U.S. fugitive arrested in Toronto led double life as 'psychic'
Patrick Lutts Jr. faces manslaughter charges stemming from a drunk-driving crash that killed two teens in Orlando on Christmas Day 1998.
Lutts, 51, vanished after skipping a plea hearing in 2003, only to later re-emerge in Toronto as a self-styled psychic and host of a local bar's monthly trivia night, according to court records and online posts reviewed by CBC.
Lutts' online presence in recent years paints the picture of a man with a busy social life. A horror movie aficionado, he enjoyed ski trips, rock concerts and frequent drinks with friends.
There's no sign his acquaintances in Toronto knew anything about his status as a wanted man, or the early-morning crash that killed 19-year-old Nancy Lopez and her boyfriend Darvin Javier DeJesus-Taboada, 18.
According to investigators, the couple were thrown several metres when Lutts — with a "strong odor of alcohol coming from his breath" after a night of drinking — slammed his pickup truck into their vehicle.
Lutts was found to have had a blood-alcohol level of 0.272 — more than three times the legal limit.
"He didn't even call to apologize or to say I'm sorry," Lopez's mother Nelida Leon told Orlando's WFTV in 2014. The family was clinging to hope that Lutts would one day be found.
"If he doesn't get justice here," Leon said at the time, "God's going to punish this guy."
Toronto police spokesperson Stephanie Sayer confirmed the agency's fugitive squad arrested Lutts on Feb. 26 "on the strength of an arrest warrant issued under the Canadian Extradition Act." He's scheduled to appear in a downtown court later this month.
Anonymous tips led police to fugitive
An anonymous tip to a Crime Stoppers-type service in Florida in November 2023 first led authorities to suspect Lutts may be in Canada, according to a summary of state prosecutors' evidence in the case, filed in Ontario Superior Court as part of extradition proceedings.
Lutts was placed under surveillance and police determined he was living in a high-rise apartment building in Toronto's Church and Wellesley area.
It's unclear how – or when – Lutts came to Canada. According to Ontario court files, he has no legal status in the country and the Canada Border Services Agency has no record of his entry.
Lutts tried to cross the border from New York to Niagara Falls, Ont., on Sept. 29, 2003 — two days before a key court hearing — but was turned away due to the criminal charges in Florida, according to a police affidavit.
A Toronto resident with Lutts' name appears on a list of participants in a local 10-kilometre run in May 2005, suggesting Lutts may have settled in the city by then, while openly using his real name. Florida authorities had already been on the lookout for him for a year and a half.
In recent years, Lutts appears to have avoided using his real name online. He instead went by the alias Pat Lighthelp, including on LifeReader, a platform for "psychic readings." Lutts' public profile shows he charged $4.50 US per minute to chat with clients and provide relationship help and life coaching.
"As an empathic and intuitive psychic reader," Lutts wrote, "I specialize in providing direct insight and clarity to matters of the heart, particularly when it comes to love and relationships."
Once a month, Lutts co-hosted a popular horror-themed trivia night at a bar in Toronto's 2SLGBTQ+ neighbourhood and frequently promoted the event on Facebook.
Lutts evaded police before
Lutts has a history of evading arrest.
By the time Florida prosecutors laid DUI manslaughter charges against him for the 1998 incident, Lutts was already nowhere to be found. He surfaced again in 2002 after authorities said he was involved in another impaired-driving crash in Connecticut, according to court files.
Lutts was arrested and sent back to Florida, where he posted a $5,000 US bond and was released from custody. Public records show Lutts failed to appear for a plea hearing scheduled for Oct. 1, 2003 and remained on the lam until his recent arrest in Toronto.
"Our office is actively working on extraditing Patrick Lutts back to Florida," a spokesperson for state attorney Monique H. Worrell said in a brief email to CBC.
Canada's Justice Department, which handles extradition requests, declined to comment on the case. A Florida-based lawyer who previously represented Lutts did not respond to requests for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
Friends and family of Andrew Cristillo call for legislative changes in the wake of deadly crash
Toronto Watch Friends and family of Andrew Cristillo are calling for legislative changes in the wake of his death by what authorities allege is a repeat dangerous driver. CTV's Jon Woodward reports.
