Eighty years on from Labour's landslide, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza brings Clement Attlee's failure on Israel and Palestine to mind
Trade unionists and Labour MPs are celebrating, claiming the nation still owes a debt of gratitude for the historic achievements of Clement Attlee's government.
Yet today, as the world watches the humanitarian crisis in Gaza with horror, it's worth recalling that one of Attlee's biggest failures was his Israel - Palestine policy.
(Oh, and while Attlee's health minister Aneurin Bevan boasted he "stuffed their mouths with gold" to overcome doctors' opposition to the NHS, today doctors are on strike over pay again.)
The 1945 election took place on 5 July, the same date Sir Keir Starmer entered 10 Downing Street last year. But with British armed forces still serving overseas in 1945, it took until 26 July to declare the result.
9:30
Labour won 393 seats in 1945, compared with 411 last year. But while Sir Keir's Labour only won 34% of the votes, Mr Attlee won nearly 50%. But then, there was no insurgent Reform UK back then.
Celebrating the 80th anniversary, Joanne Thomas, who became general secretary of the shopworkers' union Usdaw in April this year, said the Attlee government left a lasting legacy.
"Usdaw's predecessor unions were proud to play a role in the 1945 election victory and to see 18 of our members elected," she said.
"Not least a hero of our union 'Red Ellen', a fiery trade union organiser who led the Jarrow hunger march and went on to serve as education minister."
Wilkinson was indeed red. Attlee biographer Trevor Burridge wrote: "Ellen Wilkinson was made minister of education despite the fact that she had actively campaigned against his leadership."
She was MP for Jarrow, not a million miles from the current education secretary and Starmer super-loyalist Bridget Phillipson's Houghton and Sunderland South constituency. But not even her best friends would call her red!
Ellen Wilkinson was also the only woman in Attlee's 1945 cabinet. Last year, Sir Keir made history by appointing 11 women to his cabinet.
Labour MP Marie Tidball, elected last year, joined the tributes to Attlee. "He transformed Britain for working people and this legacy laid the foundations for Britain today - our NHS, welfare state and homes for heroes.
"Those public services meant I could grow up to fulfil my potential. Labour legend."
But if Attlee's NHS, welfare state and nationalisation are viewed as successes by Labour trade unionists and MPs, his government's policy on Palestine is widely agreed to have been a failure.
In his acclaimed biography of Attlee's foreign secretary, "Ernest Bevin: Labour's Churchill", former Blairite cabinet minister Andrew Adonis wrote: "Why did Bevin get Israel/Palestine so wrong?"
Adonis says Bevin's policy on Palestine "led to the precise opposite of its declared intention of stability and the peaceful co-existence of the Jewish and Palestinian communities within one state at peace with its neighbours".
He concluded: "Instead, Bevin's legacy was a Jewish state of Israel, much larger than even most of its advocates previously favoured, in periodic war and perpetual tension with both its Palestinians and its Arab neighbours."
Where did Bevin go wrong? Adonis wrote: "In the first place, because, during the three key years 1945-48, he did not agree that his central policy objective was 'good relations with the United States'."
As Sir Keir Starmer prepares to meet Donald Trump in Scotland, 80 years after the historic Attlee victory, that's clearly not a mistake the current Labour PM has made in his relations with the US president.
" I like your prime minister," the president said as he arrived in Scotland, "he's slightly more liberal than I am, but I like him".
