Report clearing MI5 over IRA spy disclosures branded ‘whitewash'
Last year, MI5 files were accused of being deliberately withheld from an investigation into the IRA agent known as Stakeknife, who at one point was linked to 50 murders.
However, a review conducted by Helen Ball, a former assistant commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, found that no material was deliberately withheld from the investigation, known as Kenova.
Kevin Winters, a solicitor at KRW Law, which represents 21 families linked to Kenova, said the 'risible' review was a 'whitewash'.
'When it comes to state accountability, conflict-bereaved families across the board are conditioned to being let down by the Government and its various agencies.
He added: 'In many ways, they can rightly feel insulted that they are being asked to buy into the notion that filing and indexing issues caused a communication deficit between MI5 and Kenova.'
'Stakeknife', a notorious double agent, is believed to have been Freddie Scappaticci, a former bricklayer who worked secretly for the British Army while he was part of the IRA's Internal Security Unit (ISU), which tortured and killed suspected informants.
Operation Kenova was a seven-year, £40 million investigation into Stakeknife's links to kidnap, torture and murder. An interim report found that during the Troubles 'preventable and serious crimes took place and went unsolved and unpunished as a result of steps taken by the security forces to protect and maintain their agents'.
But a cache of documents was unearthed by MI5 in the months after the report which showed evidence that MI5 had been aware of the agent's existence decades earlier than it had previously claimed.
Jon Boutcher, former head of Kenova and current Police Service of Northern Ireland Chief Constable, said last year it was unacceptable that MI5 had discovered the material so late and that the files appeared to contain 'significant new material which appears to point to new investigative leads not previously known'.
A review into the late disclosure was carried out at MI5's request by Helen Ball, a former assistant commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, which said: 'I have not seen evidence of a deliberate attempt to withhold the material identified in 2024.
'Therefore, I have concluded that none of the material was deliberately withheld from Operation Kenova at either an individual or an organisational level.
'However, MI5's disclosure exercise drew on historic information management practices for Northern Ireland material which were not as strong in the past as those that MI5 had in place for its other material.
'This meant in some cases that material was not properly stored and indexed when it should have been, and in others that it was indexed in a way that meant its relationship to Kenova's remit was not recognised.'
Ms Ball added: 'In addition, MI5's approach to the disclosure exercise was, as agreed with Kenova, to respond to requests for information provided to it.
'MI5 did not conduct a broader assessment of its own position in relation to Kenova's investigative remit and the material it might hold.
'Had it done, some of the material might have been identified earlier... So might it have been if MI5 had maintained stronger relationships with the Kenova team.'
Sir Iain Livingstone, the current Kenova head, said: 'It is, of course, deeply regrettable that material was discovered and disclosed after the investigative phase of Kenova had concluded and after the Director of Public Prosecutions for Northern Ireland had made decisions concerning prosecutions of the Kenova cases.
'The circumstances and relevance of the non-disclosed material will form part of the Kenova final report which is due to be published later this year.'
Some 32 people, including former police, ex-military personnel and people linked with the IRA, were considered for prosecution on a range of charges from murder and abduction to misconduct in public office and perjury as a result of the Kenova investigation.
The Public Prosecution Service in Northern Ireland found there was insufficient evidence to pursue any cases.
The final Kenova report is due to be published this year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
11 hours ago
- The Independent
Moment man found guilty of attempted murder in Dalston shooting pulls up outside restaurant
A man who has been found guilty of the attempted murder of a nine-year-old girl in Dalston was caught on CCTV driving towards the restaurant where the shooting took place. Footage released by the Metropolitan Police on Monday (18 August) shows a Nissan Juke being driven by Javon Riley, 33, heading towards Evin restaurant on Kingsland High Street on 29 May 2024. Riley drove past the restaurant several times to ensure the intended targets, three men who belonged to a rival gang, were present. A gunman on a motorbike then pulled up and opened fire six times. One of the bullets lodged in the girl's brain. Police said Riley was instrumental in ensuring the shooter evaded capture, transferring him from the scene as well as disposing of the firearm. Neither the gunman nor the weapon has been found. Riley will be sentenced on Friday, 12 September at the Old Bailey.
