Security regulator warns against hospital security guards doubling as cleaners
Concerns have been raised about hospital security guards doubling as cleaners.
Photo:
123RF
Security guards at two rural hospitals are doubling as cleaners, leading to concerns about the safety of patients and hospital staff.
The integrated model meant ISS Facility Services Limited's employees contracted to do security work at Health New Zealand-operated hospitals in Te Kūiti and Tokoroa could also pick up cleaning and orderlies duties on the same shift.
The model was highlighted in a recent Private Security Personnel Licensing Authority (PSPLA) decision in which the head of the authority, Trish McConnell, raised concerns about the dual workload.
"...where a security threat arises, the sooner appropriately trained security guards respond, the more likely it is for the situation to be resolved without serious harm," McConnell wrote.
"If the security guard is working in another part of the hospital as a cleaner or orderly when a security risk arises, there are likely to be delays in them being able to respond and remove the person or deescalate the incident.
"This has the potential of putting staff and other members of the public at greater risk of harm."
McConnell's concerns were prompted by a report by Department of Internal Affairs' Complaints Investigation and Prosecution Unit (CIPU) which received an unrelated complaint about ISS and its security licenses.
The basis of the licensing complaint was later found to be a misunderstanding by the company and a penalty was not issued.
CIPU diverged from the complaint in its report and addressed the dual working model.
It said that it wasn't illegal but a legislative change should be made.
Echoing CIPU's concerns, McConnell said in her decision that the model reduced the effectiveness of security guards and "has potential health and safety risks".
"The integrated model used in ISS's contract with Health New Zealand fails to recognise the key preventative role security guards play in hospital security by merely being present in waiting areas, emergency departments and other areas where pressure can be high," she said.
"Just having a security guard visibly on duty can significantly reduce security situations arising and volatile situations escalating."
The dual model was a practice the New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO) also described as being a risk to patients and hospital staff.
"Every nurse has the right to go home safe from work, and patients shouldn't be injured in hospitals," NZNO health and safety spokesperson John Crocker told NZME.
"Healthcare workers suffer disproportionate violence at work, and Te Whatu Ora has moral and legal obligations to keep them safe."
Crocker said in some rural towns, police staffing was often limited, so hospitals relied on the protection of security guards while on shift.
McConnell said the PSPLA did not have the jurisdiction to limit the scope of someone's contract.
But she suggested HNZ considered her comments in its contracting arrangements.
Stephanie Doe, HNZ director of operations for hospital and specialist services in the Waikato, said while the integrated model was still in place at the hospitals, opportunities were being explored to adjust it, particularly around the overnight shifts.
"We will actively engage with our teams and unions to support people to feel safe at work, with a view to implementing changes over the next month."
Doe said security staff at Tokoroa and Te Kūiti hospitals were on site around the clock and were in the vicinity of the emergency department and ward at night.
-This story originally appeared in the
New Zealand Herald
.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gynaecological cancer patients forced to travel from Wellington to Christchurch for surgery
Health New Zealand has confirmed that more than 100 women with gynaecological cancer in Wellington must travel to Christchurch for surgery. Photo: 123RF Health New Zealand has confirmed that more than 100 women with gynaecological cancer in Wellington must travel to Christchurch for surgery. Chief Medical Officer of Capital Coast and Hutt Valley, Andre Cromhout, confirmed that Wellington Hospital's sole gynaeoncologist - who left the service in November last year - would not be replaced. In a bid to "better utilise available clinical expertise", Health New Zealand was consolidating its services, he said. It means gynaecological oncology surgery over the next four to five years, would take place "mainly in Christchurch and Auckland". Cromhout said the result was that 130 women per year in the central region - Wellington, Hutt Valley, Wairarapa, MidCentral, Whanganui, Taranaki and Hawke's Bay - would have to travel to Christchurch to receive more complex care. He said there would be help with the logistical and financial challenges, but recognised "having to travel to Christchurch for treatment will be a significant inconvenience to many women and their families who are already distressed". He said annually more than 600 women in the central region received gynae-oncology support and some surgery would still take place once-a-month in Wellington when a Christchurch-based gynaecological oncologist visited. Other services, such as medical and radiation oncology and specialist nursing support for gynaecological oncology patients would also continue, he said. "Our focus remains on ensuring we minimise the travel for patients and their families as much as possible. Work is underway to consider the best long-term approach for delivering gynaecological oncology services in the future. "We don't anticipate that the decision to shift more acute surgeries from Wellington to Christchurch will materially affect wait times. These wait times will continue to be monitored." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Drag racing-loving teen Katie Iti dies from flu complications
