logo
Exclusive: Military contractor says she was fired for noting problem that ‘jeopardized the safety of U.S civilians and troops'

Exclusive: Military contractor says she was fired for noting problem that ‘jeopardized the safety of U.S civilians and troops'

Yahoo17-07-2025
A software engineer working for one of the Pentagon's most prominent defense contractors claims she was fired after flagging 'critical software safety issues and errors' written into the code that controls high-tech automated artillery systems used by U.S. forces, as well as various other nations throughout the world.
Deborah Hale alleges the problems violated at least eight different laws, rules, or regulations set out by the Army, Department of Defense, NATO and even NASA, which 'would have prevented appropriate safety tests from being properly developed and tested, severely jeopardizing the safety of American civilians, troops, and allies,' according to a state lawsuit that has now been removed to federal court.
Hale's suit says that since she was let go in 2023, the Reston, Virginia-based Science Applications International Corporation – known as SAIC, Inc. – has blackballed her throughout the industry.
SAIC has annual revenues of some $7.5 billion, and works extensively with the federal government across numerous agencies, in addition to the DOD.
Attorney Kelly Chanfrau, who is representing Hale, called her client 'an incredible employee with vast knowledge and experience.'
'Her allegations and complaints are serious and no employee should be retaliated against based upon complaints, especially when she was trying to protect our military and civilians,' Chanfrau told The Independent.
In an email, an SAIC spokesperson said, 'SAIC cannot comment on any litigation matters.'
The software underpinning the U.S. military's Multiple Launch Rocket System, or, MLRS, contained crucial errors, according to a whistleblower lawsuit. The software underpinning the U.S. military's Multiple Launch Rocket System, or, MLRS, contained crucial errors, according to whistleblower Deborah Hale's lawsuit (U.S. Army photo by KCpl. Siwon Koo, 2nd Infantry/ROK-U.S. Combined Division Public Affairs)
Hale has worked as a software safety engineer since 1983, at defense giants such as BAE Systems, Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman. A Subject Matter Expert in system safety of military weapons, SAIC hired Hale in September 2022, as a software safety engineer, her complaint states.
On April 1, 2023, Hale was promoted to system safety manager, which came with a salary increase from $175,000 to $180,000, and 'required [her] to conduct a line-by-line review of the software code' underpinning the Multiple Launch Rocket System, or, MLRS, an automated surface-to-surface rocket artillery platform, according to the complaint.
Among other things, the MLRS software is used to calculate missile trajectories based on targeting information human operators type into the system, military analyst Dan Grazier, who served as an officer in the U.S. Marine Corps and is now at the nonprofit Stimson Center, told The Independent.
In addition to the U.S. military, precision-fire MLRS systems are a key part of various European arsenals, along with Egypt, South Korea, and Norway, and have seen action in Iraq, Ukraine and beyond.
Shortly after beginning the code review, Hale discovered 'several' serious problems with it that could put U.S. and allied troops in harm's way, the complaint contends.
'The issues and errors were in violation of the following laws, rules, and regulations, including, but not limited to: the Department of the Army and United States Army Aviation and Missile Command AMCOM Regulation 385-17 Software System Safety Policy, the Defense Acquisition System, the United States Army Safety Program, the Department of Defense Standard Practice for System Safety, Joint Services Safety Authorities, Missile Defense Agency Assurance Provisions, NASA-GB-1740.13, and North Atlantic Treaty Organization Allied Ordinance Publication 52,' the complaint goes on.
Deborah Hale says the problems she brought up concerning the MLRS missile system could have put American civilians, troops, and allies in harm's way, but that she was ignored by her supervisors at defense contractor SAIC (PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP via Getty Images)
