Judge rejects Trump administration effort to unseal Epstein grand jury records in Florida
U.S. District Judge Robin Rosenberg in West Palm Beach said the request to release grand jury documents from 2005 and 2007 did not meet any of the extraordinary exceptions under federal law that could make them public.
The Justice Department last week asked the judge to release records to quell a storm among supporters of President Donald Trump who believe there was a conspiracy to protect Epstein's clients, conceal videos of crimes being committed and other evidence.
In 2008, Epstein cut a deal with federal prosecutors in Florida that allowed him to escape more severe federal charges and instead plead guilty to state charges of procuring a person under 18 for prostitution and solicitation of prostitution.
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche had asked judges in Florida and New York to unseal transcripts from grand jury proceedings that resulted in indictments against Epstein and former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell, saying 'transparency to the American public is of the utmost importance to this Administration.'
Federal grand juries hear evidence in secret and then decide whether there is enough for an indictment. Experts say the transcripts likely would not reveal much because prosecutors typically are trying only to present enough material to get charges and don't introduce the entire investigation.
Epstein, a wealthy financier, years later was arrested in 2019 on federal sex trafficking charges, while Maxwell was charged with helping him abuse teenage girls.
Epstein was found dead in his cell at a federal jail in New York City about a month after he was arrested. Investigators concluded he killed himself. Maxwell later was convicted at trial and sentenced to 20 years in prison.
The case attracted attention because of Epstein and Maxwell's links to famous people, including royals, presidents and billionaires. It also led to some of the biggest conspiracy theories animating Trump's base.
The furor over records has been stoked by the Justice Department. In February, far-right influencers were invited to the White House and provided with binders marked 'The Epstein Files: Phase 1' and 'Declassified.' The binders contained documents that had largely already been in the public domain.
The department on July 7 acknowledged that Epstein did not have a list of clients. It also said no more files related to his case would be made public.
A two-page memo that bore the logos of the FBI and Justice Department, but that was not signed by any individual, said the department determined that no 'further disclosure would be appropriate or warranted.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
20 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘Let them destroy each other': Democrats planning Epstein-focused town halls in GOP districts
Democrats are once again planning a blitz of town hall meetings in Republican-led communities, though this time they are armed with a new and polarizing topic: Jeffrey Epstein. The issue of the so-called 'Epstein files' — including the details of high-profile people associated with the disgraced financier and sex offender — continues to divide the GOP, with some calling for further transparency and others, including the president himself, urging people to move on. 'Let them destroy each other. If we have to throw a log on the fire, we'll do it,' one House Democratic aide told The Hill. Further fuel for such fires followed a report from The Wall Street Journal that revealed the alleged existence of a 'bawdy' 50th birthday card from Trump to Epstein. The president has denied the validity of the letter and has filed a $10 billion defamation lawsuit against right-wing media mogul Rupert Murdoch, WSJ 's parent company Dow Jones and the two journalists whose bylines appear on the story. During the town halls, Democrats will reportedly attempt to marry the Epstein fallout with their previous attack lines, including broken promises by Trump and the GOP to lower costs for working families. Tax cuts and an apparent refusal to share information of those allegedly associated with Epstein demonstrate the GOP's protections for the super wealthy, Democratic officials argue. 'Everything that House Republicans have done, everything this administration has done since Donald Trump took office, is in defense of the elites,' Democratic whip Katherine Clark told The Hill. The outlet points to scheduled visits to Republican towns by Democrats in coming weeks. On July 31, Democratic Rep. Mark Pocan is scheduled to speak in Prairie du Chien, Wisconsin — the hometown of his GOP counterpart Derrick Van Orden. Florida Democrat Maxwell Frost has also planned a series of meetings, including a July 26 town hall in Dayton, Ohio, with Senator Chris Murphy, and another event with Senator Elizabeth Warren in Nebraska at the end of August. New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who launched a series of 'fighting oligarchy' rallies with Senator Bernie Sanders earlier this year, is also reportedly eyeing additional travel to Republican hotbeds while Congress is on its summer recess. The plans appear to already be rattling some Republicans. 'Democrats are still pretty determined to hijack our town halls and try to prevent us from having this conversation with our constituents, so I would encourage them to use other means,' National Republican Congressional Committee chair Richard Hudson told The Hill. Meanwhile, the Epstein saga shows no signs of slowing down after the financier's ex-girlfriend, British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, met with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche twice last week. During the in-depth interviews Maxwell answered questions about '100 different people,' her lawyer said. According to The New York Times, Maxwell has made it clear that in exchange for information she wants a reduction of her 20-year sentence or a pardon. When asked by reporters about a potential pardon for her, Trump replied: 'I'm allowed to do it, but it's something I haven't thought about.'
