Corwen: Crash that killed cyclist 'unavoidable', inquest hears
A woman who fatally hit a cyclist while driving said there was nothing she could do to stop it and she thinks about it "every single day", an inquest has heard.David Fanning, 56, from Pencoed, Corwen, Denbighshire, was cycling along the A5 towards Llangollen on the evening of 31 January 2022 when he was hit by a car.Despite attempts to resuscitate Mr Fanning, he died at the scene from severe chest injuries.Speaking at the inquest in Ruthin, a forensic collision investigator described the crash as "unavoidable", while a coroner said Mr Fanning's dark, non-reflective clothing "diminished his visibility to other road users".
Driver Lowri Williams said she momentarily glanced down at her gearstick and when she looked up there was "suddenly" a cyclist wearing dark clothing in front of her.She told John Gittins, the senior coroner for North Wales East and Central, she tried to swerve but the vehicle struck Mr Fanning. She estimated her speed was between 50-55mph in a 60 mph zone.After seeing him lying in the road she called 999 while another passing motorist - a district nurse - performed CPR on him. Miss Williams said she had been arrested at the scene following the incident but was released without charge after being interviewed.She was breathalysed by police and found to be under the legal drink drive limit."I wish I could have changed what happened but I couldn't. There was nothing to stop it from happening," she said.
Forensic collision investigator Ian Thompson compiled a report on behalf of North Wales Police, and said: "In my opinion this collision was unavoidable."His findings were consistent with Miss Williams swerving away at the last minute based on a reaction time of about 1.6 seconds.He told the inquest that Miss Williams' phone was examined and it was not being used at the time.Mr Thompson accepted that although lights from Mr Fanning's bike couldn't be found it was possible they were thrown off during the crash and lost.
William Tyler, representing Mr Fanning's family, told the inquest they have "concerns about the way the collision was modelled" by Mr Thompson.His family said cycling was Mr Fanning's preferred mode of transport ever since his childhood. He cycled to France with a friend at 18 years old and was a popular member of the cycling club community, including Bala Cycling Club. Other motorists gave evidence about seeing Mr Fanning riding along the A5 that day and most said he was wearing dark clothes and they couldn't see any rear lights.One witness said they spotted him "at the last minute" because of his pedal reflectors and swerved to avoid him.Mr Gittins concluded Mr Fanning's death was caused by a road traffic collision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Couple subjected grandson to ‘pain and misery' before his murder, court told
A 'withdrawn' and painfully thin' toddler was subjected to 'distress, pain and misery' in the weeks before he was murdered by his grandparents, a court has heard. Kerry Ives, 46, and her husband Michael, 47, are accused of the murder of their two-year-old grandson Ethan Ives-Griffiths, who died in hospital on August 16 2021 after an ambulance was called to their home in Deeside, Flintshire, two days earlier. Mold Crown Court heard the couple blamed his death on their daughter, Ethan's mother, Shannon Ives, who is accused along with her parents of causing or allowing his death and of child cruelty. At the opening of their trial on Wednesday, a jury was told Shannon Ives, 28, and her son had been living with her parents in the time leading up to his death. Caroline Rees KC said: 'The prosecution say Ethan's time at the first and second defendants' home was thoroughly miserable and he was targeted by the defendants as an object of abuse and neglect.' She added: 'He was quiet and withdrawn, small and painfully thin.' She said the toddler was exposed to 'casual brutality' and, according to a medical expert, would have experienced 'distress, pain and misery in the days and weeks prior to his death'. On the night of August 14, Ethan was downstairs with his grandparents while his mother was upstairs on the phone at the time he sustained his fatal injury, the court heard. Ms Rees said: 'The prosecution say what must have been a forceful attack on Ethan that night was the culmination of physical and emotional neglect and abuse upon him by those who should have cared for him the most.' Both Michael and Kerry Ives told police their grandson had collapsed suddenly. Ms Rees said: 'The prosecution say these two defendants entered a pact of silence as to what they did to Ethan that night, immediately working together as a team of two to conceal the truth about the reason for his fatal collapse.' She said the grandparents had chosen to 'blame their own daughter' rather than admit what really happened. 'They say it must have been Shannon Ives who inflicted the injuries which led to Ethan's death,' she said. Ms Rees said Shannon Ives was aware her parents 'represented a significant risk of physical harm' but 'took no steps to protect her child'. In interview, she said she was scared of her parents and knew them to be abusive, the court heard. Ms Rees said: 'She had seen them shaking Ethan in anger on many occasions. She said she was petrified of her father in particular.' The court heard Kerry Ives delayed calling 999 for almost 20 minutes after Ethan's collapse, before making the call at 9.21pm. Ethan was taken to the Countess of Chester Hospital and then transferred to Alder Hey Children's Hospital for brain surgery, but was pronounced dead at 6pm on August 16. He had 'serious, catastrophic head injuries' and found to be 'severely underweight' and 'covered in bruises', the court heard. The jury was told he weighed 10kg, or 22lb, when he died and at a post-mortem examination 40 external injuries were observed. Medical evidence showed his fatal head injury was caused by deliberate use of force which may have included an element of forceful shaking, Ms Rees said. Abdominal injuries consistent with forceful blows were also found, the court heard. CCTV footage taken from outside the family home in the weeks before his death showed his mother 'standing by, totally unconcerned whilst Ethan was ill-treated and handled by her father in a totally inhumane way', Ms Rees said. In clips shown to the court, Michael Ives could be seen carrying his grandson by the top of his arm, 'dangling him like a rag doll' and appearing to hit out at him after putting him into the backseat of a car. Another clip showed Ethan on a trampoline, where Michael Ives was seen to put the toddler's hands on his head – a technique Ms Rees said was used 'to discipline' the child. Ms Rees said: 'We say that footage can properly be described as harrowing, with a view into how traumatic the last weeks of Ethan's life must have been.' Michael and Kerry Ives, of Kingsley Road, Garden City, deny murder, an alternative count of causing or allowing the death of a child and cruelty to a person under 16. Shannon Ives, of Nant Garmon, Mold, denies causing or allowing the death of a child and cruelty to a person under 16. The trial, which is expected to last six weeks, will continue on Monday.
