Bloemfontein Celtic identity crisis: revival or rivalry?
Marumo Gallants Fans/Bloemfontein Celtic fans during the Betway Premiership 2024/25 football match against Kaizer Chiefs at Free State Stadium, Bloemfontein on 14 September 2024 @Gavin Barker/BackpagePix
Now that the dust has settled and SuperSport United's demise is officially confirmed, it's time to address the elephant in the room.
Will the real Bloemfontein Celtic please stand up? The curious state of affairs in trying to revive the club would be funny if it wasn't this confusing to all football lovers in the Free State province.
ALSO READ: Sundowns unveil home and away kits for 2025/26 season
The PSL status formerly held by United has been acquired by a new entity, Siwelele FC, backed by a Bloemfontein-based consortium led by Calvin Le John, son of Sports, Arts and Culture Minister Gayton McKenzie.
Celtic in Tshwane
The club is set to play its 2025/26 Betway Premiership campaign out of Lucas Moripe Stadium in Tshwane, and despite the change in location, it is already positioning itself as the spiritual successor to the original Celtic.
Mckenzie has publicly shared his family's emotional connection to the club, with the outspoken sports minister once revealing, 'The only time my father hugged me was when Celtic scored a goal.' While the minister insists he will not interfere in club matters while in office, his influence looms large over the project.
However, the situation is far from clear-cut. Edward Modise, a Free State businessman, has legally acquired the naming rights to Bloemfontein Celtic from former owner Max Tshabalala.
In an interview with Radio 2000's Thabiso Mosia, Modise outlined plans to purchase a Motsepe Foundation Championship status and restore the Celtic brand through promotion, rather than top-flight acquisition.
This has left some supporters in a state of confusion. Should they rally behind Siwelele FC, who have a PSL status but no official claim to the Celtic name, or wait for Modise's version, rooted in Free State and built from the ground up?
ALSO READ: Ex-Pirates star compares Nkota to Bale
Social media activity suggests Siwelele FC has already begun engaging with fans, holding community meetings and using club iconography. Yet, the legitimacy of this effort remains in question given that the actual naming rights reside with Modise.
Tug-of-war
It's a tug-of-war for heritage, identity and fan loyalty. It threatens to further fracture a supporter base already left heartbroken by the club's earlier sale. Instead of a long-awaited return, Celtic fans are now watching two rival visions pulling in different directions.
Siwelele FC will open their premiership campaign against Golden Arrows while the true revival of Bloemfontein Celtic remains in limbo. The question remains, where does this leave the loyal Phunya Sele Sele faithful? Who do they back, Le John's Siwelele FC, or Modise's bid to bring back the real Celtic?
What happens if Modise follows through and secures a status in the NFD? The naming rights legally belong to him, and a potential clash seems inevitable. At this stage, it's difficult to speak of a true revival when two camps claim the same legacy but are pulling in opposite directions.
ALSO READ: Banyana star Salgado on the mend after successful surgery
For now, the light at the end of the tunnel looks increasingly more like an oncoming train. Once again, the fans risk ending up on the wrong side of a messy collision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
13 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Nabi says Chiefs could sign more as Betway Prem kicks off
'If you have a good opportunity, why not?,' Nabi told journalists this week Nasreddine Nabi says Kaizer Chiefs have certainly not closed the door on more new signings before the transfer window shuts. ALSO READ: Sundowns' Cardoso backs young Mabena to step up Amakhosi will kick off their Betway Premiership campaign against Stellenbosch at Athlone Stadium on Sunday. Chiefs' Nabi – 'More to the table' The transfer window, however, only closes on September 22. 'The window is not closed. I think if we have opportunities, our scouting team will do the work. If you have a good opportunity, why not?,' Nabi told journalists this week at the Betway Premiership launch in Sandton. 'But I'm looking for a player who brings more to the table, not someone who offers the same qualities as those we already have.' One player heavily linked with a move to Chiefs is striker Etiosa Ighodaro. There were eyebrows raised when a video announcing Ighodaro was seemingly leaked on social media, as the player is still contracted to Mamelodi Sundowns. 'That player belongs to another team … but he or another striker that we put on our transfer list will be welcomed,' Nabi told reporters. 'For now, we will wait to hear. I saw the player you are asking about last season, he was playing for AmaZulu, and I believe he's a good player. But he's a player that doesn't belong to our club, and we can't say much about it.' Of the players Chiefs have signed, it remains to be seen how many take to the field on Sunday in their first official appearance for the club. Nkanyiso Shinga, Thabiso Monyane and Flavio Da Silva were the three new signings who started the Toyota Cup clash with Ghana's Asante Kotoko. Stellenbosch, meanwhile, lost three times to Chiefs last season, but Steve Barker's side generally fared far better than Amakhosi, finishing third in the Premiership table. Stellies exits Stellies have again had their share of departures. Fawaaz Basadien has joined Sundowns, midfielder Sihle Ndluli has moved to Pirates and defenders Olivier Toure and Tymon Smith have gone overseas, to name a few. Barker's side, however, have also brought in some new faces, like Belgian centre back Henry Stanic, while Bradley Mojela is back and available after a long-term injury. ALSO READ: Barker sees benefits in early Chiefs clash 'He is also like a new signing, he was out for nine months. He showed what he can do at the beginning of last season … it is good to have him back,' said Barker.