The Herald Scotland
20 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
No arrests made at anti-Trump demonstrations, police say
In Glasgow, a woman aged 49 was arrested at a 'mass deportation rally' led by Ukip's Nick Tenconi, which was met by a counter-protest in George Square. The woman, who was a counter-protester, was arrested in connection with an alleged obstruction of the police and a report will be submitted to the procurator fiscal. People take part in a Stop Trump Scotland protest outside the US consulate in Edinburgh (Jane Barlow/PA) Police Scotland said two arrests were made in Aberdeen at 'other events' on Saturday, but not at a huge anti-Trump demonstration in the city. A spokesperson said the force 'took action at demonstrations and protest events' but did not make any arrests at Trump rallies across the country. In Aberdeen, an 18-year-old man was arrested in connection with a number of outstanding warrants and will appear in court at a later date, according to Police Scotland. A 56-year-old man will be the subject of a report to the procurator fiscal after an alleged assault in Aberdeen city centre. Police Scotland said they could not give further details.
Scottish Sun
20 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Locals have their say as President Donald Trump visits sleepy Scots seaside village
The area is used to hosting big shots like Robert the Bruce MAKE AYRSHIRE GREAT AGAIN Locals have their say as President Donald Trump visits sleepy Scots seaside village THE sleepy seaside village of Maidens looked to be completely unaffected by the Presidential hullabaloo happening just along the coast — until two excited MAGA hat-wearing fans turned up. This was not a pair of US Trump supporters either as brother and sister Ben, 16, and Alicia Skilling, 15, had only travelled 30 miles from their home in Kilmarnock to try and catch a glimpse of their idol. 5 Brother and sister Ben, 16, and Alicia Skilling, 15, travelled 30 miles to try and catch a glimpse of Trump Credit: John Kirkby 5 Dave Carter, 86, reckons the US President has been a breath of fresh air for the area Credit: John Kirkby 5 Angela Bryce dreams of having an 'appointment' with the President one day Credit: John Kirkby Ben said: 'I would describe myself as a Trump fan for sure. I'm just back from Florida and wore my MAGA hat all the time. 'In Disney everyone kept saying to me 'nice hat'. I get a lot more stick over here for wearing it than I ever got in America.' However, sister Alicia is a less vocal Trump advocate, stretching only as far to say she thinks the US President is 'alright'. So why is she wearing a MAGA hat then? She sighs: 'Because he has four of them.' Their mum, student teacher Jacqueline Malone, 44, added: 'He even bought a Turnberry hat for £45 and Trump gold cufflinks, but he lost one of them at school.' The family head off with a long lens camera, desperate to snap a picture of Donald's arrival at his golf resort in Turnberry. But they were the only sign that in a few hours' time the leader of the free world would arrive by motorcade as the people of Maidens continued life at their normal laidback pace. Hosting big shots OAPs played bowls in the local bowling club, while kids squeals heard from the swing park as folk dined out on the balcony of Ropes Bistro. Then again historically this area has been used to hosting big shots. Donald Trump touches down in Scotland In 1307, Robert the Bruce landed in Maidens after sailing from Ireland — a stone's throw from his childhood home in Turnberry — accompanied by a small army of 300 men. No doubt The Bruce would have been impressed by the 6,000-strong battalion of officers drafted from across the country to protect The Donald. Strolling along the seafront I spotted a man with a Turnberry logo on his jacket, who turned out to be a caddie at the golf course. Not wishing to be named, he told me security had been ramped up since the last time Trump was President. He explained: 'Before you just had to show your work pass to get in, but since someone took a shot at him we've now got to go through airport scanners.' Chris Saunders, 61, from the charity Adventure Carrick, was also expecting to get the third degree as he arrived to take a class of disadvantaged kids paddleboarding on the Firth of Clyde. He added: 'There are roadblocks all around Turnberry but the way I heard it on the radio I was expecting to have a real problem getting here today — I even brought my ID in case I was asked. "Sure you see the odd police van about, but I just drove in no problem at all. There aren't even any protesters. It's pretty much as normal.' What also seems to be normal for these parts is the amount of dog walkers taking their pooches for a stroll. Retired sewage plant manager Dave Carter, 86, from Warrington, who has been holidaying here for the last 30 years, reckons the US President has been a breath of fresh air for the area. He says: 'Trump has been better than some of the daytrippers you get down here when the weather is nice. 