How scammers are using AI to steal college financial aid
The rise of artificial intelligence and the popularity of online classes have led to an explosion of financial aid fraud. Fake college enrollments have been surging as crime rings deploy 'ghost students' — chatbots that join online classrooms and stay just long enough to collect a financial aid check.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
In some cases, professors discover almost no one in their class is real. Students get locked out of the classes they need to graduate as bots push courses over their enrollment limits. And victims of identity theft who discover loans fraudulently taken out in their names must go through months of calling colleges, the Federal Student Aid office and loan servicers to try to get the debt erased.
Advertisement
On Friday, the US Education Department introduced a temporary rule requiring students to show colleges a government-issued ID to prove their identity. It will apply only to first-time applicants for federal student aid for the summer term, affecting some 125,000 borrowers. The agency said it is developing more advanced screening for the fall.
Advertisement
'The rate of fraud through stolen identities has reached a level that imperils the federal student aid program,' the department said in its guidance to colleges.
An Associated Press analysis of fraud reports obtained through a public records request shows California colleges in 2024 reported 1.2 million fraudulent applications, which resulted in 223,000 suspected fake enrollments. Other states are affected by the same problem, but with 116 community colleges, California is a particularly large target.
Criminals stole at least $11.1 million in federal, state, and local financial aid from California community colleges last year that could not be recovered, according to the reports.
Colleges typically receive a portion of the loans intended for tuition, with the balance going directly to students for other expenses. Community colleges are targeted in part because their lower tuition means larger percentages of grants and loans go to borrowers.
Scammers frequently use AI chatbots to carry out the fraud, targeting courses that are online and allow students to watch lectures and complete coursework on their own time.
In January, Wayne Chaw started getting emails about a class he never signed up for at De Anza Community College, where he had taken coding classes a decade earlier. Identity thieves had obtained his Social Security number and collected $1,395 in financial aid in his name.
The energy management class required students to submit a homework assignment to prove they were real. But someone wrote submissions impersonating Chaw, likely using a chatbot.
'This person is typing as me, saying my first and last name. ... It's very freaky when I saw that,' said Chaw.
Advertisement
The fraud involved a grant, not loans, so Chaw himself did not lose money. He called the Social Security Administration to report the identity theft, but after five hours on hold, he never got through to a person.
As the Trump administration moves to dismantle the Education Department, federal cuts may make it harder to catch criminals and help victims of identity theft. In March, the Trump administration fired more than 300 people from the Federal Student Aid office, and the department's Office of Inspector General, which investigates fraud, has lost more than 20 percent of its staff through attrition and retirements since October.
'I'm just nervous that I'm going to be stuck with this,' Brady said. 'The agency is going to be so broken down and disintegrated that I won't be able to do anything, and I'm just going to be stuck with those $9,000' in loans.
Criminal cases around the country offer a glimpse of the schemes' pervasiveness.
In the past year, investigators indicted a man accused of leading a Texas fraud ring that used stolen identities to pursue $1.5 million in student aid. Another person in Texas pleaded guilty to using the names of prison inmates to apply for over $650,000 in student aid at colleges across the South and Southwest. And a person in New York recently pleaded guilty to a $450,000 student aid scam that lasted a decade.
Brittnee Nelson of Shreveport, La., was bringing her daughter to day-care two years ago when she received a notification that her credit score had dropped 27 points.
Advertisement
Loans had been taken out in her name for colleges in California and Louisiana, she discovered. She canceled one before it was paid out, but it was too late to stop a loan of over $5,000 for Delgado Community College in New Orleans.
Nelson runs her own housecleaning business and didn't go to college. She already was signed up for identity theft protection and carefully monitored her credit. Still, her debt almost went into collections before the loan was put in forbearance. She recently got the loans taken off her record after two years of effort.
'It's like if someone came into your house and robbed you,' she said.
The federal government's efforts to verify borrowers' identity could help, she said.
