No ‘special exemptions' for students under latest Rent Pressure Zone system, James Browne says
There will be no special exemption for students under new
Rent Pressure Zone
(RPZ) legislation, Minister for Housing
James Browne
has said.
In advance of a meeting with the Minister for Higher and Further Education
James Lawless
over concerns students could face higher rents, Mr Browne said a special protection for student tenants in the private market would be 'unworkable' and 'unenforceable'.
Earlier this week, Mr Lawless had
called for special exemptions for students
who could be 'inadvertently disadvantaged' by the new regulations due to the fact students change tenancies more frequently than other cohorts.
Under the proposed reform of RPZs, a student who started a new tenancy for each college year could see their rent increase to the market rate each time.
READ MORE
Speaking after the Cabinet agreed on Tuesday to rush through legislation to extend RPZs to the entire country, Mr Browne said there 'won't be any special measures put in place in terms of the private rental sector, it will become impossible to police or to manage in those circumstances'.
He added: 'There is no special exemptions in current law for people in that particular situation, and there won't be under the new legislation either.'
Mr Browne said he would 'engage' with Mr Lawless on proposals for students who could be coming into and out of a tenancy in one year as 'that's a very different particular set of circumstances'.
'But I think to try and engineer into the legislation that a landlord would then have to identify what [is] that person's role? Are they a student? Are they a full-time student, part-time student, what qualifies as a student? It will be unworkable, and I think it will be unenforceable.'
Mr Browne also denied it was a 'mistake' not to rush through legislation to extend RPZs nationwide last week.
'I think we have moved very swiftly on this,' he said.
Earlier,
Labour's
housing spokesman Conor Sheehan claimed he had seen 'anecdotal' evidence of landlords in areas not yet covered by RPZs trying to increase their rents before the law was passed.
Some 17 per cent of existing tenancies are not covered by RPZs, according to latest estimates.
Mr Browne said there 'may' be some landlords who are currently carrying out a review of rents.
'What I always say to all the tenants, your rights are there in law. I know some tenants maybe may not be aware of that.'
He advised them to reach out to renters' organisation Threshold, their local councillor or TD who would 'certainly ensure that your rights are put in place'.
The Cabinet on Tuesday agreed to publish Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Bill 2025 for 'priority enactment' with a view to having it pass all stages in the Oireachtas and be ready to be signed into law by the end of the week.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Government hopes pace of housing announcements increases output
There may be no silver bullet to magically boost housing output, but the Government has certainly accelerated its own output on housing decisions. After a slow start, Minister for Housing James Browne has been making a raft of announcements in an effort to unblock problems and speed up delivery. There is no big bang, but the message now is on a constant flow of weekly actions. All this emphasises the pledge from Mr Browne that the housing crisis is an emergency and is being treated as one. Today brought three changes. Firstly, more powers and a broader remit for the Land Development Agency. Also, emergency legislation to quickly extend rent pressure zones nationwide. And the appointment of the former HSE boss Paul Reid to chair the new planning body, An Coimisiún Pleanála which replaces An Bord Pleanála. This comes on top of extensions to planning permissions, rental reforms, the establishment of the Housing Activation Office and the revised National Planning Framework. Also, there is a push to encourage local authorities to rezone much more land for housing. And there is more to come, with big announcements next month on the National Development Plan and a revamp of the current housing blueprint, Housing for All. In addition, it is clear that a downgrading of apartment standards is being examined to address the viability impasse. No surprise that the Opposition are underwhelmed with this spate of new measures. Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore told the Dáil that the Government may be taking decisions, but she said they were "the wrong ones". Opposition parties have slammed the rental reforms with Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald labelling it the "Fianna Fáil rent hike bill". In particular, they have focused on the lack of protection for short-term renters like students who could face repeated rent hikes every time they move. For Mr Browne, it's clear that after a difficult start in the job, he seems to be on surer ground. But all acknowledge that any uptick in supply is some way off. What does success look like? Housing delivery takes years but before then, the direction of travel will be signalled by several strands of data. A Government source suggests that commencement figures are part of this, but they are not the only important piece of data. First up, ministers will be hoping to see a rise in planning permission applications, especially for large developments. Another important measure is how quickly these applications pass through the system. And if they end up in An Coimisiún Pleanála, how quickly are they dealt with. But trickier decisions loom, namely on potential tax breaks to stimulate private sector development. Builders have walked away from big projects citing the impossibility of delivering at a price buyers are willing to pay. Their solution is a tax incentive, perhaps on VAT. The political battlelines on such a measure are clear; Labour leader Ivana Bacik calling them "Bertienomics tax breaks". And there is already resistance within Government with Minster for Finance Paschal Donohoe publicly opposing them. Proponents of the measure in Government, claim these tax incentives would be different - narrowly drawn, time limited and targeted. Ministers know they will be a tough sell, but some believe they are necessary to deliver the big bang to scale up delivery.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Ireland needs to tackle ‘stark gap' between ‘rhetoric and reality' of children's rights, says child protection rapporteur