So, 80 years on from Attlee, lessons have been learned. So far, so good, that is.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
27 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Livingston MP calls for chat platform that's a 'magnet for predators' to be banned
Gregor Poynton's remarks came as new Online Safety Codes were introduced Livingston's MP has called for the banning of an online chat platform for young people which he claims is failing to keep users safe from online predators. Gregor Poynton, who is Chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Children's Online Safety, called for the Wizz app to be banned in the UK following mounting evidence that it is being used by predators to groom and exploit children. At least two UK child sexual abuse cases have been linked to the platform. His remarks came following an investigation by London-based talk radio station LBC. A 22-year-old reporter was able to bypass age verification on the app and pose as a teenager to access profiles of children as young as 14, and exposed how the app was failing to keep young users safe. The Wizz app, marketed as a teen social platform, claims to restrict interactions to users of similar ages and use facial recognition tools for verification. However, the investigation revealed that these safeguards can be easily bypassed. Gregor Poynton MP said: 'Wizz is clearly a magnet for predators, a place where abuse is already happening. 'It's not enough to tweak the technology or add disclaimers. There is no legitimate purpose for an app like this. It should be banned.' The Livingston constituency MP's comments came on the day landmark protections for children online come into force under new Ofcom-enforced rules introduced by the Labour UK Government. 'Our lives are no longer split between the online and offline world – and the harm done online can be just as devastating,' he said. 'We've now got some of the toughest laws anywhere in the world to protect kids online. But enforcement has to match ambition – and when apps like this fail to act, they should be banned.' Mr Poynton told LBC that the protections Wizz has in place are, 'not worth the paper they're written on.' He also raised broader concerns about the rise of apps with no social value but huge potential for harm, referencing so-called 'nudification' apps used in sextortion scams. He added: 'These apps serve no positive purpose. They don't enrich lives – they endanger them. Enough is enough.' The new Online Safety Codes require platforms to: Introduce robust age checks to block access to pornography, self-harm and other harmful material. Tackle toxic algorithms that feed children harmful content, from dangerous stunts to hate speech. Act fast to remove harmful content, with clear routes for reporting and complaints. Face serious penalties, including fines of up to £18 million or 10 per cent of global annual revenue, for non-compliance. Mr Poynton confirmed he would work cross-party in the autumn to review gaps in the legislation, particularly in light of emerging technologies like AI. 'Tech moves fast – but our response must be faster. If fines aren't enough, we'll legislate again. We owe it to our children to keep them safe.' Wizz has been approached for comment.
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Gaza, girders ...but no golf: Keir Starmer meets Donald Trump in Scotland to talk steel tariffs deal and Middle East violence amid Cabinet rift
Keri Starmer sat down with Donald Trump in Scotland today as he tries to gain the president's backing for ending tariffs on UK steel and the humanitarian crisis being perpetuated by Israel in Gaza. The Prime Minister travelled to one of Trump's Scottish golf courses amid a backdrop of issues both foreign and domestic to take up with the erratic world leader. Security is tight at Turnberry in Ayeshire where they are discussing how to continue putting into place the US-UK trade deal they signed earlier this year, as well as the Middle East crisis. Speaking to reporters as he left the White House on Friday, Mr Trump said he and Sir Keir would be 'fine-tuning' the US-UK trade deal when they meet in Scotland. But he downplayed the prospect on an agreement on steel, warning there was 'not a lot' of wiggle room on steel tariffs. Sir Keir and the US President struck a trade agreement to reduce tariffs on car and aerospace imports, but questions remain over whether UK steel imports into America will face 50 per cent tariffs. The PM's meeting with Mr Trump also comes amid growing global outrage at the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, while peace talks between Hamas and Israel came to a standstill last week. Some 255 MPs from nine parties have now signed a letter demanding the UK follow the lead of France and recognise a Palestinian state. And reports suggest the row over whether to do this stretches all the way into the Cabinet. But the PM's attempt to win over the president does not stretch to joining the golf-mad leader on the first tee. No 10 said there was no plan for the two men to play a round together. White House special envoy Steve Witkoff blamed Hamas for a 'lack of desire' to reach an agreement in the Middle East. Since then, Israel has promised military pauses in three populated areas of Gaza to allow designated UN convoys of aid to reach desperate Palestinians. But the UK, which is joining efforts to airdrop aid into the enclave and evacuate children in need of medical assistance, has said that access to supplies must be 'urgently' widened. Sir Keir is under increasing pressure from MPs and even his own ministers to recognise Palestinian statehood. It comes after French President Emmanuel Macron said his country will do so in September. Some 221 MPs from Labour, the Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, SNP, Greens, Plaid Cymru, SDLP and independents have signed a letter pressuring the Government to follow suit at a UN meeting next week. The majority of those who have signed, 131, are Labour MPs. The US is the country 'with the leverage' to make a difference in the conflict in Gaza, the Business Secretary suggested this morning. Speaking to BBC Breakfast ahead of Sir Keir's meeting with Mr Trump, Jonathan Reynolds said: 'Of course, Gaza will be on the agenda today. 