The Citizen
13 minutes ago
- The Citizen
For the PSL to regain its edge, competitiveness must come first
There's an urgent need to bring back the competitive edge and excitement that once defined local football. The excitement ahead of the 2025/26 Betway Premiership season will mean very little if teams fail to deliver on the pitch. Judging by the strong attendance at last weekend's MTN8 quarter-finals, particularly at a packed Orlando Stadium and a lively Lucas Moripe Stadium, fans are clearly eager for the return of domestic football. The PSL needs more entertainment The sold out encounter between Pirates and Polokwane City was proof that the football-loving public could hardly wait for the new season to begin. Now, it's over to the players and coaches to honour their side of the bargain, and that means playing entertaining football. Goals, not goalless draws, should be the order of the day. ALSO READ: Barker sees benefits in early Chiefs clash 16 goals were scored across the four MTN8 quarter-finals, setting a high standard ahead of this weekend's league fixtures. Goals are the lifeblood of the beautiful game, and while modern football has often seen teams prioritising survival over style, there's an urgent need to bring back the competitive edge and excitement that once defined local football. One of the standout matches was undoubtedly Sekhukhune United's 3–2 win over TS Galaxy. It was a five-goal thriller in which Babina Noko came from two goals down in a spirited comeback. It was a pulsating contest that reminded us just how exciting the local game can be when teams play without fear. Another dramatic encounter came in the tie between Stellenbosch FC and AmaZulu. The game ended in a 2–2 draw after 90 minutes before Stellies edged it 3–2 in extra time. These are the sort of encounters that inject life into the local game. Fans want more than just tactical discipline or defensive football , they want goals, drama, and excitement. ALSO READ: 'It was a dream debut' – Basadien wants more game time at Downs Both Pirates and Mamelodi Sundowns proved too strong for their respective opponents in City and Richards Bay, but overall, the MTN8 quarter-finals were a good advert for South African football. The challenge, however, lies in maintaining this momentum, especially among clubs outside the so-called 'big three'. Step up so-called smaller teams It's crucial that so-called smaller teams also become regular attractions. For that to happen, the overall standard of football must improve, and clubs need to embrace a more expansive and entertaining approach I remember the days when Golden Arrows were revered for their slick passing football. Free State Stars and Black Leopards also had distinctive styles and fans could name their starting XI with relative ease. Gone are those days because the entertainment aspect has been replaced by a survival-first mentality. Clubs are focused on clinging to their top-flight status, often at the expense of being competitive. Another one-horse race? Unless this trend changes, the ongoing debate around the declining competitiveness of the PSL will continue. With Sundowns chasing a record-extending ninth consecutive league title, the onus is on the rest to step up and make the league more than just a one-horse race. ALSO READ: Mariko reflects on memorable Orlando Pirates debut The fans have shown up and it's now it's time for teams to do the same by being brave and playing attacking football. That will hopefully bring back the magic of the local game.
The Citizen
42 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Sundowns' Cardoso backs young Mabena to step up
'He also played too much for the public but he can't do that, he'll have to learn to make his own decisions,' said Cardoso. As the 2025–26 Betway Premiership campaign kicks off this weekend, Mamelodi Sundowns head coach Miguel Cardoso believes this could be the season rising star Siyabonga Mabena truly comes of age. Sundowns' young goalscorer After a lengthy injury layoff, the 18-year-old came off the bench in the MTN8 quarter-final match against Richards Bay to round off the scoring in a comprehensive 4–0 victory for the Brazilians. ALSO READ: Mngqithi – we are all gunning for Cardoso's Sundowns Mabena's goal sparked wild celebrations, both in the stands and on the Sundowns bench, with Cardoso sprinting to the corner flag to embrace the teenager. The Portuguese coach gave an honest assessment of Mabena's impactful cameo appearance after Sundowns booked their place in the semi-finals of the Top 8 competition, where they will face Orlando Pirates. 'It's time for him to try and that's how he will learn by watching videos on what he could have done. I'm happy for him how he played after entering the game,' Cardoso said of the rising talent. 'Just like Kutlwano (Letlhaku), I hope in the future we can give more opportunities but it's important that they embrace the behaviours that we want for the team. 'Playing them allows us to try things that we have been working on for the future. I'm happy for him and I also celebrated in a special way because the boy needed this.' Despite Mabena's immense talent, he tends to over-elaborate, using his pace and dribbling skills to entertain the crowd. Cardoso, a well-travelled coach with extensive experience in youth development, believes the fan-favourite needs to improve in some key aspects of his game. 'We should also understand the role of a young player and the role of a group when we have young players in terms of supporting them to grow and the role of a coach in order to support young players,' Cardoso concluded. 'Too much for the public' 'Young players will succeed if the teams are strong. It's easy for them to enter in contexts like this because Mabena made wonderful things but he also made mistakes. 'He also played too much for the public but he can't do that, he'll have to learn to make his own decisions and not be influenced by people who are cheering for his dribbles because football is not played that way.' Masandawana will be away to Chippa United at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium as they begin the official defence of their premiership title on Saturday. ALSO READ: Nabi promises better Chiefs season as Betway Premiership launches Kick-off against the Chilli Boys is scheduled for 3pm on Saturday. Chippa are under the guidance of former Sundowns youth coach Sinethemba Badela who took over from Thabo September.
