Archway lecture theatre: Treasure or toilet block?
The Otago Daily Times yesterday reported that the Dunedin City Council was considering stepping in to save the Archway Lecture Theatre building from the wrecking ball. University wants to demo building
The building is on a draft list of 146 to be protected under changes to the district plan, but university vice-chancellor Grant Robertson wants it down. What do you think of the building? Let us know
The building went up in 1974 and won a New Zealand Institute of Architects Southern Architecture Award for Enduring Architecture in 2020.
In a heritage assessment report the DCC said: "This building is both unique and special to Dunedin. It also contributes to a nationwide body of Brutalist architecture."
However, many ODT readers have expressed far less favourable views of the building.
Former student Jeremy Callander didn't hold back
"I think I speak for every single human being that has ever had to sit through a lecture or an exam in the Archway Lecture Theatre, when I say that the Archway Lecture Theatre is......just the worst.
"The Richardson Building looks like a maximum security prison. The Commerce Building looks like the administration block of a maximum security prison at mardi gras. But the Archway Lecture Theatre takes the cake: it looks like a toilet block.
"Ooooh, it won a prize did it? News flash: you can pin a ribbon on a giant cow turd - doesn't make it cheese cake.
"To the university: just tear the damn thing down. You can ask for forgiveness later."
Readers on social media also had frank views on the building.
One called it "the ugliest building in education", another called it "hideous", and someone else said it was "fugly as hell. Bowl the bloody thing."
A minority of commenters wanted the building kept.
University music lecturer Andrew Perkins said: "They're wonderful, very well designed, and have everything going for them. I've been lecturing in them the past few years, and they're great!"
Another person said they loved Archway's "cheesy brutalist style. Keep Dunedin weird and leave it alone".
Mark Baxter, a life member of the Otago University Students Association, said it was "the only strongly Brutalist building left on the campus and is part of a set of very different architectural styles from different ages closely grouped together making an architectural history of NZ display, hence I think it'd be an architectural crime to demolish them".
- APL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
18-07-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Cat monitoring details shown
Rats, cats, possums, kiwi, tītī and white tail deer star in the first round of camera monitoring on Stewart Island. Details of the monitoring which took place during two weeks in May can be found on the Department of Conservation's Conservation blog website. About 300 trail cameras have been set up across 2300 hectares to record the presence of feral cats, rats and possums before, during and after the aerial 1080 poison operation. Last year the Department of Conservation announced a two-phase operation to drop 1080 bait to reduce the feral cat population endangering the Pukunui/Southern NZ dotterel. Phase one in about 6000 hectares of the island was completed earlier this month. The cameras are set up from sea level at Doughboy Bay to up and over the tops of the Tin Range where one of the last pukunui breeding grounds is. There are also cameras set up outside of the 1080 drop area to serve as a comparison. A lure, often containing rabbit meat, is set up in front of the trail cameras which are programmed to take bursts of photographs when they sense movement. On the blog it states the photographs show there are "lots of cats". The Otago Daily Times asked if Doc knew how many cats were in the area and could it be the cats were featuring in more than one camera and being counted twice or more. Doc Rakiura operations manager Jennifer Ross said the purpose of the monitoring was not count the number of pests. "Our aim is to measure the relative abundance of feral cats, rats and possums in the operational area before, during and after predator control. "This will help us to measure the results of the predator control operation." The results of the monitoring were what was expected and are similar to the non-drop area at Ruggedy Range, she said. Kiore, (Pacific rats) , Norway and ships rats feature in the photographs. Rakiura Tītī Islands administering body member Tāne Davis said kiore were smaller and less common than ship or Norway rats but they still had major impact on insects, land snails, lizards, bats and smaller land and seabirds. It is thought kiore arrived in New Zealand with the first Polynesians about 100 years ago, he said. While Ngāi Tahu acknowledged the cultural importance of kiore rats to some groups its position as kaitiaki or guardians was to eradicate them, he said. ZIP operations director Duncan Kay said Norway rats were a formidable predator. "They can grow much larger than kiore and ship rats — up to 25 cm, including the tail." They were also better swimmers and could easily swim 2km. "While they're not such good climbers as ship rats, they can still reach birds' nests above the ground."
