls for the ICC to implement more consistent enforcement and clearer communication regarding over-rate penalties. With teams vying for a coveted spot in the WTC final, stakeholders are urging the governing body to ensure a level playing field in terms of disciplinary actions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
42 minutes ago
- India.com
WATCH: Jasprit Bumrah hobbling back to dressing room, get worse for Team India at Old Trafford, video goes viral
WATCH: Jasprit Bumrah hobbling back to dressing room, get worse for Team India at Old Trafford, video goes viral New Delhi: Team India's star fast bowler Jasprit Bumrah's fitness and workload management has always been in the news. He got injured during the Manchester Test against England, which further increased the team's problems. He got this injury on the third day and due to this England scored more than 500 runs. Bumrah got this injury while climbing the stairs of Old Trafford, which was informed by the bowling coach. Bumrah came on the field despite injury The Manchester Test started on 23 July. Even before this match, Indian bowlers Akash Deep and Arshdeep Singh were out due to injury. In such a situation, there was doubt about Bumrah's playing, but considering the situation, he was included in the team. The team hoped that Bumrah would show some impact. Bumrah slipped on the stairs Despite Bumrah being on the field, his performance was normal on the second and third days. The team's concern increased when he slipped on the stairs. Bowling coach Morne Morkel said that on the third day Bumrah's foot was twisted in the stairs. Due to this he was in pain and could not bowl with the new ball. However, the injury was not serious. There is this video shared by a user on r/cricket (Reddit). The caption that accompanied it stated that Bumrah tripped while coming down the stairs. That is how he hurt is ankle. Even Ravi Shastri mentioned it on comms. #ENGvsIND #Bumrah — Darpan Tikiya (@DarpanTikiya) July 25, 2025 Team India suffered Not only Bumrah, Mohammed Siraj was also seen struggling with injury. When Team India took the new ball, both the bowlers got injured at the same time. Morkel said that due to this the team got into trouble. After taking the new ball, Bumrah went out in one over and returned late, while Siraj also had to return to the dressing room. Dominance of England batsmen By the end of the third day, England had scored 544 runs and only 7 wickets fell. England played a total of 135 overs. Out of these, Bumrah bowled 28 overs and took one wicket for 95 runs. Siraj also got a wicket but he gave 113 runs. Other bowlers also remained dull Other Indian fast bowlers also could not impress. Anshul Kamboj took 1 wicket for 89 runs in 18 overs, while Shardul Thakur gave 55 runs in 11 overs and could not take any wicket. The Indian pace attack looked completely pale against England.
Hindustan Times
42 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Rishabh Pant compared to ‘Gary Sobers, Brian Lara' as England legend rues India star's injury: ‘I'm actually so sorry…'
Much to the disappointment of Indian cricket fans, Rishabh Pant is set to miss the fifth Test of the ongoing five-match series vs England. Pant fractured his toe on Day 1 of the ongoing fourth Test in Manchester, which saw him having to retire hurt. Then to the surprise of everyone, he resumed his innings on Day 2, and registered 54 off 75 balls. India's Rishabh Pant reacts as he is stretchered off.(Action Images via Reuters) But Pant's didn't don the gloves, with Dhruv Jurel taking over the wicketkeeper role. Speaking to PTI, England legend David Gower lavished praise on the likes of Pant and Ben Duckett, even comparing them to Brian Lara and Gary Sobers. 'Tongue-in-cheek…we have always said left-handers are the best. For some reason when you look at left-handed batsmen it seems to be more graceful than right-handed. I've watched a lot of great left-handers from my days growing up, Gary Sobers for one, Brian Lara of course probably the best of those when I was first starting to grace commentary boxes and describe these things,' he said. 'Now we have a guy called Ben Duckett, he has a very different style to mine but incredible to watch. Every time I look at him bat you're kind of wondering what happens next and you cannot forget especially in the context of this series, Rishabh Pant.' David Gower rues Rishabh Pant's injury The former England captain also rued Pant's injury. 'I'm actually so sorry that he's injured, and if this foot thing is terminal (and he is out of the series). There is a man who does the things that only others dream of. Some people call them nightmares but he's an absolutely brilliant extraordinary player to watch,' he said. 'So, you cannot replicate what he does. You cannot ask a young player, say age 15-16 to bat like Rishabh Pant, go on try that because that would be probably fatal to their career. But when you've got someone like that who plays this most extraordinary version of the game you cannot but admire it. He takes incredible to another level,' he added. According to reports, Pant has been asked to rest for six weeks, and his return to bat on Day 2 came as a surprise. The BCCI hasn't released an official update yet.
