Police force orders media not to report court evidence in free speech threat
In the email, sent by Hertfordshire Police's corporate communications department, the force said: 'We are writing to remind you of the Ipso notice below which has been issued.
'We are aware of some coverage going against this notice, and we ask you to please review your content that has been published to ensure it complies with the below.'
The email then contained the Ipso advisory notice which had been circulated on Wednesday in advance of Clifford's trial.
Clifford had pleaded guilty to the murders of his ex-girlfriend Louise Hunt, 25, and her sister Hannah Hunt, 28, whom he killed with a crossbow, and their mother Carol Hunt who he stabbed to death. On Thursday, he was found guilty by a jury of raping Louise Hunt prior to her murder in July 2024.
The women were the wife and daughters of John Hunt, the BBC horse racing commentator.
'Think they have more authority than they do'
The demand by police that the media complies with voluntary guidance will raise concern among advocates of free speech.
Harry Miller, a former police officer and free speech advocate, said: 'The police continually overreach.
'They think they have more authority than they do have. They have one job and that is to uphold the law.
'They are playing outside of their box yet again. They need to restrict themselves entirely to upholding the law.'
Mr Miller, who fought a successful legal battle against Humberside Police after he was reported for a non-crime hate incident, said it sets a 'dangerous precedent'.
He added: 'It is another example of the chilling effect on free speech. It will have a chilling effect on the fourth estate and I don't think the public can put up with that.'
'Editors retain full control of decision making'
Ipso has been accused of threatening the key principle of open justice in the past. In 2022, it circulated a request from a former primary school teacher charged with slapping a horse that newspapers refrain from taking her photograph outside the court.
Ipso operates a privacy notice system in which specific requests made by individuals and organisations are passed to editors and journalists. It has stressed that such notices are private and passed on on a confidential basis and that 'editors retain full control of decision making'.
In a statement issued as a result of concern over the horse cruelty case, Ipso said at the time: 'Privacy notices do not prevent reporting on matters of public interest, including court proceedings, and do not supersede the standards set by the Editors' Code.'
But last year, Ipso ruled against journalists reporting evidence given in open court in a decision branded a dangerous intrusion. In that case, Ipso said that details of a rape trial reported by the website Aberdeen Live had been an 'intrusion into grief or shock' of the anonymous victim in the case.
The victim, whose identity is protected by law, had complained to Ipso that the website's report of a specific 'detailed description of her physical reaction to the attack' had contained a 'level of detail' that 'had retraumatised her'.
Lawyers on that occasion warned that the case could create a 'slippery slope' in which the press regulator interferes in reporting on court cases held in public.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Pensioner accused of stalking BBC star after ‘sending gifts and going to her home'
The OAP is also said to have not shown at a court date 'DON'T APPROACH' Pensioner accused of stalking BBC star after 'sending gifts and going to her home' A PENSIONER is accused of stalking a BBC Scotland news presenter for almost four years. Robert Green, 70, allegedly harassed the Beeb's Anne McAlpine between February 2021 and November 2024. Advertisement 2 Anne McAlpine filming an Isle of Skye telly special for Landward Credit: Instagram/annemcalp Green faces a charge of engaging in conduct which caused the 39-year-old journalist fear and alarm. It is claimed the OAP repeatedly sent letters, poems, cards and gifts for Miss McAlpine to the BBC Scotland headquarters in Glasgow's Pacific Quay as well as to her home. Green is also said to have turned up at her property uninvited, loitered outside and asked to come in. He then faces a separate charge that he was subject to an "undertaking" to appear at court in January this year in connection with the alleged offence. Advertisement Green had been ordered not to approach, communicate or contact Miss McAlpine. But, it is claimed that on November 14 2024 he went near where she lived and again tried to get in touch with her. On a further charge sheet, Green is also said to have not shown at a court date in January this year. The case called this week for a summary hearing - a case with no jury - at Glasgow Sheriff Court. Advertisement Green, of the city's Hillhead, was not present. His lawyer, Ron Mackenna said he had reported having "serious surgery" a few days earlier and was unable to leave home. A sheriff told the solicitor that Green must provide proof of that by this week or a warrant will be issued for his arrest. The case will be heard again at a later date. Advertisement Miss McAlpine is best known for presenting Reporting Scotland and Landward. She has also been the narrator for Scotland's Home of the Year show.