Otago Daily Times
10-07-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Southland's court appearance
Scenes of Mitre Peak, Stewart Island and Bowen Falls form a background to the Southland provincial court being set up at the New Zealand and South Seas Exhibition at Logan Park, Dunedin. — Otago Witness, 21.7.1925 Intern residence urged In conversation with a representative of the Otago Daily Times, Mr H.J. Farrant (chairman) and Mr J.E. Winsloe (secretary) of the Southland Provincial Court of the New Zealand and South Seas Exhibition stated that they were highly pleased with the work that Mr Rooney had so far completed on their behalf. The views of Milford Sound, Mitre Peak, Stewart Island and the Bowen Falls were not only attractive, but were true to nature. The artist had excelled himself in the pastoral scene which would occupy a considerable space on the east wall. Mr Rooney had now commenced work on a very fine picture of the Pourakino River. He had also been supplied with copies for reproduction of other Southland scenic views. On the north partition a large space was to be reserved for the purpose of depicting Bluff and Bluff Harbour. Arrangements were being made in conjunction with Otago for the erection of an extensive freezing chamber, so designed as to give each province ample space to display meat, fish, butter, cheese etc under cool storage conditions. Asked if Southland had any other specialised attractions, the organisers replied that it was necessary to retain one or two "trump cards" up their sleeves. The following report by Dr Falconer, Medical Superintendent of the Dunedin Hospital, will be considered at the next meeting of the Otago Hospital Board: "Without a resident appointment in a modern hospital a medical student's training is incomplete. Herein lies an essential difference between American and English methods. After passing the final examination, an English student does not obtain his degree until he has spent a further year in residence in a hospital as an intern, where he is given a course of advanced clinical instruction and learns to apply the knowledge he has previously obtained in the clinical years of his medical course. Any errors he may make in diagnosis or in suggested treatment are corrected, and actually aid in his training. "Following such a training he enters practice after his skill in diagnosis and treatment has been demonstrated — a matter of obvious importance to the public. To my mind no greater present advance could be made in medical training in New Zealand than by carrying out Sir Lindo Ferguson's idea of instituting a 'hostel' for final-year students adjacent to the Dunedin Hospital." Dunedin's new Scout HQ The new headquarters of the Boy Scouts in Rattray street were officially opened last evening. Over 200 visitors were present, including representatives of the Rotary Club and troop committees. The Mayor (Mr H.L. Tapley) addressed those present, and in doing so emphasised the valuable benefit of scoutcraft to the community, and wished Commissioner Meek, his scouters and executive every success in their headquarters. Dr Marshall Macdonald, who has been appointed to represent Otago on the Dominion Council, spoke on the many handicrafts taught to scouts, and emphasised the fact that scouting trained a boy to be loyal to God, to help others and do his best to keep the 10 scout ideals. . Following a humorous "drill down" by the Ocean Beach scouts, the singing of the National Anthem concluded an instructive and enjoyable evening. — ODT, 10.7.1925 Compiled by Peter Dowden
Otago Daily Times
09-07-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Untold stories and meeting to tell them
For many, the student experience takes place off-campus, in the streets of North Dunedin, on Instagram stories, and within a culture of exclusivity and social capital that is often defined by who-knows-who. As a result, student politics, activism, and engagement with societies, communities, and opportunities frequently go unnoticed. This raises questions: how do we experience community, trust and support? Some of the most widely faced issues, like housing, financial stress, and wellbeing, can't be solved by information alone. They require a level of human connection: a sense of being seen, heard and supported by others facing the same challenges. Some experiences remain especially difficult to name aloud, like those involving sexual harm. For many students, these stories are held quietly, shaped by shame, fear, or uncertainty. Initiatives like Thursdays in Black offer vital support, awareness, and solidarity for those navigating these realities. They remind us of the power of being seen and believed. As poet Maya Angelou wrote: "There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story inside you." Her words and her work speak to the importance of creating spaces where individuals can feel strong