Although court filings do not list the specific aspects the code allegedly violated, AMCOM Regulation 385-17, for example, says '[s]oftware defects affecting safety-critical functions are causes of system level hazards, such as unplanned missile launch,' and that 'near-misses' have occurred 'as a result of software defects or inadequate specification of software system safety requirements.'
Hale promptly notified her bosses about her findings, according to the complaint. However, it maintains, 'Instead of taking action to correct the code and ensure the code was safe, [SAIC] ignored [Hale's] reports, and nothing was done.'
A week later, Hale raised the issue again, bringing her concerns to a different manager at SAIC, the complaint continues. This manager, it says, looped in two higher-level managers 'due to the seriousness of the issue.'
But a few days after that, Hale was suddenly informed by her supervisor that she was being removed from the MLRS project and would be reassigned to another team, the complaint states.
On April 13, 2023, before the transfer had a chance to occur, Hale spoke up at a staff meeting, appealing to higher-ups about the issues and errors she said were baked into the MLRS project's code, according to the complaint. A senior safety engineer corroborated Hale's findings, it says. In response, Hale's boss reiterated that the MLRS program 'would be moving forward without her,' the complaint alleges.
The next day, Hale was placed on unpaid leave, and told that she had until May 12 to find another job at SAIC or she would be terminated, according to the complaint.
'To no surprise to [Hale], she could not secure another position with [SAIC] due to her complaints of violations, rules, and regulations compromising safety,' the complaint states.
It says that by making it impossible for Hale to transfer internally, she was 'effectively terminated' on April 14.
Since then, SAIC 'has continued to retaliate against [Hale] by making it difficult for her to find subsequent employment,' according to the complaint.
Hale's 'allegations and complaints are serious and no employee should be retaliated against based upon complaints, especially when she was trying to protect our military and civilians,' her attorney Kelly Chanfrau told The Independent (75th Field Artillery Brigade/U.S. Army photo by Sgt. Christian Carrillo)
'The whistleblower angle of this story is all-too-common unfortunately,' Grazier told The Independent. 'I've seen this a few times, when earnest people identify a problem and try to deal with it through the appropriate channels only to see their concerns ignored and receive a termination notice as a reward for trying to do the right thing.'
Had everyone on Hale's team had simply listened to her and dealt with things, the outcome, across the board, would have been far better, according to Grazier.
'But for some odd reason, it happens this way far too often,' he said.
It is unclear if the issues that Hale flagged have since been addressed. An Army spokesperson told The Independent that it 'does not comment on ongoing litigation.'
Contrary to SAIC's apparent distaste for Hale, she has received glowing recommendations on LinkedIn from former managers.
'Deborah is the single smartest woman with whom I have ever worked in systems safety,' one wrote. 'Her high level of professionalism ending with products exceeding expectations make her a valuable asset to any organization.'
Another said: 'I was Deborah's manager when she transferred into System Safety, an engineering discipline that usually takes years to become effective; she grasped the concepts and was producing within months… Deb is definitely a team player[,] always ready to assist others and ensures the final product achieves the customer's expectations.'
Hale's lawsuit says her firing from SAIC led to emotional distress and humiliation.
She is seeking back pay and benefits, front pay, compensatory damages, emotional distress damages, punitive damages, attorneys' fees and court costs and reinstatement to her former position.
Solve the daily Crossword
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PTC Inc. (PTC) Is Up 3.15% in One Week: What You Should Know
PTC Inc. (PTC) Is Up 3.15% in One Week: What You Should Know

