Mother ordered to repay £50k inheritance she stole from daughters
Katherine Hill, 54, and her father Gerald Hill, 94, from south Wales, were said to have acted out of 'greed and spite' in staging the 'blatant and brazen' theft.
Margaret Hill had intended to place the money in a trust for her grandchildren, Gemma and Jessica Thomas, which could be accessed on their 25th birthdays.
Katherine and Gerald were made trustees of the account when Mrs Hill died in 2013 and secretly drained the account in just over a year.
The deceit was only discovered in 2018 when one of the daughters sought to access the money early to buy a house with her boyfriend, which was allowed under the terms of the will.
Prosecutors said the withdrawals had been made either by Katherine, who worked at Lloyds Bank, or by their father acting as a 'useful stooge'.
Gerald claimed he had posted the cash to his grandchildren in envelopes but the daughters claimed to have never received a penny.
The pair were found guilty of fraud by abuse of position last year, with Katherine sentenced to 30 months in prison, of which she served half in custody, and Gerald received a 12-month suspended sentence.
The judge told Katherine she stole the money because she was 'so annoyed that your daughters received more money than you, that you took their inheritance'.
They returned to Swansea Crown Court for a proceeds of crime hearing.
James Hartson, prosecuting, said Katherine had initially told investigators she had a 50 per cent equity share in her partner's home after paying the mortgage for nine years.
She later withdrew the claim and said she had no equitable right to the house, with Mr Hartson saying the move was a 'thoroughly dishonest' attempt to avoid payment.
Judge Greg Bull KC ruled in favour of the prosecution, saying Katherine had 'laundered' some of her daughters' money by paying her partner's mortgage.
He said Katherine and Phillip Lloyd, a window cleaner, 'lived together as man and wife' and she could repay her daughters by raising equity from their home.
Mr Bull said: 'It is significant that investigations could not reveal what had happened either to that £50,000, or to what had happened to other relatively substantial sums left to Katherine Hill after her mother's demise.
'She still maintains that she has never received the £50,000. I disbelieve her on that and I find her answer to be totally untruthful.
'Mr Lloyd is fully aware of what happened to that £50,000 and has probably helped her at least launder it, if not enjoy the fruits of her fraud.'
Mr Bull added: 'That £50,000 was used for the benefit of both of them, it would have been used to pay the mortgage, it would have been used to pay their utilities, it would have used to enjoy their lifestyles - a lifestyle that they would not have been able to afford.'
Katherine was told she must pay £50,000 in three months or face six months' imprisonment in default, while Gerald was ordered to pay £6,000 for his part in the fraud or face three months in prison.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
US woman to be sentenced over failed assassination plot in Birmingham
A would-be assassin who flew to the UK only for her gun to jam during an assassination attempt while she was disguised in a niqab will be sentenced on Thursday. Aimee Betro, 45, was found guilty of conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol and fraudulently evading the prohibition on importing ammunition after a three-week trial which ended last week. The graphic design and childhood education graduate tried to shoot Sikander Ali at point-blank range outside his home in Measham Grove, Yardley, Birmingham, shortly after 8pm on September 7 2019. Judge Simon Drew KC will sentence Betro, who is originally from West Allis in Wisconsin but lived in Armenia until earlier this year, at Birmingham Crown Court. Jurors at her trial heard she took part in a plot orchestrated by co-conspirators Mohammed Aslam, 56, and his son Mohammed Nabil Nazir, 31, who were sentenced for their part last year, following a feud with Mr Ali's father, Aslat Mahumad. Nazir was jailed for 32 years in November 2024 for offences including conspiracy to murder while Aslam was sentenced to 10 years. Prosecution counsel Tom Walkling KC said 'revenge was the motive' after Nazir and Aslam were injured during disorder at Mr Mahumad's clothing boutique in Birmingham in July 2018, which led them to conspire to have someone kill him or a member of his family. Mr Walkling told Betro's trial that she met Nazir, who lived in Derby, on a dating app in late 2018 and then communicated with him via Snapchat before flying to the UK on Christmas Day of the same year. She told the court she slept with Nazir at an Airbnb in London before returning to the US in January 2019. Records show Betro landed at Manchester Airport on a flight from Atlanta on August 22 2019, two weeks before the attempted killing of Mr Ali. Betro was caught on CCTV at and near the scene of the failed attempt to shoot Mr Ali, who fled in his car after the gun jammed. Security camera footage also captured her return to the scene hours later, when she aimed three shots through the front windows of Mr Ali's family home. Betro told the court she flew into the UK to celebrate her 40th birthday and knew nothing of any shooting or murder plot by the time she returned to the US. She also attempted to explain away evidence against her by claiming the woman caught on CCTV wielding a gun and recorded booking taxis was 'another American woman' known to Nazir who had a similar voice and footwear.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Sun, sea and struggle: growing up in England's coastal towns
As a teenager, the Today in Focus presenter Helen Pidd could not wait to leave her home town on the Lancashire coast. But today she looks back with fondness at her time spent at the fairground or misbehaving on the beachfront, and watching bands at the local music venue. She returned this summer to find out what life was like for young people today – and found things were not as she remembered. All of her old haunts had shut down and young people spoke about a town in which they had nothing to do. Eleanor Adamson, a 22-year-old carer, describes how hard it has been to forge her own path in life in Morecambe. Impoverished coastal towns have lower life expectancy and worse educational outcomes than elsewhere. Students at Helen's former school say they feel 'disregarded' by successive governments that have left seaside towns to decay. Reform UK politicians see an opportunity in towns like Morecambe. But do they have any solutions? Helen speaks to local Reform and Labour councillors about what policies they have for young people in Morecambe. 'Our coastline is littered with lost opportunities and left behind communities. Other countries celebrate and invest in their seaside. It's about time we did, too,' she says.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Is this a good time to buy shares in Convatec?