enough to speak and safe enough to seek support. Despite being more connected than ever through digital channels, student life can feel fragmented. The digital connection might be the reason for this. There is a culture of popularity and following that almost breeds an underbelly of nervousness to step out of your comfort zone and push yourself into new spaces. Reflecting on this, I've decided that I miss school assemblies. Assemblies serve as a venue where the entire student body can receive messages simultaneously. Notices were shared like announcements about other students' achievements, speakers came and shared stories, choirs and kapa haka performed, and we sang the school song. It was symbolic, perhaps boring at times, often moving, and always unifying. My friends and I frequently discuss how this nervousness to engage and put oneself out there was largely absent at school, where everyone knew each other and largely supported one another. Now at university, though the stakes are higher, we no longer gather as a whole unified group, or even large parts of a group, aside from open days and lectures. The assemblies are gone, and with them a sense of collective orientation and responsibility, as well as a unity of vision and purpose. For many, the prospect of joining a new group or entering a room of strangers is daunting. I know it is infeasible to expect the entire population of Otago University to gather in one space or hold one shared purpose, but I can't help but feel that there is a disconnect between groups of people who have the potential to engage but seem lost in the day-to-day slog of university life, where the need for connection is being met on social media rather than in that room of strangers who share an issue, or a passion. Universities still have centralised communication: emails, notices, and social media posts. But it feels disjointed at times, or impersonal. Messages arrive daily but disappear just as fast: in the inbox, into the camera roll, on to the walls of bathroom stalls. It is communication without encounter. Centralisation without connection. I am currently at Hui-a-Tauira, the National Māori Law Students' conference, organised by Te Hunga Rōia Māori o Aotearoa, the Māori Law Society. This brings together law students from campuses across the motu. I attended last year and made many new connections. Here I am reminded of how powerful it is to be in a space where messages are shared not just to you, but with you. Due to the nature of this conference, there are obvious points in common with other attendees, creating implicit starting points for conversations and connection building. We are then able to hear about the current legal issues Māori are facing, developments in the law, and listen to talks from a wide range of speakers. We then leave equipped with strategies to deal with these issues and with meaningful points to share with our friends and whānau when we get home. The aforementioned nervousness that comes with putting yourself out there is eased once something is shared between people. However, some students may not realise that the university itself offers opportunities to help them overcome these initial barriers. Although we don't have university assemblies, we could create something similar, especially when it comes to major, widespread issues like student housing. The common points of connection that I share with the other tauira at Hui are being Māori and studying law. What if we had an annual or biannual hui to discuss housing? The commonality would be having some noteworthy experiences while flatting. This could be a space to hear stories, meet people going through similar things, learn about your rights, options, and the support available. Not a web page or a post, but a room and people. Space to sit, listen and know that your issue is shared and solutions are possible. These stories aren't just anecdotes — they are patterns, and the stories get reported on and spoken about, not so much the systemic nature of these issues. I am not trying to undermine the services already available. The poster for SOULS' tenancy programme, in which legal students offer free tenancy advice, is excellent and engages many. However, I am sure that some kind of hui, where you could bring your flat to, would serve a purpose. Admittedly, this may not always be feasible due to constraints such as space, funding, or levels of interest — but perhaps there are imaginative ways to work around these realities. A unifying issue, such as student housing, could demonstrate that there is something valuable to be found in engaging with the on-campus student experience. Sometimes, all it takes is a room, a story, and a shared meal to begin building something whole — a positive experience born from the bravery of putting oneself out there. Kind regards, Grace. • Dunedin resident Grace Togneri is a fourth-year law student.
