Erin Patterson 'didn't look unwell' like other lunch guests, nurse tells mushroom murder trial
Kristian Silva
, ABC
Erin Patterson was arrested and charged with murder on 2 November 2023.
Photo:
Screenshot /
ABC
A nurse says Erin Patterson did not appear to be sick while in hospital, two days after hosting the fatal beef Wellington lunch that caused the deaths of three relatives.
The focus of Patterson's triple-murder trial today shifted to the medical care she received in the aftermath of the lunch on July 29, 2023.
The Supreme Court, sitting in Morwell, heard Patterson's condition around midday on 31 July appeared to be significantly different from the four other lunch guests.
By that stage, Don and Gail Patterson and Heather and Ian Wilkinson had all been admitted to hospitals with severe vomiting and diarrhoea.
"She didn't look unwell like Ian and Heather," Leongatha hospital nurse Cindy Munro said.
"I recall Ian being so unwell he could barely lift his head off the pillow.
"Erin was sitting up in the bed in the trolley and she didn't look unwell to me."
At the time, Munro said, Patterson was hesitant about receiving intravenous fluids and liver-protecting medication.
"Erin sort of stressed she didn't want any of this," Munro said.
Munro said medical staff were concerned the lunch attendees were suffering from mushroom poisoning, and were worried Patterson's two children had been exposed to the toxins after eating some of the leftovers.
"At that stage she said, 'No, no I scraped off all the mushroom' and the children were not unwell," Munro said.
"She didn't want to cause any hassle. She didn't want to take them out of school and that was when she became quite teary, quite worried."
Munro said she warned Patterson it was possible toxins could have seeped into the meat eaten by the children.
Eventually, Patterson agreed to having the children checked out.
Earlier on Thursday, doctor Veronica Foote told the court Patterson had discharged herself from the hospital on July 31 after a five-minute stay.
Patterson's decision, against medical advice, prompted another concerned doctor to call police when she failed to return in an agreed 20-minute window.
Dr Foote said she formed the view Patterson was moderately dehydrated and appeared to have a gastro illness, after having a conversation with her and performing a physical examination.
Later, after Patterson was transported to Monash hospital in Clayton, she was visited by Tanya Patterson, the wife of her brother-in-law.
"She said she was feeling nauseous and dizzy and tired," Tanya Patterson said.
Tayna Patterson said Patterson inquired about the welfare of the other lunch guests, with Tanya telling her they were "going downhill quickly".
"She told me she knew Don and Gail were in a coma," Tanya Patterson said.
Tanya Patterson said the conversation then shifted to Patterson wanting to take her children on a boat cruise.
A toxicologist then entered the room and informed Patterson that her potassium levels were "fine", Tanya Patterson said.
"I stayed and heard the toxicologist say Erin was fine and well enough to go home," she said.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to the alleged murders of Don and Gail Patterson, and Heather Wilkinson, all members of her estranged husband's family. She also denies a charge of attempted murder regarding Ian Wilkinson, the only lunch guest to survive.
Ian Wilkinson (left) was the sole surviving guest of the lunch.
Photo:
ABC / Supplied
Prosecutors allege Patterson deliberately poisoned the group with death cap mushrooms in the main course of the lunch, a beef Wellington.
Senior Constable Adrian Martinez-Villalobis told the court he'd been dispatched to Patterson's Leongatha house to find leftovers of the meal.
He called Patterson in hospital, who directed him to a bin outside the property. The officer said he put on two sets of gloves, found the remnants at the bottom of the bin in a paper bag, and took it to the Leongatha hospital.
"She was cooperative throughout," he said of Patterson.