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

PTC Inc. (PTC) Is Up 3.15% in One Week: What You Should Know

Momentum investing is all about the idea of following a stock's recent trend, which can be in either direction. In the "long context," investors will essentially be "buying high, but hoping to sell even higher." And for investors following this methodology, taking advantage of trends in a stock's price is key; once a stock establishes a course, it is more than likely to continue moving in that direction. The goal is that once a stock heads down a fixed path, it will lead to timely and profitable trades. Even though momentum is a popular stock characteristic, it can be tough to define. Debate surrounding which are the best and worst metrics to focus on is lengthy, but the Zacks Momentum Style Score, part of the Zacks Style Scores, helps address this issue for us. Below, we take a look at PTC Inc. (PTC), a company that currently holds a Momentum Style Score of B. We also talk about price change and earnings estimate revisions, two of the main aspects of the Momentum Style Score. It's also important to note that Style Scores work as a complement to the Zacks Rank, our stock rating system that has an impressive track record of outperformance. PTC Inc. currently has a Zacks Rank of #2 (Buy). Our research shows that stocks rated Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy) and #2 (Buy) and Style Scores of "A or B" outperform the market over the following one-month period. You can see the current list of Zacks #1 Rank Stocks here >>> Set to Beat the Market? In order to see if PTC is a promising momentum pick, let's examine some Momentum Style elements to see if this product development software maker holds up. Looking at a stock's short-term price activity is a great way to gauge if it has momentum, since this can reflect both the current interest in a stock and if buyers or sellers have the upper hand at the moment. It's also helpful to compare a security to its industry; this can show investors the best companies in a particular area. For PTC, shares are up 3.15% over the past week while the Zacks Computer - Software industry is up 1.22% over the same time period. Shares are looking quite well from a longer time frame too, as the monthly price change of 19.43% compares favorably with the industry's 2.79% performance as well. While any stock can see its price increase, it takes a real winner to consistently beat the market. That is why looking at longer term price metrics -- such as performance over the past three months or year -- can be useful as well. Over the past quarter, shares of PTC Inc. have risen 29.93%, and are up 16.85% in the last year. In comparison, the S&P 500 has only moved 18.84% and 15.9%, respectively. Investors should also take note of PTC's average 20-day trading volume. Volume is a useful item in many ways, and the 20-day average establishes a good price-to-volume baseline; a rising stock with above average volume is generally a bullish sign, whereas a declining stock on above average volume is typically bearish. Right now PTC is averaging 1,512,517 shares for the last 20 days.. Earnings Outlook The Zacks Momentum Style Score encompasses many things, including estimate revisions and a stock's price movement. Investors should note that earnings estimates are also significant to the Zacks Rank, and a nice path here can be promising. We have recently been noticing this with PTC. Over the past two months, 1 earnings estimate moved higher compared to 1 lower for the full year. These revisions helped boost PTC's consensus estimate, increasing from $6.02 to $6.09 in the past 60 days. Looking at the next fiscal year, 1 estimate has moved upwards while there have been 1 downward revision in the same time period. Bottom Line Taking into account all of these elements, it should come as no surprise that PTC is a #2 (Buy) stock with a Momentum Score of B. If you've been searching for a fresh pick that's set to rise in the near-term, make sure to keep PTC Inc. on your short list. Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report PTC Inc. (PTC) : Free Stock Analysis Report This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research ( Zacks Investment Research

iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here: Download Apple's Liquid Glass Update Today
iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here: Download Apple's Liquid Glass Update Today

CNET

time10 hours ago

  • CNET

iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here: Download Apple's Liquid Glass Update Today

If you've been itching to poke around Apple's next big iPhone update, today's your day. Apple just opened the first iOS 26 public beta (July 23) to anyone in its free Beta Software Program, letting everyday users try the new OS months before it ships alongside the iPhone 17 this fall. The public beta follows six weeks of dev-only releases, capped yesterday with developer beta 4. iOS 26 is Apple's most ambitious revamp in years. The entire interface now shimmers with Liquid Glass, a translucent layer that morphs as you scroll, and an updated Apple Intelligence powers live call translation and a souped-up Visual Intelligence search. You'll also see other perks like call screening and personalized text message chats. Before you download, double-check your hardware: iOS 26 needs at least an A13 Bionic chip, so only the iPhone 11 model and newer qualify. Apple Intelligence features stay exclusive to the iPhone 16 line and iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max. Also remember that it's still beta software. Expect bugs, battery dips and the occasional app crash. You should definitely back up your phone first (better yet, create an archive on your computer), consider installing on a spare device and keep your computer nearby in case you need to roll back to iOS 18. If that sounds good, here's how to install the iOS 26 public beta. Don't miss: Revert Back to iOS 18 From iOS 26 Beta: The No-Stress, Step-by-Step Guide How to download the iOS 26 public beta on your iPhone As long as you know the risks and have backed up your phone, you can download the iOS 26 public beta. Here's what you need to do: 1. Enroll in Apple's Beta Software Program On the iPhone you want to update, open Safari and visit Sign in with your Apple ID. If you're new to the program, tap Sign Up and follow the prompts to accept Apple's beta agreement. 2. Sign up for the iOS 26 public beta After signing in, choose iOS at the top of the page. You'll land on a dashboard with details about the iOS 26 public beta. Under Get Started, tap Enroll your iOS device. Because Apple now handles betas directly in Settings (no more configuration profiles), all you need to do is link your Apple ID and you're good to go. 3. Enable beta updates On your iPhone, go to Settings > General > Software Update > Beta Updates. Choose iOS 26 Public Beta from the list. 4. Download and install iOS 26 beta Now, return to Settings > General > Software Update. The iOS 26 public beta should appear. Tap Download and Install and follow the on-screen instructions. Keep your phone on Wi-Fi and plugged in during the update. Once your iPhone reboots, you'll be running the latest iOS 26 public beta—complete with the new Liquid Glass interface and (if your hardware supports it) Apple Intelligence features.