Telegraph
17 hours ago
- Telegraph
BBC Arabic apologises for claiming Jews spit on Christians in ‘holiday ritual'
The BBC has been forced to apologise following claims by its Arabic service that Jews spit on Christians in a 'holiday ritual'. Claims were made in a video released by the corporation alongside an article titled 'Sukkot: Spitting and Assault on Christians and Harassment of Muslims on the Jewish Holiday'. In the video, released in October 2023, a caption claimed observant Jews celebrated their religious holiday, Sukkot, in Israel by spitting on Christians. After the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (Camera) complained to the BBC, the caption was corrected to say: 'Some observant Jews consider spitting on Christians a holiday ritual.' However, Camera had to wait 19 months for a written apology to be issued. In the correspondence, the BBC said: 'We apologise for the errors and thank you for your patience in waiting for this reply/confirmation of corrections that were made in October 2023.' The footage sparked outrage after ultra-Orthodox Jews could be seen spitting on the ground alongside a procession of foreign Christian worshippers carrying a wooden cross in Jerusalem. The spitting scene, captured by a reporter at Israel's Haaretz newspaper, showed a group of foreign pilgrims beginning their procession through the limestone labyrinth of the Old City. They were retracing the steps along the route they believe Jesus took before his crucifixion, raising a giant wooden cross. However, ultra-Orthodox Jews in dark suits and broad-brimmed black hats squeezed past the pilgrims through narrow alleyways, their ritual palm fronds for the week-long Jewish holiday of Sukkot in hand. At least seven ultra-Orthodox Jews spit on the ground beside the Christian tour group. A second BBC Arabic article, published on the 22nd anniversary of the 9/11 and titled 'The story of suicide bombers throughout history: from the fanatical Jews, through Assassins, to the Jihadists', linked 'fanatical Jews' to the US terror attacks. The article describes the Sicarii, a militant Jewish group active during Roman occupation, as the earliest example of suicide attackers. It then went on to link them to modern jihadist tactics. The Sicarii seized Jerusalem with other forces during the Jewish revolt in 70AD, before retreating to Masada. However, Camera complained and argued that while the Sicarii did commit mass suicide at Masada, they did not carry out suicide attacks. Camera wrote in a complaint to the BBC: 'Since the Sicarii's attacks weren't suicidal, and their mass suicide was not an attack, they do not fit a narrative about suicide attacks at all. Yet, they are the only ones labelled 'fanatics' and 'extremists' in the entire article.' 'Material inaccuracy' The BBC executive complaints unit agreed the original article contained a 'material inaccuracy' after Camera made further complaints. In a ruling issued on April 10, they said: 'Although the Sicarii may have preferred suicide to capture, there was no evidence of their using suicide as a means of an attack.' The headline was changed to 'The Story of Suicide Bombers Throughout History: From Assassins to Jihadists'. Lord Carlile, the government's former independent reviewer of terrorism legislation, condemned the piece at the time and warned the BBC about publishing 'deliberate and sometimes even casual anti-Semitism'. He told The Telegraph after the apology was issued: 'I'm glad they have apologised.' Camera also said there were six other complaints about BBC Arabic content that have not been resolved as of June 9. A Camera spokesman said: 'Having demonstrated such ignorance in covering Jewish affairs, it seems that part of the problem lies not only with the Arabic service's inability to respond to complaints on time, but also in the lack of training its staff undergo upon hiring.' Last month, the BBC announced it would appoint an independent figure to investigate its Arabic channel over repeated allegations of anti-Semitism exposed by The Telegraph. The Telegraph has previously revealed a number of BBC Arabic's contributors have posted anti-Jewish sentiments and expressed their apparent support for Hamas, both before and after the Oct 7 attacks. Speaking to Times Radio in May, Dr Samir Shah, the chairman of the BBC, said: ' The Arabic service, we are looking at it, we've been examining it. I think this whole business of how we've covered Israel-Gaza is a proper thing to examine thoroughly, which is why we're going to identify... we're going to get hold of an independent figure to look at our coverage.'
Daily Record
a day ago
- Daily Record
'Scots' suspect arrested over Spain 'gangland' shooting of Ross Monaghan and Eddie Lyons Jnr
He is now facing extradition to Spain so he can be questioned about the May 31 murders. Any extradition would have to be approved by a UK court. A man arrested in connection with a "gangland" shooting in Spain is believed to be Scottish. Spanish police have confirmed a man, believed to be in his 40s, has been arrested in the UK on suspicion of the Costa del Sol gangland execution of Scots mobsters Ross Monaghan and Eddie Lyons Jnr. The BBC reported earlier this morning the suspect was taken into custody in Liverpool by Merseyside Police under an international arrest warrant issued by the Spanish authorities. Spanish cops have yet to make a formal statement. But a well-placed Spanish police source said today when asked about the arrest: 'The specialist UDYCO Costa del Sol police group which is leading the investigation has identified this man. 'As they couldn't find him in the places where they thought he could have been in Malaga, they asked a court in Fuengirola which has opened a judicial probe into the shootings to issue an international arrest warrant for this man. 'Police in the UK have arrested the man in Liverpool under this international warrant.' He is now facing extradition to Spain so he can be questioned about the May 31 murders. Any extradition would have to be approved by a UK court. The suspect's return to Spain would be delayed if he decides to oppose extradition. Spanish officials said days after the murders they had 'no doubt' they would catch the gunman who shot dead Monaghan and Lyons Jnr. Javier Salas was the first Spanish government representative to confirm the victims were Scottish after the horror shooting at Monaghan's Irish pub Monaghans Fuengirola. And he spoke again three days later to say he was convinced police would find and arrest the culprit. Graphic CCTV footage first published by Spanish TV showed one of the two men murdered being cornered inside the premises and shot in the chest and stomach from close range. The killer, dressed in black, was filmed shooting Glaswegian Ross Monaghan, 43, dead after targeting his pal Lyons Jnr outside the pub seconds earlier as terrified tourists and locals ran for cover. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Spanish police sources confirmed they believed the killer was blond following claims detectives haven't commented on that he could also be Scottish. He fled on foot but was driven from the scene by an accomplice in a car waiting nearby which headed along the old N340 dual carriageway east towards the resort of Benalmadena. Officers from the elite Spanish National Police Costa del Sol-based Anti-Drug and Organised Crime Unit UDYCO have headed the ongoing probe, although they are reporting to a Fuengirola-based investigating judge coordinating the operation. Career criminal Monaghan, who fled Scotland for Spain after a failed attempt on his life outside a Glasgow primary school in 2017, was tried but acquitted over the murder of notorious Glasgow hood Kevin 'Gerbil' Carroll at an Asda car park in 2010. In August 2017 he and Eddie Lyons Jr, both members of the Lyons Glasgow crime family, were cleared of being involved in a brutal street attack on three men outside the Campsie bar in Bishopbriggs, East Dunbartonshire. The shooting in Spain came amid a violent gang war that has ripped through Scotland since March said to have started over a fallout over drugs. However Police Scotland have said they have no intelligence to link the shootings to the feud.