Wales Online
3 hours ago
- Wales Online
A&E 'should have been warned' by paramedics about seriously ill 21-year-old with sepsis
A&E 'should have been warned' by paramedics about seriously ill 21-year-old with sepsis .'Caring' Bethan Amy James was admitted to hospital by ambulance and died the next day Bethan James was just 21 when she died Paramedics 'should have' alerted A&E staff that the seriously ill daughter of a former cricket star was on her way to hospital, an inquest has heard. 'Caring' and 'beautiful' Bethan Amy James was admitted to hospital on February 8, 2020 and died the next day. An ongoing inquest into her death, which began on Tuesday, heard that her death was caused by a combination of sepsis, pneumonia and Crohn's disease. Budding journalist Bethan was the daughter of former Glamorgan and England cricketer Steve James. A highly respected sports journalist himself, Mr James was away covering Wales' Six Nations match in Ireland when his daughter was taken seriously ill. Heartbreakingly due to weather delays he was unable to get home and see her before she died. In the lead up to Bethan's death, her family say she was 'dismissed' by multiple medics and that 'her life could have been saved'. During the second day of Bethan's inquest on Wednesday it was heard how there was an apparent 'insufficient urgency' when paramedics arrived at Bethan's home in St Mellons, Cardiff, that evening. Giving evidence, paramedic Laura Wilson accepted that she should have 'pre-alerted' the University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff of Bethan's arrival. However, she did not. Article continues below She said her experience with Bethan has informed her practice as a paramedic as well as her understanding of sepsis. Speaking to coroner Patricia Morgan, Ms Wilson said: 'It was a long time ago. My practice is completely different now than it was then. 'At the time, on reflection, I should have pre-alerted and taken that phone call to the hospital. I was aware Bethan was very poorly and we needed to get her to hospital.' She added that at the time she wasn't fully aware of the 'nature of decline' associated with sepsis. Emergency medical technician Aaron Hook - who drove the ambulance and accompanied Ms Wilson - agreed that a pre-alert 'definitely' should have happened. The inquest heard evidence that blue lights were not activated during the journey from Bethan's home to the hospital. Ms Wilson accepted this was her decision but said activating the lights may not have been appropriate. 'The purpose is to make progress to [the destination] and alert other road users of your presence,' she told the inquest. 'Their use wouldn't have achieved [this] any quicker and my thought process was using sirens and lights would have only served to add to Bethan's stress.' She noted that Bethan looked 'very poorly' and that she was 'very upset and distressed'. Bethan was the daughter of Glamorgan and England cricket star Steve James The inquest heard how the ambulance was on the scene for 29 minutes in total, which Ms Wilson said was 'not unreasonable'. Although she did not pre-alert the hospital she told the inquest that the University Hospital of Wales is 'prompt' and 'the best' in the area at offloading patients from ambulances. She estimated that it took around five or 10 minutes for Bethan to get into hospital, adding there was 'no major delay'. However the inquest heard further evidence that Mr Hook rushed into the hospital to find a bed for Bethan in resus. It was heard that the nurse in charge of resus that day, Carys Williams, told Mr Hook that the ward was at full capacity, but that she was aware of a 'buffer bed' - which is used when no beds are available - in the nearby 'majors' department. It is understood that resus is the highest-intensity department at a hospital where those with life-threatening conditions are treated, whereas majors is a step down from this; where patients requiring close observation and treatment are seen. It was heard how Bethan was taken to the buffer bed at the majors department when she first entered the hospital shortly after 7.45pm. She later went down to resus at 9.15pm, before she fell into cardiac arrest at around 9.35pm, it was previously heard. Ms Williams said if staff had been pre-alerted it would have 'rung alarm bells' and triggered a discussion with the consultant. It may have given medics time to select and transfer a current resus patient to the majors buffer bed, she explained. Ms Williams told the inquest how when Mr Hook spoke to her on Bethan's arrival she only recalls him describing Bethan as 'unwell'. When probed by Welsh Ambulance Service Trust Advocate Jack Scott on why she didn't ask Mr Hook for more information, she reiterated that she had no capacity and it could have delayed matters at that point to take a medical history. The family's advocate, Richard Booth, put to Ms Williams an FOI obtained by the family detailing how many beds were available in resus that day, which suggested a bed may have been available. Ms Williams reiterated that she was at full capacity for adults and that the availability