Hindustan Times
43 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Ravi Shastri doesn't hold back, shreds Shubman Gill's ‘tactics' over Washington Sundar move: ‘What are you telling him?'
It took 68 overs for Shubman Gill to introduce Washington Sundar into the attack in the ongoing Manchester Test against England. The hosts are making merry as they are in a solid position of 544/7 in the first innings, with their lead extending to 186 in the fourth Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy. Off-spinner Sundar had scalped four wickets in the second innings at Lord's, hence it was all the more surprising that Sundar wasn't trusted enough by the skipper. Washington Sundar scalped two wickets on Day 3 of the Manchester Test. (PTI) Once Sundar was introduced into the attack, he dismissed Ollie Pope and Harry Brook, further highlighting Gill and his captaincy. Former Team India head coach Ravi Shastri didn't hold back as he gave a brutal assessment of Gill's captaincy, saying the call of not bowling Sundar enough was wrong on all levels. He further called out the 25-year-old for making several tactical blunders in the Manchester Test, which has led to England gaining a significant advantage. At stumps on Day 3, England's score read 544/7 with Ben Stokes and Liam Dawson unbeaten on 77 and 21, respectively. 'He took four wickets in the last game. Then you bring that bloke after 67, 69 overs. I mean, what does it tell that player? Here, I've taken four. I should be like a front-runner, bowling within the first 30, 35 overs. And you're getting me on after 69. And then he takes the first two wickets,' Shastri said on Sky Sports. Also Read: Gautam Gambhir takes the bullet for Shubman Gill's blunder 'So tactically, I thought they were found wanting. I thought Siraj should have taken the new ball yesterday. Instead of giving it to Kamboj, who's new, playing his first Test match. That let the pressure off England. Then the bouncer tactic, which they're 24 hours late. That should have been tried yesterday to see if they could have made further inroads. So tactically a lot was missing," he added. Virat Kohli example However, Shastri also stated that Shubman Gill will become a better captain as he learns from his experiences. He also highlighted the importance of the support staff and how the likes of Gautam Gambhir and Morne Morkel can help Gill. 'I'll cite an example of Virat when he took over. He was the other way, as far as Shubman goes. He was extra, ultra-aggressive. Where you had to, at times, from the dressing room, calm him down, especially with field placing. It was a case of as if you wanted five wickets every session of play. It doesn't happen,' said Shastri. 'Sometimes you've got to, you know, respect the conditions and set fields accordingly. And that's why I think the team management becomes now crucial in helping someone like Shubman Gill over the first year and a half. I think that is the key,' he added. The former India head coach also stated that the senior bowlers in the side, such as Ravindra Jadeja and Jasprit Bumrah, also need to step up as they can set the field for themselves as they have been playing for long. 'The senior players in the side, they have to start being accountable and be able to set their own fields, have their own ideas. That should come from the bowlers as well. Okay, I want to try this now, captain,' said Shastri. 'What do you think? Rather than the captain going and telling them, if they played 50, 60 test matches and more, it should be them going and telling the captain, listen, I need to take a wicket and I want to set this kind of field. That's what Stokes does. He thinks how he's going to disrupt things and find ways of breaking partnerships,' he added.