'The intolerable scenes that we're seeing, the world is seeing, are the backdrop to that. 'And of course, the US has itself secured on two occasions ceasefires in the conflict, so they have been actively engaged in it, working with Egypt, the Qataris, and other key partners in the region. 'The US is the country I think we'd all recognise with the leverage here to really make a difference on both sides. So their role is fundamentally important.' Mr Reynolds dismissed the idea that there is a split at the top of Government over when to recognise a Palestinian state. Health Secretary Wes Streeting is among those to have signalled a desire for hastened action calling for recognition 'while there's still a state of Palestine left to recognise'. Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said the Government wants to recognise a Palestinian state 'in contribution to a peace process'. Speaking to Good Morning Britain, Mr Reynolds said: 'There's no split. The whole of the Labour Party, every Labour MP, was elected on a manifesto of recognition of a Palestinian state, and we all want it to happen. 'It is a case of when, not if.' He added: 'It's about how we use this moment, because you can only do it once to have a meaningful breakthrough.' Mr Reynolds also admitted there is 'more to do' on the US-UK trade deal, but played down the prospect of a fresh announcement later. The Business Secretary said: 'We were very happy to announce the breakthrough that we had a few months ago in relation to sectors like automotive, aerospace, which are really important to the UK economy. 'But we always said it was job saved, but it wasn't job done. There's more to do. 'The negotiations have been going on on a daily basis since then. There's a few issues to push a little bit further today. 'We won't perhaps have anything to announce a resolution of those talks. 'But there's some sectors that we still need to resolve, particularly around steel and aluminium, and there's the wider conversation about what the US calls its reciprocal tariffs.' The US-UK agreement signed at the G7 summit last month slashed trade barriers on goods from both countries. But tariffs for the steel industry, which is of key economic importance to the UK, were left to stand at 25 per cent rather than falling to zero as originally agreed. Concerns had previously been raised that the sector could face a levy of up to 50 per cent - the US's global rate - unless a further agreement was made by July 9, when Mr Trump said he would start implementing import taxes on America's trading partners. But that deadline has been and gone without any concrete update on the status of UK steel. Sir Keir and Mr Trump are also expected to discuss the war in Ukraine, which Downign Street said would include 'applying pressure' on Vladimir Putin to end the invasion. Speaking to journalists on Sunday about his meeting with Sir Keir, Mr Trump said: 'We're meeting about a lot of things. We have our trade deal and it's been a great deal. 'It's good for us. It's good for them and good for us. I think the UK is very happy, they've been trying for 12 years to get it and they got it, and it's a great trade deal for both, works out very well. 'We'll be discussing that. I think we're going to be discussing a lot about Israel. They're very much involved in terms of wanting something to happen. 'He's doing a very good job, by the way.' Mr Trump's private trip to the UK comes ahead of a planned state visit in September.
BreakingNews.ie
27 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Protests planned for Barack Obama's Freedom of Dublin visit in September
Protests are being planned for former US president Barack Obama's visit in September. Obama and his wife have been invited to accept their Freedom of Dublin award during the trip. Advertisement Barack and Michelle Obama were originally given the Freedom of Dublin award in 2017, but have not yet formally accepted it. It is Dublin's highest honour, and is given to individuals whose leadership has made 'a profound contribution to the world'. PRO and secretary of the Irish Anti-War Movement, Jim Roche, said the group protested when Obama visited in 2011 and will protest again in September. He maintains that Obama's contribution to the world is not peaceful. Advertisement "How the industrial military complex works in America, how the presidents have seemingly little power even if they wanted to change it and make real peace in the world, so he wasn't a peace president in that sense," he said. "We're seeing the impact of the development of drone warfare horrifically now in Gaza and of course there's great collaboration between the US military and Israeli military." On the other hand, Lord Mayor Ray McAdam said the couple are more than deserving of the Freedom of Dublin. "During his term in office, he led with a sense of hope and, in terms of Mrs Obama, through her voice she was an inspiration to many young girls and women across the world," he said. The Obamas will not have to worry about paying any customs duties on their trip, at least, as one privilege included in the Freedom of Dublin is the right to bring goods into Dublin through the city gates without paying a fee.