likely referred to a free paediatric bay, adding: 'I don't recall any children coming in on that day.' Mr Booth further asked Ms Williams to confirm if she later referred to Bethan's deceased body as 'it'. Ms Williams said she did not and would not have said this. The inquest heard evidence from consultant Bethan Morgan who took charge of Bethan's care less than an hour before she died. Shortly before she passed it was heard how Bethan suffered a cardiac arrest. Mr Booth asked Dr Morgan if she agreed that the cardiac arrest could have been prevented if Bethan had been promptly transferred to the hospital and arrived at resus. In response she said: 'My opinion is I think Bethan would have died of this illness regardless.' She added that it was difficult to say for definite since she had not seen Bethan at the time paramedics first attended her home. She described Bethan's deterioration as 'atypical'. Mr Booth acknowledged that medics at the time were 'trying to piece together' what was causing Bethan's presentation that day, and that it was not known that the cause of Bethan's sepsis was 'viral'. Dr Morgan said: 'I think we assumed it was bacterial at the time of seeing her.' During the first day of the inquest on Tuesday it was heard how Bethan was 'dismissed' by a number of medics in the weeks that led up to her death. Speaking on Tuesday her heartbroken mother Jane James described Bethan as a 'caring' and 'beautiful' person who always put others before herself. Diagnosed with Crohn's disease in 2019 at the age of 20, Bethan documented her experience of the condition through a vlog and had hopes of becoming a journalist. Article continues below Mrs James said: 'As a person she never moaned, she never made a fuss. She was very caring. She was just beautiful. 'She put people before herself. She was more interested in other people and their stories and I think that's why she would have made a brilliant journalist.' The inquest continues
Telegraph
4 hours ago
- Telegraph
Mother ordered to repay £50k inheritance she stole from daughters
A mother has been ordered to repay £50,000 she stole from her daughters, which had been bestowed on them in their grandmother's will. Katherine Hill, 54, and her father Gerald Hill, 94, from south Wales, were said to have acted out of 'greed and spite' in staging the 'blatant and brazen' theft. Margaret Hill had intended to place the money in a trust for her grandchildren, Gemma and Jessica Thomas, which could be accessed on their 25th birthdays. Katherine and Gerald were made trustees of the account when Mrs Hill died in 2013 and secretly drained the account in just over a year. The deceit was only discovered in 2018 when one of the daughters sought to access the money early to buy a house with her boyfriend, which was allowed under the terms of the will. Prosecutors said the withdrawals had been made either by Katherine, who worked at Lloyds Bank, or by their father acting as a 'useful stooge'. Gerald claimed he had posted the cash to his grandchildren in envelopes but the daughters claimed to have never received a penny. The pair were found guilty of fraud by abuse of position last year, with Katherine sentenced to 30 months in prison, of which she served half in custody, and Gerald received a 12-month suspended sentence. The judge told Katherine she stole the money because she was 'so annoyed that your daughters received more money than you, that you took their inheritance'. They returned to Swansea Crown Court for a proceeds of crime hearing. James Hartson, prosecuting, said Katherine had initially told investigators she had a 50 per cent equity share in her partner's home after paying the mortgage for nine years. She later withdrew the claim and said she had no equitable right to the house, with Mr Hartson saying the move was a 'thoroughly dishonest' attempt to avoid payment. Judge Greg Bull KC ruled in favour of the prosecution, saying Katherine had 'laundered' some of her daughters' money by paying her partner's mortgage. He said Katherine and Phillip Lloyd, a window cleaner, 'lived together as man and wife' and she could repay her daughters by raising equity from their home. Mr Bull said: 'It is significant that investigations could not reveal what had happened either to that £50,000, or to what had happened to other relatively substantial sums left to Katherine Hill after her mother's demise. 'She still maintains that she has never received the £50,000. I disbelieve her on that and I find her answer to be totally untruthful. 'Mr Lloyd is fully aware of what happened to that £50,000 and has probably helped her at least launder it, if not enjoy the fruits of her fraud.' Mr Bull added: 'That £50,000 was used for the benefit of both of them, it would have been used to pay the mortgage, it would have been used to pay their utilities, it would have used to enjoy their lifestyles - a lifestyle that they would not have been able to afford.' Katherine was told she must pay £50,000 in three months or face six months' imprisonment in default, while Gerald was ordered to pay £6,000 for his part in the fraud or face three months in prison.
