Appeals court confirms that tracking-based online advertising is illegal in Europe
The Belgian Court of Appeal ruled today that the Transparency and Consent Framework (TCF) currently used as the foundation for most online advertising is illegal in the EU. This decision upholds the findings of the Belgian Data Protection Authority from 2022 that the technology underpinning online ads violates several principles of the General Data Protection Regulations , an EU digital privacy law that took effect in 2018.
Engadget's Daniel Cooper wrote a thorough explainer of the different systems that support the current online advertising ecosystem, which is valuable reading for anybody spending time online. The very simplified version is that advertisers participate in real-time bidding (RTB) to show their content online. Currently, those bids are based on information gathered from tracking individuals' activities online with cookies. The TCF was created by the Interactive Advertising Bureau as a way to standardize how websites ask users for permission to be tracked. The original 2022 decision determined that both the consent collected by the TCF and the data collected in the RTB process were illegal under the GDPR.
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
"Today's court's decision shows that the consent system used by Google, Amazon, X, Microsoft, deceives hundreds of millions of Europeans," said Dr Johnny Ryan, director of Enforce at the Irish Council for Civil Liberties, who has been leading the legal charge against the current approach to ad tech. "The tech industry has sought to hide its vast data breach behind sham consent popups. Tech companies turned the GDPR into a daily nuisance rather than a shield for people."
The reaction from IAB Europe, which filed the appeal, seems to mostly be relief that it hasn't been found responsible for the data collected by TCF. "The Market Court has rejected the APD's view that IAB Europe is a joint controller together with TCF participants for their own respective processing of personal data, for instance for the purpose of digital advertising," the organization's statement says. IAB Europe notes that it has already suggested changes to the TCF that better reflect the "limited controllership" and submitted them to the Belgian Data Protection Authority. The group faced fines and was ordered to rebuild its current ad-tech framework as a result of the original decision.
We've also reached out to some of the major advertisers that use the RTB technology for comment on the ruling.
While this does seem like a big win for privacy advocates and internet users in the EU, it's unclear exactly what the next steps will be for advertisers and for ad tech systems. Most likely, regulators will oversee changes the IAB Europe makes to the TCF, so consent pop-ups may not yet be a thing of the past.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
EU Eyes Capital Relief for Insurers to Spur Asset-Backed Market
The European Commission is considering reducing the capital that insurers must hold against investments in asset-backed securities, part of a broader effort to revive a €1.2 trillion ($1.4 trillion) market that can finance areas like housing, energy, and defense. The reduction would be as much as 40% in some cases, according to a document being discussed with a panel of experts, with the size of the cut depending on the credit rating and whether the transaction complies with a framework for securitizations.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
European Commission gives fiscal verdicts for member states, with defence looming large
The European Commission delivered its Spring Package on Wednesday, an economic update that feeds into its five-year plan to boost the EU's resilience and includes country-specific recommendations. While fiscal responsibility remains important, the Commission underlined a need to boost defence capabilities. This comes not only in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, but also increased hostility from Washington. US President Donald Trump has continually warned Europe that it needs to increase financial contributions to guarantee its own security. 'Amid rising security challenges, the national escape clause (NEC) under the Stability and Growth Pact is also drawn upon for the first time,' said the Commission. The NEC allows member states to temporarily exceed maximum growth rates of net expenditure to boost defence financing. A total of 16 countries asked the Commission to implement this mechanism, specifically: Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czechia, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia and Slovenia. Related MEPs oppose Commission's overhaul of EU budget after 2027 'Choices need to be made': EU Commission to propose simpler, more focused long-term budget Wednesday's Package also outlined country-specific recommendations to ensure that EU members are on track to boost their economic standing. 'Member States are encouraged to boost their competitiveness by closing the innovation gap, advancing decarbonisation in line with the Clean Industrial Deal, reducing excessive dependencies, increasing security and resilience, including by building up defence capabilities and promoting skills and quality jobs while ensuring social fairness,' said the Commission. While 12 member states are considered to be 'compliant' in terms of medium-term spending plans, the Commission flagged Cyprus, Ireland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands as countries that could overshoot fiscal limits. Portugal and Spain were considered to be 'broadly compliant'. The Commission noted that Austria, on the other hand, will face a formal procedure to bring its deficit back under control. Romania was another member state rebuked in the report. 'Romania's net expenditure growth is significantly above the ceiling set by its corrective path, posing clear risks to correcting its excessive deficit by 2030,' said the Commission. 'The Commission is therefore recommending that the Council adopt a decision that establishes Romania has not taken effective action.'
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Bulgaria Poised to Join Euro Zone After Winning EU Support
The euro-zone is poised to welcome its 21st member: Bulgaria, a nation of 6.4 million, today won the European Commission's backing to adopt the common currency in 2026. Necessary criteria including inflation and public debt have been fulfilled, according to the Commission and the European Central Bank. Joining the euro-zone would cap an effort that started as early as in 2007, when Bulgaria joined the European Union. There's still work to be done — EU governments, along with the European Parliament, must also give their blessing, and Bulgaria was urged by the ECB to fulfill requirements of the Financial Action Task Force. There's also opposition at home. Bulgaria's pro-Russia president, Rumen Radev, has called the decision into question. And the nationalist Revival party has been seeking a referendum in an attempt to delay accession indefinitely. — The US is refusing to provide air defenses to back a 'reassurance force' the UK and France are planning in a postwar Ukraine, we're told. British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has insisted such a US backstop is necessary to deter Russia from breaching any future ceasefire deal, but European allies have concluded that Donald Trump won't provide the guarantees they have sought. The UK and France remain hopeful the US will continue to provide intelligence as well as surveillance of the border between Ukraine and Russia, sources tell us.