Katie Iti's passion was drag racing. Photo: Supplied The father of a Lower Hutt teenager who died in hospital with flu symptoms says she had only been unwell for a few days. Shayne Iti said his 15-year-old daughter Katie Margaret Iti died on Saturday in Hutt Hospital from complications of influenza B. "She fell ill probably Tuesday last week and just was getting slightly worse over the few days - we were just monitoring her at home," he said. "And then I woke up early Saturday morning to hear her moaning and groaning and I was like 'I can't see my baby like this anymore, let's go to the hospital'." Iti said Katie was seen by a cardiologist and a surgeon, and tests found fluid around her heart. He thought she appeared to improve over the day and another scan confirmed the fluid had not increased. But 13 hours after her arrival, Katie suddenly deteriorated and her heart stopped, Iti said. "She was gone. I was with her right up until the end." Iti said Katie's passion was drag racing and she had completed her first season of racing her own car. She became interested in the motorsport after she and Iti began helping his boss build a drag racing car. After that Katie was hooked, going to 'the drags' as often as she could, an enthusiasm also supported by mum Jamie Halse. "She started getting quite friendly with all the junior drag racers because it's quite big - the scene," Iti said. "She always wanted her own car and started jumping into people's cars and sitting in them and dreaming about having one, one day." When it became known that Katie wanted to 'go down the strip', 2022 New Zealand Super Street Champion Cindy Mendoza took her for the ride. "It spiralled on from there because she wanted to do it herself," Iti said. "I used to say to her 'No, you can't have one, we can't really afford it' but then she'd go round the pits talking to all the other adults telling them to 'Go tell my Dad to get me a drag car' and, of course, everyone was always in my ear about getting her a car so we made it happen." Iti taught Katie to drive the manuel racing car when she was 14, starting off on grass and then in a carpark. Once she mastered it, the then-Year 10 Naenae College student competed in her first race in October, racing the entire season. Katie's car. Photo: Supplied Though Katie had no siblings, Iti described her as "a sister to everyone" and said the drag racing community had been hard hit by her death. "They're all struggling. Everyone's trying to lean against each other just 'cos they're all struggling," he said. "Everyone's in complete disbelief. I'm still in disbelief. I'm still expecting her to jump out and give me a fright. "We can't even stay in our own house at the moment because it just feels so empty." Iti said the drag racing community would take cars to Katie's funeral in Wainuiomata on Thursday and there would be a tribute to the teen's love of the sport. Online tributes had been flowing with descriptions of Katie as a "beautiful soul" who was always happy, smiling, respectful, fun and entertaining. A girl with a passion for drag racing and life, one person wrote. "In life and in our sport you meet lots of different people , some leave a lasting memory when they are gone and Katie Iti was one of those," another person wrote on the Wild Bunch New Zealand Facebook page. "Her raw passion and enthusiasm was genuine and unwavering and her love of our sport and those in it knew no bounds. "Personally thank you Katie for all the messages and gifts and for just being yourself in amongst a sea of testosterone and competitiveness you proved the sport is so much more than that..." Online tributes had been flowing with descriptions of Katie as a "beautiful soul" who was always happy, smiling, respectful, fun and entertaining. Photo: Supplied Iti said some online reports that Katie had died in a drag racing event were incorrect. "The season's over. It has been for quite some time." He said Katie had the best safety equipment possible and they had never had any incidents while racing. Iti said Katie's driving partner Azaliya would continue her legacy, and keep racing the number 109 car. Health New Zealand said without a privacy waiver it could not confirm if Katie's death was referred to the Coroner or if Hutt Hospital was conducting a review. Iti said Katie's initial symptoms appeared to be routine - an achy body, runny nose, and cough - and his message to other families was to get vaccinated. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Health NZ board re-established by government
Health New Zealand commissioner Lester Levy will chair the new governance board for the next year. Photo: RNZ / Nick Monro The government is re-establishing the Health New Zealand governance board, putting current commissioner Lester Levy in charge. The board was axed a year ago, when the government said it had serious concerns about oversight and a budget blow-out. Levy was then brought in to lead the agency, saying his priorities were reducing wait times and improving productivity . Health Minister Simeon Brown said under Levy's leadership as commissioner, Health New Zealand had delivered a strong financial plan, and a clear health delivery plan was now in place. "He is refocusing the organisation on patients and driving progress on the government's health targets, which are seeing waitlists reduced," Brown said. Brown said Levy would chair the new board for a 12 month term to ensure continuity of leadership. He said he would begin a nomination process later this year for a permanent chair to take effect from July next year. Other key appointments announced by the minister: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.