The First iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here, But Think Twice About Installing It Now
The First iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here, But Think Twice About Installing It Now

CNET

time10 hours ago

  • CNET

The First iOS 26 Public Beta Is Here, But Think Twice About Installing It Now

Now that the iOS 26 public beta is now available, you may be itching to install it on your iPhone and start to experience the new Liquid Glass interface, live translation and other features coming in the fall. But I'm going to be the annoying voice of reason for a moment and encourage you to hold off for now -- or at least make sure you're loading it on a test device. The "beta" in "public beta" is there for a reason. Prerelease software is unfinished, and even though a public beta means Apple is confident enough to seed it on several thousand iPhones, the goal is to see how the update fares before it's deployed on millions of iPhones. Although the iOS 26 developer beta has been pretty stable, one never knows what bugs could slip through. For more on what iOS 26 brings to the iPhone, make sure you check out everything Apple announced at WWDC 2025. I'm Impressed With iOS 26. Apple Just Made iPhones Better I'm Impressed With iOS 26. Apple Just Made iPhones Better Click to unmute Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Skip Backward Skip Forward Next playlist item Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration 5:40 Loaded : 10.49% 0:00 Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 5:40 Share Fullscreen This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Text Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Caption Area Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Drop shadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Close Modal Dialog This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button. Close Modal Dialog This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button. I'm Impressed With iOS 26. Apple Just Made iPhones Better A positive word about installing the iOS 26 public beta The public beta is more stable than the developer betas, which are intended for developers who need to skirt the edges of stability to test their products. But "more stable" isn't the same as "rock solid." Apple is still adding and changing features in the iOS 26 betas before the anticipated release of iOS 26 in September or October. If you decide to install the iOS 26 public beta, I recommend doing it on a separate iPhone that isn't used as your main personal phone. iOS 26 will work with models as old as the iPhone 11, so reach into the back of your tech drawer and put that forgotten iPhone into service. Also, as always, make sure you have good backups of your data. Bugs are part of the iOS 26 public beta Now, let's discuss why upgrading to the iOS public beta might be a bad idea. Software bugs at the development stage are to be expected -- in fact, that's kinda the point. Now is the time for bugs to skitter into the light so developers can catch them and Apple can fix them before the final release. Opening the public beta to more testers helps flush out odd interactions with a much larger pool of iPhones and third-party apps. Bugs can vary across the spectrum. You could face connectivity issues with Bluetooth or Wi-Fi, or end up with third-party applications crashing from time to time. And runaway background processes could keep the system running hotter than normal, decreasing not just how long the phone operates on a battery charge, but potentially stressing the battery's lifespan. To be fair, I've never dealt with any show-stopping, brick-your-phone bugs in a beta -- usually, they're a series of annoyances that can grate on you after a while. But all of this is perfectly normal in developer and public betas. But if you don't want to deal with bugs and other issues that could make your phone more difficult to use, you probably don't want the iOS 26 public beta on your primary iPhone. Your battery life may worsen Did you recently buy a recommended portable charger for your iPhone? Expect to make more use of it while running beta software. Energy efficiency is usually the last thing Apple's developers optimize, because the priority at this point is to make sure features work and bugs are stamped out. An iOS update also triggers a host of internal indexing, which consumes a lot of energy for a few hours or days after installation. The Photos app, for example, updates its database of recognized people, scans images for new recognizable objects or scenes for search purposes and looks for duplicates. Betas can be tough on batteries. CNET Performance may take a hit Partially because of the reindexing of gigabytes of data on your phone, the iOS 26 public beta will almost certainly not deliver the performance you might be expecting. Processor-intensive apps and games also need to be tuned to work with the new iOS, so stutters and glitches are normal. Game Mode can improve performance in demanding games but beta software could interrupt such low-level processes. Jeff Carlson/CNET I know it's tough to be patient when future features are just a download away. But I also don't want you to be burned (as I have in the past). For more about iOS 26, see how the new Liquid Glass interface compares to iOS 18.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store