The trial continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Breaking the cycle of transgenerational trauma
Dr Tara-Lyn Camilleri Photo: SUPPLIED We inherit our genes but can we inherit trauma? There's no doubt we can feel it but can the trauma of previous generations be expressed in our genetic code? How does a parent's experience of war, ethnic persecution, cultural oppression, state or domestic abuse manifest itself in their child? Dr Tara-Lyn Camilleri from Monash University in Melbourne is an expert in transgenerational effects, looking at how the lived experiences of one generation can shape those that follow. An Oxford scholar, Dr Camilleri talks to Mihi about the relationship between biology, psychology and our environment and what we can do to break the cycle of transgenerational trauma. Photo: Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay
RNZ News
17 hours ago
- RNZ News
The science of transgenerational trauma, epigenetics and hope for healing
Dr Tara-Lyn Camilleri studies epigenetics and the transgenerational effects of trauma. Photo: SUPPLIED Do we inherit the effects of trauma physically from past generations? Do parents' experiences of war, ethnic persecution, cultural oppression, state or domestic abuse have lasting effects, manifested in their children? There's no doubt we can feel it, but can the trauma of previous generations actually be coded into the bodies of their children? New research is beginning to shed light on this. Dr Tara-Lyn Camilleri, an Oxford scholar and now a researcher at Monash University in Melbourne, specialises in epigenetics - the interplay between our environments, lived experiences and how our genes are expressed. She talked to Mihingarangi Forbes about the biology and what that tells us about breaking cycles of transgenerational trauma. In a wider sense, "transgenerational trauma is when the effects of trauma in one generation ripple into the next generation, so it can shape us in a few key ways - biologically socially psychologically and culturally" Camilleri says. "So psychologically, if someone's experienced trauma it can effect how they parent, how they regulate emotion, and how safe their environment is in general - all will shape a child's development. Culturally trauma can disrupt people connection to culture, language, history, land, which can carry through generations if healing doesn't happen. So all of these things are constantly interacting with one another to produce these outcomes. "Biologically, stress can change how our bodies regulate things like hormones and immunity and those changes can be passed on sometimes through what we call epigenetic mechanisms - when we feel unsafe it can activate stress pathways in the body that alter how certain genes are expressed." Epigenetics is not changes to the DNA and genes itself, but changes to other biochemical tags that affect how DNA code is used, or to surrounding proteins. "I've described it as the directors notes on a script - these notes may tell the actors which lines to emphasise or downplay, but they're not changing the script itself," Camilleri says. For example, the fight or flight response is how the body continually responds to either real or perceived threats. And "this is when we start to get into the realm of phenotypic plasticity - it's a fundamental process in biology - it doesn't get a lot of attention, but things like stress or diet, these environmental conditions, can change our bodies, they change our neuroplasticity - the change the neurons in our brain, and they can change a whole host of other things, and that can induce these epigenetic changes." Genetics itself could mean a predisposition to experiencing stress in particular ways, including physically. Epigenetics can then "act like a volume dial" turning up or down those genes effects, and can be influenced by our parents experiences or our early childhood experiences. The effects of phenotypic plasticity can also be seen in the animal world, Camilleri says. For example what a honeybee is fed will determine if it becomes a worker or a queen. Some of those phenotypic changes can then be passed on to descendants, for example the body of stickleback fish can change to make it more difficult for predators to eat them. And this result can sometimes last for many generations when it is then cued by environmental factors like nutrients and hormones that regulate those responses. Camilleri says her own research with fruit flies found different nutrition and diet changes could result in different effects for different generations. One diet fed to both parents and their children resulted in the parents living longer but the offspring living shorter lives, whereas a different diet of more protein resulted in both grandmothers and granddaughters producing more offspring. The effects of transgenerational trauma can skip generations, and there are also actions we can take to mediate its effects, Camilleri says. "It's not always set in stone ... when we look at this research we don't see what we would call very predictable effects - it can change all the time. These epigenetic changes are what we call plastic, so they don't necessarily have to be permanent, and they are changing all the time throughout our lifetime all of the time. "So there are several things we can do to mediate it, to ensure that we might be able to break the cycle - but certainly even without intervention, our genetics are always