'If they can make these hurdles a little bit harder and have these verifications more provable, I think that's really, really, really going to protect people in the long run,' she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
8 hours ago
Nurse imposter arrested after treating over 4,000 patients without a license: Sheriff
A woman in Florida was arrested after posing as a nurse and treating over 4,000 patients without a license, according to the Flagler County Sheriff's Office. Autumn Bardisa, 29, was arrested on Tuesday after pretending to be a registered nurse and treating 4,486 individuals at a local hospital from July 2023 until she was fired on Jan. 22, the sheriff's office announced in a press release on Wednesday. "This is one of the most disturbing cases of medical fraud we've ever investigated," Sheriff Rick Staly said in a statement on Wednesday. Back in July 2023, Bardisa was hired as an advanced nurse technician, working under the supervision of a registered nurse, officials said. When she applied for the position, she stated she was an "education first" registered nurse, meaning she "passed the required schooling to become a registered nurse but had not passed the national exam to obtain her license," officials said. She then told the hospital she had passed her exams and provided a license number "matching an individual with her first name, Autumn, but with a different last name," the sheriff's office said. Bardisa explained the discrepancy, saying she "had recently gotten married and had a new last name," according to officials. The hospital requested to see her marriage license to confirm her identity, but she never provided it to them, officials said. When Bardisa was offered a promotion in January, officials said a fellow employee checked her license's status and discovered she had "an expired certified nursing assistant license" and immediately reported the findings to hospital administrators. After the hospital investigated, they learned that Bardisa had also never provided her marriage license per their previous requests, officials said. After terminating Bardisa on Jan. 22, hospital officials contacted the sheriff's office, which then began an investigation. Officials found that the nurse Bardisa stole the license from is someone at a different hospital and had attended school with Bardisa, but the two did not "personally know one another," officials said. On Tuesday, Bardisa was arrested for seven counts of practicing a health care profession without a license and seven counts of fraudulent use of personal identification, officials said. She was transported to the Sheriff Perry Hall Inmate Detention Facility, where she is being held on a $70,000 bond, officials said. This incident comes after a Pennsylvania nurse was arrested in July after using 20 aliases -- including the identities and credentials of four confirmed nurses from southern states -- and seven different Social Security numbers. Another similar incident occurred back in Nov. 2024 when a 44-year-old woman impersonated a registered nurse at a hospital in Burbank, California. Jail records do not indicate Bardisa's next court appearance. It is not immediately clear whether Bardisa has an attorney who can speak on her behalf.
Boston Globe
10 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Ghislaine Maxwell's move to ‘country club' prison smacks of special treatment, experts say
Advertisement 'It's a country club,' Hood said 0f the camp about 100 miles northwest of Houston. 'Inmates, if they have a sex offense, are not going to a place like that, period. It's truly unheard of.' Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Federal Prison Camp, Bryan is seen in Bryan, Texas, on Saturday, Aug. 2, 2025. Meredith Seaver/Associated Press Long-standing policy from the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) restricts inmates with certain elevated security classifications, known as 'public safety factors,' from serving in federal prison camps. Sex offenses are among the most severe. Maxwell was convicted in 2021 of helping Epstein groom, traffic and abuse dozens of underage girls. Inmates serving sentences of 10 years or more generally aren't eligible for transfer to minimum-security facilities. This, too, would have applied to Maxwell, who is not due for release until 2037. Exceptions can be made through what's known as a 'management variable.' In Maxwell's case, prison staff would have had to request this waiver to move her, and senior prison officials would have had to sign off on it, according to BOP policy. Advertisement While it's not uncommon for prison officials to allow inmates who cooperate with investigations to move to lower-security facilities, it's rare for sex offenders to receive such benefits, and they almost never get moved into prison camps like Bryan, experts said. 'It's enormously preferential treatment,' said Judi Garrett, a former BOP assistant director. 'Getting a public safety factor for a sex offender waived is monumental.' Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell in 2005. Joe Schildhorn/Patrick McMullan But Maxwell could have been in a position to leverage special treatment. She has become a focal point of efforts by President Donald Trump's administration to calm a growing furor over its about-face decision last month to release no further information from the FBI's Epstein files. Epstein was indicted on sex trafficking and other charges in 2019 but died while awaiting trial in what has been ruled a suicide. Members of Trump's Republican base have led a continuing clamor for the full release of the files and whatever information Maxwell may have that could implicate some of the disgraced financier's rich and powerful friends. Maxwell's transfer from a low-security prison in Tallahassee came to light just a week after she sat for two days of interviews with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche. David Oscar Markus, an attorney for Maxwell said she was asked about potentially '100 different people' and she 'answered those questions honestly, truthfully, to the best of her ability.' Blanche has said that he would release information about their interview at an appropriate time. Advertisement Neither Markus nor the Justice Department has commented on the reason for her transfer. A spokesperson for the prisons bureau didn't respond to a request for comment Tuesday. Some victims of Epstein and Maxwell decried the transfer in a joint statement, calling Maxwell a sexual predator and saying she should 'never be shown any leniency.' And while some have speculated that Maxwell's move could be the precursor to clemency, Trump has been noncommittal on the subject, though telling reporters he is 'allowed to give her a pardon.' But one aspect of Maxwell's housing is clear: Conditions at the Bryan prison camp are among the best in the corrections system and a significant improvement over even the low-security prison where the 63-year-old had been held. 'A low-security prison has a substantially higher ratio of staff to inmates than a camp. You're on a different planet,' said Larry Levine, founder of Pink Lady Prison Consultants, which helps women prisoners navigate the system. 'You're looking at double razor wire around the fence, trucks driving around it, cops with rifles. They're locking the doors of the housing units at night.' At the Bryan camp, located in a residential neighborhood, doors to dorms with bunk beds and suite housing remain unlocked, and the 635 khaki-clad inmates are generally free to roam the compound. A single layer of razor-wire fencing stretches around the back part of the perimeter, while the front entrance is lined with low, wrought-iron fencing. 'The token fence there is to keep the public and press out, really,' Hood said. 'It's not really keeping the inmates in.' Most inmates are serving time after being convicted of financial crimes or low-level drug offenses, and have less than 10 years left in their sentence. Advertisement Among the highest-profile inmates is Elizabeth Holmes, founder of the blood-testing company Theranos, who was convicted of defrauding investors. Another is Jennifer Shah, a 'Real Housewives of Salt Lake City' cast member serving time for wire fraud. Bryan also briefly housed Michelle Janavs, heiress to the Hot Pockets food empire who was sentenced for paying a fixer to help get her children into the University of Southern California. The camp offers recreational options, including an athletic field, library, and arts and crafts programs. Inmates can participate in vocational training or take on work assignments including landscaping, food service and cleaning. The camp also partners with Canine Companions for Independence, a program that allows inmates to raise and train service dogs. During the day, staff consists of a chaplain, department heads, facility workers, teachers and correctional officers - a few dozen people in total, experts said. When the camp shuts down at night, they said, fewer than a half-dozen correctional officers may remain on-site. Many inmates go to camps to prepare to leave the prison system, so conditions are less volatile and violence extremely rare. 'People are on their best behavior. They don't want to get transferred out,' said Sharon Dolovich, a prison system expert at the UCLA School of Law. 'The people inside are more relaxed. The staff are more relaxed. They're mostly just grateful.'