A specialist children's legal service could contribute to closing the 'stark gap' between the 'rhetoric and reality' of children's rights here, Ireland 's child protection rapporteur has said. Rights should be more than 'lofty principles on paper', they must be 'practical and effective', said Caoilfhoinn Gallagher . She was addressing an event in Dublin marking the publication of a new report by independent law centre Community Law & Mediation, which analysed the legal needs of children and young people and set out recommendations on how best to achieve those. Several State and non-State stakeholders, including the Ombudsman for Children's Office, Legal Aid Board and Children's Rights Alliance, were among those consulted for the report. READ MORE It particularly prioritised consultations with children and young people who had first-hand experience of legal issues. The difficulties they highlighted included school and family problems, bullying, discrimination, stigma based on 'being from a place that everyone thinks the worst of', mental health and having supports cut off after the age of 18 The report's key recommendation is for the establishment of a specialist children's legal service here with a particular focus on the practice and promotion of child-friendly justice. It recommends that priorities within the Child Poverty Unit of the Department of the Taoiseach and in the National Policy Framework Young Ireland should be reviewed to ensure commitments in relation to children's rights include an access to justice component. In her address, Ms Gallagher said former taoiseach Leo Varadkar had said he wanted Ireland to be the best country in Europe to be a child and the government's 2019 children and youth policy was aimed at improving outcomes for children and young people. That 'ambitious vision' is to be welcomed, she said, adding that she acknowledged and supported many key steps taken in recent years to improve systems, frameworks and outcomes for children. However, she said there remain 'significant and persistent and grave' concerns about child protection and the realisation of child rights in several areas. The aspiration to make Ireland the best place in the world to be a child was likely 'to ring hollow' for many, including the family of teenager Daniel McAnaspie, who was in the care of the State when he was stabbed to death in 2010. An inquest jury last month found he was unlawfully killed and his family have called for a State apology for systemic failures in his care. It was, she suspected, also likely to ring hollow for High Court judge John Jordan who presides weekly over the secure care list and recently described the continual failure of Tusla to provide enough beds for at risk children as 'an affront to the rule of law'. The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child had in 2023 set out six areas where Ireland should take 'urgent' steps, including non-discrimination, violence against children and mental health, she noted. The CLM report is a 'vital' contribution to the important discussion about the gap between rhetoric and reality and how to close that gap, she said. Law professor and child rights expert Conor O'Mahony said litigation has limits and is not normally the place where people want to start when it comes to children's rights but it is 'sometimes the only way to get things done'. He said the 2012 'quite timid' children's rights amendment to the Constitution created a charter under which the courts might do 'interesting things' in relation to children's rights but the courts had 'not really embraced that licence' in the years since. Nothing in the Constitution states that the separation of powers between the legislature and the judiciary is more important than the rights of children but the courts have tended to prioritise the former over the latter, he said.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Northern Ireland Police Ombudsman stepping aside temporarily due to commentary ‘detracting' from work
Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland Marie Anderson is to step aside temporarily because of 'current commentary', which she said was 'detracting' from the focus of her work. On Tuesday, Ms Anderson said she was taking a leave of absence with immediate effect. Authority will be delegated to the body's chief executive and senior staff in her absence 'to ensure the vital work of the office continues', she said. Unionist parties had called for Ms Anderson to temporarily stand down following an alleged incident at her home in Co Down in September 2023. A man was arrested and later issued with a police caution. READ MORE Earlier this month a file was sent to the North's Public Prosecution Service (PPS) following the conclusion of an investigation, which was carried out by West Midlands Police at the request of the Police Service of Northern Ireland. A spokeswoman for the PPS said one individual was reported for potential offences of perverting the course of justice and misconduct in public office. Ms Anderson is a solicitor and member of the Law Society of Northern Ireland. She was appointed Police Ombudsman in 2019 having been a former Public Services Ombudsman and deputy Police Ombudsman. As ombudsman, she is responsible for overseeing investigations into complaints about police conduct. She said that 'although I had decided to retire in December this year, which would have allowed me to fulfil my commitments to delivering the outcomes of investigations to a number of bereaved families, it has become increasingly clear that current commentary is detracting from the focus of that work. 'I am extremely grateful to those families who put their trust in me. And it is their interests which are at the heart of my decision to take a temporary leave of absence with immediate effect.' Ms Anderson said she had 'every confidence in all my staff and know they will work diligently' and she thanked them for their support in recent times. Trevor Clarke, a DUP MLA and member of the Policing Board scrutiny body, said Ms Anderson 'should have stepped aside at the time' but the statement 'appears to have only come following more significant public discussion on the news'. 'During that time there has been continued damage to public confidence in the Ombudsman's office,' he added.