After a volatile year for shares in Convatec they received a welcome boost on Wednesday when the FTSE 100 medical equipment company launched a share buyback of up to $300 million. The programme, representing up to 5 per cent of Convatec's market capitalisation, will run until the end of the year. The return of surplus capital to shareholders lifted the shares 5.6 per cent, gaining 13p, to close at 244¼p on the London Stock Exchange, the session's biggest riser on the premier share index. The buyback, being handled by UBS, was received by the market as a sign of health in the outlook for Convatec, whose shares, which were up 30 per cent in the first half of the year, have de-rated since June on concerns about product reimbursement cuts in the United States, its largest market, where the Trump administration has launched an efficiency drive. Despite the stock having seemingly priced in the exposure, some investors have remained on the sidelines, concerned that changes to US federal reimbursement in chronic care and skin substitutes could hit Convatec's sales and forecasts more than expected. Convatec has quantified the potential impact. It guided at its half-year results at the end of July for a potential 1 per cent to 2 per cent headwind on its 2026 revenues and the same range in 2027. The company also reiterated its forecasts for the current financial year, of group organic revenue growth of between 5.5 per cent and 7 per cent. This excludes sales of at least $75 million from InnovaMatrix, a wound treatment whose sales are uncertain because of the prospect of a curtailment of Medicare coverage, a US health insurance scheme. Convatec also reiterated an adjusted operating margin between 22 per cent and 22.5 per cent for this year and said it remained on course to 'consistently deliver' medium-term targets of 5 per cent to 7 per cent organic revenue growth and to reach a 'mid-20s' percentage adjusted operating margin by 2026 or 2027. Sellside bulls argue that investors have overlooked Convatec's results. Uncertainty, though, increased this month when Convatec announced, in a brief statement, that Karim Bitar, its well-regarded chief executive, was taking an indefinite medical leave of absence from the company. He has been replaced by Jonny Mason, the chief financial officer, on an interim basis, and Fiona Ryder, the group financial controller, will in turn take Mason's place as chief financial officer in the interim. Since Bitar, 60, was parachuted in as chief executive by Novo Holdings, a top shareholder, in 2019, he has led the turnaround of the FTSE 100 company after a period of profit warnings and boardroom upheaval. Convatec, founded in 1978, employs about 10,000 people globally and operates in around 90 countries. The company's strategy centres on four chronic care categories — including ostomy and continence care — and prioritises 12 key markets, with the United States as its largest. Since 2019 revenue growth has risen from 2.3 per cent; Convatec has delivered six straight years of accelerating growth; its annual research and development expenditure has doubled to about $100 million; and it has replenished its pipeline of new products. Amid the US and leadership uncertainty, then, the share buyback has helped reinforce the bull case. The buyback was consistent with Convatec's capital allocation plans, under which it targets a 2 times net debt/ebitda leverage ratio. Analysts at UBS, Convatec's house broker, forecast a year-end ratio of 1.3 times, rising to 1.7 times following the buyback. The broker, which reiterated its 'buy' rating and 231p price target, believes Convatec has the cashflows for a consistent buyback programme, which excluding mergers and acquisitions, could return up to $2 billion, or one third of Convatec's existing market capitalisation over the next four years. Similarly, Berenberg told clients on Wednesday, before the buyback was announced, that the 20 per cent de-rating in Convatect's shares since June was a 'buying opportunity', with the company trading on a 16 times price-earnings ratio. Advice Buy Why Buyback underpins confident outlook and shares have de-rated since Tempus's recommendation in February