Miami Herald
10 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Rubio defends Latin American democracy — except when his allies land in hot water
Marco Rubio built his reputation in Miami and the U.S. Senate as a defender of democracy in Latin America, but now, as secretary of state under President Trump, his support for such values has become selective. Rubio and Trump are using America's might to interfere in another country's court system, trying to stop the prosecution of Trump ally and former right-wing Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro for an alleged plot to overturn his electoral loss in 2022 and assassinate the current president. The U.S. has imposed 50% tariffs on the country's goods and sanctioned the Brazilian Supreme Court justice in charge of Bolsonaro's prosecution using the Magnitsky Act, which allows the U.S. to sanction human rights abusers. Rubio wrote on X in July that 'judicial robes cannot protect you.' The Trump administration is treating Brazil as though it's a dictatorship like Cuba or Nicaragua. However, leftist President Luiz Inacio 'Lula' da Silva was elected in a democratic electoral system that's been functioning for 40 years, despite Bolsonaro's attempt to undermine it. The country also has an independent judicial system that, as in many countries, hasn't been immune to accusations of judicial overreach. Meanwhile, the Trump administration supports its ally in El Salvador consolidating power, despite warnings from international human rights organizations. The country's lawmakers last week changed the constitution to let President Nayib Bukele run indefinitely. Bukele remains popular for his war on crime, despite criticism that he's doing away with checks and balances and due process. He's also cracked down on human rights activists and threatened journalists, forcing some political exiles to flee El Salvador, the Associated Press reported. No one is surprised that Trump would look at Latin American policy in a transactional way, molding America's values to fit his needs. But Rubio spent a career acting as the purported voice for righteousness. Is he truly for democracy or merely for ensuring that right-wing leaders run countries in Latin America? Both the right and the left have created authoritarian regimes. And both have failed to call out autocrats from their side of the ideological aisle. The admiration by some Latin American leaders, including Brazil's Lula, for Fidel Castro, and their inability to properly call out Venezuela's Nicolás Maduro are just as problematic. The difference is that the U.S. is using its power to try to influence a criminal case in a democracy that's been an American ally. If Rubio is truly interested in democracy in Latin America, he also should speak up against Bolsonaro's attempt to discredit Brazil's 2022 electoral results and condemn Bolsonaro's supporters who, prodded by his baseless claims of a stolen election, invaded and vandalized government buildings in the country's capital in 2023. Some Bolsonaro supporters also camped out outside military headquarters asking for an intervention by the armed forces in the elections, in what would have amounted to a coup d'état like the one that started Brazil's 20-year dictatorship in 1964. Two years earlier, Trump's supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol because of a similar belief in a conspiracy theory about stolen elections. Now Trump and Rubio are preaching about democratic values? In July, when Trump threatened Brazil with 50% tariffs, he called Bolsonaro's trial a witch hunt that 'should not be taking place.' Then, the U.S. sanctioned Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes for what Rubio described as 'serious human rights abuse' and attacking free speech. De Moraes has ordered some social media accounts to be shut down for publishing disinformation, prompting Trump's media company to sue him. He has imposed several pre-trial restrictions on Bolsonaro, including a curfew and 24-hour surveillance to prevent him from fleeing the country, according to the BBC. Most recently, de Moraes ordered Bolsonaro under house arrest for violating restrictions imposed on him by the Supreme Court as part of his criminal case, including use of social media and cell phones. His decision has been supported by some as defending the rule of law, but he has also been criticized. The editorial board of one of Brazil's largest papers criticized Bolsonaro's arrest, saying he has the right to free speech. The bigger question is why the U.S. is using its trade and diplomatic power to pressure another country to defend a Trump ally accused of terrible crimes. If Rubio is going to cast himself as a defender of democracy and human rights, then he should be consistent. Isadora Rangel is a member of the Herald Editorial Board.