talking to our environment. Our biology and our environment are always interacting with our social systems and our culture, so it's such a complicated mix of things that it's not always set in stone." Photo: (Pixabay Public Domain) Studies have found that how much of a parents' experiences result in factors affecting their children depends on which parent was affected, she says. Including one landmark study of cortisol (a stress hormone) in the children of holocaust survivors with PTSD. It found the children of mothers who were holocaust survivors were more likely to have cortisol dysregulation that made it more difficult to calm down from a stress response, compared to children of fathers who were holocaust survivors. "They are more predisposed to these baseline cortisol levels not being able to return to normal and keeping the body in ... a more prolonged stress state." Research has also found that breaking the cycle is more successful when the onus does not just fall on the individual, she says. "There are personal strategies. Obviously therapy, seeing a psychologist, building supportive relationships and learning to regulate our stress and emotion, it definitely helps and it's definitely very valuable - and that is where the emphasis is now, in society, it's sort of on the individual. "And I think what is changing is that we're realising that those personal strategies that we can do are most effective when other solutions address wider systems that people live in, so that means tackling the social, the economic and the environmental conditions that keep stress or inequity high... large-scale events, war, colonialisation. "Supporting things like cultural-led healing, community-led things by the people. Especially for these wide large-scale events - the people who've experienced these they need to lead these. Those voices need to be heard and listened to, so that it restores this sense of connection and identity and acknowledgement. Because it's about people feeling safe within the systems that they live in. "So when we change things at those broader levels we can reduce the load on individuals, and create those conditions where those individual strategies will be more likely to effect recovery and therefore affect subsequent generations."
RNZ News
10-08-2025
- RNZ News
Doctors call for NZ to ditch 'outdated' endometriosis guidelines
Endometriosis affects about one in 10 women and girls in New Zealand. Photo: 123rf New Zealand's "outdated" guidelines for treating the pelvic inflammatory disease endometriosis are delaying diagnosis and treatment for sufferers, warns an advocacy group. Endometriosis New Zealand spokesperson Dr Michael Wynn-Williams said new guidelines developed by the the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists were already being implemented in Australia for the painful condition, which affects about one in 10 women and girls. "This new guideline represents the gold standard in evidence-based care and is already being implemented across Australia," said Wynn-Williams, who chairs the clinical advisory committee. It recommends the use of non-invasive imaging, such as pelvic ultrasound, as a first-line diagnostic tool, moving away from reliance on diagnostic laparoscopy, which has contributed to long wait times for diagnosis. The current 2020 Ministry of Health document was no longer fit for purpose and needed to be urgently replaced with the new Australian Living Evidence Guideline, he said. "Our current guideline is now outdated, and out of step with modern diagnostic and treatment practices. "By contrast, RANZCOG's new guideline reflects the latest evidence and provides clear recommendations for early diagnosis, as well as first-line hormonal treatment to be run in parallel with diagnostic investigations. These are crucial to reducing the delays in diagnosis and treatment that too many patients still experience." Endometriosis New Zealand chief executive Tanya Cooke said adopting the new guideline would bring New Zealand into line with global best practice, and ensure patients received faster, less invasive and more equitable care. "We have written to the ministry and Te Whatu Ora, urging them to adopt the new guideline as soon as possible," she said. "It's also really important that they work with RANZCOG and others to support application of it across the sector, and for the benefit of the 120,000 New Zealanders living with endometriosis." A Health Ministry spokesperson said it was "grateful for the important work that RANZCOG has undertaken in developing these guidelines to support clinical care in this important aspect of women's health". "These guidelines represent a valuable resource, informing clinicians of evidence regarding diagnosis, management and care of people living with endometriosis. "Health New Zealand has established processes, through clinical networks and health pathways, to consider clinical guidelines and how they might influence on clinical service delivery to achieve better outcomes for New Zealanders." Health NZ national chief medical officer Professor Dame Helen Stokes-Lampard said clinical guidelines and health pathways were reviewed regularly. "Our immediate focus is on urgent patients and those who have been waiting the longest for treatment," she said. "We continue to work hard to put in place systems and processes, so improvements to waiting times are made." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