The Sun
11 hours ago
- The Sun
Woman, 73, killed after being hit by a bus on busy shopping street as cops launch probe
AN elderly woman has tragically died after being hit by a bus on a busy street last night. Police have issued a probe after the 73-year-old was struck on Neasden Lane, near Dudden Hill Lane junction just before 6pm. 1 Paramedics rushed to the scene where she was later pronounced dead. The pensioner is yet to be identified publicly, however, police have confirmed they are working to inform her next of kin. In an update provided by the Metropolitan Police it was announced that no one has been arrested in connection at this stage. The force also confirmed the driver of the bus is now assisting with the ongoing investigation. The busy shopping street was closed for multiple hours following the tragic incident, but has since reopened. A Metropolitan Police spokesperson said: "Police were called at 17:58hrs on Sunday, 17 August following reports of a serious road traffic collision in Neasden, Brent. "Officers were joined by the London Ambulance Service at the junction of Neasden Lane with Dudden Hill Lane, where a bus had been in collision with a pedestrian. "Sadly, despite the best efforts of emergency services, a 73-year-old woman was pronounced dead at the scene. "Enquiries are underway to inform her next of kin." is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video.
The Independent
13 hours ago
- The Independent
Volunteer officer met alleged rape victim while posing as girl, 16, court told
A volunteer Metropolitan Police officer accused of raping a woman was posing online as a 16-year-old girl when the pair began talking, a court has heard. Amersham Law Courts heard that James Bubb, who now identifies as a woman named Gwyn Samuels, allegedly raped the woman he was in an on-off relationship with between January 2018 and February 2023. On Monday, the trial heard the pair met on the online chat site Omegle while Bubb was posing as a teenage girl and that they had spoken about a sexual practice known as BDSM (bondage, discipline/domination, sadism/submission, and masochism). Jurors previously heard the woman had told police Bubb went on to use 'BDSM and kink as a way of creating control' throughout their relationship. The complainant, who cannot be named for legal reasons, told the court on Monday: 'When I met James on Omegle, I didn't know that it was James at first, they introduced themselves as a teenage girl so I was more concerned than anything else, and then kind of just talking to them about maybe this isn't what they should want to look at at their age.' She said: 'As I said, James first presented themselves as a 16-year-old girl.' Jurors previously heard the pair started talking when the complainant had 'just turned 18' and that she had been 'terrified' after Bubb had suggested 'knife-play' during their relationship. In her police interview, she said: 'When a guy is trailing a knife down you telling you the things he could do with it and you are terrified and you don't trust he would stop – the safe word means nothing.' During cross-examination, Adrian Amer, defending Bubb, asked: 'All the BDSM you had with James was completely consensual wasn't it?' 'No,' the alleged victim replied. Mr Amer continued: 'Did you introduce knife-play?' 'I did not introduce knife-play,' the woman said. Mr Amer asked: 'In your knife-play, sometimes you were blindfolded weren't you?' 'Yes,' the witness said. 'And James would use a blunt butter knife to run along your body, a blunt butter knife that's correct, isn't it?' Mr Amer asked. 'I have no way of knowing if it was a blunt butter knife, I was blindfolded,' the alleged victim said. Asked to describe the knife that Bubb would use during times where the alleged victim was not blindfolded, she said it was a 'large-ish knife' like the type 'used to cut vegetables'. Regarding the size of the knife, the woman indicated it was shorter than the length of an A4 piece of paper. The 27-year-old has denied one count of rape in relation to the complainant, and two counts of rape, two counts of sexual activity with a child, one count of assault of a child under 13 by penetration, one count of rape of a child under 13 and one count of assault by penetration in relation to another complainant. A not guilty verdict on one of the rape charges in relation to the second complainant was returned on Wednesday after the prosecution offered no evidence. All charges are alleged to have taken place between January 1 2018 and April 2 2024. The defendant, of High Street, Chesham, Buckinghamshire, denies all charges. The trial continues.