CTV News
8 hours ago
- CTV News
Thieves grab US$2 million in jewellery in Seattle heist that took less than two minutes
Suspects stole over US$2 million from a jewelry store in Seattle. SEATTLE — Smash-and-grab thieves in Seattle made off with an estimated US$2 million in diamonds, luxury watches, gold and other items in a daring midday jewellery store robbery that took just about 90 seconds, police said Friday. Video from the West Seattle store's surveillance cameras shows four masked suspects shattering the locked glass front door with hammers and then ransacking six display cases Thursday. One display held around US$750,000 worth in Rolex watches, police said in a statement, and another had an emerald necklace valued at US$125,000. A masked suspect threatened workers with bear spray and a Taser, police said, but no one was injured. 'We're pretty shook up as a staff,' Josh Menashe, vice president of the family-owned store, said by phone Friday. 'We're gonna be closed for a while.' Menashe said workers finished cleaning up the broken glass and were working on a full inventory of the losses. Police said they responded to the robbery but the suspects had already fled in a getaway car and eluded a search of the area. Cedar Attanasio, The Associated Press
Globe and Mail
8 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Trump administration agrees to leave D.C. police chief in charge after court hearing
The Trump administration on Friday reversed course and agreed to leave the Washington, D.C., police chief in control of department after a court hearing. Attorney General Pam Bondi, in a new memo, directed the District's police to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement 'notwithstanding' city law. Earlier on Friday, officials in the nation's capital sued to block President Donald Trump's takeover of the Washington police, hours after his administration escalated its intervention into the city's law enforcement by naming a federal official as the new emergency head of the department. The District of Columbia's police chief said Trump's move would threaten law and order by upending the command structure. 'In my nearly three decades in law enforcement, I have never seen a single government action that would cause a greater threat to law and order than this dangerous directive,' Chief Pamela Smith said in a court filing. The legal battle was the latest evidence of the escalating tensions in a mostly Democratic city that now has its police department under the control of the Republican president's administration that exists in its midst. Trump's takeover is historic, yet it had played out with a slow ramp-up in federal law enforcement officials and National Guard troops to start the week. As the weekend approached, though, signs across the city – from the streets to the legal system − suggested a deepening crisis over who controls the city's immigration and policing policies, the district's right to govern itself and daily life for the millions of people who live and work in the metro area. After a court hearing on the district's request for a temporary restraining order against sidelining Smith, the Trump administration and city officials seemed to be nearing a temporary agreement. The city's top lawyer, Brian Schwalb, told reporters he expects the federal government to agree that the city police chief would remain in charge of the department. The two sides sparred in court for hours Friday before U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, who is overseeing the lawsuit. She indicated the law likely doesn't grant the Trump administration power to fully take over city police, but it probably does give the president more power than the city might like. 'The way I read the statute, the president can ask, the mayor must provide, but the president can't control,' said Reyes, who was nominated to the bench by Democratic President Joe Biden. The judge asked the two sides to hammer out a compromise, but promised to issue a court order temporarily blocking the administration from naming a new chief if they couldn't agree. An attorney for the Trump administration, Yaakov Roth, said in court that the move to sideline Smith came after an immigration order that still held back some aid to federal authorities. He argued that the president has broad authority to determine what kind of help police in Washington must provide. Washington officials were pushing in court to halt U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi's order Thursday to put the head of the Drug Enforcement Administration, Terry Cole, in charge of Washington police. The police takeover is the latest move by Trump to test the limits of his legal authorities to carry out his agenda, relying on obscure statutes and a supposed state of emergency to bolster his tough-on-crime message and his plans to speed up the mass deportation of people in the United States illegally. It also marks one of the most sweeping assertions of federal authority over a local government in modern times. While Washington has grappled with spikes in violence and visible homelessness, the city's homicide rate ranks below those of several other major U.S. cities, and the capital is not in the throes of the public safety collapse the Trump administration has portrayed. The president has more power over the nation's capital than other cities, but D.C. has elected its own mayor and city council since the Home Rule Act was signed in 1973. Trump is the first president to exert control over the city's police force since it was passed. The law limits that control to 30 days without congressional approval, though Trump has suggested he'd seek to extend it. Bondi's directive came even after Smith had told MPD officers hours earlier to share information with immigration agencies regarding people not in custody, such as someone involved in a traffic stop or checkpoint. The Justice Department said Bondi disagreed with the police chief's directive because it allowed for continued practice of 'sanctuary policies,' which generally limit cooperation by local law enforcement with federal immigration officers. Bondi said she was rescinding that order and other MPD policies limiting inquiries into immigration status and preventing arrests based solely on federal immigration warrants. All new directives must now receive approval from Cole, Bondi said. Washington Mayor Muriel Bowser pushed back Thursday, writing on social media 'there is no statute that conveys the District's personnel authority to a federal official.' Meanwhile, immigrant advocates in Washington were trying to advise immigrants on how to respond to the new policies. Anusce Sanai, associate legal director for the Washington-based immigrant nonprofit Ayuda, said they're still parsing the legal aspects of the policies. 'Even with the most anti-immigrant administration, we would always tell our clients that they must call the police, that they should call the police,' Sanai said. 'But now we find ourselves that we have to be very careful on what we advise.' Amy Fischer, an organizer with Migrant Solidarity Mutual Aid, said that before the federal takeover, most of what they had seen in the nation's capital was Immigration and Customs Enforcement targeting specific individuals. But since last Friday night they've seen a 'really significant change,' she said, with ICE and federal officers doing roving patrols around the city. She said a hotline set up by immigration advocates to report ICE activity 'is receiving calls almost off the hook.' ICE said in a post on X that their teams had arrested 'several' people in Washington Friday. A video posted on X showed two uniformed personnel putting handcuffs on someone while standing outside a white transport van. A population already tense from days of ramp-up has begun seeing more significant shows of force across the city. National Guard troops watched over some of the world's most renowned landmarks, and Humvees took position in front of the busy main train station. Volunteers helped homeless people leave long-standing encampments – to where was often unclear. Twenty federal law enforcement teams had fanned out across the city Thursday night with more than 1,750 people joining the operation, said a White House official, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss the operation. They made 33 arrests, including 15 migrants who did not have permanent legal status, the official said. Others were arrested on warrants for murder, rape and driving under the influence. Department of Homeland Security police stood outside Nationals Park during a game Thursday between the Washington Nationals and the Philadelphia Phillies. DEA agents patrolled The Wharf, a popular nightlife area, while Secret Service officers were seen in the Foggy Bottom neighborhood. As the District challenged the Trump administration in court Friday, more than 100 protesters gathered less than a block away in front of police headquarters for a rally, chanting 'Protect home rule!' and waving signs saying 'Resist!'