'They leave a right mess behind. Turnberry was going to wrack and ruin until he took over. Play to his the gallery Commentary by Chris Musson, Associate Editor (Politics) KEIR Starmer and John Swinney will both meet Donald Trump in the next couple of days. But a chinwag with Trump can be a dangerous thing. Like trying to calm a temperamental toddler playing with the pin of a grenade. Just ask Volodymyr Zelensky. Though it bodes well for Starmer and Swinney that the Prez was full of cheer as he arrived in his ancestral homeland. And today he was out golfing at his beloved Turnberry — the biggest and bestest course in the universe. Frankly, given his troubles back home — not least the Jeffrey Epstein row — Trump would probably take a month in a leaky caravan in Saltcoats right now. The full-on UK-US diplomacy gets underway tomorrow when Starmer and Trump hold a TV press conference — the PM's moment of maximum danger. As for Swinney, well, Trump has said the 'Scottish leader is a good man'. But for Swinney's sake, let's hope the President didn't catch up with the papers as he tucked into his Full Scottish while gazing out at Ailsa Craig. If so, he may have spotted the First Minister virtue-signalling about Gaza and cultivating anti-Trump demos. But Trump isn't here for a row. He's here for a hol, to open his new course in Menie, Aberdeenshire, 'celebrate' a trade deal, and work out how to persuade R&A golf bosses to let Turnberry host The Open. I suspect all will be fine. Swinney has said some unwise things, but everyone in the world who's not Trump seems to have had a pop at him at some point. And the £180,000 Swinney magically announced for his Aberdeenshire course will certainly help oil the wheels of diplomacy. But a warning to Swin and Starm. When in the same room as The Donald, especially on camera, do NOT play to the gallery. If he gets an inkling you're challenging his authority or upstaging him, brace for a tantrum. Never bow down to a bully, it's said. But equally you could argue Swinney should choose his battles wisely. He should forget his grandstanding suggestion that he will confront Trump over 'war and peace, justice and democracy'. Just leave it, John. Instead, write 'don't turn Gaza into a golf resort' on a Post-it and stick it on Trump's jacket as you give him a friendly back slap. Trump will find it later, by which time Swinney will be back in Perthshire in his pyjamas. And the First Minister can stick out a half-honest press release saying he raised the big issues. One more thing. Should either UK leader end up on the golf course with Trump, then compliment his swing. And if he says it was a hole in one, then it was a hole in one. 'He has spent a fortune doing it up and now there are loads of Americans visiting here again.' Locals Jack Hannah, 65, and pal George Clark, 66, were also keen to have their views on their famous neighbour made known as they walked mutts Freddie and Tommy. George says: 'I don't want to get too political, but why do people object to him coming here? 'These protesters preach democracy yet Trump was democratically elected by millions of Americans. 'He's not done them any harm and puts money in the community, and employs a lot of people. So why can't he come here and play some golf without all the moaning. It's a free country after all.' Jack adds: 'I don't want to get into politics either but why don't the Green Party go and protest in countries like India and China who are among the worst polluters in the world. I'm all for Trump — drill baby, drill.' And that was them not being political? Just then Angela Bryce accosts me in the street as she wants to talk about Trump, along with her self-published book, show off her garden, oh, and she's also a healer to boot — even though she currently has a broken neck from a motorbike accident. She laughs: 'I've got to heal myself first.' 5 Chris Saunders was expecting the third degree he arrived to take a class of disadvantaged kids paddleboarding Credit: John Kirkby 5 George Clark and Jack Hannah don't understand why folk are protesting the President's visit Credit: John Kirkby But she dreams of having an 'appointment' with the President one day as she has '103 business ideas for him that are ready to go'. Right now though she just hopes the 79-year-old can be left in peace to enjoy some golf away from all the pressures of high office. Angela, 50, says: 'He is missing out on the simple joys of being able to just have a round of golf without all this fuss. But I really think he is a god or a king or a lord or a legend or something.' She's also enthusiastic about his wife Melania, adding: 'She is so beautiful — they are a beautiful match. And I bet she doesn't moan and do his f*****g head in while he's trying to get on with the great job he's doing.' Indeed. Surely if anyone is going to be miffed at all the road closures for The Donald it would be haulage worker Alex Hamilton, 77. But he insists: 'It's only a couple of days isn't it? The guy deserves to come here and play as he saved Turnberry.' The red MAGA hat-wearing Ben returns after being knocked back by cops while trying to make their way along the coastline towards Turnberry. He says: 'They told me they had sent Sky News packing as well. We're going to try and see him landing at Prestwick instead.' His patient mum Jacqueline adds: 'Ben is really into his politics. 'He always says that Trump would make a better Prime Minister than Keir Starmer — but I think anyone would.'
